Table of contents
The 3 Major Site Risks
- Financial / Margin: Underestimating cutting offcuts and breakage leads to an immediate net margin erosion of up to 3% to 8% on the materials line item. If the contract is entered into at a lump-sum price under art. 373 CO, the contractor alone bears these unexpected expenses without any legal recourse.
- Legal / Joint Body / SUVA: An unrealistic cost breakdown that omits procurement logistics can lead the public procurement authority to request justifications regarding abnormally low prices pursuant to art. 38 LMP, risking tender exclusion due to lack of economic viability.
- Administrative / Acceptance: Flawed procurement or stockouts generate schedule disruptions. In the event of culpable delay, the client may invoke the provisions of art. 366 CO and refuse acceptance under the rules of standard SIA 118.
In public procurement and private contracts in French-speaking Switzerland, the rigorous establishment of unit prices demands absolute control over material net costs. Estimators and construction company managers frequently make the mistake of using gross net purchase prices without factoring in actual physical overconsumption on the construction site. Between theoretical quantity take-offs derived from architectural plans and the quantities actually used on site, cuts, installation tolerances, and handling risks require applying waste and offcut coefficients rigorously calibrated by trade.
Beyond volumetric loss, direct procurement costs include cantonal freight, unloading, secure storage, and moving materials into position on the structure. Pursuant to art. 365 CO, the contractor remains liable for the flawless quality of the materials supplied. This technical guide details calculation formulas, the contractual impact of lump sums under the Code of Obligations (CO), and Swiss benchmark ratios to safeguard your tender profitability against the requirements of standard SIA 118 and CRB catalogues.
Method for calculating material net cost and overconsumption coefficients
Material net cost represents all direct expenses incurred to purchase and transport supplies to their exact installation location on the structure. When pricing a tender in Switzerland, a frequent mistake is confusing the theoretical quantity measured on the plans with the actual quantity delivered and invoiced. Under art. 365 CO, the contractor is liable for the sound quality of the materials provided. This obligation implies supplying components that comply with recognised trade practices, which inevitably generates cutting offcuts, geometric scrap, and handling losses.
For each item in the bill of quantities, unit material net cost is calculated using a strict sequential breakdown:
- Net purchase price ex-works or ex-supplier: list price minus trade discounts and negotiated price cuts, excluding early payment discounts.
- Procurement and upstream logistics costs: heavy road transport, rail-road freight fees, heavy vehicle charges, unloading in the storage area, and internal handling up to the installation zone.
- Geometric waste and offcut coefficient: multiplying surcharge compensating for tiling layouts, tongue-and-groove joints, rebar overlaps, and breakage during unloading.
- Ancillary packaging services: non-returnable packaging costs, non-refunded pallet deposits, and cutting waste disposal in accordance with cantonal waste sorting directives.
Applying a unit price without a waste coefficient exposes the firm to direct cost overruns where purchased quantities exceed billable measurements. Under a contract governed by standard SIA 118, contract award measurements are based on the theoretical dimensions of the completed work, unless the specific conditions state otherwise. If the contract is subsequently agreed at a lump-sum price pursuant to art. 373 CO, the contractor bears the entire extra cost of physical losses, with no right to claim a price increase from the client.
In public procurement governed by the LMP, failing to realistically account for these losses can skew the total tender price. Under art. 38 LMP, the procurement authority verifies compliance with requirements and evaluates bids. If it identifies an abnormally low price resulting from omitted offcuts and supply costs, it demands detailed explanations. The inability to prove full coverage of purchase and transport costs exposes the tenderer to exclusion from the procedure under art. 44 LMP.
Matrix of waste, offcut, and logistics coefficients by trade
Loss rates vary depending on material rigidity, architectural layout constraints, and access to the construction site. The following comparative table summarises the calculation practices observed in French-speaking Switzerland for major building and civil engineering line items:
| Trade / Material type | Main source of waste and offcuts | Average offcut coefficient (%) | Procurement & logistics (%) | Overall impact on net cost (%) |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Ready-mix concrete (foundations and slabs) | Formwork over-thickness, ground settlement, residue in the mixer truck and pump hose | 3,0% to 5,0% | 4,0% to 8,0% (pumping/crane) | 7,0% to 13,0% |
| Cut-and-bent reinforcing steel (rebar) | Standard code overlaps, cutting offcuts, lost reinforcement spacers | 5,0% to 8,0% | 3,0% to 5,0% (heavy freight) | 8,0% to 13,0% |
| Clay brick / sand-lime masonry | Corner cuts, opening recesses, breakage during handling and unloading | 4,0% to 7,0% | 5,0% to 7,0% (pallets/crane handling) | 9,0% to 14,0% |
| Rigid thermal insulation (facades and roofs) | Window reveal cuts, angled cutoffs, compressibility under waterproofing | 6,0% to 10,0% | 6,0% to 9,0% (transported volume) | 12,0% to 19,0% |
| Tiling and natural stone floor/wall coverings | Perimeter cuts, pipe penetrations, joints, colour shade sorting | 7,0% to 12,0% | 4,0% to 6,0% (specialised handling) | 11,0% to 18,0% |
| Plumbing pipework and buried ducting | Pipe cuts at fittings, slope adjustments, push-fit joints, and lost accessories | 3,0% to 6,0% | 3,0% to 5,0% (van/site storage) | 6,0% to 11,0% |
Common pricing errors and their financial impact on profitability
Omitting or poorly assessing waste coefficients creates major budget overruns from the very start of material deliveries. Three recurring methodological flaws jeopardize the financial viability of construction firms:
- Applying the coefficient only to the supplier ex-works price: adding a 5% surcharge to raw material while forgetting to apply this same ratio to transport and unloading expenses. If 100 tonnes require 105 tonnes of actual purchase, the logistics for the additional 5 tonnes must be included in the cost breakdown. On a structural work package invoiced around 450 000,00 CHF including 8,1% VAT, this omission represents an unrecoverable expense of roughly 6 200,00 CHF.
- Confusing plan measurements with ordering quantities: pricing reinforcing steel using theoretical gross weights from structural schedules without including mandatory overlap lengths required by technical standards. The average loss observed ranges between 5% and 8% of the steel purchase amount.
- Underestimating access in dense urban or mountainous zones: estimating standard unloading by articulated lorry when the site requires transshipment onto a short flatbed truck with an auxiliary crane. Doubling upstream freight can drive up material net cost by as much as 12 500,00 CHF on a finishing work construction site.
When the contract is governed by the Code of Obligations (CO) without contractual derogation, payment is due upon delivery in accordance with art. 372 CO. If the contractor is forced to order extra quantities to complete the work without having included these costs in the unit price, there is no legal basis to recharge this overconsumption to the client.
Illustrative practical cases (typical scenarios on Swiss construction sites)
The figures presented in the following scenarios are illustrative examples intended to model the impact of material net cost on tender profitability.
Scenario 1: Residential building construction in the canton of Vaud
This standard case study covers the structural work for an 18-unit apartment building carried out by a medium-sized general contractor employing 14 site operatives. The bill of quantities specifies an in-situ reinforced concrete volume of 1 250 m³ for slabs and shear walls.
- Negotiated price ex-batching plant: 145,00 CHF per m³ excluding taxes.
- Logistics and pumping: 22,00 CHF per m³ including delivery by truck mixer and concrete pump provision.
- Selected loss coefficient: 4,5% accounting for pipework residue and minor formwork deflection.
- Unit material net cost calculation: (145,00 CHF + 22,00 CHF) × 1,045 = 174,515 CHF, rounded per trade custom to 174,50 CHF per m³ excluding taxes.
- Budgetary impact: correctly including the 4,5% coefficient safeguards an amount of 9 397,50 CHF excluding taxes (i.e. 10 158,70 CHF including 8,1% VAT), which would otherwise have been deducted directly from the profit margin if priced using theoretical quantities only.
Scenario 2: Large-format tiling installation in an administrative centre in Geneva
This second scenario concerns interior flooring over a usable floor area of 850 m² using 60 × 120 cm porcelain stoneware tiles. Work on the construction site is carried out by a team of 4 qualified tilers.
- Tile supply net ex-works: 58,00 CHF per m².
- Cross-border haulage and tail-lift unloading: 4,50 CHF per m².
- Tile layout analysis: corridor layout and numerous round columns generate a measured offcut rate of 9,0%, to which 1,5% breakage is added for vertical transport in the material hoist, resulting in an overall overconsumption coefficient of 10,5%.
- Final unit net cost: (58,00 CHF + 4,50 CHF) × 1,105 = 69,0625 CHF, or 69,05 CHF per m² excluding taxes.
- Comparative outcome: the actual order volume amounts to 939,25 m² (rounded up to 940 m² for full boxes). Had the estimator used the theoretical quantity of 850 m² plus an arbitrary 3% allowance, the firm would have needed to order an additional 64 m² midway through the project with express delivery surcharges of 850,00 CHF, generating an unplanned direct loss of 5 269,20 CHF including 8,1% VAT.
Accurately including overconsumption coefficients and procurement constraints right from the tender stage ensures the long-term financial health of the business and total bid compliance with the requirements of Swiss clients.
Calls for tenders: free tools
Direct public procurement tenders, AIMP thresholds by canton, converting SIA 451 to Excel, quantity takeoff from an IFC model.
Frequently asked questions
How do you justify a high waste coefficient during an abnormally low price review?
Pursuant to art. 38 LMP, the contracting authority requests explanations if the total price appears abnormally low. The estimator submits a detailed cost breakdown proving geometric overconsumption—for instance, extra material amounting to around 4 860,00 CHF incl. VAT—justified by architectural complexity and actual cutting tolerances.
Does standard SIA 118 allow actual offcuts to be invoiced in as-built measurements?
Standard SIA 118 stipulates that measurement of the works is based on the theoretical dimensions of the contract drawings, without any waste markup. The contractor must therefore incorporate the financial impact of offcuts—around 2 430,25 CHF incl. VAT for a standard lot—directly into the initial unit net cost.
What is the contractor's legal liability regarding the quality of supplied materials?
Pursuant to art. 365 CO, the contractor is liable for the quality of the materials supplied. If the client insists on a defaulting supplier or an unsuitable material, the contractor must report this circumstance immediately in writing to disclaim liability for future defects and additional procurement costs.
In a lump-sum contract, can you claim for material price increases that occur after the award?
Under art. 373 CO, the contractor assumes the agreed lump sum and cannot claim an increase for ordinary price rises. Only extraordinary, unforeseeable circumstances or events ruled out by the parties' assumptions can justify a judicial price adjustment or termination of the contract for work and services.
How should access and crane hire costs be allocated in dense urban areas?
Specific access and delivery costs, which can represent around 3 780,50 CHF incl. VAT in logistics, are incorporated either into the site installation item according to the specifications, or directly into the direct material cost if individual deliveries require staged offloading by crane truck.
How do material losses affect retention money?
Retention money under standard SIA 118 applies to the total amount of billed progress claims. Since underestimating waste reduces net margin, the final retention money ties up a larger share of cash flow than the actual profit if the direct material cost was poorly calibrated.
Rigorous control of material net costs and bidding strategy
Factoring in shrinkage, offcut waste and logistics with surgical precision protects the contractor from insidious gross margin erosion. In Swiss public procurement or private contracts, consistent analytic sub-pricing ensures your tender remains robust while preventing disputes during final account verification. To fine-tune all components of your bill of quantities, explore our complementary methodological analyses:
