Skip to content
Art ConstructionTenders
Practical guide

Simap Q&A Forum: Strategy and Anonymity

Master the Simap Q&A forum: bidder anonymity, clarification strategy, and compliance with Swiss LMP principles. Secure your public procurement bids.

Table of contents
The 3 Major Site Risks
  1. Financial / Margin: Late discovery of an unclarified ambiguity in the work description, causing an unexpected gross margin reduction of 8% to 15% of the award sum (often exceeding 45 000,00 CHF on a technical lot), due to the inability to claim additional compensation under a lump-sum price pursuant to art. 373 CO if the tenderer failed to ask the question on the official forum.
  2. Legal / Joint Body / SUVA: Inadvertent disclosure of proprietary processes or breach of confidentiality when drafting a query, prompting the contracting authority to note a violation of art. 11 LMP (respect for the confidentiality of tenderers' information) or grounds for exclusion from the procedure under art. 44 LMP in the event of direct communication outside the Simap platform, treated as illicit contact.
  3. Administrative / Acceptance: Formal rejection of the tender or inadmissibility of subsequent claims during bid evaluation under art. 38 LMP, as the contracting authority dismisses any dispute regarding ambiguities in the tender documents if no formal clarification request was submitted within the deadlines set by the Simap forum.

The question-and-answer forum integrated into the Simap public procurement platform serves as the exclusive channel through which contracting authorities and tendering companies exchange requests for technical and legal clarifications. In public calls for tenders governed by the LMP or AIMP, any direct bilateral interaction between a tenderer and the contracting authority is strictly prohibited to ensure the procedural transparency, equal treatment, and non-discrimination required under art. 2 LMP. Estimators, site managers, and bid managers must approach this forum not merely as a technical messaging board, but as a strategic tool determining the future contractual scope of the project.

Every published question becomes visible to all competitors once validated by the contracting authority, requiring absolute tactical discipline to resolve ambiguities in the quote without revealing your firm's cost engineering or construction variant. The technical anonymity provided by Simap's platform does not protect against careless wording that exposes a specialist's identity or a unique installation technique. Methodically structuring your forum interventions prevents having to absorb the extra costs of an undervalued item and safeguards your tender's compliance before final submission.

The exchange forum available on the official Simap platform serves as the central mechanism ensuring the neutrality of federal, cantonal, and communal public procurement. When a firm downloads tender documents for an open procedure under art. 18 LMP or a selective procedure under art. 19 LMP, it frequently identifies discrepancies across contract documents, such as divergences between tender drawings and the items in the itemised description. Under art. 11 LMP, the contracting authority must uphold the principles of transparency, objectivity, impartiality, and equal treatment, while strictly prohibiting price negotiations and safeguarding the confidentiality of tenderers' information. The forum puts these principles into practice by centralising all requests for technical or legal clarification raised during the consultation phase.

In practice, each question submitted by a bidder is recorded in a secure interface. The contracting authority or appointed site management reviews the queries and compiles the answers into an official circular, commonly designated as an addendum or modification bulletin. In accordance with LMP and AIMP requirements, all submitted questions and their complete answers are issued simultaneously and without discrimination to every tenderer who collected the dossier. This multilateral circulation restores the level playing field required by art. 2 LMP. It governs the validity of future tenders and applies to the evaluation conducted under art. 41 LMP to identify the most advantageous offer.

Preserving anonymity and preventing competitive disclosure

The critical challenge in every forum intervention lies in how questions are phrased. While the Simap platform ensures technical anonymity by concealing the sender's identity from rival firms and, depending on administrative settings, from the contracting authority prior to the award, careless drafting can easily compromise that shield. Art. 11 LMP formally mandates respect for the confidentiality of tenderers' information, but this provision does not protect a company against its own inadvertent disclosures within the text of a message.

Disclosing your identity or methodology allows competitors to deduce an estimating department's cost structure, anticipate a consortium under art. 530 CO, or identify logistical vulnerabilities. To lock down practical anonymity, the bid manager must enforce rigorous discipline: eliminate proprietary terminology tied to company patents, omit explicit references to regular subcontractors, and avoid naming identifiable regional brands or suppliers. The following table summarises key decision criteria for deciding whether to ask a question, remain silent, or rephrase the query from a neutral, standards-based perspective.

Technical situation encounteredOperational or commercial riskRecommended decisionFormulation strategy on SimapLegal or standards basis
Discrepancy between formwork drawing and CAN descriptionVolume discrepancy and underestimation of the lump-sum priceSubmit the question formallyHighlight the numerical contradiction without suggesting proprietary methodsArt. 373 CO and art. 11 LMP
Proprietary execution variant providing a cost advantageDisclosure of know-how to direct competitorsRefrain from asking a direct questionSubmit the approach as an alternative tender if tender rules permitArt. 11 LMP and art. 31 LMP
Disproportionate technical qualification requirementUnjustified disqualification during eligibility screeningSubmit the question immediatelyEnquire about the equivalence of references without citing your own plant fleetArt. 2 LMP and art. 44 LMP
Ambiguity regarding mandatory material sourcingMajor procurement cost overrun that cannot be passed onSubmit the question formallySubmit a formal clarification requestArt. 29 LMP and art. 365 CO
Imprecision of the overall execution scheduleVagueness in the overall construction scheduleSubmit the question formallyUnwarranted application of delay penaltiesArt. 102 CO and art. 366 CO

Recurring forum mistakes and financial consequences on tenders

An analysis of unsuccessful tenders reveals three primary mistakes made by companies on the Simap forum. The first failure is inaction when faced with a glaring omission in the documents. When a tenderer notices an omission in the bill of quantities but chooses to remain silent hoping to bill extra work during execution, they expose themselves to severe legal disappointment. Under art. 373 CO, an agreed lump-sum price binds the contractor, who cannot claim an increase even if the works required more labour or expenditure. If the ambiguity was detectable through the standard diligence expected under art. 364 CO, the contracting authority will deny any addendum, leaving the financial burden entirely on the tenderer. On a finishing work lot worth 350 000,00 CHF, such an omission regularly produces an unexpected net loss of 28 500,00 CHF to 42 000,00 CHF (incl. 8,1 % VAT).

The second error is aggressive or personalised drafting. Questioning the contracting authority by challenging its competence or referring to discussions held during a preliminary meeting instantly alerts competitors to the author's identity. Finally, the third mistake is submitting a question too late, beyond the deadline set in the official notice. The contracting authority will then reject the query without review, leaving the firm to bid with major uncertainty or risk bid rejection for formal defects under art. 44 LMP.

Illustrative practical cases (typical scenarios on Swiss construction sites)

The figures and scenarios presented below are illustrative examples developed for the methodological analysis of public procurement in Switzerland.

Typical Scenario 1: Detecting a contradictory earthworks clause in the Canton of Vaud

A general contractor for structural work employing 38 staff is preparing a bid for the construction of a communal school in the Canton of Vaud. The estimated contract value is 4 850 000,00 CHF, all taxes included. While reviewing the technical documents, the lead estimator spots a clear contradiction: the geotechnical report indicates shallow groundwater requiring continuous dewatering, whereas the bill of quantities classifies the excavation as standard without dedicated pumping. Facing a potential cost impact of 115 000,00 CHF (incl. 8,1 % VAT), the company avoids gambling on a future addendum. It posts a precise question on Simap 10 days before the forum closes, strictly referencing the page numbers of the geological report and the relevant line items, without disclosing its dewatering fleet. The contracting authority issues a corrective addendum establishing a dedicated time-and-materials pumping item under SIA 118, thereby safeguarding profitability for all tenderers in accordance with art. 2 LMP.

Typical Scenario 2: Protecting a prefabrication method in the Canton of Valais

A Steel Construction firm of 18 workers is tendering for a public maintenance facility in the Canton of Valais, a contract valued at 1 280 000,00 CHF. The structural estimator develops a workshop assembly process that trims three weeks off on-site erection. If the firm posts a question on the forum asking whether its patented connection node is approved, it reveals its methodology to local competitors. The firm refrains from asking on the public forum and chooses instead to submit a compliant base tender accompanied by an explicitly documented contractor variant, as permitted by the tender regulations under art. 29 LMP. In doing so, it protects its competitive edge while ensuring the formal compliance of its submission.

Calls for tenders: free tools

Direct public procurement tenders, AIMP thresholds by canton, converting SIA 451 to Excel, quantity takeoff from an IFC model.

View tendering tools

Frequently asked questions

Can the contracting authority identify who submitted a question on the Simap forum?

On the Simap platform, the technical setup ensures anonymity towards third parties and the contracting authority during submission. In line with art. 11 LMP, the public body upholds equal treatment and confidentiality. Using neutral wording avoids revealing your identity, preventing any risk of indirect bias during tender evaluation.

What should be done if a forum response materially alters the itemised description?

Every clarification published on the forum carries binding contractual weight for tenderers. If an answer modifies quantities for a line item valued at around 45 000,00 CHF, the contracting authority must update the tender documents under the LMP, ensuring fair competition and transparent quantity take-offs for all bidders.

Can a tenderer submit a question after the Simap deadline has passed?

The deadline for the questioning period on Simap is strict. Submitting a query after the specified cut-off leads to automatic rejection by the contracting authority. This formal rule stems from the transparency principles of the LMP, preventing privileged supplementary information from being granted to an individual bidder before final submission.

How can an ambiguity in a variant be raised without revealing proprietary methods?

Address the contracting authority strictly through functional requirements, avoiding brand names or proprietary methods. Frame the issue around the project's performance criteria. Under art. 11 LMP, tenderers' proprietary information is protected, but the question and its answer will be visible to all competitors.

Does a discrepancy between drawings and specifications justify a question on the forum?

Submitting a formal question is essential as soon as a significant discrepancy is identified, such as a surface area mismatch valued at around 12 500,00 CHF. Under art. 365 CO, the contractor must report any detected defects without delay to avoid bearing the financial risk or a subsequent dispute alone.

Does a lack of response from the contracting authority allow for a qualification in the bid?

If the contracting authority fails to answer, adding a unilateral qualification exposes the bidder to exclusion from the procedure under art. 44 LMP for procedural defects. You should price the bid strictly in accordance with the base specifications while documenting all unanswered inquiries within the tender file.

Methodical participation in the Q&A forum on Simap is a key lever to make price calculations reliable and prevent contractual uncertainties under the LMP. Rigorous management of your inquiries strengthens the compliance of your public tenders across French-speaking Switzerland.

To deepen your practice with public calls for tenders, consult our additional resources:

Art Construction is an independent company: it is not affiliated with the SIA, CRB, SUVA, or KBOB. Referenced norms and standards point to publications from these bodies; only official versions are legally binding.