Table of contents
The 3 Major Site Risks
- Financial / Margin: Execution of altered works without prior agreement on unit prices or daywork, leading to a 10 % to 25 % gross margin loss on the trade package concerned and payment refusal at final account stage under standard SIA 118 and art. 373 CO.
- Legal / Joint body / SUVA: Imposition during meetings of unplanned phasing causing team disruption, a risk of exceeding the maximum weekly working hours under the Swiss Labour Act (LTr), and liability risks for the site management under art. 229 CP in the event of an accident caused by rushed work.
- Administrative / Acceptance: Master schedule slippage without a formalised time addendum, exposing the contractor to contractual penalties under art. 160 CO or to a formal notice for delay under art. 366 CO upon acceptance of the work.
On Swiss building and civil engineering construction sites, the weekly coordination meeting is a strategic forum where site management and the client frequently raise programme adjustments, material changes, or revisions to execution details. When introduced while material orders are already placed or formwork is already erected, these late variation requests directly threaten the contractual balance established by the works contract under art. 363 CO. Site foremen, site managers, and construction managers must master notification procedures to neutralise the financial and schedule impacts of these informal requests made around the meeting table.
Contractual qualification of these requests demands rigorous vigilance under standard SIA 118. A verbal instruction recorded vaguely in the meeting minutes does not constitute a validly priced variation order, leaving the contractor exposed to the fixed-lump-sum presumption of art. 373 CO. To ensure full payment for additional work or daywork under art. 374 CO, practitioners must record standard reservations during the meeting, notify anticipated impacts on contractual dates, and require a signed written addendum before committing operational resources on site.
Legal characterisation of oral orders and contractual mechanisms
During a construction site meeting, the client or the site management regularly requests finishing changes, partition relocations, or technical adjustments. Under a works contract governed by standard SIA 118, these demands constitute change orders. Where the parties rely on the Code of Obligations (CO) without explicitly reserving derogating clauses, art. 363 CO and art. 373 CO govern agreed compensation, especially under fixed-price contracts. Pursuant to art. 373 CO, the contractor executes the works for the agreed amount and cannot claim an increase, unless extraordinary, unforeseeable circumstances arise that were excluded by the original assumptions. An oral instruction altering the baseline work falls outside this fixed price if it exceeds the contractual scope.
Regarding representation, art. 32 CO provides that rights and obligations arising from a contract made in the name of another person by an authorised agent pass to the principal. However, site management does not inherently possess the authority to financially commit the client beyond the scope of its agency contract under art. 398 CO. Accepting a variation requested by the architect or the local site manager without written financial confirmation exposes the contractor to a repudiation by the client. Furthermore, accepting a variation without reserving rights regarding deadlines deprives the contractor of defence arguments against any contractual penalty stipulated under art. 160 CO.
Site meeting protocol for recording costs and deadlines on the spot
To prevent post-facto disputes, the site manager or site foreman must implement an instant handling protocol as soon as a request is raised during a meeting. This procedure involves four successive steps:
- Immediate impact assessment: identify whether the work requires supplementary engineering design, an interruption of a critical path activity, or the removal of existing elements.
- Formal notice: reiterate that every variation generates additional costs and schedule adjustments, pursuant to the duty to inform under art. 365 CO when circumstances jeopardise the proper or timely execution of the works.
- Specific wording in the minutes: dictate then and there the entry recording the request, its status as a prospective addendum, and the explicit reservation regarding pricing.
- Pricing deadline and suspension: set a cut-off date for submitting the supplementary quote, specifying that the affected works remain suspended until formal approval of the addendum.
Whenever a variation involves unforeseen structural work, the contractor must verify that safety is fully maintained. For instance, if underpinning requires earthworks exceeding a depth of 1 m 50, art. 68 OTConst mandates that trenches be propped, shored, or battered to eliminate collapse hazards. If the construction site requires temporary overtime to accommodate a variation without shifting the completion date, the overtime provisions of art. 12 LTr and the rest provisions of art. 15 LTr must be strictly observed to maintain compliance.
Comparative table of meeting stances when faced with a variation
| Situation encountered in meeting | Risky or non-compliant reaction | Recommended procedure (standard SIA 118 / CO) | Direct impact on deadlines | Direct impact on costs |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Request to relocate a technical shaft mid-pour during concreting | Agreeing orally to preserve commercial relations without recording the extra cost. | Issuing a written notice under art. 365 CO, minuting reservations, and suspending the zone. | Critical path extension documented in the site diary. | Daywork quote or new unit price agreed prior to any action. |
| Floor finish change unavailable within 6 weeks | Ordering the substitute product without giving notice of the impact on the completion date. | Issuing written notification of schedule interruption and requesting a formal schedule addendum. | Neutralisation of delay penalties under art. 160 CO via addendum. | Recharging standing time and storage costs for the teams. |
| Instruction to partially demolish a reinforced concrete wall | Carrying it out immediately on the oral instruction of the local site manager. | Requiring a written variation order and approval from the structural engineer. | Master schedule update approved by the client. | Payment for demolition and haulage works pursuant to art. 374 CO. |
| Acceleration request to recover delays caused by another trade | Increasing workforce numbers without a prior agreement covering site supervision overheads. | Executing an acceleration agreement establishing financial compensation for the measures. | Maintenance of the contractual deadline conditional upon agreed payment. | Coverage of extraordinary additional hours under art. 12 LTr and art. 13 LTr. |
| Client refusal to pay for technical engineering of the variant | Absorbing the engineering firm's design fees to settle the argument. | Reiterating that any work outside the baseline scope requires payment under art. 374 CO. | Freezing variant execution until a full commercial agreement is in place. | Full preservation of the general contractor's gross margin. |
Frequent site administration errors and financial impacts
The primary pitfall observed is tacit acceptance. Under art. 1 CO, a contract is concluded once the parties have expressed their mutual intent concordantly, whether expressly or tacitly. Commencing altered works without submitting a priced proposal places the contractor under art. 374 CO, whereby the price is determined by the value of the work and actual costs, triggering expert disputes over actual output rates. On a finishing work package worth 450 000 CHF, executing 8 % in unformalised variations routinely results in a dispute involving 36 000 CHF, which is often settled at only 50 % of its real value upon final settlement.
The second error is failing to formulate a reservation regarding schedule extensions. When a complex variation is agreed for a lump sum without referencing the time impact, the client can invoke formal notice of default under art. 102 CO as soon as the initial completion date lapses. Where a contractual penalty has been agreed under art. 160 CO, it may be claimed immediately upon occurrence of the delay, even without proof of direct damage under art. 161 CO. A lack of written records eliminates any means of demonstrating that failure to meet the schedule stems from circumstances attributable to the client pursuant to art. 369 CO.
Illustrative practical cases (typical scenarios on Swiss construction sites)
The figures shown in the scenarios below are illustrative examples intended to clarify the practical application of statutory and standard-based rules on site.
Standard Scenario 1: Internal Layout Variation on a Residential Building (Vaud)
On an 18-unit residential construction site in Lausanne, the client requests during meeting 24 to relocate several partition walls and install additional plumbing connections on a package carried out by 6 workers. Because the service ducts are already cast, this request requires core drilling and alterations to pipework embedded under the slab. The estimated cost of these adjustments represents approximately 28 000 CHF exclusive of tax (Swiss VAT at 8,1 % added) and requires an extra procurement lead time of three weeks.
The site manager refuses immediate execution and has the following recorded in the minutes: "Out-of-scope work: penetration studies submitted to the engineer, 5 working days pricing turnaround, Level 2 works suspended pending signature of financial addendum and formal extension of the contractual deadline by 15 working days." By relying on art. 365 CO to notify without delay that this circumstance compromises timely completion, the contractor avoids the application of contractual daily delay penalties under art. 160 CO.
Standard Scenario 2: Foundation Changes Following Geological Discovery (Fribourg)
During earthworks for an industrial building in Bulle involving a crew of 4 people, the client instructs the contractor to deepen excavations by an extra 1 m 80 to rest the footings on a competent ground layer. The site foreman notes that the trench reaches 2 m 20 without adequate battering. In accordance with art. 68 OTConst, unpropped excavations deeper than 1 m 50 must be battered back or protected by appropriate safety measures. Furthermore, art. 71 OTConst requires clear, unobstructed edges of at least 1 m horizontally where trench faces are battered.
During the site meeting, the contractor gives notice that deepening requires installing shoring or widening the trench footprint, entailing an additional cost of approximately 18 500 CHF and 8 working days. The contractor refuses to proceed without a written instruction addressing safety requirements. The instruction is minuted as an addendum with an agreed new unit price, ensuring payment for earthworks according to good professional practice and preventing accidents on the construction site.
Contracts and SIA 118: free tools
Advance payments and retentions, surety bonds, price escalations, daywork reports, subcontractor monitoring.
Frequently asked questions
Does an Oral Order Given by the Client in a Meeting Commit Costs?
Standard SIA 118 makes variation orders subject to clear formalisation. Under art. 373 CO, a lump-sum price remains fixed without express agreement. For an illustrative amount around 14 000 CHF, the contractor must give written notice of the financial impact before ordering materials.
How to Record the Schedule Impact of Late Variations?
Recording it in the minutes must quantify the schedule postponement in working days. Art. 365 CO requires notifying the client without delay when circumstances jeopardise the orderly or punctual completion of the work, under penalty of bearing the financial consequences of an adverse delay.
Can the site management approve a price increase without express power of attorney?
In accordance with art. 32 CO on agency, the agent's actions bind the client only within the scope of the powers conferred. For an illustrative extra cost in the region of 28 000 CHF, the formal signature of the client remains essential to prevent any subsequent dispute.
What should you do if the client rejects the financial addendum for a requested change?
The contractor must suspend the specific modified works, citing art. 366 CO and the original works contract. Continuing without an approved addendum exposes the firm to carrying out additional services at its own expense, with no guarantee of securing the claimed compensation for an extra cost of around 9 500 CHF.
Does a penalty clause on the final deadline apply after a programme change?
Pursuant to art. 160 CO, a contractual penalty sanctions default on the agreed performance. However, if the delay results from late orders by the client, the contractor is entitled to plead this cause to neutralise the enforceability of daily penalties on the final account of the work.
What entries should be recorded in the minutes to secure payment for a variant?
The minutes must specify the detailed technical description, the estimated cost as a lump sum or on a time-and-materials basis under standard SIA 118, as well as the approved delivery postponement. An indicative amount of around 6 000 CHF becomes payable if the minutes are countersigned by the parties.
Securing building variations right from the site meeting
Securing unforeseen requirements contractually ensures the financial and scheduling stability of construction operations. A written paper trail protects stakeholders against late disputes concerning costs and deadlines. To explore site management protocols in greater detail, consult our dedicated resources:
- Weekly Meetings, Daily Log and Evidentiary Value of Site Minutes in Switzerland
- How to Draft Legally Watertight Site Meeting Minutes in Switzerland
- Deadline for Contesting Site Minutes: Legal Effect of Silence and Contractual Clauses
- Maintaining the Daily Site Diary by the Local Site Supervision and the Site Manager: Mandatory Entries
