Table of contents
The 3 Major Site Risks
- Financial / Margin: Shaft or opening deduction error generating a billing discrepancy of around 5 to 12 % on structural work pursuant to art. 373 CO and art. 374 CO.
- Legal / Joint Body / SUVA: Contract dispute over as-built quantity takeoffs during the final account, classified as a divergence under standard SIA 118 with no admissible daywork basis.
- Administrative / Acceptance: Rejection of joint quantities by site management during work verification, halting payment under art. 372 CO.
This technical guide details the Swiss rules for deducting openings on working drawings, intended for architects, draftspersons, civil engineers and quantity surveyors. Strict compliance with the requirements of the Swiss Research Centre for Building Rationalisation governs the validity of quantities submitted in tenders and standardised descriptive quotes.
In enterprise contracts governed by art. 363 CO and standard SIA 118, quantifying masonry, formwork or screeds depends on strict surface thresholds. Erroneously deducting a window below the conventional threshold or omitting the deduction of a major shaft skews actual surface assessments and undermines fair remuneration for the work.
Measurement method on plans and standard CAN thresholds
Calculating work quantities on working drawings requires strict adherence to measurement rules issued by the Swiss Research Centre for Building Rationalisation (CRB). The Swiss method is based on the principle of compensation: modestly sized openings are not deducted from the gross surface area, as the time needed to form reveals, lintels, embrasures or edges compensates for the unlaid material. Conversely, beyond a critical surface area defined by each chapter of the Standard Item Catalogue (CAN), the opening must be deducted entirely from the theoretical quantity takeoff.
Opening thresholds by CFC chapter and trade
In 2D CAD software and BIM models, the draftsperson or architect must configure filtering rules according to the exact nature of the load-bearing element or finishing layer:
- Masonry and reinforced concrete (CFC 211 / CAN 241): Window, door and clear openings less than or equal to 2,50 m² are not deducted. Slab penetrations and floor openings follow the same 2,50 m² rule. Beyond that, the opening is deducted entirely.
- Plastering and drywall partitions (CFC 241 / CAN 624): Door and window openings are measured gross up to 2,50 m². Ancillary works related to reveal edges form separate items measured by the linear metre once the area exceeds this threshold.
- Screeds and liquid waterproofing (CFC 251 / CAN 642): Penetrations, technical upstands and floor openings less than or equal to 1,00 m² remain in the gross measurement. Stair openings or service risers greater than 1,00 m² are deducted.
- Painting and wall finishes (CFC 285 / CAN 671): The non-deduction threshold is set at 2,50 m² for single openings. Lintels and returns below this limit are not measured as extra work if the void is not deducted.
- Tiling and natural stone finishes (CFC 272 / CAN 652): Unit areas of openings or obstructions less than or equal to 0,50 m² are subject to no deduction.
Comparative table of deduction thresholds on plans
| Trade (CFC / CAN) | Represented element | Non-deduction threshold | Processing rule on plans |
|---|---|---|---|
| Concrete and masonry (211) | Window / door opening | Area ≤ 2,50 m² | Gross measurement, opening not deducted |
| Reinforced concrete (211) | Slab shaft / service duct | Area ≤ 2,50 m² | Gross measurement, formwork calculated continuously |
| Plastering and partitions (241) | Internal glazed screen | Area ≤ 2,50 m² | Gross over net, linear trims excluded |
| Screeds and underlayments (251) | Floor service shaft | Area ≤ 1,00 m² | Continuous measurement of laying area |
| Wall tiling (272) | Niche or bathroom window | Area ≤ 0,50 m² | Continuous surface without deduction |
| Rainscreen facades (224) | External glazed opening | Area ≤ 2,50 m² | Framing and insulation measured continuously |
Takeoff errors on plans and contractual impacts
Omitting these criteria on plans causes major imbalances when drawing up the descriptive quote:
- Double counting: Deducting a 1,80 m² opening on the formwork plan and then adding linear measurements for stop-ends disadvantages the contractor.
- Overestimating quantities: Measuring gross over net for a 4,50 m² opening violates CAN rules and leads to disputes during joint measurement verification by site management.
- Financial variance: On a 40-unit residential project, improper deduction of service risers and reveals leads to billing discrepancies on the order of 15'000 to 45'000 CHF in the final account under standard SIA 118.
In a unit price enterprise contract governed by art. 363 CO and standard SIA 118, actual measurements take precedence over the initial drawing. If the contract is awarded at a lump-sum price under art. 373 CO, the contractor completes the work for the agreed sum and cannot claim any increase, even if measurements taken from the plan contained deduction discrepancies. Where the price was not determined in advance or was agreed on an indicative basis, remuneration is assessed according to the value of the work and the contractor's expenses under art. 374 CO.
Illustrative practical cases (typical scenarios on Swiss construction sites)
The figures and situations below are illustrative examples intended to guide measurement methodology:
Scenario 1: Residential building in the canton of Vaud
On a three-storey project in Lausanne involving an average workforce of eight workers, the ground floor formwork plan shows ten shafts for vertical risers of 0,72 m² each and two lift shafts of 3,60 m². The designer deducted all openings. Adopted correction: keeping the ten small shafts in gross area (each under 2,50 m² pursuant to CAN 241) and deducting only the two lift shafts. This difference avoids a dispute over slab quantities estimated at 4'800 CHF excl. VAT.
Scenario 2: Commercial building in the canton of Geneva
An office complex in Meyrin includes fifty 2,35 m² windows on clay brick masonry facades. The contractor challenged the lack of deduction, claiming an extra charge for precast lintels. The architectural firm confirmed the gross-over-net measurement in line with the official 2,50 m² threshold, while paying for the lintels under the specific item provided in the initial descriptive quote.
Surfaces, standards and permits: free tools
SIA 416 floor areas and volumes, cantonal zoning ratios, U-values and dew points, acoustics, planning enquiry requirements.
Frequently asked questions
How do you deduct a window opening on a CAN 211 masonry drawing?
According to the Standard Item Catalogue CAN 211, any opening less than or equal to the contractual surface threshold is not deducted from the gross takeoff invoiced by the contractor.
Who bears the cost of precast lintels spanning openings?
The enterprise contract governs remuneration pursuant to art. 363 CO. Lintels form specific items in the descriptive quote, often paid by the linear metre, for example around 85 CHF.
Must a slab penetration systematically be deducted from rebar quantities?
No, small shafts below the threshold of the CAN concrete chapter are not deducted, compensating for complex shaping and rebar reinforcement around the opening in question.
What should be done if there is a calculation discrepancy between the working drawing and the descriptive quote?
Standard SIA 118 establishes the hierarchy of contract documents. The descriptive quote based on the CAN generally takes precedence over graphic measurements regarding the calculation method.
How do you record a window modification approved during site execution?
The adjustment constitutes a change order under standard SIA 118. The financial impact is settled through a written addendum, with an extra cost estimated for example at around 450 CHF.
Does the plasterer deduct standard internal doors on a fit-out plan?
No, according to the CAN plastering-painting chapter, a standard door below the area threshold is not deducted, compensating for forming edges and complex perimeter cuts.
Mastering opening deduction rules guarantees rigorous contractual quantities and prevents tender disputes. Continue optimising your technical documentation with our guides:
- 3D Modelling, Pragmatic BIM (SIA 2051 / IFC) and Quantity Take-Off to SIA 451 Quotes in Switzerland
- SIA 2051 Technical Leaflet Explained Plainly: Implementing Pragmatic BIM in a Swiss Firm or Design Office
- Structuring 3D Objects and Layers According to eBKP-H (eCCC-Bât) and CFC Codes Right from the Sketch Stage
- Importing and Cleaning a Surveyor DWG / DXF File (Swiss MN95 Coordinates) without Bloating Your Plan
