Table of contents
The 3 Major Site Risks
- Financial / Margin: Reclassification of a succession of contracts into an open-ended employment contract requiring the payment of wages during the statutory notice periods of art. 335c CO, creating an unexpected liability in the region of 10 000 CHF to 25 000 CHF per employee.
- Legal / Joint Body / SUVA: Payment of an indemnity for abusive dismissal set by the court up to six months' salary under art. 336a CO, if terminating the contracts aimed to bypass protection against dismissal at an inopportune time under art. 336c CO.
- Administrative / Acceptance: Withholding of compliance certificates issued by joint parity commissions during trade audits, barring participation in local public procurement due to employment practices deemed evasive.
In the Swiss building sector, using fixed-term employment contracts helps absorb seasonal activity spikes. However, stringing together multiple successive contracts without objective justification constitutes an evasive manoeuvre formally prohibited by the Federal Supreme Court, exposing the employer to a comprehensive reclassification of the employment relationship into an open-ended contract governed by art. 319 CO.
This guide outlines the legal criteria applied by the courts to penalise chain contracts designed to evade the notice periods of art. 335c CO or the temporal protection against dismissal under art. 336c CO, while providing HR managers with compliant planning practices.
Criteria distinguishing legitimate successive contracts from unlawful chain contracts
The Federal Supreme Court considers that a succession of fixed-term employment contracts constitutes an unlawful chain when it lacks any objective rationale and seeks to circumvent protective rules. Under Swiss labour law, freedom of contract derived from the Code of Obligations (CO) allows entering into a contract for a fixed term pursuant to art. 319 CO. However, the prohibition of abuse of rights prevents an employer from using this mechanism to bypass the notice periods established by art. 335c CO, the rules on dismissal at an inopportune time under art. 336c CO, or the statutory sick pay requirements set out in art. 324a CO.
To assess the legality of a sequence of contracts, the courts examine whether objective, substantive justifications exist. In building and civil engineering firms, decisive criteria include the temporary nature of a project, the unforeseen replacement of an unavailable worker, or genuine seasonal fluctuations. Conversely, the continuous assignment of a bricklayer or an electrician to the regular operations of the workshop without interruption demonstrates an ongoing operational need requiring an open-ended contract governed by art. 335 CO.
| Assessment criterion | Compliant practice (objective grounds) | Unlawful practice (chain contracts) |
|---|---|---|
| Operational assignment | Specific project limited in time | Standard and ongoing company operations |
| Probationary period (art. 335b CO) | Stipulated in the initial contract only | Reintroduced with every contract renewal |
| Continuity of the relationship | Genuine, substantiated gaps between assignments | Seamless continuity without any waiting day |
| Handling incapacity for work | Continued payment of salary under art. 324a CO | Non-renewal due to illness |
| Protection against dismissal | Application of notice periods under art. 335c CO | Automatic expiry depriving worker of notice period |
Financial consequences of judicial reclassification
When a judicial authority identifies an unlawful chain, the entire working relationship is retroactively reclassified into a single open-ended contract beginning on the first day of work. This reclassification has immediate consequences for the employer's financial liabilities. If the end of an assignment was communicated as an automatic expiry, it is reclassified as an ordinary dismissal subject to the rules of art. 335 CO.
The employer must pay the salary corresponding to the statutory notice period applicable to the total cumulative length of service, in accordance with art. 335c CO (one month during the first year, two months from the second year onwards). Moreover, if the termination occurs during an unmerited incapacity for work, the dismissal is null and void or suspended as provided for by art. 336c CO. In the event of an abusive dismissal designed to prevent claims from arising, the judge may award compensation under art. 336a CO of up to six months' salary. For a tradesperson paid 5 500 CHF per month, the average retroactive liability ranges from 11 000 CHF to 33 000 CHF.
Common mistakes made by structural work employers
The primary mistake consists in routinely inserting a new probationary period into each addendum. Under art. 335b CO, the probationary period may not exceed three months and cannot be renewed for identical duties. The second failure involves handling sick leave: terminating the succession of contracts to evade art. 324a CO constitutes clear evidence of unlawful circumvention.
Finally, relying on very short-term contracts to offset inadequate schedule planning on multi-year construction sites exposes the firm to inspections by the joint parity commissions responsible for monitoring the enforcement of extended collective labour agreements under art. 1 LECCT and art. 2 LECCT.
Illustrative practical cases (typical scenarios on Swiss construction sites)
The following amounts and scenarios are illustrative examples intended to guide HR management in the construction sector.
Scenario A: Structural work in the canton of Vaud
A general masonry firm hires a formwork carpenter for a four-month period on a housing construction site in Lausanne. Upon expiry, the company extends the agreement for an additional four months, and subsequently for three months on another site, at a gross monthly salary of 5 800 CHF. The worker suffers an unmerited accident during their ninth month of cumulative service. The employer notifies the worker of the end of the employment relationship at the conclusion of the third contract.
The court reclassifies the three successive contracts into a single eleven-month open-ended engagement. The automatic termination is declared null and void pursuant to art. 336c CO, which provides a 30-day protection period during the first year of service. The employer must pay wages throughout the protection period, followed by the one-month notice period stipulated by art. 335c CO, resulting in a back-payment of 11 600 CHF, along with holiday pay under art. 329d CO.
Scenario B: Finishing work in the canton of Valais
A plastering and painting workshop employs a plasterer through five successive fixed-term contracts of two months each over ten consecutive months. Every contract stipulates a one-month probationary period pursuant to art. 335b CO. During the fifth contract, management terminates the contract with seven days' notice. The worker disputes this immediate termination.
The court strikes down the probationary period clause in the renewed contracts and reclassifies the relationship into an open-ended contract with an overall duration of ten months. The notice served with seven days' warning is reclassified under art. 335c CO, requiring one month's notice ending at the end of a calendar month. The business is ordered to pay outstanding wages of 6 200 CHF along with the corresponding social contributions.
Wages and social charges: free tools
Real cost of a tradesperson, employer contributions by canton, meal and travel allowances, notice periods under the collective agreement.
Frequently asked questions
When does a succession of fixed-term contracts become abusive under case law?
A sequence becomes unlawful without an objective ground, such as covering permanent operational needs. The Federal Supreme Court then reclassifies the relationship as an open-ended contract under art. 319 CO.
What are the financial repercussions of a court reclassification into an open-ended contract?
The employer must pay wages for the notice period under art. 335c CO, for instance around 12 000 CHF, with potential indemnities under art. 337c CO.
Is there a probationary period when renewing a fixed-term contract?
No. The probationary period provided for in art. 335b CO only applies to the first contract, unless duties change substantially, prohibiting any new probationary period upon renewal.
How does protection against dismissal at an inopportune time apply?
Following reclassification into an open-ended contract, art. 336c CO protects an unwell bricklayer: contract expiry is suspended during the period of unmerited incapacity, deferring the termination date.
What objective grounds justify successive fixed-term contracts on construction sites?
Unforeseen separate construction sites or the temporary replacement of a site foreman justify several fixed-term contracts under art. 319 CO, provided there is no intent to evade statutory dismissal rules.
Must the employer pay out untaken holidays at contract end?
Art. 329d CO prohibits compensating holidays in cash during employment; any remaining balance is paid out in cash only upon the employee's definitive departure.
To secure your employment contracts and comply with the Swiss legal framework, consult our dedicated HR guides:
- Construction Employment Contracts in Switzerland (Permanent, Fixed-term, Hourly), AVS Bogus Self-Employment Risks, and Day 1 Safety
- Monthly Permanent, Hourly Permanent, Fixed-Term or On-Call Contract: Which Contract Suits Your SME's Activity?
- Probationary Periods in Switzerland (CO & CLA): 3-Month Maximum Duration, 7-Day Notice, and Extension for Illness
- Overtime (CO) vs Statutory Overtime (LTr): +25% Pay Premium, Time off in Lieu or Flat-Rate Allowance