Table of contents
The 3 Major Site Risks
- Financial / Margin: A gross margin deficit that can reach an illustrative order of magnitude of 8 % to 15 % of the tender amount if the firm calculates prices based on an incomplete specification while the drawings require more costly work, with the client attempting to enforce a fixed price without supplements under art. 373 CO.
- Legal / Joint Body / SUVA: A risk of contractual disputes as early as the tender stage when unclarified technical discrepancies lead to the omission of safety systems required on the drawings, exposing the contractor to the consequences set out in art. 365 para. 3 CO for failing to immediately notify the client of circumstances jeopardising the work.
- Administrative / Acceptance: A formal dispute during quantity measurements or upon the final account under norm SIA 118, blocking payment applications and delaying acceptance of the work due to unresolved disagreements over whether drawings take precedence over itemised prices in the bill of quantities.
During the tender stage in Switzerland, rigorous pricing of a call for tenders frequently confronts cost estimators and business owners with substantial technical discrepancies between the designer's drawings and the bill of quantities prepared under the CAN standard item catalogue. The temptation to price only the lines in the bill without cross-checking the graphic scale of the drawings exposes the successful bidder to direct losses, as the client invokes the lump-sum price nature under art. 373 CO or the overall project description. Norm SIA 118 establishes a strict contractual framework that determines the ranking of each document whenever the special conditions do not expressly govern the order of precedence among the tender documents.
To safeguard tender profitability in public procurement governed by the LMP or in private-law contracts under art. 363 CO, bid managers must detect these contradictions before submitting the tender. Exercising the duty to notify prescribed by art. 365 para. 3 CO requires raising questions with the site management during the question-and-answer period to resolve any ambiguity regarding the expected scope of work. This methodical review makes it possible to lodge formal reservations or submit compliant alternative bids, thereby protecting the legal validity of the tender while safeguarding company margins against future demands from local site management on French-speaking Swiss construction sites.
Order of precedence of tender documents under norm SIA 118
During the tender phase, reviewing public or private call for tenders files frequently reveals discrepancies between graphic drawings and the text items in the bill of quantities. To determine which document prevails in the event of a discrepancy, norm SIA 118 establishes a strict hierarchy of contractual documents. The formal works contract ranks first, followed by the special conditions of the tender, then the works description prepared according to the CAN standard item catalogue, ahead of working drawings or design plans.
This rule means that, unless expressly stated otherwise in writing within the special conditions, the written and detailed provisions of the quote specification prevail over the graphic representations on the drawings. A contractor answering a call for tenders cannot assume that a drawing overrides an omission in the specification, nor vice versa. Under art. 365 para. 3 CO, if the documents supplied by the client or its agents contain anomalies, obvious omissions or discrepancies likely to compromise the execution of the work, the contractor has a formal duty to notify the client immediately.
In public procurement governed by the LMP, equal treatment of bidders guaranteed under art. 11 LMP prohibits any unilateral amendment of the specification by the contractor without prior approval from the contracting authority. When a major contradiction arises, submitting a request for clarification via the question forum on the simap.ch publishing platform is the only compliant channel. Under art. 38 para. 1 LMP, the contracting authority examines bids and verifies their compliance with formal requirements; pricing an undeclared variant based on a drawing that contradicts the CAN exposes the tender to formal exclusion under art. 44 para. 1 LMP.
Arbitration method during the pricing phase prior to tender submission
To secure the unit price or lump-sum price without jeopardising the admissibility of the tender, the estimator must apply a systematic protocol as soon as a discrepancy is identified:
- Identify the textual and dimensional discrepancy by systematically comparing dimensioned drawings with the units of measurement in the CAN bill of quantities.
- Submit a formal written question to site management or via the public procurement platform before the deadline set for questions.
- If no answer is received before submission, price the bill of quantities item strictly as drafted to maintain the comparability of the base offer pursuant to art. 29 LMP.
- Attach an alternative bid or an explanatory note formatted as a technical reservation specifying the exact scope priced, making explicit reference to art. 365 para. 3 CO.
Comparison table of common contractual discrepancies
| Identified contradiction scenario | Prevailing document (norm SIA 118) | Legal classification (CO / LMP) | Consequence for pricing | Tendering best practice |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Drawing quantity 30 % higher than the quantity indicated in the quote specification | CAN quote specification (unit price applicable to actual measured quantities) | Measurement contract pursuant to art. 363 CO and norm SIA 118 | Pricing of the tendered quantity without altering the line-item total | Report the volume discrepancy; never unilaterally alter the quantities |
| Masonry thickness of 20 cm on drawings, listed as 15 cm in the specification | CAN specification (prevailing over preliminary design drawings) | Duty to notify the client immediately (art. 365 para. 3 CO) | Risk of structural inadequacy and cost underestimation | Submit a formal question on simap.ch; failing that, price the 15 cm item with reservations |
| Complete omission of a waterproofing item in the specification though visible on section drawings | Specification (omission does not imply work is provided free of charge) | Out-of-scope work; scope of the lump-sum price under art. 373 CO | Loss of gross margin if the client demands complete delivery without a supplement | Submit a supplementary item not included in the base tender |
| Standard grade steel specified in the quote but reinforced grade shown on structural drawings | Special provisions of the quote specification | Execution in accordance with recognised standards of workmanship and art. 364 CO | Cost differential in materials and installation | Request written confirmation from the structural engineer before submitting the tender |
| Special conditions imposing an overall lump sum against a CAN unit-price schedule | Special conditions of the tender (ranking above the CAN) | Contractual precedence and lump-sum price under art. 373 CO | The bidder bears the full risk of quantity discrepancies | Recalculate all quantities against the drawings before committing |
Frequent interpretation errors and financial impacts
Poor analysis of the document hierarchy leads to expensive disputes. The most common mistake consists of spontaneously including work drawn on the plans but absent from the standard item catalogue into one's unit price, hoping to appeal to the contracting authority. The overall price then becomes artificially inflated, which disqualifies the offer under the price award criterion in art. 29 para. 3 LMP against competitors who strictly adhered to the bill of quantities.
Conversely, failing to request clarification in a contract awarded on a lump-sum price basis under art. 373 CO strips the contractor of any entitlement to additional compensation. Case law on works contracts holds that a professional contractor who fails to report an obvious discrepancy incurs liability under art. 364 CO. It cannot subsequently invoke art. 373 para. 2 CO to claim extraordinary unforeseen circumstances. On a structural work package worth 1 250 000,00 CHF, an unflagged discrepancy on trench shoring can generate a direct loss of 65 000,00 CHF, borne entirely by the contractor.
Illustrative practical cases (typical scenarios on Swiss construction sites)
The following situations and figures are illustrative examples designed for operational learning, based on observed practices in the Swiss construction industry.
Typical scenario 1: Discrepancy on reinforced concrete rebars in the Canton of Vaud
A masonry contractor with 25 workers submits a bid in an open public call for tenders (art. 18 LMP) for an administrative building in Lausanne with a total estimated value of 4 800 000,00 CHF. The CAN 241 bill of quantities specifies a reinforcing steel ratio of 85 kg per cubic metre of concrete across all slabs. The structural engineer's formwork and reinforcement drawings indicate an expected ratio of 115 kg per cubic metre in the calculation notes.
The contractor identifies the discrepancy of 30 kg per cubic metre over a total volume of 1 200 cubic metres, representing 36 000 kg of steel. Pricing at the drawing ratio without alerting the client would inflate the base tender by roughly 77 760,00 CHF incl. VAT (including Swiss VAT of 8,1 %), jeopardising the contract award under art. 41 LMP. The business owner strictly adheres to norm SIA 118: he submits a written question on the procurement platform forum. The contracting authority issues an addendum confirming the 115 kg ratio for all competitors, restoring fair competition under art. 2 LMP.
Typical scenario 2: Omission of a roof waterproofing layer in the Canton of Geneva
Under an invited private tender for adding storeys to a residential building in Geneva, the specification omits the levelling screed under the two-layer waterproofing, although it is clearly drawn on the 1:20 detail section. The tender amounts to 340 000,00 CHF. The specialist firm fails to enter a reservation and signs the works contract governed by norm SIA 118 on a lump-sum price basis under art. 373 CO.
During the works, site management requires the screed to be laid, citing the graphic details appended to the contract. Under norm SIA 118, the written specification overrides drawings, making the screed an amended scope of work. However, because the contractor failed to notify the client during the tender stage pursuant to art. 365 para. 3 CO, its daywork claim is disputed. Following negotiations, the financial impact of 18 360,00 CHF incl. VAT is settled through a compromise agreement that cuts into the expected profit, highlighting the need to resolve contradictions before entering into any contractual commitment.
Calls for tenders: free tools
Direct public procurement tenders, AIMP thresholds by canton, converting SIA 451 to Excel, quantity takeoff from an IFC model.
Frequently asked questions
Which document takes precedence in the event of a discrepancy under norm SIA 118?
Norm SIA 118 sets the order of precedence: special conditions override the specification, which in turn prevails over drawings in the tender package. If a discrepancy of 15 000,00 CHF emerges, the contractor must report the anomaly immediately to site management under art. 365 CO.
How should you handle dimensional discrepancies before submitting your bid?
The firm submits a formal request for clarification during the question-and-answer period of the public procurement procedure. Under the LMP, the contracting authority handles the request while upholding equal treatment. Pricing an indicative extra cost of 8 500,00 CHF without clarification exposes the tender to challenges during bid evaluation.
Does the specification prevail over drawings if a material differs?
Yes, under the standard contractual hierarchy of norm SIA 118, the text in the bill of quantities overrides drawings. If a liquid screed replaces a rough concrete slab creating a variance of 12 300,00 CHF, the contractor applies the text description, unless agreed otherwise in the contract.
What risks does a contractor face when ignoring an obvious contradiction during pricing?
By keeping quiet about a blatant discrepancy, the bidder breaches its duty of notification under art. 365 CO. In the event of a subsequent financial dispute involving 24 000,00 CHF, the client can invoke the lack of prior warning to reject any cost surcharge when determining the price under the contract for work and services.
Can a public contracting authority automatically correct a plan discrepancy?
The public contracting authority only corrects obvious calculation errors in accordance with art. 38 LMP. It cannot unilaterally modify technical specifications without violating the procedural principles under art. 11 LMP, at the risk of distorting the evaluation for an estimated amount of 45 000,00 CHF.
How should a plan discrepancy be documented in a KBOB contract?
In a KBOB contract incorporating the SIA 118 standard, the contractor records its reservations in writing before signing. If a structural discrepancy represents 18 200,00 CHF in work, the site management must approve a written addendum in accordance with the rules governing the conclusion of contracts under art. 1 CO.
Securing tender files and contractual compliance
Rigorous management of document hierarchy safeguards your company's profitability against the risks of drawing discrepancies. To explore every step of pricing and reviewing call for tenders files in Switzerland in greater detail, consult our dedicated practical guides:
