Table of contents
The 3 Major Site Risks
- Financial / Margin: Disproportionate remediation costs or dispute over a payment withholding that may reach around 10% to 25% of the trade package amount in the absence of formally setting a reasonable time limit, in connection with art. 368 CO and standard SIA 118.
- Legal / Joint / SUVA: Forfeiture of the client's rights for lack of a notice of defects within the statutory 60-day time limit for an immovable work pursuant to art. 367 CO, or physical endangerment during remedial work carried out in violation of the recognised rules of the building trade within the meaning of art. 229 CP.
- Administrative / Acceptance: Blocking of collateral release or tacit acceptance of a defective work depriving the client of its remediation prerogatives under art. 370 CO and the clauses of standard SIA 118.
Discovering a defect on a Swiss construction site requires site management and the client to maintain absolute procedural rigour to protect their contractual rights. Depending on the applicable regime, whether arising from a contract for work governed by the Code of Obligations (CO) or through the incorporation of standard SIA 118, the occurrence of a physical non-conformity opens a clearly defined hierarchy of options: the right to demand free repair of the work, a proportional reduction in price agreed in the form of a price reduction, or contract cancellation in the presence of defects so severe that the work becomes unfit for use. The revision of the law on defects, which entered into force on 1 January 2026, strengthens the legal framework by setting a mandatory 60-day time limit in art. 367 CO to notify defects in an immovable work after delivery, while prohibiting under art. 368 CO any clauses waiving the right to have building defects repaired.
In the operational practice of French-speaking Swiss construction sites, the technical and contractual characterisation of defective workmanship determines the success of steps taken by site management. While the general law of the Code of Obligations (CO) provides for the alternative exercise of the client's formative rights subject to statutory conditions, standard SIA 118 first establishes a contractor's priority right to eliminate the defect at its own expense within a reasonable time limit. This structure requires building professionals to master notification protocols, economic disproportion criteria for remediation costs, and methods for calculating an objective price reduction, in order to prevent costly disputes, ensure the traceability of completion notices, and guarantee the lasting conformity of the delivered work.
Hierarchy and exercise of client rights under standard SIA 118 and the Code of Obligations
The Swiss legal regime governing construction defects relies on a precise balance between the general rules of the Code of Obligations (CO) and the customary contractual derogations arising from standard SIA 118. When a technical or functional deviation is formally recorded during verification of the work or during operation, the client has strict prerogatives whose exercise depends on the contractual framework agreed between the parties.
Under the baseline statutory regime governed by art. 368 CO, the client may choose between remediation of the work free of charge, a proportional price reduction, or cancellation of the contract when a major defect renders the work unusable. Since the revision of the law on defects took effect on 1 January 2026, art. 368 para. 2bis CO specifies that any clause limiting or excluding in advance the right to repair a building is null and void, safeguarding this prerogative as mandatory Swiss law. For immovable property, art. 367 CO sets a 60-day time limit for notifying defects after their discovery, with any shorter contractual time limit being void.
Unlike the statutory regime where the client generally enjoys a direct option, the contractual incorporation of standard SIA 118 alters the implementation timeline. Standard SIA 118 primarily grants the contractor the right to repair the defective work within a reasonable time limit. The client may only opt unilaterally for a price reduction or cancellation after giving formal notice to the contractor to carry out remediation and noting its refusal or the failure of its intervention, in accordance with the general principles of art. 107 CO.
The priority right to remediation of the work
Remediation consists in requiring the contractor to eliminate the observed non-conformities at its own expense, restoring the work to a state that complies with the recognised rules of the building trade and the contract documents. This claim entails full assumption by the contractor of supplementary engineering, removal, supply of replacement materials, labour, and making good any affected adjacent finishes.
The contractor may only refuse remediation if it would entail disproportionate expense compared to the objective utility gained by the client. To compel the contractor, site management must serve a written warning setting a specific time limit to finish the remedial work. If the contractor remains inactive upon expiry of this deadline, the client may entrust the continuation of work or repairs to a third party at the defaulting contractor's expense and risk, pursuant to the rules of art. 366 CO and standard SIA 118.
Reduction of the price of the work (price reduction)
Where repair proves technically impossible, financially disproportionate, or is rejected by the client following the failure of a first attempt, reducing the price of the work constitutes the preferred option. The price reduction aims to offset the reduction in market value or utility resulting from the remaining defect.
The reduction is calculated using the proportional method recognised under Swiss law: the agreed price is reduced in the same proportion as that between the objective value of the defective work and its theoretical value without defect. On site, if this objective value proves difficult to isolate, the amount of the deduction may be calculated on an equivalence basis from the estimated cost of compensatory measures or the residual loss of use accepted by the client.
Cancellation of the contract in the event of a fundamental defect
Contractual cancellation represents the remedy of last resort and requires the presence of a defect so substantial that the work proves unusable or even dangerous. When the work is erected on the client's own land and cannot be demolished without excessive disadvantage, Swiss law restricts the client to remediation or price reduction to prevent disproportionate destruction of economic value, in accordance with the principles of art. 368 CO and standard SIA 118.
Cancellation entails the contractor's obligation to refund advance payments received, plus default interest of 5% per annum under art. 104 CO, while the client returns any recoverable movable items. If the defect results from an intentional breach of the rules of the building trade endangering human life or physical integrity, the site manager's criminal liability falls under art. 229 CP.
Comparative table of client rights
The table below summarises the conditions of entitlement, the exercise procedures, and the financial consequences of the three rights conferred by Swiss private construction law:
| Available right | Required prerequisites | Procedural mechanism under standard SIA 118 | Financial consequences for the client | Main operational risk for the contractor |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Free remediation | Repairable defect without causing disproportionate costs | Formal notification with a reasonable performance period | Contract price maintained, zero additional cost | Cost price overrun and loss of gross margin |
| Substituted performance | Contractor default after expiry of the set time limit | Notice informing of intervention by a third-party firm | Direct billing of third-party costs to the initial contractor | Loss of right to remedy and dispute over third-party invoice |
| Price reduction | Minor defect, irreparable, or disproportionate remediation | Mutual agreement or declaration after fruitless formal notice | Deduction applied to the final account in CHF | Direct reduction of the contractor's collectable claim |
| Contract cancellation | Major defect rendering the work unfit for its purpose | Refusal of acceptance or reasoned declaration of cancellation | Refund of advance payments with 5% default interest | Total loss of the trade package, removal and return obligation |
| Supplementary damages | Proven fault and demonstrable direct consequential loss | Joint notification alongside the exercise of the formal right | Compensation for business interruption or relocation costs | Challenge to civil liability insurance coverage |
Common procedural mistakes and their financial impacts on site
On Swiss construction sites, a lack of rigour in tracking notices of defects regularly causes major financial losses for the parties involved:
- Omission of formal warning: Directly ordering repairs from a third-party firm without having granted a reasonable performance period to the contracting contractor under art. 366 CO and standard SIA 118. The original contractor may refuse to pay the third-party invoice, leaving extra costs of around 15 000 CHF to 60 000 CHF to be borne by the client.
- Late notice of defects: For an immovable work subject to the Code of Obligations (CO), exceeding the statutory 60-day time limit set in art. 367 CO entails tacit acceptance of the work under art. 370 CO and the irreversible forfeiture of remediation rights for apparent defects.
- Arbitrary calculation of payment withholding: Unilaterally withholding a sum that far exceeds the foreseeable value of the defect. Such abusive retention exposes the client to formal notice under art. 102 CO and the registration of a statutory mortgage lien of craftsmen and contractors under art. 837 and art. 839 CC.
- Hasty substitution without a joint inspection record: Demolishing a defective work without an expert report or detailed record, stripping the client of any evidentiary means regarding the material existence of the non-conformity.
Illustrative practical cases (typical scenarios on Swiss construction sites)
The figures and situations below are illustrative examples intended to model operational decision-making by site management when faced with an identified defect.
Scenario 1: Non-conformity of basement tanking (Canton of Vaud)
On a multi-family housing construction site in the canton of Vaud with an average workforce of 18 workers, site management observes water ingress in the basement through the waterproof raft foundation. The structural work package amounts to 1 450 000 CHF. The defect is of medium severity: it prevents the use of the cellars but does not compromise the building's stability.
Because the contract incorporates standard SIA 118, the client cannot immediately claim a financial price reduction. Site management issues a notice of defects accompanied by formal notice granting 20 working days to submit a resin pressure-injection method statement. The contractor carries out the work at no extra cost within the allotted time limit. The restored watertightness is recorded in a snagging sign-off sheet, avoiding third-party remediation estimated at around 45 000 CHF.
Scenario 2: Aesthetic defect on rainscreen cladding (Canton of Geneva)
During the acceptance phase of an office building in the canton of Geneva (construction site workforce of 25 workers), alignment discrepancies and colour variations are identified across 250 m² of composite facade panels. The metalwork and facades trade package amounts to 380 000 CHF.
The expert assessment concludes that structural safety and building physics are not compromised. Complete removal and refabrication would represent an amount of around 85 000 CHF, deemed disproportionate for a purely aesthetic defect. The parties negotiate a final lump-sum price reduction of 32 000 CHF deducted from the final account, releasing the remaining retention money without legal proceedings.
Contracts and SIA 118: free tools
Advance payments and retentions, surety bonds, price escalations, daywork reports, subcontractor monitoring.
Frequently asked questions
What is the statutory deadline for reporting a defect in an immovable work?
Under art. 367 CO, the client has 60 days to report defects in an immovable work once they are discovered. A shorter contractual deadline is null and void. Under the SIA 118 standard regime, defects may be reported at any time during the two-year warranty period.
Can the contractor refuse to rectify a defect?
Under art. 368 CO, the contractor may refuse rectification if the operations entail disproportionate expenses compared to the benefit for the client. If the refusal is unjustified for an illustrative 12 000 CHF remedial cost, the client may hire a third party at the defaulting contractor's expense.
How is the amount of a price reduction calculated using the proportional method?
The method compares the value of the work without defects to its value with defects. For flooring billed at an illustrative 50 000 CHF whose objective value drops by 10% due to unmet tolerances, the final price owed to the contractor is reduced in the same proportion, namely 5 000 CHF.
When can the client demand termination of the contract for work and services?
In accordance with art. 368 CO, termination requires a defect so severe that the work is unusable or that acceptance cannot equitably be demanded. For a structure erected on the client's land, the law rules out demolition if it causes disproportionate detriment to the parties.
Is the site management liable in the event of an incorrect defect qualification?
Yes. Pursuant to art. 398 CO, the site management is liable for the diligent and faithful performance of its mandate. A classification error that deprives the principal of a formal right or generates an unjustified extra cost of an illustrative 20 000 CHF incurs the agent's contractual civil liability towards the client.
What limitation period applies to claims for construction defects?
Under art. 371 CO, the client's rights regarding defects in an immovable work are subject to a five-year limitation period from acceptance, applicable to the contractor, the architect, or the engineer. This statutory five-year period cannot be shortened to the detriment of the client.
Rigorous management of construction defects safeguards the financial and legal balance of building projects. To explore every stage of construction site supervision and standard acceptance procedures in detail, consult our dedicated guides:
- Acceptance of the Work, Classification of Defects and Commissioning (SIA Phases 52 & 53 / SIA 118)
- Acceptance of the Work (SIA 118): Notice of Completion, One-Month Period and Tacit Acceptance
- Minor vs Major Defects Preventing Handover (SIA 118): Criteria and Federal Supreme Court Case Law
- SIA Phase 52 (Commissioning): Building Services Functional Testing, Hydronic Balancing and Handover
