Table of contents
The 3 Major Site Risks
- Financial / Margin: Dead loss of pricing studies and scheduling costs calculated for the tender, which may represent an illustrative amount in the range of 15 000,00 CHF to over 45 000,00 CHF with no guarantee of full cost recovery under the LMP or AIMP framework.
- Legal / Joint body / SUVA: No automatic entitlement to contract award for the prospective successful bidder, or dismissal of an appeal against the cancellation lodged outside the statutory 20-day deadline laid down in art. 56 LMP or equivalent AIMP provisions.
- Administrative / Acceptance: Extended tie-up of operational capacity and unproductive mobilisation of the technical office during a late revocation of an award occurring before the formal implementation of the construction contract governed by standard SIA 118.
The cancellation of an award procedure or the interruption of an ongoing call for tenders is a delicate situation for construction executives and quantity surveyors in French-speaking Switzerland. When a public contracting authority decides to abandon the planned procurement, fundamentally overhaul its specifications or revoke an award, tenderers face substantial deadweight expenditure. The rules established by the LMP at the federal level and by the AIMP across the French-speaking cantons (Vaud, Geneva, Valais, Fribourg, Neuchâtel, Jura, and Bern) strictly regulate the admissible grounds for cancellation, requiring compliance with the principles of equal treatment, objectivity, and transparency set out notably in art. 2 LMP and art. 11 LMP.
Faced with a decision to close a procedure without an award or with the cancellation of a call for tenders, bidding firms must rapidly assess the merits of an administrative appeal or a formal claim for compensation covering tender preparation costs. Swiss public procurement law generally restricts compensation to essential expenses incurred in good faith, ruling out loss of profit on unexecuted works. This technical and contractual guide details the legal conditions for a lawful cancellation, the scope of financial or technical grounds cited by contracting authorities, the avenues for reviewing decisions, and the steps required to assert your rights before entering into any contractual commitment.
Legal grounds for cancelling a procedure and admissibility conditions
Under the LMP and AIMP public procurement frameworks, issuing a call for tenders does not create an unconditional obligation for the contracting authority to award a contract. The public entity retains the prerogative to cancel the procedure on objective, serious grounds, provided it upholds the principles of equal treatment and transparency. Swiss administrative case law permits cancellation whenever justified by an overriding public interest, particularly when an entire project is abandoned, parliamentary budget cuts occur, or fundamental alterations to the required scope render the specifications obsolete.
The contracting authority must abide by the general principles set out in art. 11 LMP, acting transparently, objectively, and impartially while safeguarding equal treatment among competitors. A cancellation must never conceal an unlawful attempt to exclude a top-ranked tenderer or serve as a disguised renegotiation. When the contracting authority finds that all received tenders substantially exceed the approved budget envelope or that no tender meets the eligibility criteria, terminating the procedure without an award remains lawful. Conversely, if the decision to cancel rests on purely opportunistic considerations lacking documented factual justification, it becomes open to challenge through an administrative appeal.
Avenues of appeal and challenging cancellation decisions
A formal decision to cancel the procedure or withdraw a call for tenders constitutes an appealable administrative decision. Pursuant to art. 56 LMP, substantiated appeals must be lodged in writing within 20 days of notification of the decision, noting that the appellate body may not review the appropriateness of a decision. Before the Federal Administrative Court for procurements subject to federal law, or before the competent Cantonal Court (such as the Constitutional and Administrative Court in the Canton of Vaud or the Administrative Chamber in Geneva), the ousted tenderer must establish that the authority abused its discretionary power or breached applicable law.
In the construction industry, securing suspensive effect when appealing against a cancellation decision is a demanding hurdle. The firm must prove a legitimate interest worthy of protection and demonstrate that the balance of interests tips in its favour against the public interest requiring project reorganisation. Without suspensive effect, the authority can launch a new, amended procedure, making any reversal practically impossible on the ground.
Compensation scheme for unsuccessful bidders
The overarching principle under Swiss public procurement law provides that participating in a call for tenders takes place at the tenderers' sole risk and peril. Expenses incurred in reviewing tender documents, preparing preliminary quantity surveys, consulting suppliers, and establishing unit prices represent ordinary overhead costs for an SME. Consequently, a lawful cancellation gives rise to no automatic entitlement to compensation for lost profit, nor to reimbursement of study costs.
Financial compensation may nevertheless be claimed where the authority commits a serious breach of its pre-contractual duties or infringes public procurement rules. If the contracting authority launched a call for tenders knowing that financing was unconfirmed, or if it cancelled the procedure simply to re-tender an identical project to drive prices down after seeing competitors' bids, pre-contractual liability may be established. A damages claim is restricted to negative interest (reliance loss), meaning reimbursement of actual, necessary expenses incurred in preparing the tender, strictly excluding expected profits on the construction works.
Comparison of procedural scenarios and financial entitlements
Financial and legal consequences vary substantially depending on the nature of the cancellation grounds and the conduct of the contracting authority:
| Cancellation or interruption scenario | LMP / AIMP legal compliance | Right of appeal available | Compensation prospects | Scope of recoverable loss |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Widespread cost overrun on approved funds without authority fault | Lawful cancellation | Yes, 20-day deadline without review of appropriateness | None (ordinary tendering risk) | No reimbursement, lost estimating costs |
| Fundamental overhaul of technical requirements or brief | Lawful cancellation | Yes, review of legality and arbitrariness | None if changes were unforeseeable | Zero CHF for the tenderer |
| Disproportionate submittals required without specific compensation | Questionable cancellation | Yes, review under proportionality principle | Possible upon proof of extraordinary costs | Actual costs of specific studies or mock-ups |
| Abusive cancellation to re-tender identical works without cause | Unlawful cancellation | Yes, appeal on grounds of abuse of discretion | High (public entity liability) | Negative interest (documented engineering hours) |
| Revocation of an award already notified to the tenderer | Revocation under strict conditions | Yes, challenge against the revocation decision | High, depending on commitments already entered into | Incurred expenses and preparatory costs |
Common mistakes by bidders and economic consequences
When faced with a cancelled procedure, many firms commit analytical mistakes that worsen their financial losses:
- Claiming lost profit on the construction site: Demanding anticipated margins has no legal basis. Swiss public law bars compensation for lost profit whenever no contract has been concluded within the meaning of art. 1 CO, leading to superfluous lawyer fees in the region of 5 000,00 CHF to 12 000,00 CHF.
- Failing to record design and estimating hours accurately: Without meticulous time tracking for estimators and quantity surveyors on the file, any compensation claim for extraordinary services is summarily dismissed by the courts, creating a net loss of around 18 500,00 CHF on a complex project.
- Overlooking statutory appeal deadlines: Submitting a brief after the 20-day time limit renders the appeal immediately inadmissible, permanently forfeiting any chance to challenge arbitrary decisions.
- Confusing contract negotiations with formal appeals: Pursuing informal discussions with the site management instead of serving formal legal submissions deprives your firm of any legal leverage against the contracting authority.
Illustrative practical cases (typical scenarios on Swiss construction sites)
The figures outlined in the following scenarios are illustrative examples intended to guide tenderers in their decision-making.
Scenario 1: Renovation of a school complex in the Canton of Vaud
A mid-sized general contractor (workforce of 35 employees) submits a tender for masonry and reinforced concrete works (CFC 211) for a communal secondary school. The total tender submitted amounts to 2 450 000,00 CHF including 8,1 % VAT. After opening the bids, the municipality finds that all tenders exceed the project credit approved by the communal council by more than 35 %, caused by an initial underestimation of pollutant remediation works.
The municipality serves formal notice cancelling the procedure. The firm logs 120 hours of estimating and quantity surveying undertaken in-house, representing an estimated internal cost of roughly 14 580,00 CHF. Following legal advice, the firm decides against an appeal: the budgetary justification is established, objective, and devoid of arbitrariness. The company closes the file without claiming indemnification, as this financial exposure falls within the normal risks of public procurement.
Scenario 2: Construction of an administrative building in the Canton of Geneva
Under a call for tenders for metal facades (CFC 221), budgeted at 1 850 000,00 CHF including 8,1 % VAT, the contracting authority demanded advanced structural calculations and full-scale mock-ups. Following assessment, Company A ranks first on the evaluation grid. Two weeks later, the contracting authority cancels the procedure claiming a desire to adjust aesthetic criteria, only to publish an identical call for tenders one month later with no material technical alterations.
Company A lodges a substantiated appeal with the competent cantonal court within the 20-day deadline, alleging an abuse of rights designed to lower prices. The court upholds the unlawful nature of the conduct. Unable to order the contract award directly, the court grants Company A, on grounds of pre-contractual liability, compensatory damages of 28 650,00 CHF covering all actual costs for technical calculations and prototypes produced for the initial tender.
Calls for tenders: free tools
Direct public procurement tenders, AIMP thresholds by canton, converting SIA 451 to Excel, quantity takeoff from an IFC model.
Frequently asked questions
Does the cancellation of a call for tenders entitle you to bid cost reimbursement?
As a rule, no. Bidding takes place at the tenderer's own risk. Compensation is only conceivable if the contracting authority commits an obvious fault when abandoning the procedure. A complex preparatory study, invoiced for instance around 6 485.40 CHF, remains uncompensated under general LMP rules.
What is the deadline for challenging the cancellation of a public procurement process?
Under art. 56 LMP, the firm has twenty days from official notification to lodge a written brief. This appeal requires a direct legal critique, without review of appropriateness. A dispute involving an estimated 12 500.00 CHF in evaluation costs thus demands immediate formal challenge.
Can you recover lost profit following the unjustified cancellation of a procurement competition?
No. Loss of profit is systematically excluded under Swiss public procurement law. Only actual expenses incurred to prepare the technical bid can be claimed if state liability is established, ruling out, for example, an expected profit calculation in the region of 45 200.00 CHF.
Can an award that has already been made be revoked without plausible grounds?
No. Art. 44 LMP only authorises exclusion or revocation on substantiated grounds, such as false statements or serious breaches. A revocation without just cause exposes the public entity to compensating the selected bidder for its direct preparation costs, for example around 8 750.00 CHF.
What circumstances allow a municipality to legally cancel a procurement contract?
A budget refusal, the discovery of procedural defects that cannot be rectified, or a major change in technical requirements justify cancellation. The contracting authority must comply with equal treatment as set out in art. 2 LMP and act according to the procedural principles described in art. 11 LMP.
How can you prove your out-of-pocket expenses for a potential financial claim?
Contractors must meticulously document their quantity surveying hours, engineering fees, and third-party receipts. Submitting a detailed analytical statement, amounting for instance to 4 320.00 CHF, is essential to support an action before the cantonal appeals authority or the competent administrative court.
Handling the cancellation of a call for tenders requires a methodical review of the incurred costs and the grounds for cancellation invoked by the contracting authority. To safeguard your upcoming contractual steps and strengthen your tender submissions in French-speaking Switzerland, explore our specialist guides:
- AIMP/LMP Legal Framework, ISAB/CLA Certificates, Appeals and Litigation
- Joint Committee Certificates: ISAB, CLA and National Agreement, How to Obtain Them
- Grounds for Tender Disqualification Under the AIMP: Formal Defects and Excessive Formalism
- Abnormally Low Tenders and Wage Dumping: What Public Procurement Law Requires
