Table of contents
The 3 Major Site Risks
- Financial / Margin: Undue invoicing of placement fees by the agency, often representing an arbitrary additional cost of around 3 000 to 6 000 CHF when hiring directly under an individual employment contract pursuant to art. 319 CO.
- Legal / Joint Body / SUVA: Statutory nullity of agreements restricting the tradesperson's free transfer to the hiring company under the public policy requirements set by the LSE.
- Administrative / Acceptance: Improper blocking of the permanent employment contract or dispute over the staff leasing contract under art. 22 LSE due to a misunderstanding of the rules applicable after three continuous months of assignment.
On Swiss construction sites, many installers, bricklayers, or electricians start out on an assignment delegated by a staff leasing agency before considering permanent employment with the client company. However, both the temporary craftsman and the user company are frequently unaware of the protective framework of the LSE, which governs access to stable employment.
This guide sets out the legal conditions for joining the hiring firm without abusive penalties. It analyses the scope of contractual time limits, the nullity of non-hiring clauses, and the secure transition to an individual employment contract governed by Swiss law.
Mechanism of the transition to permanent employment and nullity of exclusivity clauses
Moving from a temporary assignment to direct employment with the client company hinges on balancing the tradesperson's economic freedom with fair remuneration for the staff leasing agency's services. Under the LSE, any contractual clause barring the worker from entering into an individual employment contract pursuant to art. 319 CO with the user enterprise at the end of their assignment is null and void. The law safeguards the professional mobility of construction workers by preventing recruitment agencies from locking down access to permanent roles.
When a worker is placed under a staff leasing contract compliant with art. 22 LSE, the leasing agency cannot claim a transfer fee if the assignment lasted at least three uninterrupted months and the hiring takes place within a reasonable period following the end of the mission. If the permanent hiring occurs before this three-month threshold has elapsed, the agency retains the right to bill the client company a sliding-scale placement fee, calculated pro rata for the remaining time. Conversely, no deduction from the employee's wage and no penalty clause charged to them can be agreed upon; any such arrangements are deemed absolutely null and void.
Verification of collective agreements and vested rights
During the temporary phase, the worker benefits from the minimum wage conditions set by the Staff Leasing CLA and by the generally binding collective labour agreement applicable to the construction site, in accordance with art. 20 LSE and art. 1 LECCT. As soon as the individual employment contract is signed with the general contractor or the subcontractor, the tradesperson switches directly to the scheme of their trade's collective agreement or the Code of Obligations (CO).
This transition changes occupational pension arrangements and holiday entitlement calculations under art. 329a CO. Holiday pay previously disbursed monthly with the temporary hourly wage stops: the gross fixed monthly salary now covers all rest periods, in accordance with art. 329d CO, which bars replacing leave in kind with financial payments during the performance of the contract.
Comparison table of temp-to-perm transfer schemes
| Operational criterion | Status before 3 months of assignment | Status after 3 months of assignment |
|---|---|---|
| Fee payable by the client company | Sliding-scale residual amount authorised | No fee legally claimable |
| Fees or deductions chargeable to the worker | Strictly prohibited (art. 19 LSE) | Strictly prohibited (art. 19 LSE) |
| Validity of a non-hiring clause | Null and void | Null and void |
| Probationary period status upon hiring | Applicable pursuant to art. 335b CO | Applicable pursuant to art. 335b CO |
| Salary protection in case of illness | Temporary CLA regime | Time period of art. 324a CO or daily allowance insurance |
Frequent mistakes during direct hiring and financial impacts
A frequent mistake for user companies is to pay without question a flat-rate placement invoice demanded by the agency even though the craftsman has already completed more than three full months of work on site. This lack of vigilance causes a direct financial loss of around 4 000 CHF to 7 000 CHF per recruited worker.
A second pitfall involves improperly adding a non-competition covenant pursuant to art. 340 CO into the new employment contract of a bricklayer or electrician. Such restrictions are unenforceable for manual execution work that does not involve trade secrets, and challenging them before the cantonal courts leads to unnecessary management tension.
Illustrative practical cases (typical scenarios on Swiss construction sites)
The figures and scenarios below are illustrative examples designed to clarify how federal legislation applies in practice.
Standard Scenario 1: Hiring a bricklaying foreman in the Canton of Vaud
On a multi-family housing construction site in the Canton of Vaud, a structural work firm employs a bricklaying foreman placed for four continuous months by a staff leasing agency. Impressed by his leadership skills, the site management offers him a permanent position. The agency issues an invoice for 5 500 CHF, citing a non-solicitation clause in its general terms and conditions. The user company legitimately refuses payment: as the assignment lasted over three uninterrupted months, no compensation can be claimed under the LSE, and an individual employment contract pursuant to art. 319 CO can be concluded without any penalty.
Standard Scenario 2: Early transfer of an electrician in the Canton of Fribourg
On a commercial renovation project in the Canton of Fribourg, an electrician holding a CFC has been working on a temporary assignment for six weeks. The electrical contracting firm wishes to hire him immediately to structure its permanent workforce. Because he has worked on the site for less than three months, the temporary agency bills the hiring employer a residual placement fee of around 2 800 CHF. The calculation takes into account the six-week period remaining to reach the quarterly threshold. The agreement is settled without any deduction from the worker's pay, ensuring an onboarding process that complies with federal law.
Wages and social charges: free tools
Real cost of a tradesperson, employer contributions by canton, meal and travel allowances, notice periods under the collective agreement.
Frequently asked questions
Can the agency charge a placement fee after three months of continuous assignment?
No. Under the Federal Act on Employment Services and the Leasing of Services, any clause imposing a fee after three uninterrupted months of an assignment with the client is null and void.
Is a clause prohibiting an employee from joining the client company legally valid?
No. The Federal Act on Employment Services and the Leasing of Services renders completely null and void any clauses preventing a worker from being hired directly by the company hiring their services.
What permanent salary must the client company guarantee upon hiring on an open-ended contract?
The employer must adhere to the salary agreed upon under art. 322 CO and apply the statutory minimum rates set by the sector's generally binding collective labour agreement.
Does a non-compete agreement signed with the leasing agency apply?
Rarely. Art. 340 CO requires access to trade secrets or direct client contact. Such a clause cannot block a free transition to a permanent contract on the client's construction site.
Does a probationary period apply automatically when transitioning to a permanent contract?
Art. 335b CO sets the statutory probationary period at one month. However, the parties may agree in writing to waive it, given the assignment already completed.
What indicative cost does the client pay for hiring before the statutory threshold?
For hiring before three months, a sliding-scale administrative fee of around 3 000 CHF to 5 000 CHF is typically billed by the agency in line with placement schedules.
Moving to a permanent contract is a major step forward governed by federal legislation. To gain a deeper understanding of your rights on Swiss construction sites, consult our dedicated guides:
- Working as a Temporary Worker in Swiss Construction: Staff Leasing CLA, Rights and temptraining Funds
- Staff Leasing CLA: Why a Temporary Staffing Agency Must Comply with Construction Site Minimum Wages
- Framework Contracts vs Assignment Contracts in Switzerland: Clauses to Check Before Starting on a Construction Site
- Ending a Temporary Assignment in Switzerland: Exact Rules for 2-Day, 7-Day, and 1-Month Notice Periods