Table of contents
The 3 Major Site Risks
- Financial / Margin: Full assumption of remedial costs (often in the range of 15 to 30 % of the trade budget) if the contractor fails to report a design error or defective ground, in accordance with art. 365 CO which makes them bear the consequences.
- Legal / Joint Body / SUVA: Loss of the right to be exempted from liability for defects in the work, as art. 369 CO requires formal notices from the contractor for defective performance to be attributable to the client.
- Administrative / Acceptance: Blocking of the joint inspection and refusal of acceptance of the work under standard SIA 118, leading to an indefinite delay in final payment and release of retention money.
The duty to notify represents a cornerstone obligation for the contractor during the execution of a contract for work and services in Switzerland. Faced with technical complexity and tight deadlines, site management and site supervisors must master this reporting duty. When a design error is identified in the drawings or the designated ground proves unsuitable, silence is never a viable option. Art. 365 CO requires the contractor to immediately notify the client of any circumstance that compromises the proper or timely execution of the work. Otherwise, the contractor personally bears the technical and financial consequences. Taking this proactive approach safeguards the integrity of the work and ensures corrective decisions are made early on, preventing prohibitive repair costs.
In Swiss construction practice, standard SIA 118 formally governs this legal obligation. Notifying a design error is not an act of opposition, but an essential protective safeguard. Art. 369 CO provides that the client's rights in respect of defects are excluded if the defect is attributable to the client, notably where the client maintained instructions despite formal warnings from the contractor. To be legally effective, this notification must be made in writing, addressed without delay to site management, and thoroughly documented. It serves as a vital risk management tool to clarify liabilities before acceptance of the work. Construction professionals must integrate this procedure into their day-to-day site monitoring, ensuring every warning is tracked and accompanied by alternative solutions costed in CHF.
Criteria and procedure for notifying a design error
Detecting a design error or technical inconsistency requires an immediate, structured response from the contractor. On a Swiss construction site, the duty to notify is not merely a verbal remark made during a coordination meeting; it is a formal legal step aimed at protecting the work and establishing clear liabilities. As a specialist trade contractor, you are required to examine drawings, instructions, and supplied materials with the standard of care required by recognised trade practice.
Technical analysis and identification of non-conformities
Even before starting work, the contractor must carry out a meticulous check of the contract documents. This obligation stems from the principle that the contractor executes the work under personal supervision and assumes liability for the quality of the work, in accordance with art. 364 CO. Verification points systematically include the technical buildability of the engineer's drawings, the compatibility of specified materials with building physics requirements, and the suitability of the ground conditions. If the ground designated by the client proves defective, or if any other circumstance compromises the proper or timely execution of the work, art. 365 CO requires the contractor to inform the client immediately. This proactive analysis prevents planning errors from turning into major structural defects.
Formal procedure and submission of notices to site management
To be legally valid and release the contractor from liability, the notification must follow a strict formal procedure, even though the law does not set a mandatory format for every situation. However, standard SIA 118 and industry best practice strictly require written form. The notice must be sent without delay to site management, acting as the representative of the client. Under art. 32 CO, the rights and obligations arising from a contract made by an authorised agent in the name of another pass directly to the principal. The notice must contain three key elements: a clear description of the design error or inappropriate instruction, an explanation of the technical or financial consequences if the instruction is maintained (such as a collapse risk or non-compliance with fire protection standards), and, wherever possible, a proposed alternative solution. A simple email or an entry in the site logbook countersigned by site management constitutes sufficient proof.
Comparison table: Compliant vs non-compliant duty to notify management
The table below highlights the fundamental differences between rigorous handling of the duty to notify under standard SIA 118 and the Code of Obligations (CO), and the risky practices frequently observed in the field.
| Site situation | Risky practice (Error) | Compliant practice (SIA 118 / CO) | Consequence of the error |
|---|---|---|---|
| Discovery of unstable ground during excavation | Continuing earthworks without saying anything to meet the schedule. | Immediate work stoppage, written notice to site management (art. 365 CO). | Additional Special Foundations costs borne entirely by the contractor. |
| Major discrepancy between execution drawings and the quote description | Arbitrarily choosing the cheapest solution without consulting anyone. | Requesting written clarification from site management before execution. | Demolition and rectification at the contractor's exclusive expense. |
| Direct order to pour concrete despite reinforcement deemed insufficient | Carrying out the order assuming the structural engineer takes the blame. | Issuing a formal written notice to disclaim liability (art. 369 CO). | Joint and several liability if cracking or structural failure occurs. |
| Client-supplied material that is visibly unsuitable | Installing the material on the grounds that the choice lies with the client. | Reporting the defect in the supplied material immediately (art. 365 CO). | Obligation to replace the material and redo the work free of charge. |
| Significant delay in the delivery of final execution drawings | Waiting passively on the construction site, racking up idle hours. | Formally reporting the disruption to the timely progress of the work. | Inability to claim an extension of time or financial compensation. |
Common mistakes and financial consequences on site
Neglecting the duty to notify often causes disastrous financial repercussions for construction firms. The most common pitfall is relying on an informal verbal remark to the site manager or architect during a routine walkthrough. If a dispute later arises, the lack of written records makes it impossible to prove notice was given. The contractor is then deprived of the protection afforded by art. 369 CO, which excludes the client's defect rights where defective execution is attributable to the client, specifically following instructions maintained contrary to the contractor's formal advice. Without written proof, the client will enforce statutory warranty rights for defects, such as remediation or price reduction, under art. 368 CO.
Another classic mistake is misplaced eagerness to please or the reluctance to challenge site management. A contractor who notices that the slope of a flat roof fails to meet standard trade rules, but proceeds according to the drawings to protect the schedule, commits a serious fault. If water leaks occur two years later, remediation costs—including stripping down the waterproofing, reshaping the falls, and repairing interior finishes—can easily reach 40 000 to 80 000 CHF. The contractor will have to absorb these costs because the circumstance compromising the work was not reported under art. 365 CO. Furthermore, the limitation period for the client's claims regarding defects in immovable structures is five years against the contractor under art. 371 CO, leaving an extensive period of financial exposure if the duty to notify has not been documented.
Illustrative practical cases (typical scenarios on Swiss construction sites)
The following scenarios are illustrative examples designed to demonstrate practical enforcement of the duty to notify; they do not represent real construction sites or actual firms.
Scenario 1: Earthworks and foundations in the canton of Vaud
Context: A civil engineering contractor (workforce of 6 plant operators and masons) is contracted for the excavation of a residential building. During topsoil stripping, the site foreman discovers an old pipeline omitted from the surveyor's drawings alongside an unstable backfill pocket missing from the geotechnical report provided by the client.
Action and justification: The contractor immediately halts work in this specific zone. A written notice is sent to site management with supporting photos, stating that the designated ground is defective and threatens safe and punctual completion of the work (strict application of art. 365 CO). Clear instructions are requested from the civil engineer regarding backfill removal and pipe handling.
Consequence avoided: By formalising this notice, the firm shields itself against delays attributable to this discovery. Had excavation continued unflagged, a trench collapse could have occurred, endangering workers and requiring emergency ground stabilisation works estimated at over 50 000 CHF, all at the contractor's sole expense.
Scenario 2: Ventilation installation in the canton of Geneva
Context: An HVAC contractor (workforce of 4 installers) is working on a commercial office building. During site preparation, the technician notices that slab penetrations laid out by the civil engineer are 150 mm in diameter, whereas the quote specifications require 200 mm ventilation ducts to ensure statutory airflow rates.
Action and justification: Before the slabs are poured by the main builder, the HVAC installer sends a formal notice to site management highlighting the mismatch between the engineering drawings and quote requirements. The installer disclaims liability for future aerodynamic performance if penetration diameters are not rectified.
Consequence avoided: This notice enables site management to update formwork drawings in time. Without this intervention, the ventilation firm would have had to require core drilling through reinforced concrete during subsequent fit-out, creating around 15 000 CHF in extra costs and risking structural impairment. Reporting the design error fulfills the duty of diligence and secures the contractor's profit margin.
Scenario 3: Flooring installation in the canton of Fribourg
Context: A flooring installer (workforce of 3 craftsmen) is hired to lay solid wood parquet supplied directly by the client. Upon taking delivery of the goods on the construction site, the installer measures wood moisture levels well above the tolerances allowed by recognised trade rules.
Action and justification: The contractor immediately alerts the client and site management that the supplied material is defective (art. 365 CO). When the client insists on immediate installation to move in on time, the contractor issues a formal notice disclaiming all liability for future floor deformation, cupping, or splitting.
Consequence avoided: Six months later, the parquet buckles. Thanks to the prior written warning, the contractor benefits from the exclusion of the client's rights under art. 369 CO. The contractor does not have to pay for a full floor replacement, where material and labour costs would have meant a net loss of around 25 000 CHF.
Contracts and SIA 118: free tools
Advance payments and retentions, surety bonds, price escalations, daywork reports, subcontractor monitoring.
Frequently asked questions
Notifying an error under the Code of Obligations (CO)?
The contractor must immediately notify the client if any circumstance compromises execution, pursuant to art. 365 CO. Written notice to site management is essential to prevent the consequences of defective execution and release contractual liability.
What happens if formal notice is ignored?
If defective execution stems from instructions issued against the contractor's formal advice, art. 369 CO bars the client's defect rights. The contractor retains entitlement to compensation, for example in the region of 15 000 CHF for the works.
Time limit to report a defect after handover?
After handover, the client inspects the work as soon as feasible. For an immovable structure, art. 367 CO grants 60 days to report defects. Any shorter contractual deadline is null and void. The SIA 118 standard sets out the details of these inspections.
Liability if the designated ground is defective?
Yes, without prior notice. Art. 365 CO states that if the ground is found to be defective, the contractor must immediately notify the client, under penalty of bearing the consequences. This notice avoids illustrative additional costs of 20 000 CHF.
Criminal liability of site management?
Yes. Anyone directing construction work who intentionally breaches the recognised rules of the art and knowingly endangers life faces penalties under art. 229 CP. Concealing a structural defect triggers the contractor's criminal liability.
Handling a discrepancy between plans and quote?
The contractor suspends execution and issues a formal notice to site management. The SIA 118 standard governs the order of precedence among documents. Ignoring such a discrepancy makes the firm liable for defects and subsequent remedial costs.
The duty to notify shields the contractor against design errors. Documented notification ensures compliance with art. 365 CO and the SIA 118 standard. To explore contract management in Switzerland in greater detail, see:
- Site Management in Switzerland: Project Management/Site Supervision Roles, SIA 118 Contracts and Governance (RPH 2026)
- DGP vs DLT vs Site Manager: Division of Civil and Criminal Responsibilities (RPH SIA 2026)
- Discrepancies Between Drawings and CAN Quotes: Order of Priority of Contract Documents (SIA 118)
- Client Representation by Site Management: Financial and Legal Limits (SIA 118)
