Table of contents
The 3 Major Site Risks
- Financial / Margin: Submitting poorly documented or uncertified references leads to outright rejection of the bid during technical evaluation under art. 29 LMP, resulting in an estimated turnover loss of 5% to 12% due to missed market access.
- Legal / Joint Body / SUVA: Submitting inaccurate certificates or false statements regarding compliance with working conditions can lead to formal exclusion from the procurement procedure pursuant to art. 44 LMP and art. 12 LMP.
- Administrative / Acceptance: Lacking a certificate issued after checking of the work under art. 367 CO and standard SIA 118 halts the approval of your qualification file with public contracting authorities for future calls for tenders.
In Swiss public procurement and private construction contracts, reference sheets and certificates of satisfactory performance issued by the client are a crucial pillar for establishing the technical credibility of the tendering firm. During bid evaluation, the contracting authority assesses the operational capability of candidates by analysing similar works completed in recent years. An official certificate signed by the client or the site management confirms compliance with quality standards, contractual deadlines, costs based on quotes, and safety regulations. Perfect consistency between the reference descriptions and the evidence submitted ensures an optimal qualification score.
Methodically preparing these administrative and technical documents prevents the exclusions laid down in public procurement law. For building and civil engineering contractors, requesting a certificate of satisfactory performance as early as the acceptance of the work stage under standard SIA 118 is vital. Each reference sheet must state the nature of the work, the overall contract value in Swiss francs (CHF), the specific share completed in-house or within a bidding consortium, and contact details for the referees. This practical guide details the Swiss rules for assembling an impeccable, fully compliant reference portfolio.
Drafting Standards and Validation of Client Certificates
Submitting a certificate of satisfactory performance in an award procedure depends on strict formal criteria. The contracting authority or site management verifies the accuracy of the information provided to measure the contractor's actual capability to execute the planned work. Under the Federal Act on Public Procurement, award criteria evaluate the technical capability and reliability of tenderers based on their track record. To ensure full validity, a reference sheet must include both quantitative and qualitative data certified by the client or their authorised representative acting under agency rules pursuant to the Code of Obligations (CO).
Reference sheets should never be limited to a basic project overview. They must clearly state the financial value of the work performed by the tenderer in Swiss francs, the precise nature of the works according to the Building Cost Classification (CFC), the construction timeframe, and compliance with operational constraints. Where an enterprise acts as a subcontractor or within a simple partnership as a bidding consortium, the sheet must state the exact physical and financial share carried out. The Federal Act on Public Procurement strictly regulates consortium participation and subcontracting to verify that the core service is delivered by the bidder. An incomplete or ambiguous certificate risks rejection during bid evaluation, leading to a decisive loss of points.
Comparative Analysis of Evidence in Tender Files
Not every document submitted in a qualification portfolio carries the same evidential weight before tender panels. The table below details the technical value and operational weight of the documents routinely submitted by building and civil engineering contractors.
| Document type | Key elements included | Evidential value (Public / Private) | Administrative requirements | Impact on technical score |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Official client certificate | Final value in CHF, adherence to schedules, quality of work, confirmation of no disputes. | Very high (Primary standard of evidence) | Wet-ink or qualified electronic signature of the legal representative. | Maximum: confirms technical capability on similar construction sites. |
| Local site management certificate | Conduct on site, compliance with OTConst safety, management of daywork and quantity take-offs. | High (Valued for site operations) | Sign-off by the qualified architect or engineer managing supervision. | High: confirms operational proficiency and execution quality. |
| Internal reference sheet without third-party sign-off | Photos, CFC technical description, deployed plant and equipment, planned schedule. | Medium to low (Considered self-declaratory) | Must include reachable contact details for designated referees. | Moderate: requires direct verification by the contracting authority. |
| Partial subcontracting certificate | Exact scope of delegated works, accurate value of executed share in CHF. | Medium (Valid only for own delivered share) | Certificate signed by the general contractor or total contractor. | Targeted: only validates capability for the proven trade. |
| Acceptance report without reservations | Formal completion of the work, handover date, absence of apparent defects. | High (Legal proof of completion) | Document drawn up in accordance with standard SIA 118 rules. | High: certifies successful contract performance without material disputes. |
Common Mistakes and Inconsistencies Penalised by Contracting Authorities
Having a bid rejected for formal defects or misleading statements regarding references is a major administrative risk for construction SMEs. The contracting authority enforces the exclusion grounds defined in the Federal Act on Public Procurement when irregularities are identified in submitted certificates. One of the most common errors is presenting the total value of a project executed within a joint venture without isolating the tenderer's own share. When checking documents, claiming sole credit for an entire contract completed as a consortium is treated as a misleading statement, resulting in immediate disqualification.
Another frequent discrepancy is a mismatch between executive CVs submitted for site supervision and the cited references. If a construction director or site manager is presented as key personnel for a public contract but does not appear on any certificates of satisfactory performance for the reference sites, the evaluation panel may downgrade the tender's credibility score. Likewise, submitting references for works where final acceptance was completed more than five years ago conflicts with standard procurement guidelines, which require recent projects to demonstrate current operational capacity.
Furthermore, failing to comply with transparency rules regarding subcontracting exposes the enterprise to penalties. Under worker protection standards and fair labour requirements governed by the Federal Act on Public Procurement and the Posted Workers Act, the contracting firm must exercise due diligence. A contractor that credits its own workforce with work entirely performed by subcontractors without disclosing it transparently risks bid rejection and exclusion from future public procurement procedures.
Illustrative Case Studies (Typical Scenarios on Swiss Construction Sites)
The following scenarios are practical examples designed to examine the validity and evidential weight of certificates of satisfactory performance under Swiss standards.
Scenario A: Tender for a School Renovation in the Canton of Vaud
A finishing work general contractor based in the canton of Vaud tenders for a public contract to carry out thermal upgrades and interior alterations in a school, valued at 2 800 000,00 CHF incl. VAT. The tender specifications require at least three certificates of satisfactory performance for similar works completed in occupied premises over the past three years. In its submission file, the firm includes two certificates signed by public clients and a third reference for private office alterations valued at 950 000,00 CHF incl. VAT.
However, for the private project, the contractor only provides a descriptive sheet signed by the architect, without formal sign-off from the client. During tender evaluation under the Federal Act on Public Procurement, the contracting authority requests clarifications based on the statutory rules governing the procedure. The enterprise promptly contacts the private client to obtain a formal certificate stating compliance with the final quote and the end of guarantee work pursuant to the Code of Obligations (CO). Backed by this written confirmation certifying that no major defects were detected upon checking of the work, the tender is declared admissible and receives the highest technical capability score.
Scenario B: Earthworks and Special Foundations in the Canton of Geneva
A civil engineering SME bids in a selective procedure for earthworks and pit shoring in central Geneva, representing a lot of 4 200 000,00 CHF incl. VAT. The contracting authority requires proof of verified expertise in managing water ingress and watertight retaining structures. The contractor chooses to submit a major project completed two years earlier within an equal 50/50 simple partnership.
To meet the transparency and impartiality rules of the Federal Act on Public Procurement, the SME prepares a detailed reference sheet explicitly stating the overall project sum (8 400 000,00 CHF incl. VAT) alongside its exact 50% share performed in-house, namely 4 200 000,00 CHF incl. VAT. It attaches the original certificate issued by the client to the partnership, along with the internal consortium agreement detailing work packages. This rigorous approach enables the panel to verify that the core work was genuinely carried out by the SME, eliminating any risk of overstating its technical capability.
Methodology for Structuring a Compliant Reference Sheet
To secure top marks when technical qualification files are evaluated, reference sheets must follow a clear structure that can be verified immediately by the contracting authority. Every reference sheet should include:
- Complete project identification, site location, and the name of the contracting authority or private client.
- Full details of the professionals directing the works (name of architectural or engineering firm, contact person, and phone number).
- Precise description of the works according to the Building Cost Classification (CFC).
- Final cost of the works performed in Swiss francs (CHF incl. VAT), clearly separating the total project value from the specific awarded lot.
- Exact start and completion dates of the work, alongside confirmation that the contractual programme was respected.
- A factual technical summary outlining specific challenges overcome (work in occupied spaces, environmental requirements, waste management under the relevant federal ordinance).
- Signed confirmation that the acceptance of the work has occurred and that contractual obligations arising from the contract for work and services under the Code of Obligations (CO) have been fully met.
By systematically applying this structure, construction firms ensure their files are clear and legible, strengthening their competitive position in both public and private calls for tenders throughout Switzerland.
Calls for tenders: free tools
Direct public procurement tenders, AIMP thresholds by canton, converting SIA 451 to Excel, quantity takeoff from an IFC model.
Frequently asked questions
How do you validate a certificate for a project completed in a joint venture?
For a simple partnership under art. 530 CO, the certificate must break down precisely the share of services executed by your firm. The client validates the exact value of the work carried out in CHF, ensuring the transparency required by art. 31 LMP when assessing your technical capabilities.
Can a private client refuse to issue a certificate?
Under Swiss law, the contract for work (art. 363 CO) does not explicitly oblige a private client to sign a certificate. However, providing formal acceptance minutes and signed final accounts constitutes equivalent proof accepted to demonstrate proper execution under art. 370 CO.
How long is a reference sheet valid for a tender?
Public contracting authorities generally require references completed within the past five years. This period corresponds to the statutory limitation period for defects in immovable works established by art. 371 CO, assuring the jury of recent, up-to-date proficiency in SIA norms.
Can a certificate containing a monetary error be corrected?
Yes, if the amount in CHF contains an error, the contracting authority may request clarifications under art. 38 LMP. The contractor then submits the certified final account to rectify the information transparently, without risking exclusion from the procedure under art. 44 LMP.
How do you validate a reference if the original client has changed?
In the event of a transfer of ownership or representation under art. 32 CO, the reference sheet is signed by the legal representative or the site management mandated at the time of project acceptance, supported by the official handover minutes.
Can references obtained as a subcontractor be used?
Yes, provided that the work package actually carried out is detailed. Art. 12 LMP requires demonstrating compliance with working conditions, and the sheet must isolate your market share in CHF to prove your firm's own technical capability on that type of project.
Compiling a flawless reference portfolio validated by clients is the cornerstone of winning your public procurement and private contracts in Switzerland. To maximise your overall tender score and systematically structure your responses to calls for tenders, explore our dedicated guides:
- Winning Technical Proposal, Human Resources, Safety, and KBOB Life-Cycle Assessment
- Structuring a Method Statement to Score Top Marks: What the Panel Evaluates First
- Site Organisational Chart, Key Personnel CVs and Apprentice Bonus (SEFRI)
- Justifying Phasing in Occupied Buildings: Supporting Sketches and 2D/3D Plans
