Table of contents
The 3 Major Site Risks
- Financial / Margin: Undue continuation of salary of at least 80% of gross income without productive work under art. 324a CO, leading to temporary staffing surcharges of roughly 4 000 CHF to 9 000 CHF per month of unjustified absence.
- Legal / Joint body / SUVA: Unlawful infringement of personal rights during medical disputes or breach of the proportionality principles of art. 6 LPD through the collection of confidential diagnoses that the employer is barred from seeing.
- Administrative / Acceptance: Halting team disruption on the construction site, lack of technical substitution, and suspension of notice periods if the medical leave is not formally reassessed by a neutral practitioner.
In Swiss construction firms, sudden incapacity for work occurring during peak activity or contractual tensions directly disrupts the progress of construction sites. The employer is bound by the obligation to continue paying salary under art. 319 CO and art. 324a CO, but retains the contractual right to require a medical certificate from the very first working day of absence.
Faced with an ambiguous notification, appointing an independent medical examiner clarifies the worker's genuine fitness for their specific role. This rigorous protocol upholds health protection guaranteed by the Labour Act while safeguarding salary administration and emergency replacement plans.
Medical certificate requirement from the first day and regulatory bases
The employment contract obliges the employee to perform their work diligently. Under art. 319 CO, the payment of salary depends directly on the provision of work, except in the event of unmerited impediment falling under art. 324a CO. The custom of tolerating three consecutive days of absence before submitting a medical certificate is not based on any statutory requirement. The employer is entitled to establish, through an individual employment contract or staff regulations, the mandatory submission of a certificate from the first working day of absence.
This clause may apply generally or specifically where repeated absences occur on Mondays, Fridays, or during critical production deadlines. When the worker fails to comply with this formal contractual order, withholding salary payments is lawful as long as the incapacity remains unproven. In addition, health protection under art. 6 LTr requires management to verify the actual physical fitness of workers exposed to the hazards inherent to technical construction roles.
Protocol for summons before an independent medical examiner
Faced with an ambiguous medical certificate or one issued retroactively without an initial physical examination, the employer may refer the employee for a second medical opinion with a practitioner selected by the company. This step requires an impeccable procedure:
- The company pays all consultation fees and transport costs entirely at its own expense.
- The worker is summoned in writing, with reasonable notice, reminding them of their duty of loyalty and collaboration.
- The medical examiner is strictly bound by professional secrecy: they disclose no diagnosis or treatment to the employer, complying with art. 6 LPD as well as the definition of personal data under art. 5 LPD.
- The final report delivered to human resources concludes only with full capacity, total incapacity, or partial incapacity indicating restricted movements or duties.
An unjustified refusal to undergo this examination releases the employer from paying compensation under art. 324a CO as long as the impediment to work remains unsubstantiated.
Comparative table of absence management measures
| Operational situation | Required management action | Swiss legal basis | Direct consequence on salary |
|---|---|---|---|
| Recurring absence without a 24-hour certificate | Formal notice to submit a medical certificate within 48 hours | Duty of loyalty and art. 319 CO | Suspension of salary until proof is submitted |
| Medical certificate issued retroactively by several days | Immediate dispute and appointment of a medical examiner | Burden of proof and art. 324a CO | Payment subject to medical validation |
| Worker's refusal to attend the medical examiner | Formal warning setting a final deadline | Worker's duty of collaboration | Interruption of payments under art. 324a CO |
| Finding of full fitness upon second medical opinion | Formal demand to resume work on the construction site | Code of Obligations (CO) and art. 319 CO | Definitive cessation of salary if absence continues |
| Protection period triggered by verified medical leave | Freezing of ordinary dismissal procedures | Protection against dismissal and art. 336c CO | Continuation of salary under the applicable coverage |
Frequent mistakes and financial impacts for the company
The most widespread mistake is asking the employee for the exact nature of their illness. This intrusion exposes the company to civil sanctions for breaching privacy. Another pitfall lies in giving ordinary notice of dismissal during a valid period of medical incapacity: such dismissal given during an unmerited incapacity is void under art. 336c CO, creating unexpected residual wage liabilities of roughly 6 000 CHF to 15 000 CHF.
Terminating employment relationships unilaterally for just cause without a valid reason exposes the employer to the consequences of art. 337c CO, which provides for payment of the salary due until the end of the notice period as well as court-ordered compensation of up to six months' salary.
Illustrative practical cases (typical scenarios on Swiss construction sites)
The following figures are illustrative examples intended to guide the implementation of internal protocols.
Standard Scenario 1: Structural work in Valais (workforce of 18 workers)
On a civil engineering construction site in Martigny, a formworker reports lower back pain on the morning of a major concrete pour, providing a postdated certificate of convenience. The company applies the day-one certificate clause contained in the employment contract. Faced with doubts, it appoints a medical examiner in Sion who confirms fitness for light duties. The worker is immediately reassigned to sorting rebar components on an adapted schedule, avoiding the hiring of temporary cover costing 5 200 CHF for two weeks.
Standard Scenario 2: General contractor in Geneva (workforce of 42 employees)
In Carouge, a site supervisor verbally disputes his scheduling instructions and then submits a full sick leave note for depression that very day. Management instructs an independent medical examiner within six working days. The worker's repeated refusal justifies withholding salary under art. 324a CO. The situation is clarified formally without exposing the firm to a dismissal without just cause under art. 337 CO.
Wages and social charges: free tools
Real cost of a tradesperson, employer contributions by canton, meal and travel allowances, notice periods under the collective agreement.
Frequently asked questions
Can a medical certificate be required from the first day of absence?
Yes, under the Code of Obligations (CO), the employer can require it from the first day if the individual contract, staff regulations, or applicable collective agreement expressly provides for it.
Who pays the fees of the medical examiner appointed by the company?
The employer covers all costs of the independent medical examination, with fees usually ranging from 600 CHF to 1200 CHF, without any deduction from the worker's salary.
What health data may the medical examiner disclose to management?
In accordance with the Federal Data Protection Act, the physician discloses only the residual work capacity and the expected duration, without revealing the medical diagnosis.
What are the risks for a worker who refuses to attend the medical examination?
Under the Code of Obligations (CO), the employer may suspend salary payments pursuant to art. 324a CO if the employee refuses without a valid reason to undergo the medical check.
Does absence due to illness justify a reduction in annual leave?
Under art. 329b CO, the employer may reduce holiday entitlement only if the unmerited absence exceeds one full month during the relevant year of service.
What steps should be taken when faced with conflicting medical certificates?
Management must immediately mandate a second opinion with an independent medical examiner and notify the daily sickness allowance insurer to clarify the employee's medical situation.
Strict management of sick leave safeguards the operational balance of construction sites. Continue your legal monitoring with our practical guides:
- Absence Management, Unlawful Termination During Protected Periods (CO) and Work Certificates
- Statutory One-Twelfth Holiday Deduction (CO): Sickness (1 Month) vs Pregnancy (2 Months) Grace Periods
- Serving Ordinary Notice of Dismissal Without Formal Defects: Receipt Before Month-End and Witnesses
- The Deadly CO Trap: Void Dismissal (30/90/180 Days) and Calculating Postponement During Notice Sickness