Table of contents
The 3 Major Site Risks
- Financial / Margin: Reclassification of a practical test as an individual employment contract under art. 319 CO, requiring payment of wages under art. 322 CO with retroactive social security contributions, amounting to around 400 CHF to 650 CHF per unbudgeted day.
- Legal / Joint Body / SUVA: Personal injury sustained without mandatory accident insurance cover under the LAA or failure to uphold health protection under art. 6 LTr, exposing the employer to recourse claims in the event of non-compliance with safety measures.
- Administrative / Acceptance: Administrative penalty under art. 117a LEI punishable by a fine of up to 40 000 francs if the employer intentionally breaches the obligation to conduct an interview or professional aptitude test under art. 21a LEI for a subject trade.
This methodological guide is designed for construction managers, business owners, and HR managers in the Swiss construction sector. It establishes a rigorous operational framework for organising a technical site trial, clearly distinguishing a one-off skills assessment from actual job duties, in full compliance with collective agreements and SUVA safety rules.
Hosting a candidate for a practical trial requires planning for accident protection under the LAA and setting up a clear observation matrix for each building trade. This approach prevents disputes over work performed, ensures fair treatment during professional selection, and safeguards the firm's obligations towards joint supervisory bodies.
Legal distinction between aptitude test and work performance
On-site technical assessments involve a clear legal boundary between demonstrating competence and performing productive work. Under art. 319 CO, an individual employment contract exists as soon as a worker undertakes to perform work under an employer's direction in exchange for a salary. If the applicant becomes part of the firm's standard production process, the arrangement is automatically deemed an employment relationship, requiring payment of standard wages under art. 322 CO, even without a signed formal agreement.
To remain strictly within the scope of a technical assessment, the test must not generate any direct commercial value for the construction site. A candidate's presence must not cover for an absence or reduce scheduled staffing needs. As soon as the trial exceeds a few hours or results in finished work, the employer must enter into a written contract establishing a trial period under art. 335b CO, which defaults to the first month of employment with a seven-day notice period.
SUVA safety protocol and accident cover during trials
The presence of any individual on an active operational site directly engages the host firm's liability. Art. 6 LTr requires employers to ensure health protection by implementing all necessary measures tailored to operational conditions. A candidate who is not registered with the firm's social insurance does not automatically benefit from mandatory accident insurance (LAA) managed by SUVA or a private insurer for non-occupational accidents.
To prevent any dispute should personal injury occur on site, three prerequisites apply before any access to production areas is granted:
- Prior verification of the candidate's personal accident insurance policy (via their health insurance fund or unemployment insurance status).
- Full provision by the firm of personal protective equipment suited to the activity (hard hat, S3 safety footwear, goggles, hearing protection).
- A formal safety induction recording the prohibition against operating heavy machinery, lifting equipment, or live electrical installations without direct supervision.
Technical assessment matrix by building trade
Practical testing must be based on objective, measurable criteria in a workshop or a neutralised area of the construction site. The following table outlines the recommended technical indicators by trade:
| Trade | Neutralised technical test | Technical compliance criteria | Indicative maximum duration | Mandatory supervision |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Structural work masonry | Laying a sample pier and corner bricks | Plumb, levelness of the course, regularity of mortar joints | 2 hours | Team leader or site foreman |
| Joinery and exterior fitting | Fitting a frame on a workshop jig and sealing | Precision of rebate gaps, quality of perimeter joint sealing | 2 hours | Joinery workshop manager |
| Plumbing installation | Shaping multilayer pipes and pressing onto baseplate | Compliance with centre-to-centre distances, no leaks during hydrostatic pressure test | 1 hour 30 | Certified plumbing installer |
| Building electrical installations | Wiring an unpowered practice distribution board | Conductor identification, neatness of trunking, earth continuity | 2 hours | Electrical safety advisor |
| Painting and plastering | Sample surface prep, fine skimming, and cutting-in | No surface flaws under grazing light, sharp cut-in edges | 1 hour 30 | Painting site manager |
Common assessment mistakes and financial impacts
The most frequent mistake is having the candidate complete a full regular workday under the guise of a "real-world scenario". This practice leads to automatic retroactive reclassification by the courts or joint commissions. The back pay, combined with mandatory social contributions, amounts to a direct cost of roughly 450 to 650 CHF per unformalised trial day.
A second common error involves a lack of audit trails during administrative procedures. When the open position falls under occupations subject to national job registration requirements, failing to meet call-up or interview obligations under art. 21a LEI exposes the employer to financial penalties of up to 40 000 CHF under art. 117a LEI. Maintaining thorough records documenting the test protects the firm legally.
Illustrative practical cases (typical scenarios on Swiss construction sites)
The figures and situations below are illustrative examples designed to guide operational implementation on site.
Scenario A: Hiring a CFC mason in the canton of Vaud
A structural work firm with 35 workers in Lausanne is looking for a CFC-qualified mason. Instead of assigning the candidate to a reinforced concrete slab currently being poured, the site supervisor prepares a safe area in the yard. The trial involves building a non-productive reference low wall for 1 hour 30. The candidate brings their own safety footwear and is issued a hard hat by the company. The exercise confirms complete mastery of execution tolerances, enabling direct hiring under a written contract with the statutory trial period under art. 335b CO, avoiding any risk of contentious wage reclassification.
Scenario B: Assessing an installation electrician in the canton of Geneva
An electrical contracting firm with 12 employees in Carouge tests an installation electrician. The assessment is conducted on an unpowered test board in the workshop for 2 hours, ruling out any direct involvement on an active commercial construction site. The total absence of involvement in billable production ensures the candidate retains the status of a pure skills test, incurring neither wages nor LAA insurance obligations for the host company for this brief assessment.
Wages and social charges: free tools
Real cost of a tradesperson, employer contributions by canton, meal and travel allowances, notice periods under the collective agreement.
Frequently asked questions
Must a practical trial day on a construction site be paid?
Yes. Under art. 319 CO and art. 322 CO, any productive work entitles the worker to the collective agreement wage, for example around 320 CHF gross under the applicable collective labour agreement.
How is a candidate on a technical trial covered against accidents?
Accident protection falls under mandatory accident insurance (LAA). Upon hiring for the test, the employer reports the activity in accordance with the Federal Accident Insurance Act and applies art. 6 LTr.
Can you test a candidate for a role subject to the SECO reporting requirement?
Yes, but calling up an external applicant without complying with art. 21a LEI exposes you to penalties under art. 117a LEI. You must prioritise applications sent by the regional employment centre during the statutory restriction window.
What is the recommended maximum duration for an operational technical trial?
Half a day to one full day is sufficient to evaluate skills. Beyond that, the engagement turns into a standard trial period governed by art. 335b CO with a statutory seven-day notice period.
Can a candidate without a CFC qualify under a mason-level technical matrix?
Yes, art. 32 OFPr provides access to qualification procedures after five years of vocational practice. The matrix evaluates trade skills regardless of the craftsman's initial formal qualification.
What technical assessment data can a company legally retain?
Under art. 6 LPD and art. 8 LPD, only data strictly necessary for hiring is processed and then destroyed proportionately if the application for the construction site is ultimately rejected.
Safeguarding a technical trial requires strict compliance with collective agreements, occupational safety, and public recruitment rules. To explore your hiring procedures in greater detail:
- Recruiting in the Swiss Construction Sector: Drafting CFC Job Offers and the Mandatory ORP / SECO Job Registration (LEI)
- Mandatory Job Notification to ORP 2026: List of Construction Trades Subject to the SECO 5% Threshold
- Step-by-Step Job-Room Procedure: Complying with the 5-Working-Day Embargo and Avoiding a 40'000 CHF Fine
- Statutory Exemptions from ORP Reporting: Internal Transfers, <= 14-Day Missions, and Pre-Registered Candidates