Skip to content
Art ConstructionTenders
Practical guide

Award Criteria: Weighting Price, Quality and Sustainable Development

Understand the weighting of price, quality and sustainability under LMP and AIMP to win your calls for tenders in Switzerland.

Table of contents
The 3 Major Site Risks
  1. Financial / Margin: Calculating a quote without taking into account the weighting of qualitative criteria exposes the contractor to a margin loss of around 8 % to 15 % caused by excessive discounts. Art. 29 LMP states that the contracting authority evaluates tenders according to criteria related to the services, including profitability and sustainable development, making price cuts alone insufficient to win.
  2. Legal / Joint Body / SUVA: Disregarding social requirements leads to the outright rejection of your tender. Under art. 12 LMP, a contract is awarded only to tenderers who comply with worker protection provisions, local working conditions and the LTN. Art. 44 LMP authorises the contracting authority to exclude a tenderer who fails to meet these participation requirements or submits an unjustified abnormally low tender.
  3. Administrative / Acceptance: A technical proposal lacking organisational or environmental substantiation results in penalising scores. Under art. 41 LMP, the contract is awarded to the tenderer who submitted the most advantageous tender. Inadequate methodology compromises the award and contractual performance under standard SIA 118, barring access to public authority contracts.

This guide is aimed at SME managers, technical directors and building estimators responding to public procurement calls for tenders in Switzerland. The combined application of the LMP and the AIMP now imposes a comprehensive evaluation where price is no longer the sole decisive factor. Public and municipal clients assign decisive weighting to technical quality, deadlines, environmental impact and vocational training. Understanding these mechanisms enables you to leverage your strengths without undermining your operational profitability.

To win a tender, craftsmen and contractors must master how their offer is converted into points using official scoring scales. The criteria set out in art. 29 LMP demand a thorough demonstration of construction site methodology, excavation spoil recycling and workforce qualifications. Aligning your technical proposals with CAN descriptive bill of quantities specifications and the principles of standard SIA 118 ensures maximum scores on qualitative criteria while preserving a viable price level in CHF.

Weighting mechanics and the shift toward the most advantageous tender

The Swiss federal and cantonal legal framework strictly regulates the evaluation of tenders. Under art. 29 LMP, the contracting authority no longer assesses solely the financial figure: it examines tenders based on criteria related to the services, including quality, deadlines, technical value, profitability, sustainable development and plausibility. Art. 41 LMP confirms this principle: the contract is awarded to the most advantageous tender, and not simply to the lowest price. This harmonisation with the AIMP transforms the strategic approach of Swiss contractors when tendering.

In cantonal and municipal practice, the weighting grid is determined upon publication of the call for tenders, pursuant to art. 29 LMP. A typical weighting for structural work or finishing work usually distributes points according to a proven key: 50 % to 60 % for price, 25 % to 35 % for technical value, and 10 % to 15 % for sustainable development and apprentice training. Tenderers who base their bid on an aggressive discount without refining their methodological response regularly find that qualitative score differences outweigh moderate price variations.

Operational breakdown of the three evaluation pillars

Price and tender scoring formulas

The conversion of price into points is generally carried out using mathematical functions defined by the contracting authority, such as the standard linear curve. The lowest compliant tender receives the maximum score of 5 points, whereas a tender exceeding a defined threshold (often 20 % to 30 % above the site management estimate) receives zero points. However, artificial underpricing triggers art. 38 LMP: if the contracting authority receives an offer with an abnormally low total price, it must seek the relevant information from the tenderer to verify that participation conditions are met and that the tender requirements are understood. Art. 44 LMP permits exclusion if the firm cannot substantiate its financial viability.

Qualitative value and execution methodology

The technical component goes well beyond basic compliance with standard SIA 118 bill of quantities descriptions. The contracting authority examines construction site organisation, the quality control plan, managerial qualifications and the management of constraints (site access, phasing, logistics). Qualitative scoring runs from 0 to 5 points. Submitting generic data sheets without addressing site-specific risks results in a mediocre score of 2 or 3 out of 5, completely wiping out a 5 % to 8 % pricing advantage in the final weighting.

Sustainable development and social compliance

Environmental and social evaluations rest on precise criteria. The contracting authority assesses the carbon footprint, logistics optimisation for hauling excavated material to approved landfill sites, the use of recycled concrete or low-emission machinery. On the social front, art. 12 LMP mandates compliance with provisions on worker protection, working conditions at the place of performance, equal pay and LTN reporting obligations. Actively employing apprentices also secures valuable points.

Comparative table of scoring grids in Swiss public procurement

Type of gridPrice WeightingQuality WeightingSustainability WeightingStrategic consequence for the contractor
Standard structural work (CFC 211)60 %30 %10 %Price dominates, but a solid technical proposal offsets a 4 % to 6 % price difference.
Balanced (finishing work on an occupied site)50 %35 %15 %Logistics and safety prevail over low-margin tenders.
Qualitative (complex renovation)40 %45 %15 %The experience of key teams takes precedence over the lowest bid.
High sustainability (timber construction)45 %30 %25 %Short supply chains and certified materials determine the final award.
Specialised technical work (civil engineering, HVACSE)50 %40 %10 %A rigorous methodology eliminates purely commercial submissions.

Common evaluation errors and quantified losses

A frequent mistake involves engaging subcontractors without prior checks. Art. 31 LMP allows subcontracting, but the characteristic service must in principle be performed by the tenderer. Under art. 12 LMP, subcontractors must abide by the applicable working conditions. Pursuant to art. 5 LDét, the main contractor is civilly liable if subcontractors fail to pay net minimum wages and meet working conditions, engaging joint liability. Missing documents lead to score deductions or exclusion under art. 44 LMP, resulting in the write-off of bid preparation costs estimated at 8 450,00 CHF incl. VAT (8,1 % VAT included).

A second error lies in a mismatch between the project schedule and allocated resources. Setting unfeasible deadlines without proving adequate staffing leads to poor plausibility scores pursuant to art. 29 LMP. Conversely, overinflating prices to cover uncertainties results in immediate disqualification on tenders in the region of 450 000,00 CHF incl. VAT (8,1 % VAT included).

Illustrative practical cases (typical scenarios on Swiss construction sites)

The situations presented below are model scenarios created for educational purposes to clarify how scoring scales are applied, and do not represent actual construction sites.

Model scenario 1: Administrative renovation in the canton of Vaud

For masonry work (CFC 211) estimated at 1 200 000,00 CHF incl. VAT (8,1 % VAT included), the Vaud municipality applies a weighting of 50 % for price, 35 % for quality and 15 % for sustainability. A general contractor bids 1 180 000,00 CHF incl. VAT with a superficial technical proposal. A local SME with 18 workers quotes 1 235 000,00 CHF incl. VAT (a difference of 55 000,00 CHF incl. VAT, or 4,6 % more), documenting the use of local recycled concrete, sound waste management and three contracted apprentices. The higher price costs the SME 0,35 points. However, it scores 4,8 out of 5 in sustainability (compared to 2,2) and 4,5 in organisation (compared to 3,0). With a final score of 4,42 versus 3,98, the SME wins the contract.

Model scenario 2: Timber school construction in the canton of Geneva

For Timber Framing (CFC 214) estimated at 850 000,00 CHF incl. VAT (8,1 % VAT included), the criteria are 45 % for price, 40 % for assembly methodology in a dense urban environment and 15 % for training. Two companies with 14 employees compete. Company A bids 810 500,00 CHF incl. VAT without addressing adjacent school traffic flows. Company B quotes 838 200,00 CHF incl. VAT (a difference of 27 700,00 CHF incl. VAT) with detailed hourly phasing and proof of erector qualifications. Scoring 4,8 out of 5 on technical methodology compared to 2,8 for its competitor, Company B more than makes up for its price difference and wins the contract with 4,55 points versus 3,92.

Calls for tenders: free tools

Direct public procurement tenders, AIMP thresholds by canton, converting SIA 451 to Excel, quantity takeoff from an IFC model.

View tendering tools

Frequently asked questions

How does the contracting authority evaluate an abnormally low tender?

Under art. 38 LMP, if the contracting authority receives an offer with an abnormally low total price, it must request the relevant clarifications from the tenderer. This ensures that participation conditions are fulfilled and that call for tenders requirements have been fully understood.

Is the sustainable development criterion mandatory in Swiss public procurement?

Yes, art. 29 LMP requires tenders to be evaluated based on criteria related to the services, which expressly includes sustainable development. The contracting authority specifies these criteria and their precise weighting in the call for tenders, promoting economically viable procurement with long-term ecological and social benefits.

Can the contracting authority alter criteria weighting after tenders have been submitted?

No, the transparency principle set out in art. 11 LMP prohibits this. The contracting authority must indicate the criteria and their weighting in the call for tenders or tender documents, in accordance with art. 29 LMP. Any subsequent modification would violate equal treatment between tenderers.

Can a company be disqualified for failing to observe equal pay?

Yes, absolutely. Under art. 12 LMP, contracts may only be awarded to tenderers who comply with equal pay and worker protection provisions. In the event of non-compliance, art. 44 LMP allows the contracting authority to exclude the tenderer from the procedure or revoke the contract award.

How can you challenge an award if the quality evaluation appears arbitrary?

You must file a written, reasoned appeal within 20 days of notification, pursuant to art. 56 LMP. However, the appeals authority does not review the appropriateness of the decision, but solely breaches of the law or incorrect establishment of the facts.

Does price remain the decisive criterion for winning a call for tenders?

Not exclusively. Art. 41 LMP specifies that the contract is awarded to the most advantageous tender, and not simply the lowest bidder. Art. 29 LMP requires the inclusion of other criteria such as quality, technical value or tender plausibility to determine the winning bid.

Mastering award criteria is a decisive asset for Swiss construction companies. By understanding the weighting of price, quality and sustainable development under the Federal Act on Public Procurement, you maximise your chances of securing contracts. A structured proposal that addresses environmental requirements will stand out against competitors focused solely on costs. To refine your strategy and explore applicable procedures, consult our dedicated resources:

Art Construction is an independent company: it is not affiliated with the SIA, CRB, SUVA, or KBOB. Referenced norms and standards point to publications from these bodies; only official versions are legally binding.