Table of contents
The 3 Major Site Risks
- Financial / Margin: Losing the award criterion for technical supervision or apprentices costs between 5% and 15% of total points depending on the weighting set out in art. 29 LMP. On an earthworks or structural work contract of 2 400 000,00 CHF, this scoring gap rules out the bid against a better-structured competitor, wiping out the approximately 18 000,00 CHF in tendering costs already incurred.
- Legal / Joint Body / SUVA: Submitting unqualified profiles or failing to comply with vocational training and qualification rules exposes the firm to direct exclusion from the procedure under art. 44 LMP, together with a report to the joint committees for breach of worker protection provisions and working conditions laid down in art. 12 LMP.
- Administrative / Handover: The unapproved replacement of a key person named in the tender breaches the duty to perform the work under personal direction pursuant to art. 364 CO and infringes procurement rules, allowing the contracting authority to revoke the award under art. 44 LMP or refuse advance payment applications during site management inspections.
In public and private procurement subject to the LMP or AIMP in French-speaking Switzerland, bid evaluation is no longer based solely on the price schedule. Contracting authorities allocate a decisive share of the score to technical quality criteria governed by art. 29 LMP, which include the operational site org chart, the formal qualifications of key personnel, and an active commitment to initial vocational training leading to a federal certificate of capacity (CFC) recognized by the State Secretariat for Education, Research and Innovation (SEFRI). For estimators and construction executives, presenting these components effectively provides direct leverage to win awards against competitors with similar fee or construction quotes.
Structuring a project-specific org chart rigorously demonstrates full alignment between the specifications and the chain of command on site, from the construction manager to the site foreman. Furthermore, providing documentary evidence of SEFRI-certified apprenticeship contracts secures the bonus points available in cantonal evaluation grids, while ensuring strict compliance with the principles of transparency and equal treatment set out in art. 11 LMP. This technical submission requires complete consistency between the Swiss qualifications presented and the actual responsibilities delegated throughout the bid preparation phase.
Structure of the site org chart and chain of responsibility
The site org chart submitted with a tender serves as the formal demonstration of the tendering firm's organizational capability. Contracting authorities assess hierarchical clarity, the operational decision-making chain, and the actual availability of the personnel assigned to the works. Under art. 364 CO, the contractor is required to carry out the work under personal direction or ensure adequate direction by qualified personnel. The chain of command must clearly distinguish the company's internal site management, the construction management, and the on-site supervision provided by foremen from the local site management appointed by the contracting authority.
Under procedures governed by the LMP and AIMP, an effective org chart clearly depicts communication flows, technical interface management, and the supervision of subcontractors approved under art. 31 LMP. The contracting authority analyzes the allocation rates expressed as percentages for each key person. A construction manager listed simultaneously on several projects at an 80% allocation rate is deemed non-credible during bid evaluation under art. 38 LMP, which downgrades the technical score of the tender.
Showcasing key staff CVs and qualification compliance
The tender package requires operational CVs focused on specific experience directly relevant to the complexity of the project out to tender. Evaluation rests on the technical value and execution quality of key personnel under art. 29 LMP, which provides that the contracting authority evaluates bids based on criteria linked to the performance, notably technical value and the plausibility of the bid. Each CV must establish a compelling link between Swiss vocational qualifications and comparable completed projects.
Supervisory profiles must highlight official qualifications from the Swiss vocational education and training system:
- Project and operations management: Qualified civil engineer or holder of a master builder federal diploma, demonstrating strategic oversight of operations and command of the liabilities arising from the contract for work under art. 363 CO.
- Construction management: Construction manager with a federal diploma or ES-qualified construction management technician, handling weekly scheduling, contractual management of change orders, and financial monitoring of the contract.
- Site supervision: Qualified site foreman with a federal certificate or qualified gang leader, ensuring site safety, adherence to SUVA directives, and day-to-day organization of production teams.
For each key individual, the firm must list three references for similar construction sites completed over the past five years in Switzerland, specifying the role performed, the exact nature of the works, the total project value in CHF, and the technical challenges successfully managed.
The SEFRI apprentice bonus: integrating vocational training criteria
The initial vocational training evaluation mechanism is a decisive awarding factor in Swiss public procurement. This system rewards training companies that hold a cantonal authorization to train apprentices working toward a federal certificate of capacity (CFC) or a federal vocational certificate (AFP), recognized by the State Secretariat for Education, Research and Innovation (SEFRI).
The contracting authority includes commitment to vocational training among the award criteria under art. 29 LMP. To secure the maximum score for this criterion, the tendering firm must submit the apprenticeship contracts endorsed by the cantonal vocational training office, along with proof of contributions to the joint vocational training funds governed by universally binding collective labor agreements pursuant to the LECCT. The firm must also prove the effective integration of apprentices on the relevant construction site under the direct supervision of an apprenticeship trainer or tutor holding a federal certificate, while strictly upholding SUVA and OTConst safety rules.
Comparative table of supervisory and training submissions
| Package component | Non-compliant or penalised practice | Accepted standard practice | Targeted technical excellence (maximum score) |
|---|---|---|---|
| Operational org chart | Generic corporate chart without specifying staff allocated to the site. | Hierarchical tree indicating key positions and naming the personnel. | Project-specific org chart detailing allocation percentages, reporting lines, and planned stand-ins. |
| Construction manager CV | Generic CV unrelated to the contract subject matter and lacking assignment dates. | CV setting out diplomas and a general list of completed projects. | Detailed profile with ES or federal diploma, three comparable references valued in CHF, and precise role descriptions. |
| Site supervision | Vague allocation of a masonry crew without an appointed site foreman. | Identified site foreman with certificate of capacity and general experience. | Site foreman holding a federal certificate, up-to-date safety certifications, and proven experience on comparable works. |
| Vocational training (SEFRI) | No authorization to train apprentices or simple unsubstantiated declaration of intent. | Training company certificate provided without proof of an active contract. | Active CFC apprenticeship contracts approved by the cantonal authority, compliant apprentice ratio, and on-site supervision plan. |
| Substitution arrangements | No replacement procedure provided in the event of absence of a key person. | General mention of replacement by an employee of equivalent level. | Formal substitution matrix with full CV of the deputy showing qualifications identical to the primary holder. |
Disqualifying errors and financial impacts on the bid
The technical supervisory team submitted is verified thoroughly by tender evaluation boards. Any inaccuracy or deliberate overstatement of staff availability constitutes a breach of participation conditions. Pursuant to art. 44 LMP, the contracting authority may exclude a tenderer from the procedure, notably where false statements were provided in its submission. Such exclusion deprives the firm of a public contract and discredits its standing with contracting authorities.
At the contractual level, replacing a key person without the written consent of site management exposes the awarded contractor to a formal notice under art. 102 CO for defective performance of its commitments. If this failure threatens the smooth progress of the work, the client may invoke the provisions of art. 366 CO for non-conforming performance. The application of a contractual penalty stipulated in the contract for work under art. 160 CO results in a direct financial loss in the region of 10 000,00 CHF to 50 000,00 CHF, depending on the schedules established in the special conditions of contract.
Illustrative practical cases (typical scenarios on Swiss construction sites)
The figures presented in the scenarios below are illustrative examples intended to guide tenderers in their methodological decisions.
Scenario A: Public structural work contract in Lausanne (Canton of Vaud)
In an open-procedure call for tenders for the construction of a school complex valued at an estimated 4 800 000,00 CHF incl. VAT (8,1% VAT included), the contracting authority applies a 20% weighting to technical value, which includes key personnel (10%) and apprentice training (5%) under art. 29 LMP. The tendering firm puts forward a federally certified construction manager allocated 40% to the site and a certified site foreman present full-time (100%). It attaches two CFC mason apprenticeship contracts approved by the Direction générale de l'enseignement postobligatoire (DGEP) of the Canton of Vaud, with structured mentoring provided by the site foreman. The tender earns a score of 4,8 out of 5 for this sub-criterion, securing the award over a competing bid that was less comprehensive regarding supervisory staffing, despite a price difference of 65 000,00 CHF.
Scenario B: Major refurbishment of an administrative building in Geneva (Canton of Geneva)
An invited-procedure contract for urban alterations is valued at 1 850 000,00 CHF incl. VAT. The specifications require a construction manager with experience working directly adjacent to public roads. The tendering firm submits a candidate with fifteen years of practical experience but no official diploma recognized in Switzerland, and provides no SEFRI equivalence certificate. Furthermore, no apprentices are incorporated into the bid. When scoring the qualitative criteria governed by art. 29 LMP, the contracting authority assigns the minimum score of 1 out of 5 for the qualifications and training component. Despite offering a price 35 000,00 CHF lower than the runner-up, the company loses the contract to a competitor that submitted a rigorous org chart featuring a CFC track layer apprentice under qualified supervision.
Calls for tenders: free tools
Direct public procurement tenders, AIMP thresholds by canton, converting SIA 451 to Excel, quantity takeoff from an IFC model.
Frequently asked questions
Can a designated construction manager be replaced after award?
Under art. 364 CO, the contractor performs the work under personal direction. Replacing a key person requires written consent from the contracting authority. The proposed replacement must show strictly equivalent diplomas and references to preserve the initial evaluation under the LMP without altering the public procurement award.
How do you claim points for apprentices in training under SEFRI?
To achieve the maximum score, attach apprenticeship contracts approved by the cantonal authority along with your formal status as a SEFRI host company. Under art. 29 LMP, sustainable development includes dual vocational training, rewarded in the award criteria through the tangible engagement of young apprentices supervised by your key personnel.
Can a subcontractor provide the key personnel for the organigram?
Under art. 31 LMP, the characteristic performance must in principle be delivered by the tenderer. Putting forward a subcontracted site manager exposes you to rejection by the awarding panel. Direct operational supervision ensures compliance with the requirements of art. 364 CO regarding the faithful and personal execution of construction work.
What financial impact does a rejected profile have during tender evaluation?
Supervisory staff deemed inadequate during the evaluation under art. 38 LMP reduces your overall technical score. On an illustrative contract of 1 200 000,00 CHF, losing three points on technical suitability against competitors prevents you from securing the most advantageous tender as defined in art. 41 LMP.
What quantified references should be included in the CVs of key personnel?
Each CV must present three completed similar projects of equivalent complexity, with budgets around 850 000,00 CHF or 2 400 000,00 CHF. State the exact role, the client, the constraints managed, and compliance with professional rules under standard SIA 118.
Does the lack of a detailed organigram justify exclusion from a tender?
Yes. Under art. 44 LMP, the contracting authority may exclude a tender affected by formal defects or failing to meet participation requirements. A vague organigram makes it impossible to verify the chain of responsibility and the required presence of qualified personnel on the construction site.
Rigorously selecting supervisory staff and demonstrating verifiable support for the next generation of professionals form the technical foundation required to convince awarding panels. These supporting documents prove the company's organisational capability before the construction site opens.
To further refine the methodical preparation of your technical proposal, consult our dedicated guides:
- Winning Technical Proposal, Human Resources, Safety, and KBOB Life-Cycle Assessment
- Structuring a Method Statement to Score Top Marks: What the Panel Evaluates First
- Justifying Phasing in Occupied Buildings: Supporting Sketches and 2D/3D Plans
- Drafting the Specific Safety Concept: SUVA and OTConst Measures in the Tender
