Table of contents
The 3 Major Site Risks
- Financial / Margin: Bearing undervalued work volumes from the specifications at a loss under an overall or lump-sum award. Under art. 373 CO, the contractor cannot demand an increase for work included in its lump sum, generating gross margin erosion that can exceed 15 % of the trade package (around 45 000,00 CHF for an undersized masonry item).
- Legal / Joint / SUVA: Rejection of the tender for an abnormally low price or breach of the duty to notify the client immediately pursuant to art. 365 para. 3 CO if a major discrepancy jeopardises proper execution. In public procurement, art. 38 LMP requires the contracting authority to verify abnormally low tenders in order to guarantee equal treatment and transparency governed by art. 11 LMP.
- Administrative / Acceptance: Blocking of statement verification and disputes over joint measurements. Under standard SIA 118, if the discrepancy between architect drawings and the standard item catalogue was not reported before submitting the tender, site management may reject volume addenda, delaying approval of the final account and release of securities.
When pricing a tender in Switzerland, the contractor and its estimator regularly face glaring quantitative inconsistencies between provisional execution drawings issued for the call for tenders and volumes entered in the CAN bill of quantities. Whether in public procurement governed by the LMP or a private mandate subject to standard SIA 118, the choice of pricing method determines the final financial liability of the bidding firm. An unidentified quantification error prior to submission compromises the entire profitability of the successful bidder, particularly if the contract shifts to a strict unit price or a lump-sum price under art. 373 CO.
This guide outlines the operational strategy to adopt from the estimation phase onward when facing discrepancies in volumes, formwork surface areas or linear measurements of technical installations. Methodically analysing the root causes of discrepancies, submitting formal requests for clarification while observing the principle of equal treatment among bidders, and tailoring the structure of your tender helps safeguard margins while avoiding disqualification from the award for unauthorised unilateral changes to tender documents.
Typology of discrepancies between graphic take-offs and tender specifications
In Swiss tendering practice, inconsistencies between architect or civil engineer drawings and items in the bill of quantities represent a frequent technical hurdle for estimators. These discrepancies emerge in two primary forms: direct geometric divergence and the qualitative omission of implied work.
The first category involves pure metric discrepancies. Dimensions stated on sections or formwork plans show larger measurements than those calculated in the quantities entered in the standard item catalogue. Such differences are seen in reinforced concrete volumes, waterproofing surface areas or linear runs of precast elements. The second category stems from unbundled technical interfaces. The drawing shows an insulation system with perimeter upstands, whereas the bill of quantities omits the specific item for mechanical fixings or waterproofing head protection.
A rigorous evaluation method requires systematically overlaying the surface take-off performed on digital files with the official tender item list. The goal is to quantify accurately the actual theoretical volume before setting any unit price, in order to anticipate the financial structure of the proposal.
Legal classification of the contract and consequences of quantitative discrepancies
The significance of a volume discrepancy depends on the legal remuneration structure agreed by the parties, governed by the Swiss Code of Obligations (CO) and supplemented by standard SIA 118 when incorporated into the contract.
In a contract concluded on unit prices, quantities shown in the specifications are purely indicative for tender preparation. Final remuneration is based on actual measurements of work genuinely delivered on the construction site. The contractor is remunerated according to the value of the work and actual expenditure, in line with the general principle of art. 374 CO, by applying agreed unit prices to actual volumes measured jointly with site management.
Conversely, if the client imposes remuneration at a lump-sum price, risk allocation shifts completely. Under art. 373 CO, the contractor undertakes to execute the work for the agreed sum and cannot claim any increase, even if the work requires more labour or expenditure. Paragraph 2 of this article reserves court intervention solely for extraordinary circumstances that could not be foreseen or were excluded by the parties' assumptions. If the bidder accepts a lump sum based on an undervalued description without stating reservations or adjusting the contractual scope, the volume deficit remains entirely at its expense.
Response strategies for the bidder when facing inconsistencies
Three distinct approaches may be adopted by the firm during tender pricing, depending on the nature of the procurement and the governing regulatory framework.
The first strategy, compliant with public procurement transparency under art. 2 LMP, involves submitting a formal request for clarification to the contracting authority via the official platform within the set deadline. The contracting authority reviews the questions, issues an identical response to all competitors, and publishes a revised quote description where appropriate. This path secures equal treatment and prevents subsequent disputes.
The second strategy consists of pricing the tender by strictly adhering to specification quantities to avoid administrative non-compliance, while including an explanatory note in the technical appendix or cover letter. This method is suited to private contracts governed by standard SIA 118, where the order of priority among contractual documents generally gives precedence to specifications over drawings when determining the required works.
The third approach, often risky, relies on unbalancing unit prices tactically, increasing rates on undervalued items in the bill of quantities and decreasing them on overvalued ones. While this practice can maximise the final account under a unit-price contract, it exposes the tender to in-depth plausibility checks. Under art. 38 LMP, the contracting authority may request explanations and review price compliance. A tender showing manifest discrepancies may be eliminated under art. 44 LMP.
| Observed situation | Impact on unit-price contract | Impact on lump-sum contract | Recommended action prior to submission | Reference framework |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Concrete volume undervalued by 20 % in the quote | Invoicing based on actual take-off after completion | Direct gross loss borne entirely by the contractor | Formal request for clarification via the platform | Art. 373 CO / Standard SIA 118 |
| Complete omission of a reinforcement item | Establishment of a new price via addendum | Dispute over inclusion of the scope in the lump sum | Immediate notification to site management | Art. 365 para. 3 CO / Standard SIA 118 |
| Waterproofing surface overvalued by 30 % | Proportional decrease in turnover | Potential gain if the scope is fixed in a lump sum | Verification of the unit break-even threshold | Art. 374 CO |
| Discrepancy between drawing dimension and CAN item | Application of the document precedence rule | Disagreement over the scope of work owed | Request for written confirmation of official dimension | Standard SIA 118 / SIA RPH |
| Contradictory material specification | Risk of quality dispute during installation | Impossibility of adjusting price after award | Prior formal notice regarding material selection | Art. 364 CO / Art. 365 CO |
Common analysis errors and financial repercussions on profitability
Failing to verify quantities is a recurring cause of margin erosion. The first mistake lies in blindly trusting take-offs prepared by engineering consultants. On a structural work package involving 450 m³ of concrete walls, a 15 % estimation error represents roughly 67,50 m³ omitted from the quote. At average Swiss execution rates, the unforeseen deficit reaches approximately 23 500,00 CHF incl. VAT, borne entirely by the builder if the contract is awarded as a lump sum.
The second mistake involves unilaterally modifying quantities in the digital exchange file before submitting the tender. In a public call for tenders governed by the LMP, changing the quantities without explicit instruction leads to direct disqualification of the bid for procedural non-compliance, pursuant to art. 44 LMP.
The third frequent error is failing to issue timely notice. Under art. 365 para. 3 CO, if any circumstance jeopardises the proper or punctual completion of the work, the contractor must immediately notify the client, failing which it shall bear the consequences. Remaining silent in the hope of claiming an extra cost later exposes the company to outright rejection of its financial claims.
Illustrative practical cases (typical scenarios on Swiss construction sites)
The figures and scenarios described below are illustrative examples intended to model decision-making in a construction firm.
Scenario 1: Construction of an administrative building in the canton of Vaud. During the tendering phase for a masonry and reinforced concrete trade package involving a typical crew of 8 machine operators and masons, the estimator measures 320 m² of solid slabs on the formwork drawings, whereas the corresponding specification item only indicates 240 m². The contract is subject to the open procedure under the LMP. The firm chooses not to alter the tender file but submits a written request via the public procurement platform ten days before the deadline. The contracting authority confirms the engineering firm's data entry error and publishes a corrected schedule of quantities for all bidders. The contractor wins the contract at unit prices aligned with the revised actual measurements, securing accurate billing that represents a positive difference of around 34 500,00 CHF incl. VAT.
Scenario 2: Major refurbishment of a residential building in the canton of Geneva. The private call for tenders under standard SIA 118 calls for an overall award at a lump-sum price. The estimator spots a discrepancy between the partition wall surface area drawn on architectural plans (850 m²) and that quantified in the specification (620 m²). The planned workforce requires 4 plasterers and painters. Had the firm submitted an unqualified lump-sum tender, its duty to complete the work under art. 373 CO would have required supplying 230 m² extra without compensation, amounting to a direct margin loss estimated at roughly 21 800,00 CHF incl. VAT. By formally inserting a clause in its tender letter stating that the proposed lump sum applies strictly to the quote quantity and that any overrun will be measured against unit rates, the company protects its profitability during pre-award contract negotiations.
Calls for tenders: free tools
Direct public procurement tenders, AIMP thresholds by canton, converting SIA 451 to Excel, quantity takeoff from an IFC model.
Frequently asked questions
What should you do if specifications underestimate concrete work compared to engineer drawings?
Formally report the discrepancy via the procurement platform before submission. Under art. 365 para. 3 CO, the contractor must notify the client of identified errors. On an illustrative variance of 45 000.00 CHF, prior correction avoids later disputes during measurement accounting.
Can you unilaterally correct an erroneous quantity in the submitted SIA 451 file?
No. Modifying the quantity in the bill of quantities without consent results in tender rejection. In public procurement, art. 38 LMP allows the contracting authority to examine bids and correct calculation errors. Price the official volume and state your technical reservations in a cover letter.
Who bears the cost of a volume discrepancy in a unit price tender?
Under a works contract based on the SIA 118 standard, unit prices apply to the quantities actually executed and jointly verified. For an illustrative extra cost of 18 500.25 CHF, site management validates the actual quantity survey on monthly payment claims, without modifying the initial schedule of prices.
Does an unreported earthworks discrepancy risk losing the contract award?
Yes. In public procurement, the contracting authority may order exclusion from the procedure under art. 44 LMP if the bid proves flawed or abnormally low. For an illustrative variance of 28 000.00 CHF, failing to seek technical clarification compromises the bidder's credibility during tender evaluation.
What steps should be taken if a major inconsistency is found before tender closing?
Submit a written request for clarification to the contracting authority. Under art. 11 LMP, the procurement procedure guarantees transparency and equal treatment. If an item involves, for example, 65 000.00 CHF in unquantified reinforcement, the contracting authority issues an addendum to all competing bidders.
How does the SIA 118 standard resolve conflicts between drawings and specifications?
The SIA 118 standard establishes the hierarchy of contract documents in the event of textual or graphical discrepancies. During the execution phase, jointly verified measurements take precedence over the cost estimate. A written notice protects your firm under art. 365 CO al. 3 against any unexpected budget overruns.
Strict control of quantities during the call for tenders stage protects the contractor against financial disputes on the construction site and secures the contract award. To strengthen your methodological, contractual, and regulatory skills before finalizing prices, explore our dedicated operational guides:
