Skip to content
Art ConstructionTenders
Practical guide

Productive Hourly Cost and CLA: Integrating Them into Tender Sub-Breakdowns

Integrate productive hourly rates and CLA wage scales into unit price breakdowns to secure tenders in French-speaking Switzerland.

Table of contents
The 3 Major Site Risks
  1. Financial / Margin: Underestimating the base hourly rate or omitting actual social security contributions directly erodes net margin. Under art. 373 CO, an agreed lump-sum price binds the contractor, who cannot claim any increase for unforeseen labour cost overruns, creating a deficit that can represent an illustrative benchmark of 8 % to 15 % of the total awarded sum.
  2. Legal / Joint Body / SUVA: Disregarding minimum wages or declared generally binding agreement allowances under art. 1 LECCT and art. 2 LECCT exposes the firm to joint commission audits. In public procurement, art. 12 LMP mandates compliance with applicable working conditions and wages, under penalty of exclusion from the award procedure in accordance with art. 44 LMP.
  3. Administrative / Acceptance: An inconsistent unit price breakdown triggers a clarification procedure for an abnormally low bid under art. 38 LMP. The contracting authority requires detailed justification of the schedule of rates, bringing the award process to a halt and potentially leading to formal rejection of the bid before the works contract governed by standard SIA 118 is even signed.

In public procurement and private projects across French-speaking Switzerland, determining unit prices requires rigorous control of the labour component. Estimators, quantity surveyors, and SME directors must accurately incorporate declared generally binding collective agreement provisions into their price sub-breakdowns. The productive hourly cost is far more than the gross wage paid to the worker; it encompasses mandatory social contributions, paid leave, public holidays, contributions to early retirement schemes, as well as unproductive travel or weather-related hours borne by operations.

Given the heightened transparency requirements on the simap.ch platform and during price audits conducted by site management, an estimation error regarding execution time penalises the technical bid. This guide sets out the exact method for structuring direct hourly labour costs in compliance with federal legislation and applicable collective agreements, thereby safeguarding the company's financial sustainability when submitting tenders.

Method for determining the productive hourly cost under CLAs

Calculating the productive hourly cost is the cornerstone of direct labour cost analysis. The contractor preparing an offer must convert a standard collective labour agreement gross hourly or monthly wage into an actual on-site presence cost. Under the Federal Act on the Declaration of Collective Labour Agreements as Generally Binding, extension decrees give generally binding force to clauses governing minimum wages, travel allowances, and early retirement schemes. Art. 12 LMP requires that a public contract be awarded only to tenderers who comply with worker protection provisions and working conditions in force at the place of performance, as well as equal pay.

To determine the productive baseline, the estimator compiles all contractually paid hours over the calendar year. This theoretical volume includes the weekly working hours established by the relevant industry collective agreement. From this, one must methodically deduct hours not worked at the work face: statutory and collective agreement holiday entitlements, official public holidays in the canton of execution, waiting days for illness, absences for certified continuing education, and paid leave allowances for family events. The resulting balance represents gross attendance hours.

This volume of attendance hours is subject to a second deduction corresponding to irreducible unproductive time. On construction sites governed by recognised trade practices and standard SIA 118, this time includes daily safety briefings, workstation donning and doffing, internal travel between the site welfare facilities and the work face, and end-of-shift clean-up. Under art. 364 CO, the contractor bears a liability subject to the same rules as that of the employee and must personally manage the necessary resources. The ratio between total annual wage expenditures (gross wage plus employer contributions, early retirement schemes, and occupational insurance) and the net volume of directly productive hours establishes the baseline direct hourly cost.

Determinant wage components and mandatory social contributions

Breaking down labour costs requires the rigorous inclusion of employer contributions mandated by federal legislation and joint body agreements:

  • The 13th-month salary stipulated in the collective agreement, accrued monthly pro rata to actual working time.
  • Mandatory social insurance contributions: occupational old-age pension provision, old-age and survivors' insurance, disability insurance, and the loss of earnings compensation scheme.
  • Compulsory accident insurance administered by the national insurance fund or authorised insurers, covering occupational and non-occupational accidents.
  • Early retirement funds specific to the main building trade and finishing work, jointly funded by employers and employees to organise retirement before the statutory age.
  • Contributions to cantonal joint funds for continuing vocational training and collective labour agreement monitoring costs.
  • Mandatory collective agreement allowances for daily meals, travel, and the use of company vehicles, which constitute direct compensation components or compulsory expense reimbursements.

Any understating of these contributions to artificially deflate unit prices exposes the contractor to verification procedures under art. 38 LMP, as the contracting authority is required to seek clarifications from the tenderer if the total bid price appears abnormally low.

Comparison table of allocation parameters in the sub-breakdown

The structure of a unit price for work subject to standard SIA 118 depends on the methodical allocation of operating expenses. The following table summarises the criteria for distinguishing between components that must be built into the productive hourly cost and those covered by corporate overheads:

Cost componentCollective agreement benchmarkAllocation method in the bill of quantitiesConsequence in case of omission
Base wages and qualification bonusesExtended wage scales under the LECCTDirect hourly cost of production workersRejection of the tender or joint body adjustment
Early retirement and old-age pension provisionIndustry joint fund regulationsPercentage applied to the gross payrollStructural under-valuation of roughly 6,00 % to 9,50 %
Flat-rate travel and meal allowancesCantonal provisions on professional expensesExtended hourly rate or site setup itemCash-flow deficit on field team ancillary costs
Unproductive hours and safety briefingsInternal operations and safety monitoringDirect deduction from the divisor of hoursSystematic overrun of the budgeted labour hours
Salaries of internal local site managementArt. 364 CO and site supervision setupCorporate overheads or dedicated CFC itemDilution of net margin across the entire contract

Recurring estimating errors and their impact on profitability

The first mistake commonly observed among tenderers is using the gross hourly rate billed by temporary staffing agencies as the equivalent of their own direct hourly rate. Using employment agencies involves distinct contractual mechanics. While art. 374 CO provides that when the price is not fixed in advance, it is determined according to the value of the work and the contractor's expenses, a public tender requires a verifiable analytical calculation. A contractor who fails to determine its own ratio of actual productive hours runs the risk of critically underestimating its production cost.

The second pitfall is confusing the standard collective agreement hourly wage with the average crew wage. On a civil engineering or structural work construction site, teams combine machine operators, skilled masons, and mason's assistants. Applying an unskilled labourer's wage across the entire volume of hours to compress the quote leads to an immediate imbalance during execution. In the event of an audit under the Federal Act on Illegal Employment or art. 12 LMP, the contracting authority or the joint commission can demand exact accounting records. A glaring discrepancy can lead to exclusion from the procedure under art. 44 LMP.

From a financial perspective, miscalculating social security contribution coefficients on a masonry package involving 15 000 hours of work quickly produces a pure operating loss. An unanticipated difference of 6,25 CHF per productive hour equals a shortfall of 93 750,00 CHF including taxes (with VAT at 8,1 %). When a contract is awarded at a lump-sum price under art. 373 CO, the contractor has no legal recourse to adjust its sub-breakdown after the contract has been formed.

Illustrative practical cases (typical scenarios on Swiss construction sites)

The figures set out in the following scenarios are illustrative examples intended to guide the calculating method for estimators in Switzerland.

Scenario 1: Structural work and reinforced concrete in the canton of Vaud

A general contractor tenders for the construction of an administrative building in Lausanne. The project requires a team of six production workers over nine months, representing a quota of 7 200 productive hours at the work face.

The estimator establishes the hourly cost of a mixed crew comprising one team leader, three skilled masons, and two site assistants. Factoring in the minimum wages set by the cantonal collective agreement with generally binding force, early retirement contributions, occupational pensions, and Vaud public holidays, the total annual cost per employee averages 89 200,00 CHF. Timesheet analysis shows that each worker records 1 610 attendance hours, of which 140 hours are absorbed by logistics and safety guidelines. The net productive divisor thus comes to 1 470 annual hours per worker.

Dividing the costs gives a direct hourly labour cost of 60,70 CHF per productive hour. Adding the meal and travel allowance established by local practice at 4,30 CHF per hour brings the labour cost to be entered into the bill of quantities sub-breakdowns to 65,00 CHF. The company then applies its personal tooling coefficient and markup surcharges to formulate its unit prices in the standard catalogue of items.

Scenario 2: Alteration and finishing work in the canton of Geneva

A company specialised in interior fittings prepares its response to a call for tenders issued by a communal contracting authority in Geneva for the energy retrofit of a school complex. The assigned team comprises four qualified installers for an estimated overall volume of 2 800 hours of site work.

The tender manager factors in the prevailing Geneva cantonal minimum wage as well as the wage scales of the applicable collective agreement for finishing work. The total annual cost per worker, including the 13th-month salary, AVS/AI/APG contributions, LPP occupational pensions, and contributions to the Geneva joint fund, comes to 84 500,00 CHF. Given restricted access in urban environments and specific material handling constraints, directly productive hours are capped at 1 410 hours per year per installer.

This calculation results in a base hourly cost of 59,95 CHF. Mandatory daily allowances for urban transport and meals, assessed at 5,05 CHF per productive hour, are added to this figure, bringing the direct sub-breakdown to 65,00 CHF. By calibrating this figure accurately in its estimation software, the tenderer ensures full coverage of its statutory obligations while submitting an offer that remains financially plausible against the evaluation criteria of art. 29 LMP.

Calls for tenders: free tools

Direct public procurement tenders, AIMP thresholds by canton, converting SIA 451 to Excel, quantity takeoff from an IFC model.

View tendering tools

Frequently asked questions

How can compliance with CLA minimum wages be demonstrated during a public call for tenders?

The contracting authority applies art. 12 LMP to monitor social compliance. The tenderer submits joint certificates from the competent parity commission. For an indicative rate of 95,15 CHF per hour, the estimator attaches the CLA compliance certificate proving the absence of arrears in mandatory social contributions.

What is the risk of an abnormally low hourly rate in a bill of quantities?

Pursuant to art. 38 LMP, the contracting authority requests explanations if it receives an abnormally low tender. Offering 68,25 CHF per hour instead of 92,40 CHF exposes the firm to exclusion under art. 44 LMP if it fails to prove compliance with the participation conditions.

How should travel and meal allowances be broken down in the price calculation?

Travel or meal allowances set by the collective agreement are included in direct labour costs. For a daily allowance of around 32,50 CHF per worker, the total annual amount is divided by the actual productive hours of the financial year.

Why do bad-weather hours reduce annual productive hours?

The collective agreement and insurance law provide compensation for weather-related work stoppages. Stoppage hours reduce the volume of hours billed on construction sites. Out of a paid volume of 2 112 hours, only 1 680 hours are productive, increasing the direct hourly cost by around 11,85 CHF.

What is the contractor's joint and several liability towards its subcontractors?

Under art. 5 LDét, the main contractor is held civilly liable if subcontractors fail to comply with net minimum wages and working conditions. In accordance with art. 8b ODét, it ensures it obtains joint parity certificates to prove compliance with its statutory duty of due diligence.

Can an overrun of hours be covered by an addendum under SIA 118?

Under standard SIA 118 and art. 373 CO, a unit price or lump sum cannot be increased unilaterally if the work required more time. Only a formal change order from the site management authorises additional hours to be billed on a time-and-materials basis.

Operational summary of labour rate estimating in Switzerland

Rigorous integration of productive hourly costs ensures the profitability of every tender while meeting the requirements of Swiss collective agreements and public procurement. To explore the full methodology for calculating your unit prices and structuring your call for tenders files according to Swiss standards, consult our specialised guides:

Art Construction is an independent company: it is not affiliated with the SIA, CRB, SUVA, or KBOB. Referenced norms and standards point to publications from these bodies; only official versions are legally binding.