Table of contents
The 3 Major Site Risks
- Financial / Margin: An unlawful direct wage deduction for bodywork damage, illustrative here at 2 500 CHF, exposes the employer to having to return the funds under art. 322 CO governing the duty to pay the agreed wage.
- Legal / Joint Body / SUVA: The lack of formal instructions on sobriety violates the employer's general duty to take protective measures under art. 6 LTr and the Ordinance on Accident Prevention, jeopardising physical fitness on construction sites.
- Administrative / Acceptance: Immediate dismissal served without prior written directives regarding mobile phone use while driving deprives the firm of a recognised just cause under art. 337 CO during a dispute.
This methodological guide is intended for business owners, technical managers and HR staff in building trade SMEs operating in Romandy. It sets out how to draft workshop and road policies covering intoxication, light commercial vehicle travel and mobile communications, strictly within the framework of the individual employment contract defined in art. 319 CO.
Faced with occupational safety requirements and compliance checks, clear guidelines protect your firm against operational downtime. They formalise workers' operational responsibilities while ensuring compliance with the Federal Act on Data Protection when geolocating company vehicles.
Application framework for internal rules in construction SMEs
Introducing internal company guidelines in the construction sector aims to reconcile health protection with fleet preservation. In accordance with art. 6 LTr, the employer takes all measures that experience has shown to be necessary, that are feasible given the state of technology and that are adapted to the firm's operating conditions. In return, workers are required to support the employer in applying these provisions. Safety on sites and during travel requires precise instructions regarding sobriety, commercial vehicle use and the ban on mobile devices during hazardous work.
When an employee's mistake causes damage to a van or to equipment, the temptation to offset the financial loss against that month's pay contravenes labour law principles. Under art. 322 CO, the employer pays the worker the agreed, standard, or standard-employment-contract or collective agreement wage. No unilateral offset may be made without an express acknowledgement of debt or formal agreement, under penalty of dispute before joint commissions.
Zero tolerance for alcohol and psychotropic substances
On construction sites subject to SUVA rules and the Ordinance on Accident Prevention, consuming alcoholic beverages during working hours, including team travel, severely compromises safety. Internal rules must explicitly prohibit the consumption of alcohol and narcotics. In the event of a serious breach leading to an inability to drive or operate machinery, immediate termination for just cause may be carried out pursuant to art. 337 CO, where circumstances make it unfeasible in good faith to require continuation of the employment relationship.
Commercial vehicle rules and wage deductions
Using branded vans for personal travel without written authorisation constitutes a breach of contract. The rules must outline return terms, the handling of insurance deductibles and the settlement of traffic fines. The employer cannot arbitrarily withhold an insurance deductible or repair cost from regular pay. Such a unilateral deduction breaches the obligation to pay the agreed wage under art. 322 CO.
Arbitration matrix for workshop and fleet regulations clauses
| Regulated area | Non-compliant practice | Clause compliant with Swiss law | HR management impact |
|---|---|---|---|
| Alcohol consumption | Informal tolerance during lunch breaks | Complete ban on work stations and in vehicles under art. 6 LTr | Prevention of SUVA stop-work orders and liability mitigation |
| Smartphone use | Unrestricted use on scaffolding or boom lifts | Ban on mobile devices during high-risk operations | Reduced risk of falls and technical distraction |
| Van travel | Personal use over the weekend | Strictly limited to authorised workshop-to-site travel | Fuel cost control and fleet insurance compliance |
| Property damage | Direct deduction of the invoice from the payslip | Payment of the agreed wage under art. 322 CO and separate claim procedure | Elimination of disputes before joint commissions |
| GPS tracking | Permanent 24/24 tracking without information | Active exclusively during working hours under art. 6 LPD | Respect for proportionality and data protection |
Common administrative mistakes and operational consequences
A common mistake is inserting a clause that imposes an automatic flat-rate deduction from wages for every damaged tool. This practice conflicts with art. 322 CO and exposes the firm to reimbursing wrongfully withheld sums, alongside administrative conciliation costs that can exceed 1 500 CHF per case. Another misstep is the failure to issue a written handover confirmation when giving out vehicle keys, leaving the firm without proof of liability should a crew member damage the van.
Regarding data protection, fitting vehicles with trackers without first providing information on the purpose of data processing violates art. 19 LPD, which requires the controller to inform the data subject appropriately of the controller's identity and the processing purpose.
Illustrative practical cases (typical scenarios on Swiss construction sites)
The following figures and situations are illustrative examples designed to guide SME operational practice.
Scenario 1: Bodywork damage on a plastering van in the canton of Vaud
A plastering and painting firm with 14 employees is working on a multi-family housing refurbishment project in Lausanne. At the end of the day, a driver reverses into a retaining wall, causing damage estimated indicatively at 3 200 CHF to the rear door of the vehicle. The firm initially decides to deduct a 1 000 CHF insurance deductible from the worker's monthly wages. Alerted by the union representative, the HR manager cancels the deduction to comply with art. 322 CO. The firm pays the agreed wage in full, reviews the level of negligence, and seeks a signed settlement agreement to secure a fair contribution.
Scenario 2: Using a phone on a roof in the canton of Fribourg
During industrial roof repairs in Bulle, a roofer checks personal messages on a roof edge. The site management steps in. In application of art. 6 LTr, the SME's management enforces internal rules: a formal written warning and a reminder of the mobile device ban during work exposed to fall risks, thereby averting a work stoppage for the crew.
Wages and social charges: free tools
Real cost of a tradesperson, employer contributions by canton, meal and travel allowances, notice periods under the collective agreement.
Frequently asked questions
Can alcohol be completely banned on a Swiss construction site?
Yes. Under the health protection duty set out in art. 6 LTr, an employer can establish a zero-tolerance policy through company internal rules to prevent serious personal injury risks.
How can a breathalyser test be required from a worker suspected of intoxication?
The company internal rules must clearly specify the exact procedure. If the worker refuses, the employer removes them from the construction site on immediate safety grounds, without breaching the Labour Act.
Does damage to a van allow for a direct deduction from wages?
No. The agreed wage under art. 322 CO remains protected. Any offsetting deduction requires the worker's written acknowledgement of debt or formal judicial proof of wilful intent or gross negligence.
Can an intoxicated driver be dismissed with immediate effect?
Immediate dismissal for just cause within the meaning of art. 337 CO is possible if public safety or construction site safety was directly compromised by this conduct.
Is using a GPS tracker in a company vehicle permitted?
Yes, but the device must comply with the principles of art. 6 LPD. Continuous tracking outside working hours or without informing employees beforehand is strictly prohibited.
Who pays the 500 CHF insurance deductible after a minor collision?
An illustrative deductible of roughly 500 CHF remains the employer's sole responsibility, unless wilful intent or gross negligence by the driver is legally established.
Drafting clear internal company rules secures operational safety and shields your SME from labour tribunal claims or contractual disputes. Explore our practical guides to safeguard your hiring and employment relations across Swiss construction sites:
- Construction Employment Contracts in Switzerland (Permanent, Fixed-term, Hourly), AVS Bogus Self-Employment Risks, and Day 1 Safety
- Monthly Permanent, Hourly Permanent, Fixed-Term or On-Call Contract: Which Contract Suits Your SME's Activity?
- Probationary Periods in Switzerland (CO & CLA): 3-Month Maximum Duration, 7-Day Notice, and Extension for Illness
- Overtime (CO) vs Statutory Overtime (LTr): +25% Pay Premium, Time off in Lieu or Flat-Rate Allowance