Table of contents
The 3 Major Site Risks
- Financial / Margin: An initial underestimation of labour costs can result in an operating loss of roughly 15 % to 30 % on the awarded lot. Under art. 38 LMP, an abnormally low total price triggers a formal request for information, exposing the firm to financial insolvency before completion if the justifications fail.
- Legal / Joint Body / SUVA: Failure to comply with the minimum wages set by extended collective agreements exposes the contractor to administrative sanctions under art. 9 LDét of up to 30 000 francs or a service ban, as well as cantonal prosecution under art. 18 LTN in the event of obstruction of cantonal monitoring bodies.
- Administrative / Acceptance: Inability to demonstrate price viability or compliance with participation conditions leads to rejection under art. 44 LMP, which provides for exclusion from the procedure if a bidder submits an abnormally low tender without proving that required conditions are met.
In Swiss public procurement, submitting a price significantly below the contracting authority's estimates or the average of competing bids triggers a rigorous review procedure. Quantity surveyors, estimators, and building firm owners must master the evaluation mechanisms laid down in federal and intercantonal legislation. Under art. 38 LMP, when the contracting authority receives a tender whose total price is abnormally low, it must request the relevant information from the bidder to verify that the terms of participation are met and that the requirements of the call for tenders have been understood. This process protects the awarding authority against operational defaults and ensures fair competition.
This review focuses primarily on compliance with working conditions and the prevention of wage dumping, governed by art. 12 LMP at the place of performance. Construction firms must provide clear justification for their price breakdown structure, the provenance of their supplies, and strict compliance with binding minimum wages under collective agreements. Failing to supply convincing explanations exposes the bidder to the measures set out in art. 44 LMP: the contracting authority may exclude the bidder on the basis of sufficient indications whenever an abnormally low tender fails to prove compliance with legal and contractual requirements.
Analysis criteria and examination methodology for an abnormally low tender
The contracting authority uses a precise body of indicators to identify a disproportionately low financial offer. The review of tenders under art. 38 LMP involves a two-step analysis: first, identifying a significant discrepancy compared to the client's estimates or the average of admissible tenders; second, issuing a mandatory request for clarification to the bidder. This formal adversarial procedure ensures that participation requirements are respected and that technical specifications have been understood without ambiguity.
For structural work or civil engineering estimators, this review focuses on direct cost items. The unit prices breakdown must demonstrate that planned hourly outputs align with trade best practice and that labour rates include all mandatory social and statutory components. The contracting authority does not penalize organizational efficiency or innovative building methods, but rather obvious underpricing that threatens the proper performance of the works.
Monitoring compliance with working conditions and minimum wages
Social compliance forms the mandatory screening threshold under art. 12 LMP. The contracting authority verifies that the bidder and its subcontractors apply the working conditions in force at the place of performance, specifically the minimum wages established by collective agreements declared generally binding under the LECCT, or by cantonal standard employment contracts. Using posted workers requires strict oversight regarding the net minimum wage defined in art. 8a ODét, after deduction of social security contributions and withholding taxes.
The general contractor or prime contractor remains liable under the duty of due diligence set out in art. 8c ODét. It must establish verifiable organizational and contractual measures to ensure that the entire subcontracting chain complies with these minimum standards, or face joint and several liability under art. 5 LDét if breaches are identified.
Verification of supplies, plant, and execution methods
When a lump-sum price or a specific unit item falls well below baseline values, the bidder must justify its productivity gains through objective evidence:
- Supply purchasing terms negotiated directly with manufacturers or material distributors, supported by firm quotes free of one-sided price revision clauses;
- The deployment of fully amortized company-owned machinery and equipment, lowering job-site operating expenses in line with the contractor's obligation to supply its own equipment under art. 364 CO;
- Prefabrication processes or authorized technical alternatives that demonstrably shorten on-site installation times;
- No underpricing of Site Installations or safety measures mandated by Swiss construction site regulations.
Comparative overview: Legitimate cost optimization versus unlawful wage dumping
The table below details the evaluation criteria applied by contracting authorities when assessing tender plausibility under art. 29 LMP and art. 38 LMP:
| Cost item analyzed | Legitimate cost optimization (Admissible tender) | Underbidding or dumping practice (Ground for exclusion) | Swiss legal and contractual framework |
|---|---|---|---|
| Labour and wages | Strict application of extended CLA wage scales, optimizing site crews through exact qualifications. | Hourly pay below net minimum wages or evasion of mandatory social security contributions. | Art. 12 LMP, art. 2 LDét, art. 8a ODét, and art. 1 LECCT |
| Installation output rates | Production rates substantiated by modern mechanized plant or shop-prefabricated components. | Unrealistic hours allocated in the bill of quantities without technical justification, concealing undeclared work. | Art. 29 LMP, art. 38 LMP, and art. 364 CO |
| Specialist subcontracting | Engaging vetted local partners registered with joint professional bodies holding valid certificates. | Multi-tier subcontracting without compliance checks, breach of art. 8c ODét, and risk of illegal employment. | Art. 31 LMP, art. 5 LDét, and art. 6 LTN |
| Material supplies | Framework supply agreements featuring firm price guarantees and documented volume discounts. | Assuming below-market purchase prices without formal vendor agreements; one-sided speculation. | Art. 365 CO and art. 373 CO |
| Overheads and margin | Reduced overhead rate achieved through lean management structure and closely calculated gross margin. | Complete elimination of margins or selling below cost designed to eliminate competitors artificially. | Art. 2 LMP, art. 11 LMP, and art. 44 LMP |
Common pricing errors and financial risks for the bidder
Misjudging statutory requirements when establishing tender pricing creates immediate, detrimental consequences for a building firm:
The first mistake is undercutting hourly wages of posted workers by disregarding mandatory statutory deductions. If the main contracting company fails to perform the verifications required by art. 8b ODét, it faces administrative fines of up to 5000 francs under art. 9 LDét for breach of due diligence, independent of civil liability under joint and several guarantees for unpaid wages under art. 5 LDét.
The second pitfall involves intentionally omitting certain indirect costs to secure the award under art. 41 LMP, hoping to recover losses later through addenda. Art. 373 CO establishes that under a fixed-price contract, the contractor must carry out the work for the agreed sum and cannot demand an increase even if the work required more expenditure, except under extraordinary, unforeseeable circumstances.
Lastly, submitting vague or evasive documentation when queried under art. 38 LMP leads straight to exclusion under art. 44 LMP. On sufficient indications of an abnormally low tender without proof of compliance with terms of participation, the authority rejects the tender without examining its substance, causing the loss of preliminary study costs that routinely exceed 15 000,00 CHF on major projects.
Illustrative practical cases (typical scenarios on Swiss construction sites)
The figures presented below are illustrative examples formulated for technical analysis and do not correspond to any specific contract.
Standard Scenario 1: Structural work in the Canton of Vaud (Earthworks and reinforced concrete)
A contracting authority launches an open call for tenders for the reinforced concrete structural work of a municipal facility, with an initial cost estimate of 2 850 000,00 CHF including taxes (8,1 % VAT included). A masonry contractor submits a tender of 1 995 000,00 CHF incl. VAT, representing a price gap of 30 % below the estimate and 25 % below the competitors' average.
Queried under art. 38 LMP, the firm files documentation proving that the entire planned workforce (12 skilled workers) is employed under the cantonal Vaud collective agreement, backed by certificates from joint professional bodies. To justify the price difference of 855 000,00 CHF, the bidder proves it owns a fleet of fully amortized metal formwork systems suited to the geometry of the structure and holds an annual ready-mix concrete supply contract granting substantial rebates. The authority confirms technical viability, checks social compliance certificates, and confirms the admissibility of the tender without issuing an exclusion.
Standard Scenario 2: Finishing work in the Canton of Geneva (Joinery and dry lining)
As part of an office refurbishment project in Geneva involving a lightweight partition wall lot estimated at 620 000,00 CHF incl. VAT, a company submits a tender at 390 000,00 CHF incl. VAT. The project specification provides for the deployment of six posted installers.
Upon the contracting authority's request for clarification, the firm provides cost breakdowns reflecting net wages below the mandatory floors set by collective agreements declared generally binding under art. 1 LECCT. The main contractor fails to prove compliance with art. 8a ODét and presents no organizational compliance agreement satisfying art. 8c ODét. The contracting authority identifies non-compliance with the working conditions cited in art. 12 LMP and formally excludes the tender under art. 44 LMP for an unsubstantiated, abnormally low tender and breach of mandatory social regulations.
Calls for tenders: free tools
Direct public procurement tenders, AIMP thresholds by canton, converting SIA 451 to Excel, quantity takeoff from an IFC model.
Frequently asked questions
How do contracting authorities detect abnormally low tenders in Swiss public procurement?
Under art. 38 LMP, the contracting authority checks the plausibility of the total price against the project's technical estimates. If a quote of 540 000,00 CHF incl. VAT reveals an excessive deviation, the authority is legally required to seek comprehensive written clarifications to ensure strict compliance with participation criteria and minimum wages.
Does an exceptional last-minute discount warrant immediate exclusion under the AIMP?
No, art. 38 LMP prohibits disqualification without a prior hearing. The contracting authority must invite the bidder to justify its price breakdown. Art. 44 LMP permits exclusion only if the contractor fails to prove legal compliance or is unable to demonstrate the financial viability of its pricing.
What liability falls on the main contractor regarding subcontractors under the LDét?
Under art. 5 LDét, the contracting main contractor is jointly and severally liable for any failure by subcontractors to pay net minimum wages. Art. 9 LDét provides for administrative sanctions of up to 5000 francs or a ban on offering services if you breach your statutory duty of due diligence on the construction site.
How do you document your duty of due diligence under the federal posted workers ordinances?
The ODét requires taking the necessary organisational and contractual steps. The main award winner must obtain a certificate from the joint paritarian bodies or proof of entry in a recognised register from the subcontractor. If a lack of monitoring is established, the authority may impose the administrative sanctions set out in art. 9 LDét.
What is the statutory deadline to appeal against a price-related exclusion decision?
Under art. 56 LMP, a reasoned appeal must be filed in writing within 20 days of official notification. The review focuses strictly on legality, as the contentious appeal authority cannot examine the appropriateness of the award decision.
How can you prove the viability of a low price without breaching the requirements of art. 12 LMP?
Art. 12 LMP makes the award conditional on compliance with working conditions and LTN obligations. The bidder must produce genuine CAN calculation sheets, showing that its competitive edge stems from innovative technical methods or fully depreciated plant, without falling below the minimum wages of the applicable collective labour agreements.
Mastering compliant pricing and strictly vetting subcontractors are essential safeguards against exclusion from a public procurement procedure. To secure your tenders and manage your files efficiently, explore our dedicated practical guides:
- AIMP/LMP Legal Framework, ISAB/CLA Certificates, Appeals and Litigation
- Joint Committee Certificates: ISAB, CLA and National Agreement, How to Obtain Them
- Grounds for Tender Disqualification Under the AIMP: Formal Defects and Excessive Formalism
- Correcting Calculation Errors in a Tender: Arithmetic and Limitations
