Table of contents
The 3 Major Site Risks
- Financial / Margin: Blindly diluting site installations into unit prices exposes the successful bidder to a loss of around 8% to 15% of gross margin if actual quantities decrease, or in the case of strict lump-sum pricing under art. 373 CO prohibiting any claims for unforeseen work outside extraordinary circumstances.
- Legal / Joint Body / SUVA: Underestimating site supervision leads to a breach of the general duty of due care under art. 364 CO, compromising direct personal supervision of the works, compliance with occupational health and safety guidelines, and team oversight subject to checks by joint commissions.
- Administrative / Acceptance: An opaque breakdown of preliminary items under standard SIA 118 holds up monthly progress claims, generates formal objections during verification by site management, and delays the final account of the work.
In Swiss construction contracting, costing site installations and site supervision represents a strategic challenge for any estimator or bid manager. The structure of tenders based on CRB catalogues requires a clear separation between general installation items, often grouped under the preliminary chapter of the CFC, and direct productive work. Neglecting the method used to allocate these fixed overheads creates a major disconnect between the actual disbursements incurred at kick-off and the billing stream approved by site management.
The fundamental rule set out in art. 364 CO states that, unless agreed otherwise, the contractor must provide at its own expense the means, machinery and tools required to perform the contract for work and services defined in art. 363 CO. To protect company cash flow against heavy initial investments while avoiding looking uncompetitive or abnormally low at bid opening, adopting a surgical allocation method becomes essential, separating the costs of mobilization, continuous operation, and demobilization of supervisory facilities.
Typology of Fixed Site Installation and Supervision Costs
Under the Swiss price calculation methodology, preliminary and logistics expenses are split into two distinct financial categories: initial installation and demobilization capital expenditure on the one hand, and ongoing operating and site management expenses on the other. Art. 364 CO underlines the contractor's duties: unless otherwise customary or agreed, the contractor must procure at its own expense the means, machinery and tools required for the proper execution of the works.
Site installation costs cover delivery, assembly, connection to municipal utility networks, ongoing maintenance, dismantling, and final removal of all temporary facilities. These items include site cabins, mess rooms, changing rooms, sanitary units connected to the wastewater network, perimeter hoarding, road signage meeting communal requirements, truck wheel-wash areas, tower cranes, and temporary metered power and water distribution.
Technical supervision expenses include remuneration for the firm's in-house site management, works managers, site supervisors, and quantity surveyors assigned to the project. Added to these wages are mandatory social security contributions under the National Agreement for the Swiss Main Construction Sector, company vehicles, mobile IT equipment, software licences for generating progress statements, and direct administrative expenses tied to managing execution documents.
Allocation Methods: Dedicated Standard Items or Proportional Mark-up
The estimator must choose between isolating these charges into lump-sum items or distributing them proportionally across the direct prime costs of each unit price. In public procurement governed by the LMP, the tender structure generally dictates dedicated standard item catalogue positions for installations, ensuring total transparency during the evaluation of tenders pursuant to art. 38 LMP.
Advantages and Limitations of a Dedicated Lump-Sum Item
Allocating these costs as a lump-sum item allows for prompt invoicing as soon as site set-up is complete, providing immediate cash-flow relief for the business. If the quantities ordered by site management decrease, the installation amount remains protected and does not drop automatically. However, this level of transparency exposes the bidder to direct comparisons at bid opening, and visible overpricing may prompt the contracting authority to seek clarifications on price plausibility.
Advantages and Risks of Inclusion in Unit Prices
Factoring fixed costs into the mark-up on direct prime costs makes the bid look very attractive if logistics lines appear low. Conversely, this method presents a severe financial risk if final bill of quantities measurements are lower than estimated in the bill of quantities: if concrete or earthwork volumes drop by 20%, payment for the crane and site management drops by the same proportion, even though their real cost remains fixed.
Comparison Table of Allocation Strategies
| Assessment criterion | Allocation via Dedicated Lump-Sum Items | Diffuse Integration into Unit Prices | Mixed Allocation (Fixed Amortisation + Hourly Rate) |
|---|---|---|---|
| Protection of initial cash flow | Maximum: fully invoiced once assembly is complete | Slow: phased income tied to overall project progress | Balanced: advance payment on mobilization, balance over duration |
| Sensitivity to reduced execution quantities | Zero: lump sum protected for installation | Critical: direct margin loss on logistics expenses | Moderate: only the proportional portion varies |
| Clarity during tender evaluation (art. 38 LMP) | Total: immediate verification of technical compliance | Opaque: risk of suspicion of an abnormally low tender | Compliant: easy justification before the contracting authority |
| Contractual management for time extensions | Simplified addendum based on known monthly costs | Complex calculation of claims for residual fixed costs | Negotiations eased by initial analytical cost breakdown |
| Remuneration of technical supervisory staff | Dedicated line for supervision per month on site | Diluted into productive labour hourly rates | Site overheads isolated per project schedule milestone |
Common Allocation Errors and Financial Losses
The most widespread mistake involves aligning site supervision duration strictly with the theoretical contractual schedule without factoring in bad-weather contingencies or technical coordination delays. If a works manager mobilized at 50% must spend six additional months on site without the contractor being entitled to a variation order, the direct wage overrun can reach roughly 45 000,00 CHF to 75 000,00 CHF per supervisory employee.
A second pitfall lies in omitting communal utility connection and public land occupation fees, as well as waste disposal costs for washing slurry. Leaving out these dedicated items shifts the burden directly onto the project's net margin, generating an immediate deficit of about 18 500,00 CHF to 35 000,00 CHF on an average-sized construction site.
Lastly, art. 373 CO provides that where the price was agreed as a lump sum, the contractor must carry out the work for the agreed amount and cannot claim any increase, even if expenses exceeded forecasts. If the initial quote failed to account properly for cranes or temporary power supply, the courts will grant an increase only in the presence of extraordinary, unforeseeable circumstances within the meaning of art. 373 para. 2 CO.
Illustrative practical cases (typical scenarios on Swiss construction sites)
The figures presented in the following scenarios are illustrative examples developed for technical analysis and do not represent actual construction sites.
Scenario 1: Residential Building Construction in the Canton of Vaud
In an open-procedure call for tenders under the LMP for a multi-family housing development in the municipality of Lausanne, the average structural work workforce numbers 14 operatives over an estimated 16-month period. Site installations include erecting a crane with a 45-metre jib, setting up container units for the mess hall and sanitary facilities, and placing a temporary electrical transformer. The bidding firm chose to isolate 128 500,00 CHF including 8,1% VAT into mobilization and monthly operating items in the standard catalogue, while allocating the site foreman's wages to productive hourly rates. This strategy secured 42 000,00 CHF in cash flow during month one while safeguarding profitability against potential drops in masonry quantities.
Scenario 2: Heavy Renovation in a Dense Urban Area in the Canton of Geneva
On a refurbishment project involving 8 workers over 10 months, public roadway occupation restrictions require strict cantonal permits and working-hour caps. Total fixed costs for site installation, external material hoists, and supervision were costed at 86 400,00 CHF including 8,1% VAT. The tenderer allocated 60% of this sum to dedicated fixed lump-sum positions and the remaining 40% as a mark-up on concrete sawing and demolition unit prices. This split won the contract on the price criterion under art. 41 LMP while protecting irreducible roadway and occupational safety costs.
Calls for tenders: free tools
Direct public procurement tenders, AIMP thresholds by canton, converting SIA 451 to Excel, quantity takeoff from an IFC model.
Frequently asked questions
Should supervision be isolated into a dedicated item or absorbed into unit prices?
Separating supervision into specific site installation items protects initial cash flow. Under art. 373 CO, an all-inclusive lump-sum price for these overheads ensures payment upon mobilization, avoiding having to wait for bill-of-quantities progress to cover, say, 85 000,00 CHF in upfront site engineering.
How do you justify a site installation cost viewed as abnormally low by the client?
In public procurement governed by the LMP, the contracting authority reviews disbursements under art. 38 LMP. The bidder must submit an analytical rate breakdown proving the depreciation of fully amortised owned plant, justifying for instance an illustrative saving of 42 500,00 CHF on the crane without compromising safety.
Which allocation method: labour-hour pro rata or prime cost mark-up?
Allocating costs pro rata to productive labour hours accurately reflects the actual workload of site management. It prevents loading items that contain high-value materials and shields the operating margin if expensive supplies are cancelled by site management.
What are the risks if a contractor underprices site hoarding and access roads?
The contractor contractually warrants its own resources under art. 364 CO. Any underestimation of temporary protection works, amounting for instance to 18 500,00 CHF, remains entirely at its own expense. Site management can demand immediate remediation without granting any price adjustment over agreed rates.
How do you pass on supervision costs for delays not attributable to the contractor?
If the client delays the work, the contractor invokes art. 375 CO or the rules of standard SIA 118. Supervisory staff mobilised beyond the initial schedule are subject to a claim for immobilisation costs, calculated on the basis of a predefined weekly rate, for example 4 250,00 CHF.
Why break down the assembly, maintenance, and dismantling phases separately?
This breakdown secures monthly advance payments in accordance with standard SIA 118. It allows you to invoice the setup as soon as the construction site opens, for instance 35 000,00 CHF, smooth out monthly operating expenses, and avoid a prolonged bank overdraft until final dismantling and site clearance.
Mastering analytical cost allocation for your tenders
A rigorous allocation of fixed costs and supervisory overheads guarantees the company's financial sustainability while maintaining strict compliance with the requirements of Swiss calls for tenders. Anticipating preliminary expenses safeguards cash flow from the start of the construction site and protects the successful bidder against invoicing uncertainties.
To further refine the methodical calibration of each component of your price offer, explore the following detailed analyses:
