Table of contents
The 3 Major Site Risks
- Financial / Margin: An imprecise technical proposal leads to an underevaluation of technical merit under art. 29 LMP, depriving the tenderer of decisive points against price. The lost earnings can represent the entire net margin of an operation, commonly around 5% to 8% of the total amount budgeted in CHF.
- Legal / Joint bodies / SUVA: The lack of formal commitments regarding worker protection measures and equal treatment under art. 12 LMP leaves the tender vulnerable to rejection. The contracting authority must reject any tender that does not guarantee strict compliance with working conditions and declared generally binding collective labour agreements.
- Administrative / Handover: Submitting a methodology disconnected from the real constraints of the site weakens the plausibility of the tender within the meaning of art. 29 LMP. This results in the contract being awarded to a competitor under art. 41 LMP, rendering the administrative investment of the preliminary study completely futile.
Under public procurement in Switzerland governed by the LMP and the AIMP, members of an evaluation board spend on average around twelve minutes on the initial review of each technical proposal. This strategic document, submitted alongside the bill of quantities structured according to the chapters of the CAN standard specification catalogue, determines the points awarded for technical merit, construction site organisation, environmental protection, and compliance with deadlines under art. 29 LMP. For company executives, site directors, and estimators tendering in French-speaking Switzerland, the challenge is to structure an impactful proposal that provides the required answers without drowning the jury in needless volumes of paper.
To aim for the top score, the structure of the technical proposal must strictly reflect the evaluation grid published by the contracting authority, while ensuring full compliance with the requirements of art. 11 LMP and art. 41 LMP. Each chapter must provide concrete evidence of proficiency in managing local constraints, supervisory staffing, and safety protocols, thereby avoiding the pitfall of generic promotional material that undermines the credibility of the tender.
Anatomy of express review by the awarding evaluation board
As part of the examination of tenders governed by art. 38 LMP, evaluators apply a strict scoring grid to award points for qualitative criteria defined under art. 29 LMP. In twelve minutes of actual focused reading per submission, a jury member does not read the technical proposal in a linear fashion: they scan for supporting evidence, compare organizational sheets against the requirements of the bill of quantities, and verify the practical feasibility of the work. A technical tender must therefore be engineered to provide immediate answers to the expectations of site management and the client.
The award decision set out in art. 41 LMP is based on the most advantageous tender, which requires maximising the technical score to avoid suffering from a race to the bottom on the schedule of unit prices. To win the approval of a cantonal or municipal jury, the proposal's structure must reflect the contractor's contractual obligations defined by art. 364 CO, demonstrating that the required equipment, plant, and tools have been rigorously anticipated.
The 12-minute sequence: visual flow and review hierarchy
The chronological review carried out by technical experts is divided into four distinct phases, driven by the need to de-risk the future construction site:
- Minutes 0 to 2: Key competencies alignment and supervision: The jury checks the operational organisation chart dedicated to the project. The presence of a qualified site manager and general foreman, backed by recent references on similar construction sites, guarantees compliance with the duty of personal direction under art. 364 CO.
- Minutes 2 to 5: Site installation plan and access logistics: The review turns immediately to the construction site installation plan. Access routes, truck turning circles, storage areas, and the positioning of the crane or material hoists must demonstrate a thorough knowledge of the parcel's constraints.
- Minutes 5 to 9: Execution schedule and critical path: The preliminary schedule is examined to detect any sequencing inconsistencies. Inaccurate timing assessments expose the client to risks of non-performance or delay as covered by art. 366 CO, which heavily penalises the tender's plausibility score under art. 29 LMP.
- Minutes 9 to 12: Constraint management and safety measures: The jury completes its review by verifying occupational health and safety measures. The contracting authority ensures compliance with statutory provisions under art. 12 LMP, particularly safety management in line with OTConst and SUVA requirements.
Comparison table: standard proposal versus top-scoring proposal
What sets apart a tender lost in the middle of the ranking from one achieving the top score of 5/5 comes down to the precision of the tangible evidence provided in each chapter:
| Section of the proposal | Generic approach (score 2 to 3 out of 5) | Jury-optimised approach (score 5 out of 5) | Direct impact on LMP evaluation |
|---|---|---|---|
| Human organisation | General corporate organisation chart with no specific project allocation. | Named role assignments on site with guaranteed contractual commitment rates. | Safeguards technical capability and complies with art. 364 CO. |
| Logistics and site installation plan | Standard schematic layout not tailored to actual property boundaries. | Dimensioned plan incorporating load limits, easements, and local traffic flow management. | Highlights technical feasibility under art. 29 LMP. |
| Time phasing | High-level bar chart indicating only the start and end dates of major packages. | Detailed Gantt chart with critical path, decision milestones, and realistic installation rates. | Plausibility of the tender verified under art. 29 LMP and prevention of art. 366 CO. |
| Health and safety | Full reproduction of general health and safety regulations. | Site-specific risk analysis: collective protective measures and emergency response plans. | Guarantees strict compliance with art. 12 LMP requirements. |
| Environmental protection | Vague commitment to waste sorting without designating disposal channels. | Excavation management plan, skip rotation schedules, and regional sorting centres. | Maximum points on the sustainable development criterion under art. 29 LMP. |
| Subcontractor interfaces | Mere mention of potential reliance on unidentified third parties. | Exhaustive list of delegated trades and due diligence monitoring protocols. | Compliance with art. 31 LMP and subcontractor due diligence requirements under the LDét. |
Common drafting errors and their financial impact
Neglecting editorial presentation and technical rigour leads to immediate score reductions. Several methodological pitfalls consistently lead to losing the public contract:
- Corporate filler: Inserting full pages from corporate sales brochures distracts the reader and hides the lack of technical analysis. During a timed review, a jury penalises the lack of targeted answers with a mediocre score, nullifying the advantage of a competitive price.
- Mismatch between quantities and proposed installation rates: Proposing daily outputs inconsistent with the declared workforce raises doubts within the evaluation board regarding price plausibility, exposing the firm to requests for justification under art. 38 LMP.
- Underestimating obligations regarding subcontractors: Failing to clearly distinguish works carried out in-house from those assigned to third parties breaches the principles of art. 31 LMP, which stipulates that the characteristic performance must be delivered by the tenderer.
On the financial side, falling behind on qualitative criteria (frequently weighted between 40% and 60% of the overall score according to the award criteria of art. 29 LMP) forces the company to artificially cut its financial offer in an attempt to win. On a mid-sized construction project, a deficit of 0.5 points on the qualitative score requires offering an additional financial discount of around 60 000,00 CHF to 120 000,00 CHF, all taxes included (including 8,1% VAT), heavily eroding the gross operating margin.
Illustrative practical cases (typical scenarios on Swiss construction sites)
The figures and scenarios presented below are illustrative examples formulated to analyse the evaluation mechanisms of a technical jury.
Scenario 1: Major renovation of an occupied school building (Canton of Vaud)
For a refurbishment and energy retrofit contract valued at 4 850 000,00 CHF (including 8,1% VAT), the call for tenders under an open procedure governed by the LMP set a weighting of 50% for price and 50% for technical merit and construction site organisation. The average workforce planned by the structural work contractor consisted of 14 tradespeople alongside supervision comprising a certified general foreman and a site manager assigned at 50%.
The approach selected in the technical proposal abandoned a general narrative presentation in favour of a phasing book structured around school holidays. Using detailed access sections, the contractor demonstrated how teaching areas would be physically separated from construction vehicle traffic, guaranteeing the safety of building users. The jury awarded the maximum score of 5/5 on the methodology criterion, making up for a price difference of 85 000,00 CHF against a competitor with a lower quote whose technical proposal failed to address coactivity with running classrooms.
Scenario 2: Civil engineering structure and municipal sewer installation (Canton of Fribourg)
For a public procurement contract covering the installation of a sewer main under a busy cantonal road, valued at 1 240 000,00 CHF (including 8,1% VAT), the award criteria under art. 29 LMP allocated a 30% weighting to the schedule and traffic impact. The site execution team consisted of 6 specialised civil works operatives.
The tendering contractor structured its proposal around maintaining traffic flow via alternating single-lane traffic controlled by signals. The technical document detailed trench shoring rates, daily temporary road reinstatement by 17:00, and coordination with emergency services. This operational justification secured the contract award within the meaning of art. 41 LMP, as the contracting authority confirmed that traffic disruption risks were well managed, unlike competing tenders deemed overly theoretical.
Calls for tenders: free tools
Direct public procurement tenders, AIMP thresholds by canton, converting SIA 451 to Excel, quantity takeoff from an IFC model.
Frequently asked questions
How does the jury penalise a generic technical proposal during evaluation?
Under art. 29 LMP, the contracting authority scores technical merit and plausibility. A standardised proposal lacking detailed phasing or failing to consider local municipal constraints receives a minimal score. On an illustrative 1 200 000,00 CHF contract, this loss of points disqualifies the tender against context-specific competitors.
Can you alter the methodology or price in the technical proposal after submission?
No. Art. 11 LMP strictly prohibits negotiations on price or scope of work. Only formal explanations under art. 38 LMP are permitted to correct obvious calculation errors or clarify a technical point without modifying the original tender, under penalty of exclusion from the procedure.
What proof of safety must be included in the proposal to meet the award criteria?
The company includes its safety concept tailored to SUVA directives and the OTConst. For a masonry package valued around 450 000,00 CHF, the document details access, fall protection, and the appointed competent person, guaranteeing the statutory compliance required by the public contracting authority.
Does an extremely low price remove the need for a high-quality technical proposal?
Absolutely not. Under art. 38 LMP, the contracting authority checks financial plausibility. An understated amount in the region of 350 000,00 CHF without detailed methodological justification triggers a formal inquiry. Without a rigorous demonstration of production rates and processes in the technical proposal, the bid is rejected under art. 44 LMP.
How can you showcase construction site supervision within formal award criteria?
Art. 29 LMP permits assessing the qualifications of the designated team. The technical proposal outlines the nominative organisational chart of the site manager and foreman, their recognised qualifications and their actual availability. This section proves the organisational capacity required by art. 364 CO to carry out the work without foreseeable defects.
What is the legal deadline to appeal an adverse evaluation of the technical proposal?
Under art. 56 LMP, an unsuccessful tenderer has 20 days from notification of the award to file a reasoned written appeal. The appellate body reviews legality and compliance with tender criteria, but does not reassess the discretionary evaluation.
To win public procurement or private contracts in Switzerland, drafting a technical proposal requires a factual, site-specific demonstration tailored directly to the concrete expectations of the award committee. Explore each methodological aspect in depth with our dedicated guides:
- Winning Technical Proposal, Human Resources, Safety, and KBOB Life-Cycle Assessment
- Site Organisational Chart, Key Personnel CVs and Apprentice Bonus (SEFRI)
- Justifying Phasing in Occupied Buildings: Supporting Sketches and 2D/3D Plans
- Drafting the Specific Safety Concept: SUVA and OTConst Measures in the Tender
