Skip to content
Art ConstructionTenders
Practical guide

Correcting Calculation Errors in Tenders: Arithmetic and Limits

Ex officio correction of arithmetic calculation errors in public tenders under LMP and AIMP. Rules and limits for Swiss estimators.

Table of contents
The 3 Major Site Risks
  1. Financial / Margin: An uncorrected multiplication or carry-over error can force the contractor to execute an item at a loss under the lump-sum price regime of art. 373 CO, eroding gross margins by an illustrative order of magnitude of 15% to 25% on the affected lot.
  2. Legal / Joint / SUVA: The unilateral arithmetic correction of an underestimated unit price can lead to the bid's exclusion under art. 44 LMP for inadmissible bid modification, or trigger an in-depth audit of wages and social security contributions under art. 12 LMP.
  3. Administrative / Acceptance: The contracting authority's refusal to acknowledge a transmission error can lead to the formal exclusion of the tender under art. 38 LMP, stalling validation of the award file before any formal conclusion of the works contract.

During the evaluation of a public or private call for tenders in Switzerland, detecting a calculation discrepancy confronts estimators and site supervisors with a strict line between legitimate formal correction and prohibited substantive modification. Art. 38 LMP expressly grants the contracting authority the power and duty to correct ex officio any obvious calculation errors found in bills of quantities. This intervention aims to restore strict arithmetic consistency in the tender without altering the bidder's true intent, thereby preserving the equal treatment enshrined in art. 11 LMP and the transparency of competitive bidding.

However, this prerogative can under no circumstances be used to rescue a bid distorted by structural underpricing or the deliberate omission of services described in the CAN catalogue of standard articles. Practice rigorously distinguishes a purely mechanical clerical error, such as a clearly mistaken quantity-price product on a line of the bill of quantities, from a technical misjudgement regarding production rates. Bid managers must master these legal boundaries to prevent the exclusion of their file under art. 44 LMP or the formation of a works contract based on an unsustainable lump-sum price within the meaning of art. 373 CO.

Typology and legal qualification of calculation errors

The formal review of bids requires drawing an unambiguous line between an obvious calculation error and an unlawful substantive modification. Under art. 38 LMP, the contracting authority verifies compliance with formal requirements and corrects obvious calculation errors ex officio. This statutory prerogative applies whenever a simple arithmetic operation can restore the initial intent expressed in the tender without interpretation. Conversely, art. 11 LMP prohibits any price negotiations, strictly ruling out any intervention aimed at changing the substance of the bid or adapting price bases after the submission deadline.

Rectifiable obvious calculation errors

An arithmetic anomaly is deemed obvious when it is directly apparent from the tender document without requiring external assumptions. It stems from simple inadvertence in calculation or typing when finalising the quote:

  • Elementary multiplication error: the product of the unit price and the quantity shown in the bill of quantities does not match the total amount for the item.
  • Vertical addition error: the arithmetic addition of items in a work section or the general summary of sections contains a numerical discrepancy.
  • Carry-over error: incorrect transcription of a page or section subtotal to the general summary sheet of the bid.
  • Rate carry-over error: application of an incorrect VAT rate even though the pre-tax amount and statutory rate are explicitly set out in the tender documents.

Non-rectifiable substantive appraisal errors

An economic or technical appraisal error affects the building blocks of the unit price. Under no circumstances may it be corrected by the contracting authority, as this would violate the equal treatment enshrined in art. 11 LMP:

  • Deliberate or inadvertent omission of an entire item: the bidder entered no unit price for a required service.
  • Underestimation of execution paces and crew outputs, whether deliberate or through lack of knowledge.
  • Misjudgement of site constraints, logistical difficulties or geological conditions.
  • Internal error in the breakdown of the unit price, such as an unseen reduction in labour costs or raw material prices.

Normative hierarchy and priority rule of unit prices

Administrative doctrine and tender specifications consistently apply the absolute precedence of the unit price over the total price of the line item. The contractor makes a legal commitment based on the unit amount applied to the prescribed unit of measurement. As soon as a discrepancy arises between the multiplication of the quantity by the unit price and the line total, the authority corrects the total amount while keeping the unit price intact.

Under art. 38 LMP, the contracting authority may request explanations from bidders when the grounds for the anomaly remain ambiguous. Such clarification requests must be strictly limited to elucidating the visible error, without allowing any retroactive adjustment to the base price. If the automatic correction leads to a substantial reduction in the overall amount, the authority applies art. 38 LMP to request relevant information to check the technical and financial plausibility of the service. If the bidder insists on changing its unit price by claiming a mere input error, the bid risks exclusion from the procedure pursuant to art. 44 LMP for inadmissible bid modification after opening.

Processing matrix for tender calculation anomalies

Nature of the detected anomalyTechnical finding in the bill of quantitiesRegulatory processing by the authorityConsequence on financial ranking
Multiplication discrepancyExact unit price, incorrect line resultEx officio correction under art. 38 LMPUnit price maintained, total adjusted
Addition error in a sectionSum of lines differs from subtotalAutomatic arithmetic correctionRecalculation of total bid amount
Omission of a mandatory unit priceUnit price box left blankRefusal to complete, risk under art. 44 LMPExclusion of the bid for formal defect
Carry-over error to the summarySection subtotal incorrectly transcribedEx officio correction based on detailsRestoration of true arithmetic sum
Application of an incorrect tax rateVAT calculation inconsistent with statutory rateEx officio correction to the statutory rate of 8,1 %Mechanical adjustment of final incl. VAT total
Item priced with a conflicting unitPrice stated per 100 m² instead of per unitClarification without altering intentCorrection if the intention is unambiguous

Common errors and financial impacts of ex officio corrections

A poor grasp of the rectification mechanism has direct financial consequences for the bidding firm. When the contracting authority corrects an arithmetic error, the amended amount becomes binding on the successful bidder, with no option to renegotiate the agreed price bases.

Margin loss through upward correction of quantities

When an estimator inputs an absurdly low unit price thinking it offsets a small volume, the automatic correction of an incorrect carry-over can lock in a contractual duty to execute at a loss. In accordance with the definition of a works contract in art. 363 CO and the contractor's duties under art. 364 CO, the contractor must execute the promised work with due care. If the bid leads to a unit-price contract or a lump-sum price contract based on art. 373 CO, the contractor cannot claim any increase on grounds of an arithmetic undervaluation it committed itself.

On a finishing work lot with an initial amount of 450 000,00 CHF, a simple typographical error on a partitioning item inadvertently reducing a unit price from 85,00 CHF to 8,50 CHF causes, after ex officio correction by the contracting authority, an immediate cash shortfall in the range of 42 000,00 CHF to 68 000,00 CHF. This imbalance completely wipes out the construction site's projected margin.

Exclusion following the emergence of an abnormally low price

The ex officio correction of an addition error can push the total bid amount below the financial anomaly threshold. The contracting authority is then forced to open the detailed examination procedure laid down in art. 38 LMP. If the firm cannot prove its ability to comply with working conditions, minimum wages, or the commercial viability of its operations, the contracting authority issues an exclusion order pursuant to art. 44 LMP.

Illustrative practical cases (typical scenarios on Swiss construction sites)

The figures presented in the following scenarios are illustrative examples developed for technical and legal analysis, and do not represent executed contracts.

Scenario 1: Ex officio correction in a structural work contract (Canton of Vaud)

In a public tender for the construction of a school complex in the canton of Vaud, a general contractor deploys a team of 14 workers. The quote comprises 420 items. During data entry, the estimator enters a quantity of 850 m³ with a unit price of 240,00 CHF for the reinforced concrete raft slab item, but mistakenly inputs a line total of 24 000,00 CHF instead of 204 000,00 CHF.

During formal examination, the engineering office applies the unit price priority rule and corrects the item total ex officio to 204 000,00 CHF pursuant to art. 38 LMP. The tender total consequently increases from 3 120 000,00 CHF to 3 300 000,00 CHF incl. VAT. The firm's bid, initially ranked first financially, drops to third place in the comparison table. The contracting authority applies art. 41 LMP and awards the contract to the bidder submitting the most advantageous tender based on the corrected ranking, leaving the penalised firm unable to dispute this purely arithmetic operation.

Scenario 2: Addition discrepancy in a plumbing & sanitary installations lot (Canton of Geneva)

In Geneva, a building services SME with 8 workers submits a bid for the refurbishment of soil stacks in a municipal housing complex. The total amount displayed at the end of the tender is 184 250,00 CHF. When checking the subtotals across the five work sections, the authority finds that the true arithmetic sum stands at 214 250,00 CHF incl. VAT, an intermediate carry-over having omitted a partial subtotal of 30 000,00 CHF.

The contracting authority applies art. 38 LMP and restores the correct total amount ex officio to 214 250,00 CHF. The contractor attempts to request an equivalent lump-sum discount to maintain its initial total of 184 250,00 CHF. The authority categorically rejects this request pursuant to art. 11 LMP, which prohibits price negotiations after bid opening. The firm is kept in the procedure with its corrected amount of 214 250,00 CHF, thereby protecting the competitive fairness of the process.

Calls for tenders: free tools

Direct public procurement tenders, AIMP thresholds by canton, converting SIA 451 to Excel, quantity takeoff from an IFC model.

View tendering tools

Frequently asked questions

Who bears the error if the product of the quantity and unit price is wrong?

Under art. 38 LMP, the contracting authority corrects obvious calculation errors ex officio by restoring the exact arithmetic product. The unit price always takes precedence over the line total. The contractor remains strictly bound by its original unit price without any option to adjust its pricing schedule.

Can the contracting authority alter an obviously underestimated unit price?

No. Art. 11 LMP prohibits any price negotiations. An erroneous unit, such as 12,50 CHF instead of 125,00 CHF, does not constitute an arithmetic error that can be corrected ex officio. The authority must question the bidder under art. 38 LMP regarding the financial plausibility of the bid.

Does a discrepancy between the summary total and the breakdown lead to exclusion?

A simple addition discrepancy constitutes a transcription error corrected ex officio pursuant to art. 38 LMP. However, art. 44 LMP permits exclusion if the discrepancy reveals an incomplete or contradictory tender preventing an objective comparison, which then amounts to a fatal formal defect for the contracting authority.

Can the ranking of tenders change after an ex officio rectification?

Yes. The arithmetic recalculation alters the decisive total amount of the tender. Art. 41 LMP requires awarding the contract to the most advantageous tender based on the rectified amounts. A tenderer originally ranked first may thus lose their position to a competitor.

Does the contractor have the right to refuse the rectification carried out?

No. The contractor cannot refuse an arithmetic rectification performed in accordance with public procurement rules. If they refuse to execute the works at the rectified total price, their tender is rejected for failure to maintain their offer, without prejudice to the contractual rules of art. 363 CO upon award.

What appeal can be lodged if a competitor's rectification violates equal treatment?

Any aggrieved competitor may challenge the award decision by invoking art. 11 LMP. A reasoned appeal in writing must be lodged within a 20-day deadline under art. 56 LMP from official notification, in order to sanction a disguised substantive amendment to the competing tender.

Bill of quantities validation and legal compliance

The distinction between the ex officio rectification of an arithmetic error and the prohibited modification of tender content protects fairness in public procurement across Switzerland. Absolute accuracy during unit pricing avoids the trap of formal defects or downgrading when envelopes are opened.

To delve deeper into the rigorous management of your tender files, consult our specialised analyses:

Art Construction is an independent company: it is not affiliated with the SIA, CRB, SUVA, or KBOB. Referenced norms and standards point to publications from these bodies; only official versions are legally binding.