Table of contents
The 3 Major Site Risks
- Financial / Margin: Underestimating depreciation on formwork panels or excavators can trigger a direct erosion of operational margins of around 8% to 15% on the structural work package. Under art. 373 CO, if the contractor commits to a firm unit price converted into a lump-sum price for specific items, no price increase may be claimed for premature wear or insufficient rotation of its plant.
- Legal / Joint bodies / SUVA: Deploying non-compliant equipment to cut inventory costs engages the company's liability. Under art. 364 CO, the contractor must supply the means required to execute the works, complying with occupational health and safety requirements defined by the Ordinance on the Safety and Health of Workers in Construction Work and CFST 6508 guidelines.
- Administrative / Acceptance: An improper breakdown of tower crane or formwork costs between site installation and unit prices exposes the tender to formal requests for clarification during bid evaluation under art. 38 LMP, risking exclusion for an implausible tender or disputes at the final account stage under SIA 118.
Allocating inventory costs for heavy machinery and formwork systems is a critical technical trade-off when submitting a tender in Switzerland. Under art. 364 CO, the contractor is required, unless agreed otherwise, to procure at its own expense the means, equipment, and tools essential for the proper execution of the works. Estimators and executives in the main construction sector must translate wear, capital depreciation, preventive maintenance, and consumables for each machine into rigorous cost components within net direct costs or specific standard specification positions.
A methodical distinction between equipment dedicated to general construction site installation and plant directly consumed by the progress of a specific item guarantees robust price breakdowns. Drawing on the contractual rules of SIA 118 and principles governing unit price transparency, contractors protect their tenders from rejection due to arithmetic inconsistencies while securing the return on their capital assets.
Analytical allocation methods: direct plant outlay versus site establishment costs
Breaking down inventory costs relies on a strict distinction between plant assigned to an individual production task and equipment supporting overall site logistics. Art. 364 CO reiterates the guiding principle that the contractor procures the necessary tools and plant at its own expense. When preparing a tender under public procurement law or a private contract, the estimator must select the appropriate analytical vessel to avoid distorting the tender structure.
In Swiss tendering practice, two main vehicles absorb inventory costs:
- Allocation to the production unit price: this approach incorporates the equipment's share of wear, provision, and servicing directly into the price breakdown of the corresponding standard item. It applies to equipment whose operation is strictly proportional to measured volume, such as earthmoving excavators per cubic metre, compactors, or wall formwork panels per square metre.
- Allocation to construction site establishment items: reserved for heavy, fixed, or shared plant (tower cranes, on-site concrete batching plants, wheel-washing stations), this method isolates assembly, dismantling, round-trip transport, and operational depreciation into global summary items within the bill of quantities.
Factoring crane depreciation directly into the unit price of concrete placement creates major financial exposure. If the site management reduces actual quantities during final measurement, the contractor incurs a direct loss on recovering fixed capital expenditure. Conversely, art. 373 CO caps remuneration when working under a lump-sum price: the contractor absorbs all additional expenditure if deployed equipment requires unplanned repairs.
Breakdown of machinery hourly costs and calculation of formwork wear
To establish a rigorous machine cost in the price breakdown, the hourly operating cost must be broken down into fixed inventory charges and variable operating expenses. Plant deployed must strictly comply with the Machinery Ordinance (OMach, RS 819.14) to maintain bid eligibility before contracting authorities governed by the LMP.
Calculating the hourly inventory rate of an item of plant incorporates:
- Depreciation and interest on capital: calculated over the realistic economic depreciation period of the machine (typically 5 to 8 years for heavy earthmoving equipment, 4 to 6 years for modular steel formwork) relative to forecast annual operating hours.
- Maintenance costs: major overhauls, replacement of wear parts (bucket teeth, hydraulic hoses, formwork facing panels), and scheduled workshop servicings.
- Direct running costs: fuels, lubricants, site electricity, and associated consumable small power tools.
For wall and slab formwork, costs are generally allocated per square metre of formed surface. The unit cost is calculated by dividing the residual value of the panel and its accessories (tie rods, nuts, concreting brackets, release agents) by the number of allowable reuses prior to scrapping or major refacing of the contact surface.
Comparative table of allocation methods according to equipment type
The table below summarises recommended allocation criteria in price breakdowns to prevent margin distortion and ensure tender compliance during price evaluations under art. 38 LMP.
| Equipment category | Preferred allocation unit | Vehicle in the bill of quantities | Technical depreciation baseline | Risk in the event of misallocation |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Tracked excavator (20-30 t) | CHF / productive machine hour | Unit price (trenching, earthworks) | Actual hours on the hour meter | Underestimation of fuel consumption and undercarriage wear |
| Large-area steel formwork panels | CHF / m² of formed surface | Unit price (reinforced concrete walls) | Number of rotations of the formwork facing | Financial loss if rotation rates are not achieved on site |
| Modular-erection tower crane | CHF / month (provision) | Construction site establishment items | Overall calendar duration of the structural work | Shortfall in inventory recovery if concrete volumes are reduced |
| Shoring system for upper slabs | CHF / m² of slab or CHF / unit | Unit price or dedicated shoring item | Retention duration under the slab (curing) | Extended retention that cannot be billed without a dedicated item |
| Small equipment and power tools | Percentage of productive wages | Marked up in supplementary direct costs | Company overall statistical consumption | Artificial inflation of the hourly labour rate |
Common pricing errors and their financial impact on tenders
Overlooking downtime and non-productive rotation cycles is the most widespread calculation error among estimators. Allocating the full monthly value of a formwork set across a continuous theoretical baseline of 30 calendar days underestimates the square-metre unit price by 25% to 40%. Reinforcement installation phases, concrete curing periods mandated by the site management, and bad weather mechanically reduce actual monthly rotations.
Another frequent error involves omitting demobilisation transport and reconditioning costs for formwork facing panels at the central yard. On a medium-scale construction site with 2 500 m² of vertical walls, high-pressure washing, patching tie-holes, and replacing damaged edge profiles routinely generate unplanned costs between 14 500,00 CHF and 22 000,00 CHF, including 8,1% VAT. These expenses directly erode the net operating margin of the package if no specific net direct maintenance cost was incorporated beforehand.
Finally, under a public procurement contract governed by the LMP, poor inventory allocation can prompt an inquiry for an abnormally low tender under art. 38 LMP, or even trigger exclusion from the award procedure under art. 44 LMP if the bidder cannot substantiate the economic reality of its equipment depreciation rates.
Illustrative practical cases (typical scenarios on Swiss construction sites)
The figures and scenarios below provide illustrative benchmarks to guide calculation methods on typical construction sites in Switzerland.
Scenario A: Commercial building in Geneva (GE) – Formwork rotation strategy
A 4-storey commercial building requires the execution of 4 800 m² of fair-faced interior concrete walls. The structural work team consists of 8 skilled workers meeting local qualification standards. The estimator faces two inventory options:
- Option 1: Deploy a fleet of company-owned modular formwork that is fully amortised on the balance sheet, but requires 4,20 CHF in maintenance per square metre to meet the flatness tolerances mandated by Swiss standards.
- Option 2: Hire a complete new steel-frame formwork system for a 3-month duration from a specialist supplier, for a total cost of 31 200,00 CHF, including 8,1% VAT.
The estimator selects Option 1, factoring in a net formwork unit cost of 7,85 CHF per square metre (comprising 4,20 CHF in maintenance, 1,45 CHF for anchoring accessories, and 2,20 CHF in internal residual depreciation). This strategy keeps the unit price under control while safeguarding the return on the SME's own capital assets, avoiding plant hire penalties in the event of site delays.
Scenario B: Reinforced concrete retaining structure in Valais (VS) – Combined machinery and shoring allocation
Building a 350-metre linear road retaining wall requiring 1 850 m³ of bulk excavation and 920 m² of single-sided formwork against the cut involves an average crew of 4 civil engineering masons and 1 machine operator. The contractor deploys a 24-tonne excavator equipped with a down-the-hole hammer and a ditching bucket.
The excavator is priced at a direct hourly inventory cost of 86,50 CHF (excluding operator wages), supplemented by 38,00 CHF for fuel and 12,20 CHF for preventive maintenance per productive hour. For the single-faced formwork, the estimator sets up a dedicated sub-item incorporating inclined raking props, with depreciation calculated over 6 successive reuses along the wall. This technical strategy isolates initial prop installation under site establishment to avoid inflating the unit price of the mass concrete infill, ensuring a balanced bid that meets the expectations of the cantonal public procurement body.
Calls for tenders: free tools
Direct public procurement tenders, AIMP thresholds by canton, converting SIA 451 to Excel, quantity takeoff from an IFC model.
Frequently asked questions
How should tower crane depreciation be allocated in a public tender?
The fixed cost of erection and dismantling is included in general site establishment. The monthly hire charge, typically around 4 850,00 CHF in our example, is allocated across the unit prices of precast components and reinforced concrete according to the project schedule, in compliance with tender requirements under art. 29 LMP.
Can extra costs for complex formwork be claimed without a signed addendum?
No. Under art. 373 CO, a lump-sum price prohibits any unilateral price increase by the contractor. If unexpected architectural requirements demand non-standard formwork not detailed in the quote, a formal order variation must be agreed in writing with the site management before pouring walls.
Who bears the cost of damaged or prematurely worn plant on the construction site?
The contractor alone bears the burden of their plant inventory. Under art. 364 CO, they supply the required tools and resources at their own expense. Formwork skin wear and losses, estimated for illustration purposes at 12,50 CHF per square metre, form part of their direct operating costs and direct operational responsibility.
Can a public procurement authority challenge an equipment rate breakdown deemed too low?
Yes. Pursuant to art. 38 LMP, the authority eliminates an abnormally low tender if the tenderer fails to prove the technical plausibility of their equipment inventory. Art. 44 LMP authorises the exclusion of any applicant unable to demonstrate that their prices cover maintenance, energy, and the statutory compliance of their construction site equipment.
Which allocation method should be used for reusable steel formwork?
Allocation is calculated per square metre of developed formed surface area per rotation. The residual acquisition value, routine maintenance of indicative 3,25 CHF per rotation, and form release agents are aggregated into the unit price breakdown, without ever being treated as permanent materials under art. 365 CO.
How do you handle abnormal shutter wear caused by specified aggressive concrete?
If the client specifies a particular binder that damages steel form faces, the contractor must immediately issue written notice under art. 365 CO al. 3. Without this formal warning, they will bear all costs for reconditioning or replacing the degraded panels.
Operational management of equipment inventory in Swiss tenders
Rigorously incorporating heavy plant, earthmoving machinery, and formwork fleets into your unit prices safeguards your firm's profitability right from the tendering stage. An accurate cost breakdown prevents underestimations penalised during tender evaluation and secures the contractual balance before work starts on the construction site.
To structure your bills of quantities, calibrate your financial assumptions, and optimise your entire call for tenders submission, consult our specialised methodological guides:
