Table of contents
The 3 Major Site Risks
- Financial / Margin: Sinking non-recoverable estimating and calculation costs, frequently amounting to an internal cost of about 4 500,00 CHF to 12 000,00 CHF per tender for an SME, on a contract whose biased technical specifications already favour an incumbent competitor in breach of the principle of economical use of public funds set out in art. 2 LMP.
- Legal / Joint body / SUVA: Risk of formal disqualification during the evaluation of tenders pursuant to art. 44 LMP for administrative non-compliance or the omission of a reference requirement deliberately tailored for a third party, with no right of appeal regarding the appropriateness of such an exclusion decision under art. 56 LMP.
- Administrative / Acceptance: Finding yourself bound by a rock-bottom bid on a skewed call for tenders where the award criteria under art. 29 LMP were tailored to conceal insoluble execution constraints, shifting delay risks onto the winning contractor right from the start of the contract for work governed by art. 363 CO and standard SIA 118.
This operational guide is aimed at building company directors, estimators, quantity surveyors, and bid managers in French-speaking Switzerland reviewing public or utility calls for tenders published on Simap.ch and cantonal official gazettes. Within public procurement governed by the LMP and AIMP, equal treatment and transparency required under art. 11 LMP serve as fundamental theoretical safeguards. However, some contracting authorities draft technical specifications or award criteria so specific that they implicitly target a pre-selected bidder, creating what practitioners term a locked-in or rigged tender. Knowing how to identify these warning signals right from publication saves companies from wasting valuable technical office estimating resources.
To safeguard your process, a meticulous review of the itemised bill of quantities based on the standard building catalogue (CAN) published by CRB and checking the award criteria under art. 29 LMP are essential. By spotting proprietary technical specifications or unworkable schedules, professionals can objectively assess their actual chances of success before committing, thereby protecting their firm's profitability against skewed procedures.
Method for analysing a call for tenders: spotting the telltale signs of a rigged procurement
In the Swiss construction sector, methodically screening notices published on official platforms demands a sharp critical eye. Although legislation mandates fair competition pursuant to art. 2 LMP and the AIMP, certain public or utility procedures conceal requirements tailored to a specific operator. Spotting these signals before undertaking estimating work prevents exhausting your technical office resources.
A rigged tender is characterised by a combination of administrative anomalies, disproportionate qualification criteria, and restrictive technical specifications. When a public buyer seeks tacitly to renew an incumbent contractor or favour a specific regional manufacturer, it introduces subtle constraints that artificially restrict access to the contract, in violation of the principle of equal treatment guaranteed by art. 11 LMP.
Sign 1: Oversized financial and technical qualification criteria
The assessment of qualification criteria must remain strictly commensurate with the complexity of the works. When a contracting authority requires, for standard remediation work valued at an estimated 400 000,00 CHF, proof of an outsized annual turnover or the execution of three strictly identical reference projects over the past twenty-four months in the same district, the lock-in is flagrant. These restrictions directly target the equipment fleet of a specific competitor or its track record with the public authority. Art. 31 LMP permits the formation of bidding consortia to pool required capabilities, unless the call for tenders restricts this without objective technical justification.
Sign 2: Submission deadlines incompatible with a thorough review
Setting a particularly short submission deadline for a voluminous tender dossier is a classic filtering tactic. The contracting authority formally complies with time limits, yet publishes a comprehensive itemised bill of quantities containing dozens of items without detailed quantities, requiring mandatory site visits during single, narrow time slots of just a few hours. The pre-selected candidate, having often participated in preparatory studies or already holding execution surveys, can submit a fully calculated bid while other bidders struggle to obtain pricing from their suppliers in the meantime.
Sign 3: Proprietary material specifications lacking an equivalence clause
In itemised bills of quantities structured around the standard building catalogue (CAN) or Construction Cost Code (CFC) chapters, referencing brand names, trade catalogue numbers, or patented processes directly is strictly regulated. If the contracting authority specifies an extrusion profile, a waterproofing system, or an air handling unit from a single manufacturer without explicitly adding "or equivalent", the procurement is biased. Even when an equivalence clause is included in the special conditions, millimetric dimensional requirements or non-harmonised proprietary certifications aim to disqualify any alternative system during technical compliance checks.
Sign 4: Award criteria weighting that encourages subjectivity
Art. 29 LMP provides that the contracting authority evaluates tenders based on criteria related to performance, such as price, quality, delivery schedules, technical value, and sustainability, whose weighting must be disclosed in advance. A call for tenders where price accounts for only 20 % alongside a vague criterion such as "understanding of the local context" or "organisational methodology" weighted at 50 % without a clear scoring rubric gives the award panel excessive discretionary leeway. This mechanism makes it easy to assign top marks to the regular partner while arbitrarily penalising more competitive financial bids.
Comparative decoding grid: neutral call for tenders vs tailored procurement
A quick analysis of the tender package allows you to categorise the risk level as soon as the procurement documents are opened. The table below outlines the essential check points to verify on Simap.ch or in the itemised bill of quantities:
| Analysis parameter | Neutral and open call for tenders | Rigged or biased call for tenders | Impact on the bidder |
|---|---|---|---|
| Material specifications | Functional descriptions, recognised technical standards, systematic "or equivalent" clause. | Exclusive reference to a commercial brand, dimensional tolerances modelled on a single catalogue. | Risk of technical variant rejection or procurement surcharges imposed by an exclusive distributor. |
| Required project references | Works of comparable complexity and volume completed over the last 5 years in Switzerland. | Identical works carried out within the municipal area or with the same client within a very short timeframe. | Automatic disqualification during formal qualification screening due to lack of prior local involvement. |
| Tendering schedule | Deadline proportionate to project scale, allowing sufficient time to consult subcontractors and suppliers. | Extremely short deadline coupled with a mandatory briefing session set 48 hours after publication. | Practical impossibility of optimising unit prices, leading to an uncompetitive tender. |
| Price weighting (art. 29 LMP) | Balanced weighting (40 % to 60 % for standard construction works) with a linear scoring formula. | Marginal price weighting (under 30 %) favouring subjective qualitative criteria without sub-criteria. | Price advantages achieved through strict cost control are wiped out by the panel's subjective scoring. |
| Site visit and queries | Anonymised Q&A forum, all answers published fully and simultaneously for all candidates. | No structured forum, evasive answers, or clarifications provided on the eve of the submission deadline. | Critical information asymmetry favouring the incumbent firm already familiar with site constraints. |
Frequent evaluation errors and financial consequences for the firm
For an estimator or site manager, the costliest mistake is giving in to the illusion of volume by bidding indiscriminately on every available call for tenders. Preparing a complete tender based on an itemised bill of quantities for CFC 211 (masonry, reinforced concrete) or CFC 271 (joinery) requires between 35 and 80 hours of skilled labour, representing an internal direct cost of roughly 4 800,00 CHF to 11 500,00 CHF incl. VAT per dossier.
A second common mistake is trying to challenge a locked-in procurement by submitting an alternative product without first having its equivalence confirmed via the procurement platform's official forum. The contracting authority will then reject the tender for non-compliance with the itemised bill of quantities, depriving the company of any viable recourse. If obvious irregularities breach equal treatment, art. 56 LMP allows a 20-day period from the notification or publication of the decision to lodge a reasoned written appeal. However, initiating litigation without documented evidence incurs substantial legal fees, frequently between 6 000,00 CHF and 15 000,00 CHF incl. VAT, with no guarantee of securing suspensive effect or cancellation of the procedure.
Illustrative practical cases (typical scenarios on Swiss construction sites)
The following situations are sample scenarios designed for methodological analysis and do not correspond to any actual construction site; all figures in CHF are purely indicative and include 8,1 % VAT.
Scenario 1: Interior Joinery work for a public building in the Canton of Vaud
A joinery firm based in Vaud with 14 employees spots an open call for tenders on the public procurement platform for the replacement of fire doors in a municipal administrative centre, with an estimated budget of 520 000,00 CHF incl. VAT. While examining the technical specifications in the itemised bill of quantities, the bid manager discovers that the required ironmongery refers to a proprietary specification from a German-speaking Swiss manufacturer with only one approved installer in the canton. Moreover, the submission deadline is set at 18 working days right in the middle of summer.
Following an assessment of the estimating cost, valued at 5 250,00 CHF incl. VAT, management chooses not to bid alone. The firm uses the Q&A forum to officially ask whether equivalent ironmongery certified to current fire protection standards is permitted. Upon receiving an evasive refusal from the contracting authority upholding the mandatory brand, the contractor immediately shelves the dossier. This decision protects the firm's operating margin by avoiding estimating expenditure doomed to fail against the already favoured approved distributor.
Scenario 2: Pipe laying and earthworks network in the Canton of Fribourg
An SME civil engineering contractor in Fribourg with 28 workers analyses a call for tenders for a wastewater network extension valued at 1 450 000,00 CHF incl. VAT. The contracting authority allocates 30 % of the score to price and 70 % to organisational criteria, including an environmental concept requiring an operational fleet of electric lorries on site as soon as the construction site opens. The qualification criteria further demand proof of two similar construction sites completed for a Fribourg public authority within the last 18 months.
The technical director immediately spots specifications tailored to favour a major local group that recently invested in battery-powered heavy transport vehicles. Faced with an estimated study cost of 8 750,00 CHF incl. VAT, the SME decides to leverage art. 31 LMP by forming a consortium with a fellow contractor who has complementary plant, enabling them to submit an admissible joint bid. This pragmatic strategy circumvents technical bias without risking formal exclusion during qualification assessment.
Calls for tenders: free tools
Direct public procurement tenders, AIMP thresholds by canton, converting SIA 451 to Excel, quantity takeoff from an IFC model.
Frequently asked questions
How should you react to technical requirements that appear tailored to a specific competitor?
The contracting authority must abide by the principles of impartiality and equal treatment set out in art. 11 LMP. Submit a formal query via the platform asking to allow equivalent solutions. If the technical bias remains, file a reasoned appeal under art. 56 LMP within 20 days.
Does opaque weighting of award criteria indicate a rigged tender?
Yes, because art. 29 LMP requires the contracting authority to state the criteria and their weighting in the tender notice. If subjective factors obscure the most advantageous tender under art. 41 LMP, request quantified clarifications. An obvious imbalance compromises profitability on an indicative quote of 150 000,00 CHF.
Does an extremely tight submission deadline signal an intent to sideline bidders?
It is a common sign of advance preparation for an insider. In an open procedure governed by art. 18 LMP, an unduly short deadline prevents reliable pricing on an indicative 85 000,00 CHF bid. Request an official extension via the anonymous forum to safeguard fair competition in line with the objectives of art. 2 LMP.
Can you cut prices aggressively to try to win a seemingly pre-allocated contract?
This is a risky strategy. Under art. 38 LMP, the contracting authority must seek pertinent explanations if a price appears abnormally low. Without solid proof of profitability, the authority can exclude the bidder from the procedure pursuant to art. 44 LMP. In addition, the contract for work and services under art. 363 CO requires viable performance.
Does forming a consortium help bypass restrictive criteria?
Yes, whenever reference requirements prevent an independent bid. Art. 31 LMP permits consortiums to bid unless specifically prohibited. Operating as an ordinary partnership under art. 530 CO, the partners combine their technical resources to satisfy the qualification criteria of the competitive tender.
What signs reveal an unlawful splitting of a large public contract in Switzerland?
Watch for improper use of the direct award procedure defined in art. 21 LMP or the invitation procedure under art. 20 LMP. To circumvent the threshold values in art. 16 LMP, some contracting authorities split lots beyond the 2 million francs de minimis clause.
A rigorous review of tender documents helps you avoid wasting study costs on biased tenders. To refine your strategy and secure your public tenders, explore our complementary guides:
