Skip to content
Art ConstructionPortal
Practical guide

Delay Penalties (CO Contractual Penalties) vs Actual Damages: Calculation and Withholding

Delay penalties, CO contractual penalties and actual damages on Swiss sites. Calculation and deduction rules under the CO and SIA 118.

Table of contents
The 3 Major Site Risks
  1. Financial / Margin: Unjustified unilateral deduction on monthly payment certificates or the final account, causing a cash flow dispute of around 5% to 10% of the works contract amount (art. 363 CO). Under art. 161 CO, the agreed penalty is incurred even without proven damage, but if the damage exceeds the penalty, the creditor can claim a higher indemnity only by establishing fault on the part of the debtor. In addition, art. 163 CO requires the judge to reduce excessive penalties.
  2. Legal / Joint / SUVA: Legal confusion between default under art. 102 CO and contractual reminder mechanisms. The lack of formal notice or the absence of debtor accountability for the delay under art. 97 CO prevents proper enforcement of the contractual clause, paving the way for civil challenges without solid grounds.
  3. Administrative / Acceptance: Definitive forfeiture of the right to claim the agreed clause upon acceptance of the work. Pursuant to art. 160 CO, where the penalty is stipulated for non-performance at the agreed time, the client cannot demand both performance and the penalty if it accepts the work without formulating an express reservation during verification.

On Swiss construction sites, missing intermediate milestones or the completion date immediately raises the financial issue of client compensation. For site management and the client, the challenge lies in rigorously classifying the delay under standard SIA 118 and the Code of Obligations. A clear distinction must be made between the contractual penalty, which sanctions exceeding time limits irrespective of proof of direct loss under art. 161 CO, and an action for actual damages governed by art. 97 CO, which cumulatively requires showing an attributable delay, fault and actual financial loss quantified in Swiss francs.

This practical guide examines the contractual implementation of these deductions on advance payments, daywork accounts and the closing invoice. Construction management professionals must master the rules on formal notification, the duty to express reservations upon acceptance under art. 160 CO and the attribution criteria to secure their accounts without exposing the project to litigation.

Legal classification: Contractual penalty and compensation for damages under the Code of Obligations

In the practice of works contracts governed by the Code of Obligations or incorporating standard SIA 118, managing a schedule overrun requires a rigorous legal qualification of the claim the client intends to assert. Two distinct regimes coexist in Swiss law: the penalty clause, referred to as a contractual penalty, and the general action for damages for breach of contract.

Formation of the contract results from the reciprocal and matching expression of the parties' intent, in accordance with art. 1 CO. When the parties include a penalty clause for delivery delays, the rules of art. 160 CO apply. Under this provision, where the penalty is agreed for non-performance of the obligation at the stipulated time, the client may demand both performance of the work and payment of the agreed amount, provided it has not waived this right expressly or accepted the work without formulating an express reservation.

The evidentiary mechanism of the penalty clause offers a decisive benefit for the creditor. Under art. 161 CO, the contractual penalty falls due as soon as default is established, even if the creditor has suffered no direct damage. If the client sustains financial loss exceeding the lump sum of the clause, it can claim additional compensation only by establishing fault attributable to the contractor, as specified in art. 161 CO. The amount of this clause is set freely by the contracting parties under art. 163 CO, but the judge retains the duty to reduce amounts deemed excessive.

Conversely, in the absence of a penalty clause in the contract documents, the client must base its claim on the general regime of art. 97 CO. This course of action cumulatively requires proving a breach of contract through unjustified delay, actual economic loss calculated down to the cent, an adequate causal link, as well as fault on the part of the debtor, the latter being presumed unless the contractor proves that no fault is attributable to it.

Formal notice, counting of days and financial set-off

The right to make financial deductions arises only upon the formal occurrence of contractor default, governed by art. 102 CO. If the works contract specifies a precise calendar date for completion, the expiry of that day puts the debtor directly in default. If the deadline stems from an indicative master schedule without a fixed date, a written formal reminder from site management or the client remains essential to trigger the legal effects of delay.

For site management, the daily calculation must isolate disruptions attributable to the client, variation orders and exceptional weather conditions. As soon as the contractor realizes that an event jeopardizes the timely execution of the works, it must immediately inform the client or bear the consequences, in accordance with art. 365 CO. If the contractor fails to provide this prompt notice, it loses the benefit of an automatic extension of its execution deadlines.

The deduction from an advance payment certificate operates by way of set-off of claims. Site management must notify in writing the precise breakdown of deducted days of delay, the stipulated daily rate and the total amount deducted from the monthly certificate. This deduction must imperatively be formalized on each interim certificate to prevent any presumption of tacit acceptance of progress without reservation.

Comparison table: Contractual penalty versus actual damages

The choice of legal basis dictates the burden of proof, collection speed and procedural risk for the parties to the works contract:

Assessment criterion Contractual penalty (art. 160 CO) Actual damages (art. 97 CO)
Contractual basis Mandatory express clause in the works contract or particular conditions. Default statutory regime of the Code of Obligations, applicable even without a written clause.
Proof of loss No proof of damage required (art. 161 CO). The amount is a lump sum. Full accounting proof of the financial loss suffered with supporting vouchers.
Occurrence of default Expiry of the agreed date or formal reminder under art. 102 CO. Mandatory formal notice under art. 102 CO, accompanied by a notice of delay.
Judicial power of reduction The judge reduces manifestly excessive amounts ex officio under art. 163 CO. The amount awarded strictly corresponds to compensation for proven loss.
Continued performance Cumulative claim of performance and penalty allowed if agreed for time (art. 160 CO). Right to set a grace period for performance or claim compensation under art. 107 CO.
Reservation right at acceptance Mandatory express written reservation upon acceptance to safeguard the claim. Recommended reservation during verification of the work to maintain the claim.

Common management errors and financial impacts on site

Poor control of contractual procedures regularly leads to the complete loss of financial deductions for the client, or to cash flow freezes harmful to the entire construction site:

  • Lack of reservations upon acceptance of the work: The most damaging error consists of signing the verification report without expressly mentioning the reservation of the contractual penalty. Under art. 160 CO, acceptance without reservation extinguishes the right to demand the penalty stipulated for the agreed time. For a finishing work contract of 450 000 CHF, omitting this entry forfeits a delay claim of around 35 000 CHF.
  • Confusion between liquidated damages and cumulative losses: Demanding both the agreed daily penalty and actual rehousing costs without proving specific fault breaches art. 161 CO. A client who unilaterally deducts both amounts risks having to refund the unproven portion with default interest at 5% per annum under art. 104 CO.
  • Failure to issue a reminder under a flexible schedule: Treating a provisional execution schedule as a series of firm dates without issuing a formal reminder (art. 102 CO) prevents default from arising. On a structural work site, the cancellation of a 60 000 CHF deduction can be ordered due to defective formal notice.
  • Unilateral deduction without a joint account: Making a blunt cut on the final payment (art. 372 CO) without producing a substantiated daily breakdown exposes the client to conciliation proceedings and the registration of a statutory mortgage lien of craftsmen and contractors under art. 837 CC.

Illustrative practical cases (typical scenarios on Swiss construction sites)

The figures and situations presented below are illustrative examples designed to guide the practice of construction professionals.

Scenario 1: Residential building in the canton of Vaud (CFC 211 Structural work)

On a construction site for three rental apartment buildings in Lausanne, the masonry firm holds a works contract (art. 363 CO) stipulating a contractual penalty of 1 500 CHF per working day of delay against the contractual master schedule, capped at 10% of the total contract sum, i.e. a maximum amount of 180 000 CHF. Planned average staffing was 14 workers on site.

A delay of 24 working days is identified when pouring the top slab. The firm invokes rainy spells, but issued no formal notice of interruption under art. 365 CO during the works. Site management, acting on behalf of and representing the client under agency rules (art. 32 CO), applies the contractual penalty rules (art. 160 CO):

  • Drafting of the joint inspection record of overrun: 24 gross days of delay.
  • Deduction of 4 days justified by adverse weather recorded by the cantonal weather station that prevented safe working conditions.
  • Net attributable delay: 20 days at 1 500 CHF, giving a total amount of 30 000 CHF.
  • Application of the deduction to monthly advance payment certificate number 6, with immediate written notification and formal recording of reservations for the acceptance report.

Scenario 2: Office renovation in the canton of Geneva (CFC 232 Electrical installations)

In a commercial building in Geneva's banking district, heavy electrical installation works run 30 days past the mutually agreed completion date. The contract contained no contractual penalty clause. The installer mobilized a team of 6 technicians.

The client suffers direct loss: postponed move-in of the commercial tenant, entailing rent compensation of 45 000 CHF, as well as extended site management costs amounting to 12 000 CHF. Under art. 97 CO, the client places the contractor in default (art. 102 CO) and proves organizational fault by the debtor, who unilaterally pulled workers off this site to staff another. The actual damage of 57 000 CHF forms the subject of a claim substantiated by the landlord's accounting vouchers and the additional fee invoice, notified before final payment for the work.

Contracts and SIA 118: free tools

Advance payments and retentions, surety bonds, price escalations, daywork reports, subcontractor monitoring.

View the contracts and SIA 118 tools

Frequently asked questions

Can a contractual penalty and performance of the work be combined under the Code of Obligations?

Yes. Under art. 160 CO, when the contractual penalty sanctions non-compliance with the agreed deadline, the creditor may cumulatively claim performance and the penalty, provided formal reservations are expressed upon acceptance of the work without expressly waiving them.

Must actual financial loss be proven to claim the agreed penalty?

No. Under art. 161 CO, the contractual penalty remains due even if the client has suffered no quantifiable loss. In contrast, claiming additional financial compensation requires proving a greater loss as well as fault on the part of the defaulting contractor.

Does a Swiss judge have the power to reduce an excessive contractual penalty ex officio?

Yes. Under art. 163 CO, the judge must reduce penalties deemed excessive, although the parties are free to determine the contractual amount. This judicial reduction protects economic proportionality against disproportionate withholdings in the final account.

What action can the client take if delay makes completion on time impossible?

Pursuant to art. 366 CO, if accumulated delay prevents the agreed completion, the client may withdraw from the contract without waiting for the deadline. They may also set a reasonable deadline before entrusting continuation of the works to a third party at the contractor's expense.

Is a prior formal notice required to withhold the contractual penalty?

Under art. 102 CO, default occurs as soon as the mutually agreed deadline expires. Art. 108 CO dispenses with a reminder if the contract specifies a strict execution date or if the contractor's conduct makes any formal notice futile.

What formal reservations must be entered in the acceptance report under standard SIA 118?

The site management must immediately enter written reservations regarding delay during the inspection under standard SIA 118. Pursuant to art. 160 CO, accepting performance without reservation extinguishes the right to claim the penalty stipulated for delay: reservations must therefore be stated upon taking possession.

Mastering project schedules requires a clear distinction between a lump-sum contractual penalty and compensation for direct loss on the statement. To consolidate your intervention schedules, phase trades, and manage contractor defaults legally under the Code of Obligations (CO) and standard SIA 118, explore our dedicated resources:

Art Construction is an independent company: it is not affiliated with the SIA, CRB, SUVA, or KBOB. Referenced norms and standards point to publications from these bodies; only official versions are legally binding.