Table of contents
The 3 Major Site Risks
- Financial / Margin: Improperly withholding a final account of several hundred thousand CHF for mere finishing imperfections, exposing the client to default interest of 5% per annum under art. 104 CO, or facing an excessive, unagreed price reduction under art. 368 CO.
- Legal / Joint Body / SUVA: Misclassification leading to the forfeiture of the client's rights through tacit approval under art. 370 CO, or physical endangerment under art. 229 CP in the event of a serious construction defect affecting the stability or safety of the works without protective measures.
- Administrative / Acceptance: Wrongfully refusing the joint inspection record under standard SIA 118 for defects that do not preclude the agreed use, triggering an unjustified postponement of the transfer of risks and opening a dispute regarding the starting point of the five-year limitation period under art. 371 CO.
On Swiss construction sites governed by a contract for work and services, distinguishing between a minor defect and a major defect is the cornerstone of inspection operations conducted by site management and the client. While physical delivery marks the completion of construction works, legal acceptance confirms the approval of the works and triggers the transfer of risks as well as the running of warranty periods. Under the settled case law of the Federal Supreme Court and the regime of standard SIA 118 combined with art. 367 CO, the existence of defects does not automatically justify refusing acceptance. The precise classification of the condition of the works directly dictates the outcome of the acceptance report, the release of securities and the due date of the agreed price.
For construction professionals in French-speaking Switzerland, site managers, architects and clients, the challenge lies in applying objective criteria to distinguish a major defect, which renders the works unfit for their agreed use or inadmissible according to good faith, from a minor defect, which mandates acceptance subject to remediation. Through the revised art. 368 CO and the rules of standard SIA 118, this analysis prevents improper site standstills while ensuring the rigorous exercise of the right to remediation within statutory deadlines.
Legal classification criteria: minor defect versus major defect
In Swiss construction law practice, site management and the client must classify each non-conformity recorded during the joint inspection. The core issue lies in the ability of the works to serve the agreed or objectively expected use. The Federal Supreme Court has established clear guidance: not every deviation from the contract justifies a refusal of acceptance. A defect is classified as minor when it does not appreciably impair the normal operation, safety or habitability of the building. Conversely, a major defect renders the works unfit for their intended purpose or makes acceptance objectively intolerable.
Under the Code of Obligations (CO) as well as under the contractual framework of standard SIA 118, this distinction produces opposite legal effects. When the recorded imperfections are classified as minor defects, acceptance takes effect upon conclusion of the inspection. The works are deemed accepted, risks are transferred to the client, and the starting point of the limitation periods begins to run pursuant to the applicable rules. The contractor remains bound to carry out remediation works within the agreed timeframe. If the defect is classified as major, the client may refuse acceptance: the works remain in the contractor's custody, without transfer of risks or maturity of the balance for the works within the meaning of art. 372 CO.
Structural safety and the recognised rules of the art
A defect that compromises the stability of a load-bearing element or user safety is invariably classified as major. Under art. 229 CP, which penalises violations of the recognised rules of construction when life or physical integrity is endangered, compliance with fundamental technical requirements is mandatory for every party involved. For instance, a reinforcement error or an insufficient slab load capacity precludes any acceptance, as the client cannot be forced to take over an unsafe building. Watertightness requirements for roofs or basement tanking also consistently represent cases of major defects, since water ingress rapidly degrades the building structure.
Impairment of commercial operation or habitability
Fitness for use is also assessed in light of the economic purpose of the building. In an office complex or a rental property, the overall failure of the central ventilation system or the lack of main electrical power supply constitutes a major defect precluding handover. Conversely, imperfect finishes, minor deviations in levelness that do not prevent the laying of floor coverings, or superficial hairline cracks without structural implications constitute minor defects. These imperfections entitle the client to remediation under art. 368 CO, without bringing the transfer of the works to a standstill.
Comparative table of classifications and their effects
The following table summarises the evaluation criteria applied by Swiss courts and site management practitioners to classify non-conformities:
| Evaluation criterion | Minor defect (SIA 118 / CO) | Major defect (SIA 118 / CO) | Consequence on acceptance | Financial and contractual impact |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Fitness for the intended use | Fully preserved, limited aesthetic or ergonomic inconvenience | Compromised or intolerable for the client | Acceptance pronounced with snag list for minor; acceptance refused for major | Minor: balance due subject to right of retention; Major: balance not due |
| Safety and recognised rules of the art | No risk to persons or the structure | Risk to stability or user safety | Acceptance mandatorily postponed in case of major defect until remediation | Minor: completion deadline set; Major: continuation of project delay possible |
| Transfer of risks | Risks transferred to the client on the agreed date | Risks remain with the contractor | Closure of execution phase for minor defect; site remains under contractor custody for major | Minor: property insurance takes over; Major: construction site insurance maintained |
| Limitation periods | Starting point of the five-year limitation period under art. 371 CO | Limitation periods suspended, not triggered | Inspection does not constitute acceptance when a major defect is identified | Minor: progressive release of guarantees; Major: full retention of securities |
| Rights of the client | Remediation demand as a priority, or price reduction | Refusal of acceptance, prior remediation, possible contract termination | Acceptance report signed with reservations or reasoned notice of refusal | Application of art. 368 CO for remediation of identified defects |
Frequent mistakes by site management and financial consequences
Incorrect classification during a joint inspection record exposes the parties to heavy financial losses. Site management must act with technical and legal rigour to protect its principal's rights.
Unjustified refusal of acceptance for minor defects
The most widespread mistake consists in refusing acceptance due to an accumulation of unfinished finishing details, even though the building is fully habitable. Legally, such a refusal is ineffective. The Federal Supreme Court considers that the client commits an abuse of rights by refusing to accept works that exhibit only minor defects. The financial consequences are immediate: the client is served with a formal notice for payment of the final advance payment or the balance under art. 102 CO, risking liability for default interest of 5% per annum under art. 104 CO. On a contractor claim of 400 000 CHF wrongly withheld for six months, default interest amounts to an unnecessary additional cost of roughly 10 000 CHF, not including legal fees.
Acceptance without reservation and forfeiture of rights
Conversely, allowing the handover of works affected by non-conformities without drafting a detailed inspection report can amount to tacit approval under art. 370 CO. If the client or site management fails to notify recorded defects within the statutory 60-day notice period provided for in art. 367 CO for immovable structures, visible defects are deemed approved. The contractor is discharged from warranty obligations for those specific elements, shifting the financial burden of repairs onto the client, which can amount to tens of thousands of CHF for poorly installed finishes or joinery.
Illustrative practical cases (typical scenarios on Swiss construction sites)
The following situations are illustrative examples designed for technical and contractual analysis, and do not represent actual construction sites.
Standard Scenario 1: Rental residential building in the Canton of Vaud (interior finishes)
On a construction site for 18 housing units in the Canton of Vaud, involving an average workforce of 15 finishing work operatives, the final inspection reveals several punch-list items: scratches on balcony glazing, incomplete silicone joints in three bathrooms, and interior doors slightly rubbing on parquet flooring. The estimated total cost of these repairs is approximately 8 500 CHF out of an overall joinery contract of 320 000 CHF.
Classification and decision: Site management classifies these defects as minor. Habitability of the apartments is not compromised, and health standards are respected. Acceptance is granted with reservations. A performance deadline of 20 working days is granted to the contractor to carry out remediation. The client withholds a proportionate amount of 15 000 CHF on the final invoice until all punch-list items are fully cleared, avoiding any risk of an unjustified formal notice.
Standard Scenario 2: Office building in the Canton of Geneva (safety and waterproofing)
During the inspection of an office building in Geneva, involving a team of 25 workers on structural work and building envelopes, water ingress is detected on the flat roof during a rain event, soaking insulation layers and technical suspended ceilings. At the same time, the smoke extraction system in the main staircase suffers an engine breakdown.
Classification and decision: These non-conformities directly compromise occupant safety and the preservation of the works. They are classified as major defects. Acceptance is formally refused by site management on behalf of the client, pursuant to the contract for work and services governed by standard SIA 118 and art. 368 CO. The works are not accepted, risks remain with the contractors concerned, and a new inspection date is scheduled following complete remediation of the waterproofing and replacement of the smoke extraction system.
Contracts and SIA 118: free tools
Advance payments and retentions, surety bonds, price escalations, daywork reports, subcontractor monitoring.
Frequently asked questions
Can an aesthetic defect justify refusing acceptance under standard SIA 118?
No. An aesthetic defect with no impact on safety or use is classified as a minor defect. Under standard SIA 118, the works are accepted subject to the obligation to rectify the defect. If remediation entails disproportionate costs, for example 15 000 CHF for exterior render, a price reduction applies.
What impact does a major defect have on the limitation periods under art. 371 CO?
In the event of a major defect, acceptance is refused. Since the works are not delivered, the five-year limitation period for defects in immovable structures under art. 371 CO does not begin to run. The contractor remains bound to achieve full completion before requesting a new joint inspection.
How does site management record defects in the inspection report?
Site management itemises each defect in the acceptance report, specifies its classification as minor or major, and sets a completion deadline. For a minor defect estimated at 4 000 CHF, the works are accepted, which triggers the warranty period provided for in standard SIA 118.
Does the absence of an HVAC compliance report constitute a major defect?
Yes, if the lack of testing makes it impossible to prove that the installations are safe or operational. If the premises cannot be used for their intended purpose, the client may refuse acceptance under standard SIA 118 until full measurements are provided by the specialist contractor.
Can acceptance be refused if temporary guardrails remain on the construction site?
The absence of compliant permanent guardrails compromises user safety and prevents the normal use of the building. This non-conformity constitutes a major defect justifying a refusal of acceptance under standard SIA 118. The works cannot be handed over to the client in such a state.
What direct financial consequences does a refusal of acceptance have for the contractor?
The contractor bears the risks associated with the works and cannot demand final payment under art. 372 CO, as the price only becomes payable upon delivery. In addition, contractual penalties for delay may continue to accrue if a specific clause was formally stipulated in the contract.
Rigorous management of acceptance and traceability on Swiss construction sites
Distinguishing between a minor defect and a major defect protects the financial and legal interests of project stakeholders. An accurate classification recorded in the formal record avoids costly disputes and ensures contractual commitments are met. To learn more about acceptance protocols, explore our dedicated resources:
- Acceptance of the Work, Classification of Defects and Commissioning (SIA Phases 52 & 53 / SIA 118)
- Acceptance of the Work (SIA 118): Notice of Completion, One-Month Period and Tacit Acceptance
- The Client's 3 Remedies for Defects (SIA 118 / CO 2026): Repair, Price Reduction or Termination
- SIA Phase 52 (Commissioning): Building Services Functional Testing, Hydronic Balancing and Handover
