Table of contents
The 3 Major Site Risks
- Financial / Margin: Misinterpretation of a 1:100 drawing by the contractor, leading to quantity surveying errors and illustrative cost overruns of around 10% on the item, impacting the contract for work (art. 363 CO).
- Legal / Joint / SUVA: Rejection of the application by the municipality due to insufficient detail at 1:100, blocking the building permit under the Federal Act on Spatial Planning (LAT).
- Administrative / Acceptance: Dispute during the joint inspection of the work (standard SIA 118) caused by a discrepancy between the architectural drawing and the 1:50 execution drawing, delaying handover.
The graphic representation of projects in Switzerland follows the rules of standard SIA 400. Moving from the project design phase to execution involves transitioning between scale 1:100 and 1:50. This distinction sets the level of detail, the precision of dimensioning and the information provided to contractors. The 1:100 drawing serves for public planning inquiries, whereas the 1:50 becomes the contractual reference document on the construction site.
For architects and site management, mastering these scales ensures compliant execution. Standard SIA 400 specifies the graphic elements required on each drawing. A poor transition to 1:50 causes uncertainties, exposing parties to disputes or defects. This article breaks down the specific requirements to keep your technical documentation robust.
Graphic requirements and level of detail under standard SIA 400
Standard SIA 400 strictly defines the representation of architectural and engineering drawings in Switzerland. Choosing the scale determines not only the legibility of the document, but also its legal standing under the contract for work defined by art. 363 CO.
Scale 1:100 corresponds to the developed design phase. It is required by municipalities for the public planning inquiry and obtaining the building permit, in compliance with the Federal Act on Spatial Planning (art. 22 LAT). At this stage, the drawing conveys overall massing, layout and room functions. Walls are generally solid-filled or hatched uniformly, without distinguishing individual constructive layers.
Scale 1:50 marks the transition to working drawings. This drawing becomes the reference document on the construction site for site management and successful contractors. At this scale, standard SIA 400 requires a clear differentiation of materials through specific hatching (concrete, masonry, insulation, timber). Actual cladding thicknesses, window reveals and blockouts for technical building services must appear precisely.
Comparative table: Scale 1:100 vs 1:50 (Standard SIA 400)
| Architectural element | Representation at 1:100 (Design / Planning Inquiry) | Representation at 1:50 (Execution / Construction site) | Contractual and technical impact |
|---|---|---|---|
| Walls and partitions | Overall representation, single hatching or solid fill. | Differentiation of layers (structural, insulation, facing) with standardised hatching. | Defines exact quantities for contractor billing. |
| Openings (doors, windows) | Schematic layout, basic door-swing direction. | Detailed frames, reveals, thresholds and lintels. | Enables custom manufacturing by the joiner without dimensioning errors. |
| Dimensions and levels | Overall dimensions, primary gridlines, basic running dimensions. | Detail dimensions, execution dimensions, precise finished and structural levels. | Prevents defects during execution and disputes at formal acceptance. |
| Building services installations | Indicative locations of main riser ducts. | Precise routing, dimensioned blockouts and penetrations in concrete and masonry. | Prevents unplanned core drilling and structural weakening. |
| Floor and wall finishes | Often omitted graphically or included within the overall thickness. | Thicknesses drawn graphically and dimensioned (screeds, tiling). | Ensures compliance with clear ceiling heights and thresholds. |
Common errors when transitioning to execution and financial consequences
One of the most critical errors on a Swiss construction site is using 1:100 drawings to execute works. This practice violates recognized trade standards and generates substantial uncertainty for tradesmen. Without the level of detail of a 1:50 drawing, the contractor must guess material thicknesses or blockout dimensions.
Misinterpreting drawings frequently results in defects in the work. If the client reports these defects (art. 367 CO), the contractor or designer can be held liable for remediation (art. 368 CO). The financial consequences are severe: a blockout error in a reinforced concrete slab caused by an insufficiently detailed drawing can generate illustrative cost overruns of around 3 000 to 8 000 CHF for corrective core drilling and structural retrofitting.
Another common error is a mismatch in running dimensions between the two scales. Standard SIA 400 demands absolute precision regarding reference elevations. A discrepancy overlooked by site management can stall the sign-off of key construction site milestones.
Illustrative practical cases (typical scenarios on Swiss construction sites)
These figures and situations are illustrative examples and do not represent actual construction sites.
Scenario 1: Construction of a residential building (Canton of Vaud)
Within a residential project employing a 15-worker crew for the structural work, the architecture firm submits a 1:100 application to the municipality for the building permit (art. 22 LAT). Once the permit is granted, site management requires 1:50 drawings for the masonry firm.
Selected approach and justification: The draftsman incorporates the standardised hatching from standard SIA 400 to distinguish reinforced concrete from clay brick and perimeter insulation. Execution dimensions are added. This level of detail is vital for the contractor to fulfil obligations (art. 364 CO) and deliver compliant work, preventing costly disputes during the inspection of the work.
Scenario 2: Conversion of an industrial hall (Canton of Fribourg)
A client plans the renovation of a hall with a significant works budget. The 1:50 execution drawings include the specific Swiss colour coding for conversions (grey for existing, red for new, yellow for demolitions).
Selected approach and justification: Strict application of standard SIA 400 at 1:50 enables the demolition contractor to calculate exact volumes for disposal. This also guarantees the proper sorting of mineral deconstruction waste, in compliance with the Waste Ordinance (OLED), and secures the agreed lump-sum price (art. 373 CO) by mitigating graphic misinterpretation risks of around 10 000 to 15 000 CHF.
Surfaces, standards and permits: free tools
SIA 416 floor areas and volumes, cantonal zoning ratios, U-values and dew points, acoustics, planning enquiry requirements.
Frequently asked questions
When should you switch from scale 1:100 to 1:50 under standard SIA 400?
The shift to 1:50 happens during the execution phase. Standard SIA 400 requires it to detail junctions, insulation and running dimensions essential for tradesmen.
Is a 1:100 planning inquiry drawing sufficient for the municipality?
Yes, for the building permit, 1:100 is the standard required by the LAT. It validates the layout, building envelopes and facades of the architectural design.
How should tolerances be handled on a 1:50 drawing?
Tolerances must be anticipated directly at the 1:50 drafting stage. Standard SIA 400 mandates accurate dimensioning, complemented by the guidelines of standard SIA 118 for execution.
Does the 1:50 drawing replace 1:20 details?
No, 1:50 coordinates trades. Complex assemblies, such as waterproofing, require 1:20 or 1:10 detail drawings per standard SIA 400 recommendations.
What is the financial impact of a scale error on a construction site?
Misreading a scale causes workmanship errors. Cost overruns, illustratively in the thousands of CHF, engage the contractor's liability under the Code of Obligations (CO).
Are site safety plans drawn at 1:50?
OTConst does not impose a strict scale, but 1:100 is generally preferred to view access routes, cranes and collective protections like perimeter guardrails.
Mastering scales 1:100 and 1:50 under standard SIA 400 ensures precise execution across Switzerland. Explore our resources dedicated to drafting standards:
- Standard SIA 400: Complete Guide to Architectural and Execution Drawings in Switzerland
- Swiss Colour Code on Renovation Plans (Grey Existing, Red New, Yellow Demolition - SIA 400)
- Cumulative Dimensions and Levels (±0.00 and m a.s.l. Pierre du Niton): SIA 400 Dimensioning Rules
- Standardised Material Hatching (SIA 400): Reinforced Concrete, Masonry, Insulation, Timber and Natural Ground
