Skip to content
Candidates
Jobs
Employers
Companies
Pricing
Change language: French
Tool and user guide

Swiss Construction Total Employer Cost vs Staffing Agency Calculator (Contributions, FAR/RESOR, Holidays)

Calculate total employer cost vs temporary staffing agencies in Swiss construction. Factor in contributions, FAR/RESOR, and holiday pay under the CN.

Table of contents
The 3 Major Site Risks
  1. Financial / Margin: Underestimating the cost of permanent staff compared to temp workers carries a risk of budget overruns of around 15 %. An inaccurate assessment of contributions and total holiday compensation (art. 329d CO) distorts profitability.
  2. Legal / Joint bodies / SUVA: Hiring through an agency without checking its operating licence exposes the user company to penalties. The Federal Act on Employment Services and the Hiring of Services (LSE) governs this practice to ensure compliance with working conditions.
  3. Administrative / Site acceptance: Mishandling employment contracts complicates joint audits. An incomplete file during a National Collective Agreement (CN) audit can block access to public construction sites and delay stage sign-offs by site management.

In Swiss construction, deciding whether to hire permanent staff or turn to a temporary staffing agency is a strategic choice for employers. This evaluation goes well beyond comparing gross hourly wages. You must factor in employer contributions, social security contributions, SUVA premiums, and specific contributions such as early retirement under FAR or RESOR. The total cost calculator puts this analysis on an objective footing by quantifying the financial differences. Accurate budgeting safeguards your competitiveness during tenders and ensures compliance with collective agreements, such as the National Collective Agreement (CN) or the CLA for finishing work in French-speaking Switzerland.

Human resources management on a construction site demands thorough mastery of statutory obligations. Employers must pay full holiday compensation under art. 329d CO and set aside provisions for public holidays and the 13th-month salary. Conversely, agency rates governed by the Federal Act on Employment Services and the Hiring of Services (LSE) already include these provisions, delivering immediate flexibility at a higher hourly rate. Our tool helps pinpoint the break-even threshold between both models. For hourly selling price calculations and invoicing, visit /erp/; technical coordination by site management is handled via /portail/.

Transparency of algorithms and applied standards

The total cost calculator relies on a strict algorithmic architecture incorporating Swiss legal and collective agreement parameters. Its objective is to provide an exact comparison between hiring an employee directly and using an agency for the hiring of services. Calculations incorporate the requirements of the National Collective Agreement (CN Structural work) and the CLA SOR for finishing work in French-speaking Switzerland. The algorithm accounts for social security contributions, SUVA AP premiums (unemployment insurance and occupational accidents), as well as mandatory joint contributions such as FAR or RESOR early retirement.

The modelling of provisions for paid leave is based on the Code of Obligations (CO). Under art. 329d CO on holiday pay, the employer must pay the full salary; for the duration of the employment relationship, holidays cannot be replaced by cash compensation or other benefits. On the temporary agency side, the algorithm checks compliance with the Federal Act on Employment Services and the Hiring of Services. Under art. 20 LSE on declared-binding collective agreements, whenever the hiring company is bound by an extended CLA, the staffing agency must apply the agreement's provisions on pay and working hours to the worker.

Coefficients and calculation structure

For a skilled worker, the internal employer contribution multiplier typically ranges between 1,38 and 1,45 applied to the basic gross wage. This multiplier includes social security contributions (AVS/AI/APG, AC, LPP), SUVA AP premiums, FAR or RESOR contributions, as well as provisions for the 13th-month salary and public holidays. Conversely, the hourly rate billed by a staffing agency applies a multiplier that often sits between 1,60 and 1,75. This rate covers gross wages, social security contributions, statutory accruals, as well as the agency's commercial margin and overheads.

Detailed breakdown of hourly costs

The table below illustrates the cost breakdown for an identical base wage, highlighting the financial variations between in-house employment and agency hire.

Hourly cost component In-House Cost (CHF) Temp Cost (CHF) Observed variance (CHF)
Basic gross wage 35.00 35.00 0.00
Social security contributions (AVS, LPP, SUVA) 6.30 Included -
Provisions (Holidays, 13th month, FAR/RESOR) 8.40 Included -
Agency margin and overheads 0.00 16.45 +16.45
Estimated total hourly cost 49.70 57.75 +8.05

Complete calculation example in CHF

Take the example of a 160-hour assignment for a skilled bricklayer. The base wage is set at 35.00 CHF per hour. With in-house employment, the total hourly cost comes to 49.70 CHF. Total cost for the period is therefore 7952.00 CHF (net of tax, as payroll is exempt from VAT).

If the firm hires through a temporary agency billing at 57.75 CHF per hour, the net cost invoiced by the agency reaches 9240.00 CHF excl. VAT. Unlike in-house payroll, invoices from temporary staffing agencies are subject to value-added tax. Swiss VAT must therefore be added at the standard rate of 8,1 %. The VAT amount comes to 748.44 CHF (9240.00 multiplied by 8,1 %). The total cost incl. VAT billed by the agency thus reaches 9988.44 CHF. Over time, the net cash outflow difference for the client firm is substantial.

Illustrative practical cases (typical scenarios on Swiss construction sites)

The figures and situations presented below are illustrative examples constructed to demonstrate how the calculator works and do not represent actual construction sites.

Scenario 1: Long-term reinforcement in the canton of Vaud (VD)

A Vaud construction firm anticipates a peak in activity for structural work requiring three extra bricklayers for six months (around 960 hours per worker). The calculator highlights that the markup from the agency margin significantly exceeds the administrative overhead of hiring on fixed-term contracts. Direct fixed-term hiring is chosen. This decision lowers the total cost while ensuring strict adherence to the CN Structural work and contributions to the FAR foundation. The recruitment overhead is amortised smoothly over this six-month duration.

Scenario 2: Emergency replacement in the canton of Geneva (GE)

A Geneva finishing work firm needs to replace two absent painters for a period of three weeks (around 120 hours per worker). The tool's analysis shows that the administrative burden required to enrol staff in social security plans, process LPP registrations, and administer SUVA AP premiums is disproportionate to the assignment's length. The firm opts for a licensed temporary agency. While the hourly cost is higher, the immediate flexibility warrants the difference. The agency guarantees compliance with the wage provisions of the CLA SOR, ensuring legal compliance without burdening the host firm's administration.

00:00 to 00:15 Voiceover: Hesitating between permanent hiring and temporary staff? Agency rates look high, but do you know the true cost of a permanent employee?

00:15 to 01:10 Screen and Diagrams: On-screen software demo: calculator. The screen shows a wage entry. The tool adds contributions, holiday pay (art. 329a CO), and FAR dues. On-screen diagram: comparison. The chart shows the difference: permanent costs factor in absences (art. 324a CO), whereas agencies deliver full flexibility.

01:10 to 01:30 Voiceover: Use our calculator to compare these costs in CHF and boost your team's profitability. Access our Academy to master your contracts.

Wages and social charges: free tools

Real cost of a tradesperson, employer contributions by canton, meal and travel allowances, notice periods under the collective agreement.

View payroll and HR tools

Frequently asked questions

Does the minimum wage apply to temporary agency workers?

Yes, art. 20 LSE requires the staffing agency to apply the provisions of extended collective agreements regarding wages and working hours to temporary workers.

How do you calculate holiday pay for a permanent employee?

Art. 329d CO requires the employer to pay the full salary during holidays. The true cost includes this gross wage plus social security contributions, representing an estimated overhead of 10 %.

Does the temp agency pay FAR and RESOR contributions?

Yes, as the legal employer, the staffing agency bills an all-inclusive hourly rate that must incorporate mandatory joint contributions for FAR or RESOR early retirement under extended collective agreements.

What is the notice period for temporary agency work?

Under art. 19 LSE, the staffing assignment contract sets the notice period. Collective agreements frequently set very short notice periods initially, offering great flexibility on the construction site.

Can you hire a foreign worker without a permit through an agency?

No, art. 11 LEI requires a permit for any gainful employment. Art. 117 LEI penalises the employment of foreign nationals without authorization. The agency must obtain the proper work permit beforehand.

Who handles workplace safety for a temporary worker?

The host company must integrate temporary workers into its site safety and prevention procedures. Art. 6 LTr mandates employers to safeguard worker health, applying to all staff present on the construction site.

Optimise your recruitment decisions

Human resources management calls for a crystal-clear overview of costs. Between statutory obligations, contributions, and contingencies, choosing between permanent staff and temporary workers directly affects your bottom line. Simulate your employer costs with our tool and make profitable decisions. Explore our simulators on the recruitment tools page.

Art Construction is an independent company: it is not affiliated with the SIA, CRB, SUVA, or KBOB. Referenced norms and standards point to publications from these bodies; only official versions are legally binding.