Table of contents
The 3 Major Site Risks
- Financial / Profit margin: An unjustified financial deduction or prolonged withholding of the final account exposes contractors to severe liquidity shortfalls, with the cash flow impact potentially reaching 5 % to 10 % of the total contract sum retained as retention money under SIA 118. Failing to distinguish between legitimate remediation and a disputed price reduction destabilises the overall profitability of successful tenderers by tying up working capital vital for day-to-day operations.
- Legal / Joint body / SUVA: Premature commissioning or admitting users to a building with incomplete guardrails or unprotected openings directly triggers the criminal liability of lead consultants under art. 229 CP, which penalises breaches of the recognised rules of construction that endanger life or physical integrity. At the same time, keeping undeclared workers on site during final finishing and snagging phases exposes parties to joint inspections by the joint committee and cantonal enforcement bodies under the Federal Act on Combating Undeclared Work (LTN).
- Administrative / Acceptance: Carelessness in conducting the joint inspection or failure to formally issue the notice of completion can lead to unintended tacit acceptance under SIA 118, depriving the client of its rights to an adversarial record. The local building authority's refusal to issue an occupancy permit due to missing fire safety documentation or certificates of technical conformity leaves the closing of the as-built documentation indefinitely suspended.
The administrative, technical, and legal close-out of a Swiss construction project is a pivotal phase during which all contractual and regulatory requirements agreed at procurement converge. Aligning SIA phases 52 (commissioning) and 53 (acceptance of the work and handover of files) demands a rigorous approach from site management, clients, and appointed contractors alike. In Swiss practice, SIA 118 structures the transition from mere physical execution to legal assumption of the building, precisely defining the joint inspection process, the binding effects of the joint report, and the notification duties incumbent on all parties. The legal framework governing construction defects incorporates the provisions of the Code of Obligations (CO), notably art. 367 CO, which sets a 60-day notice period to report defects discovered after the delivery of immovable structures, thereby enhancing transactional certainty and clarity in contractual relations.
Managing these stages successfully requires a comprehensive grasp of defect classification, distinguishing minor snags that do not prevent acceptance from major defects warranting a full deferral of formal handover. This comprehensive guide details all operational mechanisms applicable on Swiss construction sites, from the chronological scheduling of HVAC-SE (heating, ventilation, air conditioning, plumbing, and electrical) functional testing to the systematic compilation of the as-built documentation (DOE). Throughout this document, building practitioners will find an in-depth analysis of the three rights granted to the client in response to non-conformities under art. 368 CO, technical arbitration procedures between physical remediation and financial compensation, as well as strategies for managing construction guarantees. For initial costing stages and preparing responses to public or private calls for tenders, professionals are invited to consult the dedicated tenders section on our tenders portal. Regarding unit rates for remedial works or construction price reference baselines, checking our ACIP index provides key metrics within the limit of 12 requests per quarter-hour. Finally, technical recruitment needs and wage cost calculations can be addressed on our jobs portal.
Commissioning a building cannot be improvised at the expense of safety or occupant comfort. Phase 52 of SIA 112 begins well before the final inspection with strict self-checks conducted by each trade, followed by air and water balancing, the commissioning of building management system (BMS) controllers, and verification of fire-door interlocks and smoke and heat exhaust ventilation systems. Local site management coordinates these preliminary steps to ensure the work is genuinely complete before the contractor issues its formal notice of completion. This notice triggers the regulatory countdown under SIA 118 to arrange the joint inspection alongside all specialist engineers and appointed contractors.
During this on-site inspection, methodically recording every observation forms the evidentiary foundation for all subsequent decisions. Snagging lists compiled via digital software or site minutes must clearly define each discrepancy against the CAN bill of quantities and approved working drawings. If the work exhibits only minor defects that do not hinder its intended use, acceptance is deemed granted on the inspection date, making the contract sum due and triggering the specific guarantee periods under SIA 118 alongside the five-year statutory limitation period under art. 371 CO for immovable structures. Conversely, discovering a structural flaw, a major waterproofing failure, or a critical hazard affecting occupant safety mandates the refusal of acceptance, requiring the contractor to undertake immediate remedial works under the continuous supervision of site management.
The financial management of performance bonds and retentions forms an integral part of this handover phase. Withholding retention money from final interim payments or releasing it against a joint and several guarantee complying with Code of Obligations rules protects the client against potential contractor insolvency during the hidden defect notification window. Concurrently, craftsmen and contractors retain the prerogatives granted by the Civil Code (CC) to secure their construction claims, necessitating impeccable traceability of payments and final accounts to prevent statutory construction liens from being registered on the land register.
Finally, handing over the work concludes with the delivery of a complete as-built file, including record drawings updated by design consultants, single-line diagrams for electrical distribution boards, technical datasheets for installed equipment, and operating and maintenance manuals essential for the facility manager. Incomplete documentation can delay the occupancy permit issued by cantonal and communal authorities, postpone tenant move-in or unit handover in condominium ownership (PPE), and trigger protracted disputes. Through a detailed review of Swiss contractual procedures and real-world site feedback, this technical brief equips site management with the tools required to secure every decision and steer acceptance in full compliance with Swiss building standards.
Swiss contractual and regulatory framework for acceptance and commissioning
The rigorous delivery of construction works in Switzerland relies on a clear hierarchy between federal private law and established industry standards. The contract for work and services binds the client and the contractor to execute a specified project in exchange for remuneration. When the parties expressly incorporate SIA 118 into their agreement, it supplements the baseline provisions of the Swiss Code of Obligations by establishing detailed rules on notices of completion, joint inspections, defect management, and warranty periods. The fundamental distinction between the general statutory rules and the agreed modifications under SIA 118 forms the bedrock of all technical and administrative close-out operations.
Within the overarching project stages defined by the SIA 112 scope-of-services model, this transition corresponds primarily to phases 52 and 53. Phase 52 covers commissioning, including technical testing and balancing of building services, user instructions, key handover, and compiling final operation and maintenance files. Phase 53 encompasses the formal acceptance of the work, final account settlement, rectification of any outstanding non-conformities, and support throughout warranty periods. Seamless coordination between site management and specialist engineering consultants is vital to ensure that every system functions optimally before possession of the premises transfers to the client.
The Swiss regulatory framework mandates a strict distinction between the physical completion of works and the legal delivery of the construction. Physical completion occurs when the contractor finishes the services stipulated in the contract for work and services and any approved addenda. Delivery, in the legal sense, requires the actual physical handover or making the completed work available to the client, accompanied by the intention to transfer custody. Under the sole authority of the Code of Obligations, acceptance usually coincides with handover, requiring the client to inspect the work as soon as feasible and promptly notify defects. In contrast, under SIA 118, acceptance results from a structured joint inspection process initiated by the contractor's formal notice of completion and documented in an adversarial joint report.
Regarding fundamental duties of performance, the contractor remains bound to execute the construction with utmost care, under personal direction or qualified supervision, in accordance with the recognised rules of building and engineering trades. When complex technical HVAC, sanitary, or electrical installations enter their commissioning phase, the contractor must also ensure that all safety devices are fully functional. The safety of building users and site personnel during these transitional stages is a shared responsibility among project stakeholders, who must coordinate operations without compromising structural stability or indoor health standards.
The client, for its part, must establish a suitable organisation to discharge its duties of inspection and decision-making. By delegating the operational oversight of the construction site to the site management team via a mandate agreement, the client entrusts this professional with acting on its behalf within the scope of delegated authority. Site management then serves as technical guarantor: logging progress milestones, organising coordination meetings, obtaining required compliance certificates from municipal authorities, and preparing inspection minutes. Mishandling these duties exposes the client to the unintended acceptance of non-compliant works or the premature forfeiture of statutory defect rights.
Step-by-step procedure for commissioning and joint inspection (Phases 52 and 53)
The methodical completion of a construction site requires a rigorous chronology across several orderly steps. Each phase involves specific parties, dedicated forms, and indispensable physical checks to avoid any legal ambiguity regarding the custody of the work and the exercise of statutory rights.
Step 1: Formal notice of completion of the work
The procedure formally begins when the contractor considers its work completed under the contractual documents. It then sends written notice of completion to the site management and the client. In Swiss practice, this document must clearly state the scope of completed work, the anticipated date the areas will be vacated, and a request for a joint inspection date. Issuing this notice triggers a one-month deadline within which the parties must carry out the joint inspection prescribed by standard SIA 118. If the client or its representative fails to organise this joint inspection during this period without legitimate grounds, the work may be deemed tacitly accepted, depriving the client of the right to contest readily visible defects. The site management must therefore record this notice, verify the actual progress on site, and schedule the inspection sessions without delay.
Step 2: Technical pre-acceptance and functional testing of HVACSE installations
Before inviting the client to inspect the premises, the local site management and the specialist engineers carry out preliminary technical walkthroughs and supervise testing of the building's building services. This step allows the dynamic operation of components to be tested:
- Inspection of hydraulic balancing across heating and cooling networks, measurement of flow rates at risers and terminal valves.
- Verification of air handling units, testing of supply and extract flow rates, air tightness of ventilation ducts, and differential pressure measurements.
- Interlock testing of smoke clearance dampers, automatic switchover of emergency power supplies, and inspection of emergency exit signage.
- Flushing, disinfection, and pressure testing of domestic water distribution systems, checking for any micro-leaks.
- On-site acoustic insulation testing and thermographic surveys of the building envelope to detect thermal bridging or air leakage defects.
All malfunctions identified during these preliminary tests are recorded on an internal snagging list. The appointed contractors are then required to make the essential adjustments before the formal joint inspection takes place.
Step 3: Joint formal inspection and preparation of the minutes
The joint inspection takes place on site in the presence of duly authorised representatives of the contractor, the client, and the site management. The parties walk through every room, every level, and every external element methodically, referring to the contractual construction drawings and system specifications. Each non-conformity, damage, omission, or imperfection is identified through an immediate visual inspection. The findings are recorded on the spot in joint inspection minutes, which must include:
- The date, time, and precise identification of attendees along with their representative capacity.
- A detailed description of each technical finding with its exact location by room or grid line.
- The agreed or disputed characterisation of the identified non-conformity.
- The mandatory deadline granted to the contractor to remedy the issue and restore the areas to order.
- The handwritten or qualified electronic signature of each stakeholder present on the construction site.
Step 4: Legal characterisation of the inspection findings
At the end of the walkthrough, the participants must characterise the overall condition of the work according to three distinct formal outcomes:
- Work without defects: The work complies fully with the terms of the contract for work and services and good trade practice. Acceptance takes effect immediately on the date of the minutes. Warranty and limitation periods begin to run for all inspected elements.
- Work with minor defects: The work displays minor imperfections that do not hinder its use in accordance with the contractual purpose and present no risk to safety or health (paint touch-ups, hardware adjustments, irregular seal joints). Acceptance takes effect on the date the minutes are signed. The contractor remains obligated to clear every snag within the mutually agreed deadline, under regular supervision by the site management.
- Work with major defects: The work suffers from substantial deficiencies that completely prevent its normal use or render it unsanitary or non-compliant with statutory safety requirements (lack of water tightness, severe ventilation malfunction, static instability of a guardrail). Acceptance is formally refused. The work remains in the exclusive custody and at the sole risk of the contractor until full repairs are completed and a new joint inspection is called.
Step 5: Defect notices during operation and statutory revision of defects law
Once acceptance has taken effect, the client takes possession of the premises. Managing imperfections that emerge later depends on the contractual framework used. Where the contract incorporates standard SIA 118, the client benefits from a two-year warranty period during which it may report any patent or latent defect at any time, in writing, without facing immediate forfeiture of its rights. This special mechanism greatly simplifies early-stage operational management compared to general contract law.
Under statutory private law set out in the Code of Obligations (CO), the revision that took effect on 1 January 2026 fundamentally reformed the duty to give notice of defects. Previously, the client had to act within a very short customary deadline of a few working days, otherwise the work was deemed tacitly accepted. Now, for any building construction governed by statutory law, the client has a mandatory 60-day period to notify identified defects; any contractual agreement providing for a shorter period is null and void. In addition, the right to repair of defects can no longer be excluded or restricted by advance contractual clauses for construction work. Warranty claims for defects in immovable work have a limitation period of five years from acceptance of the work, against the contractor as well as against the architect or engineer; this five-year period cannot be shortened to the detriment of the client.
Step 6: Transfer of risks, preparation of the as-built documentation, and commissioning
Signing minutes recording the acceptance of the work, with or without minor snags, carries major legal consequences. The transfer of risks of accidental damage or destruction passes from the contractor to the client. This exact date also marks the start of the owner's obligation to carry fire and water damage insurance. Phase 52 of standard SIA 112 concludes with the physical handover of access keys, the transmission of home automation programming codes, and the formal handover of the as-built documentation (DOE).
The as-built documentation (DOE) must include all construction drawings updated to reflect actual modifications made on site, electrical panel schematics, technical operating and maintenance manuals in French or the local language of the canton, supplier lists, and the compliance certificates required to obtain the occupancy permit from the municipal building authority. In parallel, the preparation of the final account by the site management allows the amounts actually due to be adjusted, incorporating approved addenda, final measurement sheets, and the release of retention money in exchange for the provision of a compliant joint and several guarantee.
Detailed comparison table of acceptance situations
The table below summarises scenarios commonly encountered during acceptance operations on a Swiss construction site, the applicable standard baselines, their direct legal effects, and key operational checkpoints for the site management.
| Scenario encountered on the construction site | Reference standard or statutory requirement | What this changes in practice on the construction site | Point of vigilance for site management |
|---|---|---|---|
| Notice of completion served without a call for a joint inspection | Standard SIA 118 and federal law governing the contract for work and services | Remaining silent during the one-month period set by the standard leads to tacit acceptance of the building, preventing the client from contesting readily identifiable defects. | Record the notice on the day it is received and immediately set the joint inspection date within a maximum of 30 calendar days. |
| Major defect affecting the health conditions or water tightness of a flat roof | Standard SIA 118 and good trade practice for waterproofing | Strict refusal of acceptance of the work. Risks remain with the waterproofing contractor until the technical issue is fully rectified. | Record non-completion in the minutes, withhold release of the remaining balance, and schedule a new inspection once remedial work is complete. |
| Cosmetic finish imperfections or localised paint touch-ups | Standard SIA 118 (classification of minor defects) | The work is legally accepted on the date the minutes are signed. Warranty periods start to run for all elements. | Draw up a priced snag list with firm deadlines for each trade and retain a sufficient amount on the final payment application. |
| Discovery of a defect after handover of keys under the statutory regime | Revised Code of Obligations (CO) law (in force since 2026) | The client has a mandatory 60-day period to send written notice of defects to the contractor without risking the forfeiture of its rights. | Draft a detailed registered letter describing the exact manifestation of the problem and requiring the debtor to carry out repairs within a reasonable time. |
| Absence of ventilation or hydraulic balancing during commissioning | SIA 112 service model (Phase 52 Commissioning) | Inability to certify the building's energy performance and risk of the occupancy permit being challenged by the competent authorities. | Require the submission of joint measurement logs signed by the HVACSE consulting engineer before signing off on final acceptance of building services. |
| Refusal by a contractor to remedy a proven defect in workmanship | Contractual regime for substitute performance under standard SIA 118 | The client may have the corrective work executed by a competent third party at the defaulting contractor's expense and risk following formal notice. | Serve formal notice with a clear peremptory deadline before seeking third-party quotes to claim rectification costs. |
| Incomplete as-built documentation (DOE) at the time of handover | SIA 112 service model and maintenance regulations | Delays in the operational takeover of the building by facility management teams or condominium ownership managers. | Make payment of the final fee instalment or general contractor final invoice conditional upon full delivery of the as-built drawings. |
Technical and legal decision criteria for site management
When a discrepancy is identified during the joint inspection, the site management must make a balanced assessment between demanding repair in kind, accepting a financial price reduction, or refusing acceptance altogether. This decision must be guided by objective criteria to prevent subsequent disputes and maintain constructive contractual relationships.
1. The fitness for purpose and safety criterion
The initial assessment filter is functional and statutory. Any technical discrepancy that undermines the primary purpose of the building, its structural safety, its weatherproofing, or occupant health must immediately be classified as a major defect. For example, a reverse slope on a terrace that causes water ponding against door thresholds, or a smoke clearance system that fails to trigger automatic vents, prevents standard handover of the work. In such situations, no financial concession can be considered: acceptance must be suspended and remediation demanded without delay.
2. The proportionality criterion for rectification costs
When the observed defect is purely qualitative or of a minor aesthetic nature without impairing the durability of the structure, the principle of proportionality comes fully into play. If the cost of complete demolition and rebuilding appears disproportionate to the concrete benefit the client would derive from it, the economic solution lies in setting a fair price reduction. The site management quantifies this compensation by assessing the loss in market value of the property or the unjustified savings achieved by the contractor when using equivalent substitute materials that do not comply with the initial quote.
3. Securing financial guarantees
Administrative close-out requires strict adherence to financial balances. As long as minor defects identified during verification are not fully cleared, the site management must advise the client to withhold an adequate amount from the contractor's final payment certificate. As a rule, this amount corresponds to twice the estimated value of the rectification work. Furthermore, the release of the contractual retention money must only take place against the actual provision of an insurance certificate or a joint and several guarantee issued by a prime bank or insurance company established in Switzerland. This document guarantees any claims by the client for hidden defects appearing during the five-year limitation period.
4. Formalising records and traceability
Any agreement reached on the construction site between the site management and contractors during phases 52 and 53 must be set down clearly in writing. Oral statements or informal hallway agreements provide no legal certainty in the event of subsequent litigation before the civil courts. Every progress record, every commissioning report for a technical system and every final sample approval must be entered in the site daily log or in an interim inspection report sent immediately to the parties. Rigorous documentation provides the most effective shield to protect the client, safeguard the profitability of diligent contractors and demonstrate the value of the site management's mandate.
Operational protocols by type of structure
The physical performance of joint inspections and defect identification requires an approach tailored to the nature of the works carried out. Across Switzerland, climatic constraints, building usage and operational requirements require the site management to adapt acceptance protocols to the specific characteristics of each trade. Applying contractual rules requires technical rigour to avoid any later dispute regarding the start of warranty periods or the transfer of operating risks.
The table below details the operating procedures prescribed for three standard situations commonly encountered on Swiss construction sites, specifying the preliminary checks, the mandatory parties convened, the required technical deliverables and how non-conformities identified during joint inspections are dealt with.
| Typical situation | Essential preliminary checks | Mandatory participants on site | Required technical deliverables | Corrective measures and formalisation |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Office building: interior building services (CFC 23, 24, 25) | Airflow testing, hydraulic balancing, ambient acoustic measurements in accordance with project specifications, smoke-extraction checks and fire-safety interlocks. | Site management, HVACSE engineer, specialist contractors, designated safety specialist, future technical facility manager. | Endorsed balancing reports, laminated schematic diagrams in the boiler room and substations, self-inspection reports, instruction sheets for maintenance personnel. | Recording airflow deviations in the inspection report, setting a deadline for re-adjusting motorised dampers, withholding from the payment certificate pending a conclusive re-test. |
| Multi-family residential building: thermal envelope and waterproofing (CFC 214, 221) | Winter thermographic inspection or flat-roof water flood testing, verification of waterproofing upstands and window connections, visual inspection of ventilated façades. | Local site management, structural engineer, sheet-metal worker and roofer, façade installer, client's authorised representative. | Certificate of conformity for insulation build-ups, constant-level water-test reports, roof plans indicating fall-protection anchor points complying with safety rules. | Recording water ingress as major defects precluding handover of the affected area, obligation to rectify the waterproofing build-up, maintaining the full bank guarantee. |
| Municipal civil engineering structure: piping and roadworks (CFC 211, 224) | CCTV inspection of foul and storm sewers, plate load compaction tests on road pavement, geometric levelling of surface drainage slopes. | Site management, geotechnical engineer, earthworks and drainage contractor, representative of the municipal public works department. | CAN inspection video reports, load-bearing test charts, georeferenced as-built drawings provided in editable digital format. | Issuing a notification for full rectification of any section showing back-slopes, mandatory prior cleaning and a new camera run before any final sign-off. |
Technical specificities of checks on complex systems
On administrative or public infrastructure construction sites, functional testing cannot be carried out in isolation. The site management must ensure that the interconnections between ventilation systems, motorised fire doors, fire detection and access control correspond to the cause-and-effect matrices defined as early as the procurement phase. These joint verifications require the simultaneous mobilisation of the electrician, heating technician, ventilation technician and plumber. Any discrepancy identified in technical interlocks jeopardises the issuance of operating permits by the competent cantonal authorities.
In this context, holding preliminary technical coordination meetings during SIA phase 52 avoids carrying over into the formal acceptance phase any anomalies that fall under normal commissioning of the works. Under its obligation to execute the work in accordance with the recognised rules of the trade, the contracting firm remains bound to fine-tune its adjustments before notifying the completion of its services.
Visual checks and dimensional tolerances in finishing work
For finishing trades such as plastering, painting, resin floor coatings or interior joinery, surface quality is frequently disputed between buyers and builders. The site management strictly applies standard visual inspection criteria: finishes are examined under natural diffuse light, from a normal viewing distance, without the use of artificial grazing light not intended for standard room use.
Flatness defects in a screed or plaster only constitute material defects to the extent that they exceed the tolerances permitted by trade standards or compromise the proper installation of subsequent coverings. Where the observed imperfection is merely a minor aesthetic variation without functional impairment or objective building depreciation, the outcome moves toward rectification through targeted touch-ups or, if the intervention is disproportionate, toward considering a fair price reduction granted to the client.
Illustrative practical cases (typical scenarios on Swiss construction sites)
The following two scenarios are illustrative examples designed to explain the practical application of Swiss standard provisions and contract law on typical construction sites. The organizational data and financial amounts, stated in Swiss francs (CHF) inclusive of all taxes at the 8,1 % VAT rate where applicable, are presented for illustrative and educational purposes.
Typical scenario 1: Major refurbishment of a mixed commercial and residential building in the Canton of Vaud
The project involves the renovation of a property complex on the Vaud Riviera, comprising eighteen rental flats and three ground-floor retail units. The average workforce deployed by the various trade contractors amounts to forty-five workers during peak phases of finishing work. The total cost of works under the general contractor agreement is set at an order of magnitude of 6 800 000 CHF incl. VAT. The agreement between the parties incorporates standard SIA 118 as an integral part of the contract.
Three weeks before the contractual completion deadline, the general contractor submits its formal notice of completion and requests a date for a joint acceptance inspection of the residential units. During the joint inspection conducted by the site management and the consulting engineering firm, several substantial anomalies are recorded in the minutes:
- The air handling unit serving the retail units shows defective fastening of flexible duct connectors, causing significant acoustic vibration and a fresh air flow rate 25 % below the project's design values.
- Four upper-floor flats exhibit residual water ingress at the masonry balcony thresholds, caused by an incomplete waterproofing upstand against the window sub-frames.
- In the shared stairwells, various minor aesthetic defects are identified: scratches on stainless steel handrails, post-construction debris on landings, and imperfect adjustment of overhead door closers.
Faced with these findings, the site management carries out the technical and legal qualification of the non-conformities:
1. Acceptance ruling: Water ingress observed in the flats and failure to meet regulatory airflow rates in the retail units directly affect the normal use of these premises and jeopardise obtaining the final occupancy permit issued by the municipal authorities. The site management issues a formal refusal of acceptance for the four damaged flats as well as for the commercial ventilation lot, classifying these issues as major defects preventing takeover. Conversely, the fourteen other flats and the shared circulation areas are declared accepted with reservations for minor defects, with the minutes recording the precise list of painting touch-ups and cleaning to be completed.
2. Financial impacts and withholdings: The general contractor had applied for the release of the final monthly advance payment of 450 000 CHF incl. VAT as well as the release of the retention money. The site management exercises its right of financial retention by withholding payment of 180 000 CHF incl. VAT, corresponding to twice the estimated cost of waterproofing repairs and airflow remediation. The waterproofing work is estimated at an illustrative order of magnitude of 65 000 CHF incl. VAT and bringing ventilation systems into compliance at approximately 25 000 CHF incl. VAT.
3. Safety measures and remediation: To rectify the balcony thresholds on the external façade without fixed scaffolding that had already been dismantled, the contractor requests the use of a cherry picker. Under art. 29 OTConst, when using a façade scaffold or standard edge protection is no longer technically feasible, equivalent measures must be established in writing in collaboration with an occupational safety specialist to protect workers from fall-from-height hazards.
4. Contractual resolution: The general contractor complies within a twenty working-day formal notice period set by the site management. Sheet-metal work repairs are validated through a six-hour continuous pressurised water test. Once the ventilation balancing reports are approved by the HVACSE engineer, supplementary acceptance for these packages is formally signed off. The site management then authorises the release of the remaining advance payment, minus contractual retention money converted into an on-demand bank guarantee.
Typical scenario 2: Construction of a commercial workshop and office building in the Canton of Fribourg
The second case involves the construction of an industrial workshop with adjoining office space, developed by a private client under separate trade contracts. The construction site workforce involves eight distinct trades with an average of twenty-two workers present during structural work and heavy finishing work. The project's overall budget represents an order of magnitude of 3 200 000 CHF incl. VAT. The contracts are governed by the rules of standard SIA 118, supplemented subsidiarily by the provisions of the Code of Obligations (CO).
The contractor awarded the screed and industrial floor resin package (CFC 252) intervened to lay a slab with a polyurethane finish designed to withstand light vehicle traffic. The contract value amounted to 125 000 CHF incl. VAT. Ten days after pouring the surface coating, uncontrolled surface cracking as well as areas of peeling film appeared over a cumulative area of approximately 180 m².
Claiming to have completed the work, the craftsman submitted the final invoice and requested inspection of the works to carry out formal acceptance. Site management summoned the contractor, the civil engineer, and the resin binder manufacturer to investigate the cause of the defects:
1. Technical joint inspection record: Direct pull-off tensile tests were performed on six sample core drills. The results showed adhesive failure at the interface between the concrete slab and the self-levelling screed, resulting from excessively high residual moisture in the mineral substrate when the primer bond coat was applied. The contractor alleged having followed oral instructions regarding schedule progress issued by the client.
2. Classification of breach and legal notice: Pursuant to art. 365 CO, if materials supplied by the client or ground designated by the client are found to be defective, or if any other circumstance jeopardises the proper or timely completion of the works, the contractor must inform the client immediately, failing which the contractor bears the consequences. In this case, the screed applicator took no moisture measurements using the calcium carbide method prior to applying the waterproof resin and issued no formal notice of moisture risk. Full contractual liability lies with the contractor regarding the choice and application of the materials installed.
3. Exercise of the client's rights: The defect does not permit long-term use of the workshop under forklift traffic without the risk of accelerated floor peeling. Full remediation of the affected surface was demanded by the client. Disputing the need for total stripping, the contractor proposed a simple superficial impregnation with no guarantee of mechanical durability, which site management rejected based on the manufacturer's technical specifications.
4. Formal notice and third-party remediation: Given the contractor's inaction in refusing to strip the unbonded layer, site management applied the contractual procedure: formal notice to intervene within ten business days, followed by notice that repair work would be assigned to a third party at the defaulting craftsman's expense and risk. The specialist firm finally engaged a planing contractor to remove the damaged system, carried out controlled forced drying, and then applied an epoxy vapour-barrier primer before reapplying the resin. The total cost of the work, approximately 42 000 CHF incl. VAT, was borne entirely by the screed contractor, who was denied any extension of the contractual deadline.
5. Final acceptance of the trade package: Three weeks after the full remediation and the validation of new adhesion tests, a joint acceptance record was signed noting the absence of defects. The starting point of the two-year defect notice period under standard SIA 118 was set at the effective date of this second conclusive inspection.
Operational checklist for acceptance and defect management
To structure the work of site management and minimise the risk of methodological omissions, the closing procedure for a Swiss construction site requires systematically reviewing a series of technical, administrative, and contractual checkpoints. The following list summarises the essential actions to take before, during, and after signing the acceptance records.
- 1. Preliminary checks prior to the joint inspection visit (SIA Phase 52):
- Verify the formal receipt of the written completion notice sent by each successful contractor.
- Compile and critically review self-inspection logs and technical test sheets from each trade.
- Verify that mandatory certificates of conformity have been obtained (electrical safety, gas tightness, thermal compliance, and fire protection).
- Validate the adjustments of technical installations by having specialist consulting engineers review the hydraulic and aeraulic balancing reports.
- Carry out thorough post-construction cleaning of the premises and outdoor surroundings, enabling an unobstructed visual inspection of all building elements.
- 2. Physical operations during the on-site joint inspection:
- Conduct a joint room-by-room, element-by-element check, requiring the presence of the contractor or an authorised representative.
- Conduct a visual inspection of finishes under standard operating lighting for finishing work (wall coverings, parquet flooring, tiling, paintwork).
- Mechanically and functionally operate all opening elements, fire doors, locks, sanitary fixtures, and regulating valves.
- Immediately and jointly classify each defect identified: minor defect not precluding acceptance, or major defect justifying refusal of acceptance for the package concerned.
- Accurately locate and descriptively record each anomaly without ambiguity in the acceptance log or on the digital inspection tablet.
- 3. Drafting and signing the acceptance record (SIA Phase 53):
- Draw up the official document specifying the identification of the parties, the exact titles of the contracts and trade packages inspected, and the exact date of the inspection.
- Explicitly state the outcome: acceptance without reservations, acceptance with reservations for duly listed minor defects, or deferral/refusal of acceptance for major defects.
- Set a firm, binding deadline for each relevant trade to clear all reservations attributed to it.
- Promptly collect the handwritten or qualified electronic signatures of authorised representatives of the client, site management, and contractors.
- Send a certified copy of the record to each signing party within forty-eight hours of the meeting.
- 4. Post-acceptance administrative and financial management:
- Withhold a financial retention on the final invoice or ongoing advance payments, proportional to the estimated cost of the remaining remedial work.
- Require the joint and several guarantee or on-demand bank guarantee certificate covering the warranty period of the works.
- Draw up the joint inspection record for the clearance of reservations upon expiry of the granted deadline, with the signing of a final discharge record.
- Formally release financial securities or approve the final account only after the complete and satisfactory clearance of all recorded minor defects.
- Officially notify insurance companies of the transfer of operating risks for the building to the client as of the recorded acceptance date.
Common site errors and their legal and financial consequences
Everyday construction supervision practice in Switzerland shows that procedural departures during the final execution phase frequently lead to heavy litigation and direct financial losses. Site managers and client representatives must identify these recurring pitfalls to guard against them effectively.
1. Confusion between occupying the premises and formal acceptance
One of the most damaging mistakes is tolerating move-in by the client or tenants before holding the joint inspection visit and signing a formal record. Active use of the works without explicit written reservations may be construed as conclusive conduct implying acceptance of the works, resulting in immediate forfeiture of the client's rights regarding unnotified apparent defects.
From the moment users take possession of a building, establishing liability for subsequent superficial damage (scuffs on woodwork, scratches on flooring, impact marks on glazing) becomes nearly impossible to attribute with certainty to executing contractors. Site management must strictly make physical handover of the keys conditional upon the prior drafting of an acceptance record in due form.
2. Imprecise or incomplete drafting of the notice of defects
A generic statement such as "paintwork to be redone throughout the building" or "thermal issues in the basement" deprives the client of the legal effect of the notice. The notice of defects must identify the non-conformity in a concrete, individualised, and geographically located manner (exact identification of the room, wall, defective equipment, and physical manifestation of the defect).
An imprecise report exposes the client to the risk of the contractor challenging the validity of the notice of defects, claiming that the notification did not allow them to ascertain the nature of the issue immediately or determine appropriate corrective actions. Swiss case law confirms that an overly vague notice does not validly suspend or interrupt limitation periods for claims.
3. Granting remediation periods without explicit financial penalties
Granting a contractor successive deadlines to clear reservations without formally setting a peremptory term or withholding an appropriate financial guarantee often leads to post-construction snagging grinding to a halt. With site crews having moved on to other active construction sites, the craftsman continually postpones minor residual interventions.
Site management must systematically link the remediation schedule to a mechanism withholding final payments. If remedial work is not performed by the agreed deadline, the client may resort to third-party remediation at the defaulting party's expense, applying the planned deductions to the final account.
4. Failing to verify signatory powers
On construction sites, the acceptance record is frequently signed on the contractor's behalf by a foreman, a de facto subcontractor, or a worker without the legal power to bind the company. In the event of a subsequent dispute regarding defect acknowledgement or agreed price reductions, the contractor may argue that the signatory was not authorised to accept reservations on behalf of the company.
Under art. 32 CO on agency, the rights and obligations arising from a legal act performed on behalf of a third party only bind the latter directly if the representative had the requisite authority. Site management must verify that individuals signing the records hold the necessary registrations in the commercial register or possess an express written power of attorney from the management of the contractor.
Long-term monitoring, document traceability, and archiving protocol
Signing acceptance records and commissioning systems do not mark the end of site management's administrative and technical duties. SIA Phase 53 demands rigorous archiving and document updates designed to safeguard the parties' rights throughout the statutory and contractual limitation period.
Organising defect tracking through to full resolution
Every non-conformity recorded during acceptance must be integrated into a digital defect tracking matrix, accessible for review by appointed professionals and involved contractors. This register centralises:
- The precise reference of the room and building element concerned according to the project's CFC classification.
- The exact wording of the defect identified, accompanied by timestamped high-resolution photographs taken during the inspection.
- The designated responsible contractor and the mandatory deadline set for executing remedial work.
- The effective date of the joint verification inspection for clearing the reservation and the respective sign-offs of the parties involved.
- The associated financial implications (amount of withheld retention, potential reduction in price, or third-party remediation costs charged).
No item on the punch list can be signed off unilaterally. Clearing a defect strictly requires an on-site inspection and a clearance form co-signed by the local site management and the contractor.
Updating and Maintaining the As-Built Documentation (DOE)
In parallel with clearing minor defects, site management coordinates the gathering and compliance check of all documents making up the as-built documentation. Too often treated as an afterthought, preparing this documentation is nevertheless vital for efficient building maintenance and future operational risk management.
Execution drawings must without exception be updated by consultants and contractors into as-built drawings. This applies particularly to the exact route of buried pipework, the layout of building services concealed in slabs or lightweight partitions, the location of emergency shut-offs (water valves, main electrical isolators, fire dampers) and any reinforced concrete rebar modified during construction.
Every technical file must include operation manuals written in the official language of the canton, safety data sheets for installed coatings and products, and the scheduled maintenance log specifying the service intervals required to keep equipment manufacturers' warranties valid.
Long-Term Archiving and Warranty Period Management
Key project records—initial works contracts, priced financial addenda, weekly site minutes, inspection and acceptance reports, cantonal compliance certificates and bank guarantee certificates—must be kept in a format that safeguards the integrity of their content.
Physical and digital archiving must be structured for immediate retrieval in the event of an insured loss or latent defects. Because statutory and contractual warranty periods run for several years after acceptance, clients and their legal successors must be able to produce tangible proof of the state of the works on handover day at any time. This strict document management protects the built asset and ensures seamless continuity between site management and the building's future facility managers.
Contracts and SIA 118: free tools
Advance payments and retentions, surety bonds, price escalations, daywork reports, subcontractor monitoring.
Frequently asked questions
How should site management react if the contractor refuses to sign the acceptance report?
When the contractor disputes the findings and refuses to sign the joint inspection record, site management must not break off the procedure. Under standard SIA 118, acceptance remains a bilateral joint inspection process, but formally recording identified defects is part of site management's supervisory duties. In practice, the report is drawn up immediately, explicitly recording the contractor's refusal to sign along with the technical objections raised. Site management formally serves this document on the client and the contractor by registered post within two business days to establish proof of the inspection date. Legally, refusing to sign does not impair the evidentiary value of the report provided the site inspection took place in the presence of the parties. For a works contract governed by the Code of Obligations (CO) or standard SIA 118, the listed defects are deemed formally notified. If remedial work estimated at around 18 000 CHF is required, the contractor remains bound to carry it out within the reasonable deadline set in the report. Should the contractor fail to act, the client may hire a third party at the defaulting contractor's expense.
What are the effects of the 2026 revision of the Code of Obligations on defect notification deadlines for real property?
Since the new provisions governing works contracts entered into force on 1 January 2026, the statutory rules for notice of defects on immovable structures have been significantly eased in the client's favour. Under former law, the client had to give notice of defects immediately upon discovery, risking forfeiture of rights within a few business days. For real property, the client now has a statutory deadline of 60 days to report identified defects to the contractor, and any contractual clause stipulating a shorter period is void. This statutory protection greatly reduces the risk of implied acceptance caused by administrative delays upon moving in. Furthermore, for contracts incorporating standard SIA 118, the agreed regime remains even more advantageous throughout the two-year warranty period, during which defects of any kind may be notified at any time up to expiry. However, once this two-year SIA 118 warranty period ends, the new statutory 60-day deadline applies to report any latent defects emerging later, before expiry of the five-year limitation period governing building works.
Can acceptance of a building be rejected if the as-built documentation is missing?
Failing to hand over as-built documentation constitutes a breach of contract that must be properly qualified before it can justify refusing acceptance. Under the phase structure of standard SIA 112 and the provisions of standard SIA 118, acceptance marks the physical completion of the built works. A building where all building services are operational and show no safety issues cannot be rejected merely because operating binders or electrical cabinet schematics are missing, unless a specific contract clause expressly made them a condition precedent to acceptance. The missing documentation must then be classified as a minor defect or an unfulfilled secondary obligation, recorded in the report with a binding 30-day deadline for delivery. Site management is then entitled to withhold a proportionate sum from the final account, for example an estimated amount of around 15 000 CHF to cover the cost of measured surveys and reverse engineering by a specialist firm. However, if missing regulatory certificates, such as smoke extraction or fire alarm compliance certificates, prevent the local building authority from issuing the occupancy permit, the building is unfit for use and acceptance may validly be refused.
What is the legal value of implied acceptance if the client moves in before the joint inspection?
Moving in early or taking actual possession of the premises before the joint inspection takes place creates a strong presumption, albeit one strictly framed by standard SIA 118. When a client occupies the building without lodging reservations and without requesting a joint inspection record, this conduct may amount to acceptance under the Code of Obligations (CO), releasing the contractor from liability for any apparent defects that a layperson could have detected. However, under standard SIA 118, taking possession does not automatically constitute formal acceptance if site management or the client notified the contractor in writing beforehand that occupancy is purely provisional to allow furnishing or commissioning trials. To rule out any risk of inadvertent implied acceptance, local site management must prepare a joint inspection record of the premises before any furniture is brought in. This document records the exact baseline condition of finishes, guards against disputes over damage caused during move-in, and confirms that the one-month window for the joint inspection remains conditional on the contractor serving a formal notice of completion for any punch-list items.
How does joint and several liability apply to designers and contractors in structural failures?
When a structural defect affects a building, such as through-thickness cracks in a reinforced concrete foundation slab, liability depends on the respective contractual duties of the contractor and consultants under the Code of Obligations (CO). The structural engineer answers for the accuracy of design calculations and drawings under mandate rules, whereas the contractor answers for the result of execution under the works contract. If the defect stems jointly from insufficient rebar detailing on the drawings and poor concrete compaction on the construction site, the engineer and the contractor bear differentiated liability toward the client for the overall loss. The client may demand full compensation from the co-liable parties. The contractor can only be released from liability by proving that they scrupulously fulfilled their duty of notification by immediately reporting discernible technical drawing errors to site management prior to pouring. In the internal relations between joint debtors, the ultimate cost of remedial work, which can reach around 120 000 CHF for underpinning, is allocated by the courts according to the relative gravity of the design and execution faults.
What conditions govern the choice between remediation of the works and price reduction?
The choice between physical remediation and compensation via a price reduction is governed by strict criteria under the Code of Obligations (CO) and standard SIA 118. Under the revised works contract rules in force since 1 January 2026, any advance clause restricting or excluding the right to defect remediation is void where building works are concerned. The client thus holds a primary right to demand cost-free remediation provided it is technically feasible and does not impose disproportionate expenses on the contractor. If the contractor proves that demolishing and rebuilding a non-structural masonry wall out of plumb by a few millimetres would cost around 45 000 CHF while the loss of utility and aesthetic disturbance are negligible, demanding remediation may be deemed an abuse of rights. In that scenario, the client must accept a financial price reduction. The deduction reflects the objective difference between the open market value of the works without defect and their actual value as built, calculated using the proportional method recognized by Swiss courts or determined through technical assessments by site management.
How to manage defect clearance and the release of the guarantee bond after 2 years?
Closing the two-year warranty period under standard SIA 118 requires a rigorous final verification procedure before any bank guarantee or insurance bond is released. Around one month before the expiry of the two-year period running from the date of the initial acceptance report, the site management organises a joint inspection of the work with the client and the contractor. This visit aims to examine the condition of the work and confirm the complete rectification of all minor defects recorded during the initial acceptance, as well as the resolution of any defects that appeared during the two years of operation. If the contractor has fulfilled all its remediation obligations, a discharge report is signed by the parties. The site management then issues a certificate authorising the client to return the deed of joint and several guarantee stipulated in the contract. On the other hand, if notified defects persist, with an estimated remediation cost in the region of 25 000 CHF, the client retains the security instrument and formally serves notice on the guarantor organisation before the commitment expires to prevent the forfeiture of its financial rights.
What are the waste sorting and traceability obligations during acceptance remediation work?
Carrying out repair or remediation work following the acceptance report must scrupulously comply with federal environmental requirements governing construction waste. Even for isolated finishing work interventions such as screed patching, replacing joinery or repairing waterproofing membranes, art. 17 OLED requires dismantled materials to be sorted directly on the construction site. Hazardous waste must strictly be separated from other categories and disposed of through licensed channels, while recoverable fractions such as metals, wood or glass must be sent to appropriate recycling facilities. The contractor carrying out the remediation remains civilly and administratively liable for cleanly removing its rubble and keeping the surroundings of the handed-over work clean. Before approving the payment voucher for the remediation or validating the release of retained funds, the site management must require waste tracking slips or controlled landfill receipts proving that the disposal of residual rubble complies with the law.
Operational summary for construction professionals
Acceptance of the work and defect management in SIA phases 52 and 53 represent the technical and legal culmination of any real estate project in Switzerland. Mastered compliance with the requirements of standard SIA 118 and the new protective provisions of the Code of Obligations (CO) allows site management and the client to secure the transfer of risks, ensure safe commissioning and preserve the asset value of completed works. To explore each specific procedure in depth and deploy the appropriate protocols on your construction sites, consult our detailed guides:
- Acceptance of the Work (SIA 118): Notice of Completion, One-Month Period and Tacit Acceptance
- Minor vs Major Defects Preventing Handover (SIA 118): Criteria and Federal Supreme Court Case Law
- The Client's 3 Remedies for Defects (SIA 118 / CO 2026): Repair, Price Reduction or Termination
- SIA Phase 52 (Commissioning): Building Services Functional Testing, Hydronic Balancing and Handover
- Compiling the As-Built Documentation (DOE) in Switzerland: As-Built Drawings and Certificates
