Skip to content
Art ConstructionTenders
Practical guide

Asbestos and PCB Pollutant Report: Check Before Pricing Under the OTConst

Check the pollutant survey before tendering. Anticipate remediation costs and protect your margins in line with OTConst and SIA 11.

Table of contents
The 3 Major Site Risks
  1. Financial / Margin: Accidental discovery of asbestos-containing materials or PCB joints during demolition, causing site shutdown and unforeseen extra costs in the region of 35 000.00 CHF to 90 000.00 CHF to set up negative pressure containment. Under a lump-sum price pursuant to art. 373 CO, the lack of explicit reservations bars any compensation claim if prior investigations were noted in the tender file.
  2. Legal / Joint Body / SUVA: Immediate site shutdown by SUVA inspectors in the event of unsafe handling of building pollutants, pursuant to OTConst safety rules. Risk of criminal liability under art. 229 CP where non-compliance with recognised rules of the art creates a danger to the life or physical integrity of workers.
  3. Administrative / Acceptance: Licensed sorting centres blocking skips from leaving and refusing hazardous waste tracking forms under the OLED. This failure brings preparatory works to a halt, triggers cascading delays on the structural work, and postpones the joint verification prescribed by standard SIA 118.

When responding to a call for tenders for alteration or demolition works, a Swiss estimator cannot rely on basic geometric quantity takeoffs alone. The presence of asbestos in tile adhesives, plasters, or pipe insulation, as well as high PCB concentrations in sealing mastics, constitutes a critical operational risk. Before committing company pricing, requesting the pre-works survey report required by worker protection and environmental legislation is mandatory. A critical review of this technical document directly determines the choice of work methods and the overall profitability of the future contract.

Under art. 365 para. 3 CO, if the ground provided by the client or existing structures prove defective, the contractor must inform the client immediately, failing which they bear the consequences. The lack of a comprehensive survey in the tender documents requires setting out clear written reservations as soon as the bid is submitted. Pricing the collective protection measures required by the OTConst and identifying disposal pathways prevents a rigid lump-sum contract from turning into a financial disaster for the successful bidder.

Pollutant survey audit method before tender pricing

When a tender dossier reaches the technical office, examining the building pollutant survey is an absolute prerequisite before entering a single unit price. The contractor submitting a tender assumes full responsibility for their methods and resources. If the file supplied by the client contains only a basic survey intended for the normal use of the building, that document cannot be used for destructive works. A critical assessment must immediately distinguish a routine management survey from a genuine pre-works survey covering the entire work area.

The estimator systematically reviews the sampling methodology applied by the surveyor. This involves checking the room-by-room sampling plan, the thorough testing of concealed layers under screeds or behind linings, and the evaluation of facade expansion joints that may contain polychlorinated biphenyls. Cross-checking demolition drawings directly against the sample locations shown in the report ensures that no demolished or drilled element was overlooked during initial testing.

Verification of destructive sampling and survey scope

A survey report noting access reservations, such as closed service ducts or inaccessible suspended ceilings, does not allow setting a reliable unit price. If the contracting authority issues a specification calling for full demolition when the shafts were not materially tested, the risk of uncovering hidden asbestos insulation or flocking is very high. In the face of such data gaps, the estimator must submit a formal request for clarification before the deadline for questions or issue an explicit tender reservation expressly excluding the handling of any untested material outside the original survey scope.

Waste qualification and disposal routes

The financial estimate for remediation depends closely on authorised sorting facilities and landfill categories. The contractor verifies whether the report clearly distinguishes inert mineral waste, contaminated combustible materials, and components requiring controlled landfill disposal or high-temperature incineration. The presence of PCBs in anti-corrosion coatings or joint sealants requires dedicated handling and standardised sealed packaging, substantially driving up logistics costs per tonne removed compared with standard unpolluted demolition.

Report analysis matrix prior to tender sign-off

The table below summarises the compliance criteria an estimator must check in the survey report before validating pricing assumptions in the itemised quote.

Criterion examinedExpected compliant contentHigh financial risk situationOperational pricing action
Investigation scopeExhaustive destructive survey covering the entire alteration area.Partial visual survey with reservations for inaccessible rooms or locked attics.Exclude unsampled areas from the base price or submit a tender question.
Adhesive and plaster testingMulti-layer electron microscopy laboratory analysis.Complete absence of samples under tiling or on thin wall coatings.Include a contractual reservation on wall grinding and scabbling works.
Facade joints and PCBsQuantitative laboratory testing on each facade elevation and window type.General note assuming mastics are compliant without chemical analysis.Price subject to the condition precedent that no persistent organic pollutants are present.
Pipe insulationDirect sampling beneath plaster or metal cladding on service pipes.External visual assessment without core sampling through thermal insulation.Refuse a lump-sum removal price without certified prior destructive testing.
Material classificationFormal distinction between friable and strongly bound asbestos materials.Vague grouping of roofing materials together with interior technical insulation.Adjust hourly removal rates based on the complexity of the containment required.

Common estimation errors and budget impacts

The most serious mistake is accepting a lump-sum price without cross-referencing the bill of quantities demolition items against the actual list of positive samples. When a contractor enters into a lump-sum agreement without reservations while the tender dossier included an incomplete survey, standard contractual rules make subsequent disputes very difficult. With a fixed price, the client can reject any addendum on the grounds that the contractor, as a building professional, should have requested necessary further investigations before submitting their quote.

Another frequent oversight lies in underestimating the collective protection installations required when handling asbestos-containing or PCB-contaminated materials. Establishing negative pressure containment with decontamination airlocks, extractors equipped with HEPA filters, and optical or electron microscopy clearance testing creates substantial overheads. Overlooking these technical systems during estimating frequently leads to direct financial losses in the range of 45 000.00 CHF to 120 000.00 CHF on a major renovation construction site.

Contractually, if the contractor discovers an unforeseen situation that jeopardises regular or timely execution, they must notify the client immediately under art. 365 para. 3 CO, or bear the financial consequences of resulting delays. Nonetheless, anticipating these items at tender stage remains the only effective protection for profit margins.

Illustrative practical cases (typical scenarios on Swiss construction sites)

The figures and values shown in the scenarios below are illustrative examples intended to model decision-making during the tendering phase.

Typical scenario 1: Office building renovation in the canton of Vaud

A medium-sized general contractor, running a crew of 8 workers, bids on a call for tenders for the internal refurbishment of an office building built in 1974. The tender package includes specifications detailing the removal of 1 400 m² of lightweight partitions and the scabbling of 650 m² of floor tiles. The pollutant report attached to the file took only three general samples from floor slabs and performed no testing on wall tile adhesive or window mastics.

The estimator refuses to absorb the risk of airborne fibres in their standard demolition unit price. They take advantage of the query period in the procedure to submit a clarification request regarding the lack of sampling under wall tiles. With the client confirming that tests were not carried out, the firm submits its offer with an explicit reservation: baseline pricing excludes any work in a contaminated environment. If subsequent testing ordered by the site management confirms contamination, the remediation will be handled via a separate addendum estimated at 58 400.00 CHF, protecting the firm against a complete wipeout of its gross margin.

Typical scenario 2: Removal of external joinery and PCB joints in the canton of Geneva

A metal construction firm employing 12 staff tenders for the complete replacement of 180 window frames on a municipal school building built in the early 1960s. The survey provided confirms the presence of PCBs in external joint sealants, without stating the exact concentration in the adjacent perimeter concrete.

The estimator notes that simply prising off the frames without specific precautions would contaminate surrounding masonry and require heavy concrete milling not detailed in the bill of quantities. The company tailors its offer by including an adapted dry joint removal method using dedicated dust extraction and disposal into certified drums for a controlled additional cost of 28 650.00 CHF, avoiding the risk of a site shutdown following a spot check by labour inspection authorities.

Calls for tenders: free tools

Direct public procurement tenders, AIMP thresholds by canton, converting SIA 451 to Excel, quantity takeoff from an IFC model.

View tendering tools

Frequently asked questions

What should you do if the pollutant report is completely missing from the tender?

Contact the site management in writing during the tender query period. Under art. 365 para. 3 CO, the contractor must report defective ground or substrates immediately. A prior asbestos or PCB survey remains essential to price protection measures before any dismantling.

How do you claim an asbestos remediation cost overrun not listed in the quote?

The contractor issues immediate formal notice under art. 365 para. 3 CO and standard SIA 118. Unforeseen disposal of asbestos adhesive, around 6500.00 CHF for illustration, constitutes an unforeseeable circumstance under art. 373 para. 2 CO, granting the right to a price adjustment.

Can the contracting authority exclude a tender that includes reservations on pollutants?

Under the LMP, the contracting authority eliminates tenders that do not meet mandatory tender conditions. However, raising a formal technical question before submission avoids entering an impermissible reservation. In addition, art. 12 LMP mandates strict compliance with worker health and safety regulations on the construction site.

What risks does a contractor run if they start demolition work without a PCB survey?

The client may invoke art. 366 para. 2 CO if performance fails to comply with recognised rules of the art. Furthermore, art. 229 CP governs criminal liability where human life or physical safety is endangered during construction or demolition works.

Who pays for additional characterisation required during work on the construction site?

The client is responsible for handing over a building free from hidden defects. If the plans and quotes omit hazardous materials, additional tests—around 1850.00 CHF as an illustration—must be covered by an addendum approved under standard SIA 118.

How should asbestos disposal routes be priced into the offer?

Pricing must set out secure transport and regulated landfill disposal fees separately. Under art. 364 CO, the contractor is liable for the equipment and resources needed to carry out the work, which means these specialised technical costs must be priced thoroughly in the tender bill of quantities.

Protecting your tenders against pollutant risks

Factoring hazardous substances in early safeguards your bids' profitability and your firm's legal standing right from the call for tenders stage. Thoroughly vetting the diagnostic report establishes sound working relations with site management and protects your operating margin.

To explore your estimating and contract review processes in Switzerland in greater detail, consult our dedicated guides:

Art Construction is an independent company: it is not affiliated with the SIA, CRB, SUVA, or KBOB. Referenced norms and standards point to publications from these bodies; only official versions are legally binding.