Table of contents
The 3 Major Site Risks
- Financial / Margin: Risk of major administrative sanctions imposed by the Competition Commission, amounting to hundreds of thousands of CHF or a substantial percentage of turnover under the Cartel Act, in addition to the total loss of gross margin on public and private procurement contracts.
- Legal / Joint Body / SUVA: Risk of an in-depth administrative investigation opened by COMCO for unlawful agreements, combined with surveillance measures and increased audits by cantonal joint committees on compliance with working conditions and collective labour agreements.
- Administrative / Acceptance: Risk of formal exclusion from the award procedure or revocation of the award pursuant to art. 44 LMP when the contracting authority holds sufficient evidence or finds that the principles of effective and fair competition under art. 2 LMP and art. 11 LMP have not been observed.
Submitting tenders for Swiss construction projects, whether governed by public procurement law or by private contracts subject to standard SIA 118, requires absolute commercial autonomy from each bidder. Prior collusion between competing bidders, the exchange of confidential pricing information, geographic market sharing across construction sites, or the submission of courtesy cover bids constitute practices strictly prohibited under the Cartel Act. For contractors, site directors, chief estimators, and building quantity surveyors, these practices are closely monitored by the Competition Commission (COMCO), which carries out meticulous investigations to safeguard the economic integrity of award procedures throughout Switzerland.
This operational guide details the specific mechanisms used to uncover unlawful agreements and sets out the full range of penalties faced by main structural work and finishing work contractors. Beyond financial sanctions and exclusion from public procurement decided by the contracting authority, bid rigging undermines a firm's long-term solvency and destroys relationships of trust built with institutional or private clients. By clearly understanding the independence obligations imposed from the initial pricing phase through to bid submission, every contractor protects its commercial operations and upholds its professional standing in strict compliance with the Swiss regulatory framework.
Types of conduct prohibited by the Cartel Act in tenders
In the Swiss construction market, the Competition Commission rigorously scrutinises the conduct of bidding contractors. Unlawful agreements in call for tenders procedures take specific forms that every business owner and estimator must know how to identify to avoid major legal risks.
Cover bids and courtesy bids
A cover bid occurs when a contractor that does not wish to win the contract, or lacks the production capacity required by the project schedule, submits a bid that is intentionally overpriced or laden with unacceptable terms. The objective, agreed with a competitor, is to make the competitor's bid appear more competitive to the contracting authority or private client. This manipulation distorts the objective price comparison required by the Federal Act on Public Procurement and eliminates genuine price competition.
Market allocation by geography and rotation
Some informal groups of contractors agree on a tacit or explicit allocation of construction sites according to specific geographic areas, cantons, or building types. Under this arrangement, competing firms refrain from submitting tenders or submit courtesy bids to ensure that the award goes to the designated local player. This rotation system causes lasting distortion in access to public and private contracts.
Exchange of sensitive information and price fixing
Direct or indirect communication between competitors regarding unit price schedules, wage mark-up coefficients, target gross margins, or planned discounts prior to final bid submission constitutes an unlawful horizontal agreement. Under the Federal Act on Public Procurement, specifically art. 2 LMP, which establishes effective and fair competition with measures against unlawful agreements as an objective, and art. 11 LMP, which requires contracting authorities to take measures against unlawful agreements, any prior coordination vitiates the entire procurement procedure.
Legal distinction between a lawful consortium and an unlawful agreement
Forming a bidding consortium is a common and legitimate practice in the Swiss construction sector, provided that it meets strict economic and technical criteria. Art. 31 LMP states that the participation of bidding consortia is permitted unless the contracting authority restricts or excludes it in the call for tenders or tender documents, and the characteristic performance must, in principle, be provided by the bidder. Under private law, pooling resources is governed by the rules of the simple partnership pursuant to art. 530 CO.
To remain compliant with cartel law, establishing a consortium must be justified by an individual contractor's technical, financial, or capacity limitations in executing the entire project alone. When two leading firms, each possessing the required technical resources, personnel, and qualifications, join forces solely to eliminate price competition on a trade lot, the arrangement qualifies as an unlawful agreement under the Cartel Act.
| Assessment criterion | Lawful consortium (Simple partnership art. 530 CO) | Prohibited cartel agreement |
|---|---|---|
| Execution capacity | Technical complementarity and pooling of resources genuinely required to deliver the project | Two contractors capable of bidding alone who partner to lock up the market |
| Transparency towards the contracting authority | Joint bid disclosed upon submission, with explicit allocation of roles and work packages | Secret upfront deals, concealed subcontracting, or mirror bids not coordinated openly |
| Unit price setting | Transparent joint internal costing for a single consolidated bid with joint and several liability | Prior alignment of price schedules or setting of minimum pricing between competing bids |
| Economic purpose | Enhancing technical capabilities, meeting tight deadlines, or managing major project risks | Securing an artificial margin by collectively removing competitive pressure |
| Status of bidders | Single joint bid submitted under art. 31 LMP with a designated lead contractor | Formal submission of separate bids creating a false impression of genuine competition |
Procedural and contractual consequences for the contractor
A firm's involvement in an unlawful agreement has severe legal and financial ramifications under both administrative procurement law and general contract law.
Exclusion from public procurement
In public procurement, when a contracting authority uncovers substantial evidence of collusion, it exercises the legal remedies at its disposal. Pursuant to art. 44 LMP, the contracting authority may exclude a bidder from the procedure when there is sufficient evidence of unlawful conduct, or revoke an award already made. Such an exclusion may be paired with a ban on participating in public procurement procedures for a specified period, depriving the company of substantial business opportunities.
Contractual invalidity and civil liability
Under private contract law, art. 1 CO establishes that a contract is concluded when the parties have expressed their mutual agreement. A contract entered into on the basis of unlawful price manipulation is fundamentally tainted by a defect in consent. The contracting authority or private client may invoke contractual civil liability under art. 97 CO to claim full damages, corresponding to the additional cost paid compared to the competitive market price that would have prevailed under effective competition.
Common mistakes made by SMEs and financial penalties
Many construction firms commit organisational missteps due to a lack of familiarity with how the Cartel Act is applied. Informal discussions within regional trade associations concerning workload schedules or price levels constitute strong evidentiary leads regularly relied upon during Competition Commission dawn raids.
Another common mistake consists in systematically subcontracting a large share of an awarded project to a competitor that had submitted a higher bid. Art. 31 LMP requires that the characteristic performance must, in principle, be carried out by the selected bidder. If the client demonstrates a prior collusive agreement, the direct financial harm arising from the abrupt termination of the works contract under art. 377 CO, coupled with legal fees, can reach amounts in the range of 180 000,00 CHF to 450 000,00 CHF for a mid-sized construction site.
Illustrative practical cases (typical scenarios on Swiss construction sites)
The figures and scenarios below are illustrative examples developed for technical and legal analysis; they do not depict actual construction projects.
Scenario 1: Open call for tenders for a school complex in the Canton of Vaud
Under a cantonal call for tenders for masonry and reinforced concrete work (CFC 211) with an estimated value of 4 800 000,00 CHF including VAT, three mid-sized Vaud contractors each employ between 25 and 40 workers. Realising that their schedules are already fully booked for the second half of the year, two of these companies agree by phone that Contractor A will submit the lowest-priced tender at 4 750 000,00 CHF including VAT, while Contractor B will submit a cover bid at 5 120 000,00 CHF including VAT.
During the examination of tenders under art. 38 LMP, the contracting authority spots troubling layout similarities and identical calculation errors across three secondary items in the standard building description. The authority requests formal explanations and then applies art. 44 LMP by excluding both bidders from the procurement procedure. Contractor A loses the project opportunity and faces an investigation by the Competition Commission. This case shows that a truthful response stating an inability to meet project schedules, or the openly declared formation of a consortium under art. 31 LMP, would have safeguarded their reputation and future market access.
Scenario 2: Private building conversion project in the Canton of Geneva
For the complete refurbishment of the heating and Plumbing & Sanitary Installations of a condominium ownership building (art. 712a CC) in Geneva, valued at 620 000,00 CHF including VAT, a property management company invites tenders from four licensed installers. Two partner installers decide to form a simple partnership under art. 530 CO to submit a joint tender. Their combined workforce totals 18 skilled workers. One contractor provides design engineering and network coordination, while the other provides rapid-installation site labour.
In their tender submission, the firms explicitly declare their joint venture structure, provide a clear breakdown of allocated tasks, and accept joint and several liability in accordance with SIA 118 standards. The property manager confirms the compliance of the bid and awards the contract at 595 000,00 CHF including VAT, ensuring absolute legal transparency and sound profitability without any risk of competition law infringement.
Calls for tenders: free tools
Direct public procurement tenders, AIMP thresholds by canton, converting SIA 451 to Excel, quantity takeoff from an IFC model.
Frequently asked questions
How does COMCO actually detect bid rigging in tenders?
The Competition Commission relies on its leniency programme, whistleblowers, and statistical tender analysis. Under art. 11 LMP, contracting authorities must report any suspicion of collusive tendering. A suspicious submission on a 450 000,00 CHF trade lot can trigger dawn raids and direct orders for document production.
Can a contractor be excluded from public procurement without a prior criminal conviction?
Yes. Under art. 44 LMP, the contracting authority excludes a tenderer as soon as sufficient evidence of collusion exists, without waiting for the final verdict from COMCO. An SME excluded from an 850 000,00 CHF contract immediately loses its qualification and suffers critical commercial damage to its business.
Is forming a joint venture considered an unlawful agreement?
No, provided it stems from genuine technical justifications. Art. 31 LMP expressly permits consortia of tenderers. However, if two firms capable of delivering a 1 200 000,00 CHF project on their own join forces solely to lock in prices, the Competition Commission sanctions the arrangement as a cartel.
What is the deadline to appeal an exclusion based on suspected collusion?
Under art. 56 LMP, the tenderer has 20 days from notification to file a reasoned written appeal. Challenging an exclusion from a lot valued at 350 000,00 CHF requires immediately providing formal proof of strictly autonomous pricing at the time of submission.
Are cover bids also prohibited in private procurement?
Absolutely. The Cartel Act penalises sham tenders between private parties. Submitting a deliberately inflated bid of 180 000,00 CHF to favour a competitor exposes the party to claims for damages, contract termination under SIA 118, and complete reputational damage.
How can you prove independent pricing during a price review?
Under art. 38 LMP, the contracting authority reviews tenders and requests detailed explanations. For a 520 000,00 CHF bid, providing the breakdown of direct costs and team productivity rates proves the absence of external collusion and confirms the full compliance of the tender.
Cost transparency and commercial independence are essential pillars for safeguarding your contract awards in French-speaking Switzerland. To explore the rules governing your procedures for calls for tenders in greater detail, consult our specialised guides:
- Public Procurement and Private Contracts in Switzerland: Procedures, Access and Tender Strategy for Construction Firms
- AIMP and LMP Thresholds: Open, Selective, or Invitation Procedure, Which Applies to Your Contract?
- Exceptional Direct Contract: Conditions Set by the AIMP and Practical Implications for Contractors
- Private Calls for Tenders: Property Management Agencies, Architects and Applicable SIA Rules
