Table of contents
The 3 Major Site Risks
- Financial / Margin: Unrecognised extra costs during variation orders caused by a discrepancy between the description and the drawing. Estimated margin loss around 10 to 15 % on the affected item if the contractor prices based on an incorrect drawing without checking the quote under standard SIA 118.
- Legal / Joint Body / SUVA: Liability incurred when executing defective work as a result of an unreported document discrepancy. The Code of Obligations requires the client to be notified if any circumstance jeopardises the proper execution of the work (art. 365 CO).
- Administrative / Acceptance: Acceptance of the work blocked and disputes over final accounts. An interpretation dispute between contract documents delays the joint inspection and handover set out in standard SIA 118.
On a construction site in Switzerland, document management is the pillar of flawless execution. Yet, it is not uncommon for site management, a site manager or a contractor to face a glaring discrepancy between the working drawings provided by the consultants and the itemised quote structured according to the Standardised Item Catalogue (CAN). Faced with such a divergence, knowing which document takes precedence becomes vital to prevent financial disputes and planning delays. Standard SIA 118 establishes a rigorous framework to resolve these conflicting interpretations by setting out a precise hierarchy of contract documents. This rule of precedence protects both the client and the executing contractors by clarifying everyone's obligations right from the preparation phase.
This guide is aimed specifically at site management teams, construction managers and clients overseeing Swiss building projects. It details the order of precedence of contract documents, from the specific agreement to the general conditions, including the project description and technical drawings. We examine how standard SIA 118 and the KBOB contract regulate these complex situations, and what the contractor's duties are regarding the duty to notify when detecting a major inconsistency. Thorough mastery of this document hierarchy is essential to safeguard the quality of the work, protect profit margins and ensure successful joint inspection, all while strictly adhering to Swiss contract law.
Order of precedence of contract documents under standard SIA 118
Within a Swiss construction project, the wide range of stakeholders and technical complexity inevitably generate an abundance of documents. When the contractor and site management face a discrepancy between the working drawings and the itemised quote drawn up under the Standardised Item Catalogue (CAN), referring to the document hierarchy is imperative. Standard SIA 118 defines a strict order of precedence for interpreting the components of a construction contract, as defined in art. 363 CO.
As a general rule, the document signed by both parties—namely the construction contract itself—holds the highest rank. Next come the special conditions, which derogate from the general conditions to suit the specific requirements of the project. Immediately after, the CAN itemised quote takes precedence over the drawings. This fundamental principle of Swiss practice confirms the primacy of written text over drawings. Through its codified structure and semantic precision, the CAN quote delivers a comprehensive description of the works, materials and execution methods. Although drawings are indispensable for geometry and setting-out, they are deemed subordinate to the written description in the event of a discrepancy.
Standard forms of contract, such as the KBOB contract widely used in public procurement, incorporate and reinforce this hierarchy. Thus, if an architect's drawing indicates a natural stone floor finish, but the CAN quote prices porcelain stoneware tiles, the quote description defines the scope of the contractor's obligation, unless an explicit addendum alters the order.
The contractor's duty to notify regarding inconsistencies
However, the precedence of the CAN quote over the drawings does not release the contractor from their duty of care. Art. 364 CO stipulates that the contractor is subject to the same liability rules as an employee and must execute the work in person or under their personal direction. If they identify an obvious discrepancy between the drawings supplied by the design team and the CAN quote description during site preparation or throughout execution, they cannot unilaterally choose the option that is most financially advantageous to them without consulting site management.
Pursuant to art. 365 CO, if any circumstance arises that compromises the proper or timely execution of the work, the contractor must inform the client immediately, or bear the consequences. This reporting requirement is critical. The contractor must issue a written notice to site management to clarify the situation before ordering materials or starting execution. If the contractor fails to report this discrepancy and executes the work according to the subordinate document (the drawing) while the quote required a higher specification, they risk having to redo the work at their own expense. Conversely, if they carry out a more expensive item shown on the drawing without prior approval, payment for the extra cost risks being refused, particularly if the contract is governed by art. 373 CO, which states that for a fixed price, the contractor must complete the work for the agreed sum and cannot claim any increase, even if the work required more labour or expenditure.
Comparison table: Resolving document discrepancies
The table below summarises the usual order of precedence of documents on a Swiss construction site, allowing site management to resolve interpretation disputes swiftly.
| Identified discrepancy | Prevailing document | Standard-based rationale (Switzerland) | Action required from site management |
|---|---|---|---|
| Construction contract vs Special conditions | Construction contract | The document signed by the parties takes precedence over appendices. | Apply the specific clauses negotiated and signed in the main contract. |
| Special conditions vs CAN quote | Special conditions | Specific derogations prevail over the standardised description. | Verify the validity of the derogation clause before approving execution. |
| CAN quote vs Working drawings | CAN quote | Standard SIA 118 confirms the primacy of the descriptive text over the drawing. | Enforce execution according to the description or issue a formal variation order. |
| Detail drawings (1:20) vs General arrangement drawings (1:100) | Detail drawings | The larger and more precise scale prevails over the smaller scale. | Update documentation and ensure the latest revision is distributed. |
| Technical description vs Applicable SIA standard | Applicable SIA standard | Recognised rules of building technology serve as a mandatory minimum standard. | Reject any work that fails to comply with safety or quality requirements. |
Common mistakes by site management and financial impacts
Careless handling of document discrepancies leads to severe financial consequences. The most frequent mistake by site management involves approving updated detail drawings from engineers or architects without checking whether those modifications create a divergence from the originally signed CAN quote. When the contractor carries out the work, they rely on the latest drawing received, stamped for construction. If that drawing incorporates higher specifications than the quote without an addendum being formally approved, the client faces justified claims for extra work.
If the delivered work shows defects related to a misinterpretation of the documents, the client will enforce their rights. Art. 367 CO requires the client to inspect the condition of the work as soon as practicable and give notice of any defects; for immovable structures, they have 60 days to report them. If non-conformity with the prevailing document is established, art. 368 CO entitles the client to demand rectification of the work, a price reduction, or to reject the work. Remedial costs, including demolition and reconstruction, can quickly reach tens of thousands of francs, drastically cutting into the defaulting contractor's profit margin if they acted without clarifying the issue. Administrative discipline is therefore the best safeguard against margin erosion.
Illustrative practical cases (typical scenarios on Swiss construction sites)
The figures and scenarios presented below are illustrative examples and do not represent actual construction sites.
Scenario 1: Discrepancy regarding reinforcement (Canton of Vaud)
On a school construction project, the structural work contractor identifies a major difference while preparing the reinforcement. The CAN quote prices a reinforcement density of 100 kilograms per cubic metre of concrete for the slabs. However, the engineer's drawings require a density of 140 kilograms per cubic metre. The contractor promptly notifies site management of this discrepancy before pouring, thereby fulfilling their duty to notify. Under standard SIA 118, the CAN quote takes precedence over the drawing. As site management realises that structural safety strictly requires the 140 kilograms, it must issue a formal variation order. The contractor is thus entitled to invoice the extra cost for the additional 40 kilograms per cubic metre, preventing an estimated dispute around 25 000 CHF. This proactive approach ensures financial transparency and protects mutual trust between the parties.
Scenario 2: Interior finishes and KBOB contract (Canton of Fribourg)
During the fit-out of an administrative building governed by a KBOB contract, the architect's drawing indicates the installation of solid oak doors. The itemised quote, meanwhile, explicitly specifies hollow-core doors with standard laminate veneer. The carpentry contractor orders and installs the solid oak doors without asking any questions, relying solely on the drawing, and then bills a substantial surcharge. Site management categorically rejects payment of this extra cost. In accordance with the document hierarchy, the itemised quote prevails over the drawing. Furthermore, under art. 373 CO, a fixed price cannot be increased unilaterally, even if the work required greater expenditure. The contractor must absorb the entire financial loss, estimated around 18 000 CHF, for failing to uphold their obligation to clarify this obvious contradiction prior to ordering materials. This case demonstrates how critical cross-checking documents is for site managers.
Contracts and SIA 118: free tools
Advance payments and retentions, surety bonds, price escalations, daywork reports, subcontractor monitoring.
Frequently asked questions
What should be done if the CAN quote specifies a different material from the one drawn on working drawings?
Under standard SIA 118, the text of the CAN itemised quote generally prevails over drawings in the event of a discrepancy. However, the contractor must exercise their duty to notify and report this divergence to site management immediately to clarify execution prior to ordering.
Does a CO construction contract allow modifying the default priority order of standard SIA 118?
Yes, the Swiss Code of Obligations upholds freedom of contract. The parties can establish a bespoke order of precedence in the special conditions. Without such a clause, incorporating standard SIA 118 applies its default hierarchy, placing the signed contract at the top.
Does a large-scale detail drawing take precedence over a general architect's drawing?
Unless the contract specifies otherwise, standard SIA 118 provides that detail drawings prevail over general drawings. This rationale ensures that the most precise technical specifications, which are often finalised last, govern site execution.
How should a conflict between the KBOB general conditions and standard SIA 118 be handled?
The KBOB general terms and conditions, frequently used in public procurement, set out their own hierarchy. As a general rule, project-specific documents take precedence over general documents. It is vital to check the works contract, which explicitly lists the agreed order of precedence.
Can the contractor claim an extra if a requirement appears on the drawing but not in the CAN quote?
If the contract incorporates standard SIA 118 and the quote takes precedence, a requirement omitted from the CAN could justify an addendum. However, the contractor must notify site management before execution. An obvious omission also falls under their duty of diligence.
What is the risk if the contractor builds according to a faulty drawing without notifying site management?
Art. 365 CO requires the contractor to notify the client immediately if any circumstance jeopardises proper performance. If they carry out work based on an obviously flawed drawing without prior notice, they are liable for defects and must bear the remediation costs, which can run into several thousand CHF.
Mastering the order of precedence of contract documents keeps any project in Switzerland secure. Rigorously managing discrepancies between drawings, CAN quotes and particular conditions prevents costly disputes. To learn more about construction site supervision and standard compliance, explore our resources:
- Site Management in Switzerland: Project Management/Site Supervision Roles, SIA 118 Contracts and Governance (RPH 2026)
- DGP vs DLT vs Site Manager: Division of Civil and Criminal Responsibilities (RPH SIA 2026)
- Contractor's Duty to Notify (SIA 118 / CO): Reporting a Design Flaw
- Client Representation by Site Management: Financial and Legal Limits (SIA 118)
