Table of contents
The 3 Major Site Risks
- Financial / Margin: Loss of business opportunity (estimated at around 15 to 25% of potential turnover) if the company is unaware of the urgency or exclusivity criteria enabling direct award without a call for tenders, thus limiting access to profitable contracts.
- Legal / Joint Body / SUVA: Annulment of the award following an appeal by a competitor (art. 56 LMP) if the strict conditions of the direct award procedure (art. 21 LMP) are not objectively met by the contracting authority, leading to the loss of the contract for the company.
- Administrative / Handover: Delay in starting works following suspensive effect granted during an appeal against the direct award decision, freezing the contractor's resource planning and generating unforeseen downtime costs.
In Switzerland, access to public procurement is strictly regulated to guarantee transparency and fair competition. However, the Federal Act on Public Procurement (LMP) and the Intercantonal Agreement on Public Procurement (AIMP) provide for precise derogations enabling a contracting authority to award a contract directly to a company, without prior publication. The direct award procedure, defined notably by art. 21 LMP, constitutes a major exception to the rule of open or selective calls for tenders. For construction, civil engineering, and finishing work firms, understanding these exceptional mechanisms is essential. This not only allows them to position themselves strategically in niche or emergency markets, but also ensures that the award obtained will not be overturned by an appeal from an excluded competitor.
Applying this exceptional procedure relies on exhaustive grounds strictly reviewed by case law. Whether dealing with an absolute emergency arising from unforeseeable events, the protection of intellectual property rights, or the total absence of acceptable tenders during a prior procedure, the contracting authority must systematically document and justify its choice. For the tenderer, accepting a direct award contract requires verifying that the statutory conditions are met, otherwise the contract risks being annulled. This guide details the application criteria under the AIMP and LMP, the contracting authority's documentation duties, and the practical implications for construction companies that benefit from these direct awards or wish to challenge them.
Derogation Conditions for Direct Award Procedures
The fundamental rule of public procurement in Switzerland rests on transparent competition between companies. However, the legislature provided strict exceptional mechanisms. Under art. 21 LMP, regarding the direct award procedure: the contracting authority awards the contract directly to a tenderer without a call for tenders; without regard to threshold values when one of the conditions of para. 2 is met (no acceptable tender, suspected unlawful agreement, only one possible tenderer, urgency due to unforeseeable events...); the contracting authority draws up documentation for each contract awarded by direct award. The Intercantonal Agreement on Public Procurement (AIMP) adopts these principles for cantonal and communal procurement, requiring contracting authorities to justify any deviation from standard procedures rigorously.
For a construction firm, identifying these exceptional situations represents a strategic opportunity. It enables positioning as the public authority's natural partner when deadlines or technical complexity render a public call for tenders unworkable. However, the contracting authority cannot invoke these grounds arbitrarily. Cantonal administrative courts scrutinise the justifications put forward with great severity, as direct award massively restricts free competition.
Urgency Due to Unforeseeable Events
Urgency is the most frequently invoked ground, but also the most strictly regulated. It must stem from an event that the contracting authority could not objectively anticipate. A natural disaster (landslide, flood destroying public infrastructure) or the sudden failure of a structure threatening public safety justifies immediate intervention. In this context, art. 21 LMP allows commissioning a civil engineering or ground stabilisation firm directly, because the time required to organise an open or selective procedure would expose the community to serious danger. Conversely, an administrative delay in the planning of a construction project under no circumstances constitutes an unforeseeable event. If a municipality delays launching a tender for the renovation of a school before the start of the school year, it cannot use this self-inflicted delay to justify a direct award.
Technical Monopoly or Only One Possible Tenderer
Another major derogation condition arises when the technical characteristics of the structure or intellectual property rights limit the choice of contractor. Art. 21 LMP explicitly provides for cases where only one tenderer is possible. On a construction site, this often occurs during extension works or maintenance of proprietary systems (for example, a specific building management system, or a water treatment installation protected by a patent). If the intervention of a third-party company voids existing warranties or proves technically unfeasible without the proprietary drawings of the original manufacturer, the contracting authority is justified in awarding the contract directly to this single firm.
Absence of Acceptable Tenders or Suspected Unlawful Agreement
An open or selective procedure sometimes fails to reach a conclusion. If, following publication, the contracting authority receives no tenders, or if the tenders submitted do not meet suitability criteria or disproportionately exceed the allocated budget, the standard procedure fails. Similarly, if the contracting authority notes indications of bid-rigging, art. 21 LMP permits switching to a direct award in the event of a suspected unlawful agreement. In these situations, the public client may turn to the company of its choice to negotiate the terms of the works contract directly, provided that the initial specifications of the contract are not substantially altered.
Comparison Table: Standard Procedure vs Exceptional Direct Award
| Assessment criterion | Open / Selective Procedure | Direct Award Procedure (AIMP/LMP Exception) |
|---|---|---|
| Competition | Mandatory, publication on the simap.ch platform. | None, direct award to a chosen company. |
| Tender deadlines | Strict (generally 40 days minimum). | Immediate, negotiated directly according to urgency. |
| Legal justification | Exceeding cantonal or federal threshold values. | Strict conditions (urgency, monopoly, absence of tenders). |
| Required documentation | Full tender dossier, weighted criteria. | The contracting authority establishes documentation for each contract. |
| Risk of appeal | Standard, regarding the evaluation of award criteria. | High, regarding the very legitimacy of the chosen procedure. |
Common Mistakes and Consequences for Contractors
A lack of knowledge regarding direct award rules exposes companies to significant legal and financial risks. The first mistake consists in accepting a direct contract from a municipality for standard renovation works under the pretext that the amount is deemed "modest" by local elected officials, even though threshold values mandate an invited or open procedure. If an excluded competitor files an appeal, the award may be cancelled. Under art. 56 LMP, regarding the deadline and grounds for appeal: appeals, duly substantiated, must be submitted in writing within 20 days of notification of the decision; the appropriateness of a decision cannot be examined. The awarded contractor then risks losing a contract valued at 250 000 CHF, while already having incurred unrecoverable costs for design or construction site preparation.
A second common mistake relates to documentation. Art. 21 LMP stipulates that the contracting authority establishes documentation for each contract awarded by direct award. If the contractor does not ensure that the client has formally documented the grounds for the exception (for instance, a technical report proving it is the only firm capable of handling a specific drilling technique), it faces the risk of the contract being invalidated by the supervisory authority. Finally, assuming that a supplementary contract (additional works not originally planned) can systematically be awarded directly to the contractor already on site is a mistake. If these works exceed a certain percentage of the main structure or alter its nature, fresh competition is required by the AIMP and cantonal guidelines.
Illustrative practical cases (typical scenarios on Swiss construction sites)
The figures and situations presented below are illustrative examples intended to demonstrate the practical application of tendering rules on the ground.
Scenario 1: Emergency Stabilisation Following a Rockfall (Canton of Valais)
Context: Following severe weather, a retaining wall along a cantonal road collapses, blocking traffic and threatening homes below. The civil engineering department must act immediately.
Company workforce: 18 employees (local civil engineering and earthmoving contractor).
Chosen route: Direct award of the contract for clearing and provisional shoring (estimated at 180 000 CHF).
Standard justification: The contracting authority relies on art. 21 LMP (urgency due to unforeseeable events). Because public safety demands intervention within 24 hours, setting up an open procedure, even with shortened deadlines, is physically impossible. The contractor, possessing suitable excavators nearby, is directly commissioned in full compliance with the law.
Scenario 2: Extension of a Proprietary Security System (Canton of Geneva)
Context: A cantonal public hospital is constructing a new wing and must integrate it into the existing access control and fire detection system installed five years earlier by a specific firm. The system relies on closed, patented computer protocols.
Company workforce: 45 employees (building automation and security specialist).
Chosen route: Direct award for the network extension (estimated at 320 000 CHF).
Standard justification: The hospital applies art. 21 LMP (only one possible tenderer). An independent technical assessment placed in the procurement file demonstrates that no other firm can ensure interoperability without replacing the entire existing system, which would cause disproportionate costs. The technical monopoly justifies dispensing with a call for tenders.
Scenario 3: Failed Tender for a Sports Complex (Canton of Vaud)
Context: A municipality launches an open procedure on simap.ch for the construction of a complex timber frame intended for a new ice rink. Upon opening the envelopes, the only two tenders received exceed the construction credit approved by the municipal council by 40%, due to a sudden spike in material prices.
Company workforce: 30 employees (carpenters and timber engineers).
Chosen route: Termination of the open procedure and switch to direct award with one of the tenderers to redefine the project.
Standard justification: The municipality invokes art. 21 LMP (no acceptable tender). As the initial bids were economically unacceptable, the standard procedure failed. The municipality can thus negotiate directly with the tenderer with the highest technical rating to explore execution alternatives (changing timber species, simplifying spans) in order to meet the budget, without having to launch a lengthy full procedure lasting several months.
Calls for tenders: free tools
Direct public procurement tenders, AIMP thresholds by canton, converting SIA 451 to Excel, quantity takeoff from an IFC model.
Frequently asked questions
When May a Contracting Authority Use a Direct Award Under the LMP?
Art. 21 LMP allows the contracting authority to award a contract directly without a call for tenders, irrespective of threshold values, if no acceptable bid was submitted, in case of urgency due to unforeseeable events, or if only one bidder qualifies.
How do you challenge an exceptional direct award at the cantonal level?
Under the Intercantonal Agreement on Public Procurement, an exceptional direct award must be published officially. Competing firms then have a strict time limit to lodge a reasoned written appeal with the competent cantonal authority if they believe the statutory requirements were not met.
Can a contract worth 150 000 CHF be awarded by direct agreement without an exceptional justification?
Yes, provided the contract value remains below the cantonal thresholds set by the AIMP for the invitation procedure. In that case, the contracting authority awards the mandate freely, for example for renovation work estimated at 150 000 CHF, without having to invoke urgency or exclusivity.
Can the contracting authority negotiate the price in an exceptional direct award procedure?
Unlike open procedures where art. 11 LMP prohibits negotiations on price, the exceptional direct award procedure allows the contracting authority to discuss rates and services directly with the sole selected firm in order to optimise the use of public funds.
What happens if a bidder submits an abnormally low bid in public procurement?
Under art. 38 LMP, the contracting authority must request appropriate clarifications from the bidder to ensure participation conditions are met. If it fails to prove compliance, art. 44 LMP allows the contracting authority to exclude it from the procedure or revoke the award based on sufficient evidence.
Can a general contractor subcontract the entirety of a contract obtained by direct award?
Art. 31 LMP allows the use of subcontractors unless explicitly excluded. However, the characteristic performance must, as a rule, be delivered by the bidder itself. A general contractor cannot therefore delegate the entire contract, valued for example at 850 000 CHF, without carrying out the core part.
The exceptional direct award procedure provides essential flexibility when emergencies arise on Swiss construction sites. Its use remains strictly regulated by federal and cantonal law to ensure transparency. Construction firms need to master these mechanisms to protect their interests, challenge an unjustified award or negotiate a direct mandate. To expand your knowledge and optimise your tenders, explore our specialised resources:
- Public Procurement and Private Contracts in Switzerland: Procedures, Access and Tender Strategy for Construction Firms
- AIMP and LMP Thresholds: Open, Selective, or Invitation Procedure, Which Applies to Your Contract?
- Private Calls for Tenders: Property Management Agencies, Architects and Applicable SIA Rules
- General Contractor and Design-Build Contractor: Responding to a Call for Tenders as a Bidder
