Table of contents
The 3 Major Site Risks
- Financial / Margin: Confusing the elementary component approach of eCCC-Bât with the trade-by-trade breakdown of the CFC exposes the tenderer to interface omissions, leading to lost contract awards or margin erosion in the range of 8 % to 15 % of the construction cost, in contradiction with agreed price requirements within the meaning of art. 373 CO or art. 374 CO.
- Legal / Joint Body / SUVA: Responding to a call for tenders without properly breaking down health and safety, scaffolding or collective protective provisions planned under element chapters generates a risk of non-compliance with the award criteria of art. 29 LMP and may trigger disputes during standard Swiss joint committee audits.
- Administrative / Acceptance: A structural mismatch between a quote priced according to the cost classification and the specifications of the client's detailed estimate complicates the traceability of variation orders and undermines the final account during verification under the SIA 118 standard.
In Swiss tendering practice, company directors, site managers and estimators deal with two classification frameworks established by the Swiss Research Centre for Rationalization in Building and Civil Engineering (CRB). While the Building Cost Classification (CFC) historically structures budgets according to trades and contractor work packages, eCCC-Bât deploys a method focused on the functional elements of the building. This fundamental distinction alters the cost breakdown from the preliminary design stages through to the submission of the technical and financial bid.
Navigating between these two systems requires methodological rigor to avoid overlaps or contractual gaps. Element-based costing under eCCC-Bât groups all layers of a single assembly (cladding, waterproofing, insulation, structural backing) under a single macro-reference, whereas the CFC separates these tasks across distinct trades. For bidding contractors, mastering this crosswalk is vital to convert an element-based estimate into an accurate bill of quantities, compliant with the SIA 451 standard, and to ensure the profitability of the works contract governed by art. 363 CO.
Core Principles: Functional Logic Versus Trade-Based Organisation
The distinction between the Building Cost Classification and eCCC-Bât rests on two different views of the structure. The Building Cost Classification divides the building according to trades and sequential intervention stages on the construction site. This trade-based nomenclature groups expenditure into main chapters, from earthworks through to finishes. In contrast, eCCC-Bât structures costs by building elements. Each element fulfills a specific physical or technical function within the building, regardless of the craftsman or general contractor installing it.
For an estimator responding to a call for tenders under an open procedure within the meaning of art. 18 LMP or a selective procedure under art. 19 LMP, this difference transforms how project documents are interpreted. In an element breakdown, an external wall assembly incorporates load-bearing masonry, thermal insulation, render, metal flashings and window reveals into a single value. In a breakdown under the Building Cost Classification, these same items are split across structural work, insulation, plastering and painting, and external joinery.
Contractually, the qualification of the price upon contract formation defined in art. 1 CO steers the commercial relationship. When the parties commit to a fixed lump-sum price pursuant to art. 373 CO, the contractor performs the works for the agreed amount without claiming any increase for extra labour or expenditure. If the bid is based on an approximate estimate within the meaning of art. 375 CO, misallocating interfaces between functional elements can trigger an excessive cost overrun beyond the initial forecast. The contractor answers for their duties according to the contractor's obligations defined in art. 364 CO, their work being subject to the same rules as that of an employee under their personal direction.
Comparison Table: Building Cost Classification and eCCC-Bât
The choice of cost breakdown structure directly affects the granularity of quantity take-offs, comparative tender evaluations and the integration of digital building models.
| Assessment criterion | Building Cost Classification (CFC) | Element Cost Classification (eCCC-Bât) |
|---|---|---|
| Structuring unit | Trades, contractor groupings and the nature of the construction works. | Functional elements of the building (external walls, roofs, slabs). |
| Primary project stage | Tendering, contract award and construction site execution stages. | Preliminary study, scheme design and pre-project stages. |
| Link with specifications | Direct link with the Standard Specification Elements for procurement. | Direct link with geometric volumes and digital building models. |
| Quantity surveying | Execution take-offs per unit of installed materials (m², m³, kg, units). | Ratios of macroscopic element surface areas referenced to floor area. |
| Interface management | Interfaces fragmented across several distinct contractual chapters. | All layers of a single constructive assembly centralized under one code. |
| Variant evaluation | Requires full recompilation of multiple series of unit prices. | Enables immediate comparison of several complete building systems. |
Calculation Methodology and Costing Risks During Tendering
Costing under eCCC-Bât uses standardized reference quantities for each group of elements. The surface area of a floor or facade element serves as the divisor to establish an all-inclusive unit cost. This approach allows the client to validate the budget alignment of their programme quickly. For the tenderer, shifting from this macro logic to the detailed unit prices of a tender involves major technical interpretation risks.
When a call for tenders requires a schedule broken down by trade, the estimator must reallocate element-based items into the corresponding chapters. If a warm roof assembly includes a vapour barrier, thermal insulation, bituminous waterproofing, a protective layer and gravel, each item must be assigned to its relevant trade package. An omission in this breakdown distorts the overall price. In the event of an abnormally low bid, the examination of tenders governed by art. 38 LMP allows the contracting authority to check formal requirements, correct obvious calculation errors ex officio and demand explanations on cost structures to verify compliance with participation requirements.
In public procurement subject to the LMP, the contracting authority applies the award criteria set out in art. 29 LMP to assess tender profitability and plausibility. The contract is awarded to the tenderer submitting the most advantageous tender pursuant to art. 41 LMP. If a tenderer submits an inconsistent bid due to overlaps between functional components and trade packages, the contracting authority may order an exclusion from the procedure under art. 44 LMP.
Common Allocation Errors and Financial Repercussions
The most widespread mistake consists in applying the price of a macro-element without verifying the associated preparatory works. Under eCCC-Bât, connections and mounting brackets are often factored into the square-metre ratio on a lump-sum basis. When transferring this figure into a tender based on the Standard Specification Elements under the SIA 118 standard framework, the contractor risks omitting specific line items required for the proper execution of the works.
A second pitfall stems from the management of scaffolding and site installations. These auxiliary facilities constitute separate general elements in an element-based estimate, whereas they form dedicated contractual chapters in the Building Cost Classification. Pursuant to art. 364 CO, the contractor procures the necessary tools, machinery and plant at their own expense, unless agreed or customary otherwise. If the tenderer mistakenly assumes that scaffolding is covered within the unit prices of each facade element, they immediately suffer an unrecoverable shortfall.
The financial repercussions of these allocation errors are substantial:
- Double counting of fixings or waterproofing joints, creating an artificial surcharge of around 45 000,00 CHF to 90 000,00 CHF that impairs bid competitiveness.
- Complete omission of base-of-wall waterproofing detailing, generating an unrecoverable deficit of around 35 000,00 CHF on a fixed-price contract under art. 373 CO.
- Omission of mobilization and setup costs for heavy craneage equipment, resulting in a direct net loss of around 22 500,00 CHF borne entirely by the awarded contractor.
Illustrative practical cases (typical scenarios on Swiss construction sites)
The following situations are illustrative examples created to analyse the decision-making mechanisms between these two costing frameworks, and do not represent actual cases.
Scenario 1: Tender for a school complex in the canton of Vaud
A medium-sized general contractor with 28 employees submits a bid for the construction of a school building in the canton of Vaud. The procurement procedure is conducted as an open procedure governed by the LMP. The tender documents provide an initial budget estimate prepared according to eCCC-Bât for a total sum of 8 450 000,00 CHF, while final award requires a strict breakdown by Building Cost Classification chapters.
The estimator isolates the element group corresponding to the external envelope. The preliminary design applied an average ratio of 620,00 CHF per square metre for the entire ventilated facade assembly. Upon performing the detailed breakdown by trade, the team discovers that inter-storey fire protection details and special structural steel lintels are not covered by the masonry items. The chosen technical strategy allocates 115 000,00 CHF specifically to metalwork and 280 000,00 CHF to the building envelope. This rigorous allocation prevents an operating margin shortfall estimated at 48 250,00 CHF during contract execution under the SIA 118 standard.
Scenario 2: Conversion of an office building in the canton of Geneva
A specialized heavy renovation contractor employing 15 staff members prepares an invited tender under art. 20 LMP for the interior refurbishment of an office building in Geneva. The designer's indicative budget estimate was structured by functional elements for an overall envelope of 2 150 000,00 CHF.
The bidding manager analyses the element covering modular interior partitions. The functional element estimate groups glazed partitions, doors and acoustic adjustments under a single code. To respond to the trade-based tender schedule, the firm separates drylining from interior joinery and acoustic glazing work. This breakdown allows the price to be adjusted to 385 450,00 CHF, while ensuring accurate coverage for installation hours and junction details with technical suspended ceilings. The adjustment prevents a structural underestimation of roughly 32 800,00 CHF on the total agreed amount.
Calls for tenders: free tools
Direct public procurement tenders, AIMP thresholds by canton, converting SIA 451 to Excel, quantity takeoff from an IFC model.
Frequently asked questions
Can You Submit a Tender Directly Using an eCCC-Bât Breakdown?
No, tenders require a detailed estimate structured according to CFC chapters and CAN items. Under art. 38 LMP, the contracting authority verifies formal compliance. An overall budget estimate of around 450 000,00 CHF in eCCC-Bât must be broken down into detailed elementary items prior to submission.
How Do You Convert an eCCC-Bât Estimate into a CFC Tender?
The transition is carried out using a mapping matrix linking the functional element to execution CAN items. For masonry work amounting to roughly 185 000,00 CHF, geometric eCCC-Bât quantities are broken down into supplies, formwork and reinforcement within the meaning of the CFC Building Cost Classification.
Can the client impose eCCC-Bât for change orders?
No, the works contract based on art. 363 CO and the SIA 118 standard governs contractual unit prices. For an addendum around 24 500,00 CHF, remuneration must be based on the initial CFC bill of quantities, as eCCC-Bât is only used for high-level monitoring of the overall budget.
Does eCCC-Bât apply to public procurement under LMP?
eCCC-Bât is used for the contracting authority's preliminary studies, but a call for tenders in an open procedure under art. 18 LMP requires a detailed execution description. Bidders' tenders, for example around 1 250 000,00 CHF, are systematically submitted using the CFC structure and CAN items.
Which method best protects margins in the case of a lump-sum price?
Detailed CFC analysis secures the tender because art. 373 CO prohibits any price increase for a fixed price. A quote prepared solely under eCCC-Bât would conceal execution constraints, risking absorbing an operating margin originally estimated at around 85 000,00 CHF for the structural work package.
Who bears the risk of discrepancies between eCCC-Bât and CFC quantity take-offs?
The contractor is responsible for pricing its tender under art. 364 CO. If the macroscopic estimate undervalues a finishing work item by around 32 000,00 CHF, the successful bidder remains bound by its execution unit prices validated in the final tender prepared according to the standard building specification code.
Mastering both the Code des frais de construction and eCCC-Bât is a strategic lever to secure tender pricing and safeguard profitability right from the call for tenders. To explore these Swiss standard structures in greater detail, consult our dedicated technical guides:
