Skip to content
Art ConstructionTenders
Practical guide

Contractor Variants and Alternative Offers: Rules Under SIA 118 and the AIMP

Rules for contractor variants and alternative offers in Switzerland under SIA 118, AIMP and LMP to secure your construction tenders.

Table of contents
The 3 Major Site Risks
  1. Financial / Margin: Risk of absorbing the preliminary design costs of a non-compliant technical solution amounting to some 8 500,00 CHF to 25 000,00 CHF without any guarantee of consideration by the contracting authority, followed by having to bear the agreed price under art. 373 CO without compensation for unforeseen expenses.
  2. Legal / Joint Body / SUVA: Risk of formal exclusion from the procedure under art. 44 LMP when submitting an alternative offer without an admissible base bid where required by the specifications, or non-compliance with the worker protection requirements set out in art. 12 LMP.
  3. Administrative / Handover: Risk of rejection of the variant during technical review under art. 38 LMP for failure to meet the award criteria defined under art. 29 LMP, or subsequent dispute over material equivalence at the time of delivery governed by standard SIA 118 and art. 365 CO.

When a Swiss general contractor or craftsman responds to a construction call for tenders, proposing a contractor variant or an alternative offer is a major strategic lever to stand out technically, economically, or environmentally. Common in public procurement governed by the AIMP or LMP, as well as in private contracts framed by standard SIA 118, this approach nevertheless involves strict procedural constraints that every estimator or managing director must master before altering the base descriptions. A poorly prepared variant exposes the tenderer to outright rejection of their bid or to a complex award dispute.

The Swiss legal framework requires a clear distinction between permissible design optimization and inadmissible unilateral changes. While standard SIA 118 and the Intercantonal Agreement on Public Procurement allow contractors to capitalize on their expertise, the contracting authority or client establishes the essential prerequisites, notably the obligation to submit a compliant base tender and substantiated proof of performance equivalence. A precise understanding of the admissibility rules under art. 29 LMP and art. 38 LMP safeguards the profitability of your technical design studies while boosting the appeal of your bids against the competition.

Regulatory framework comparison: AIMP, LMP and standard SIA 118

Proposing a contractor variant or an alternative offer follows two distinct legal rationales depending on whether the call for tenders is public or private. In public procurement subject to the LMP or AIMP, variants are strictly governed by the principles of transparency and equal treatment. Art. 11 LMP requires the contracting authority to act objectively and impartially, while expressly prohibiting price negotiations. Consequently, a contractor may only submit an alternative solution if the tender documents explicitly authorize it, or if the contracting authority has not restricted this option. In most open or selective procedures, submitting a base tender compliant with the original bill of quantities remains a mandatory condition of admissibility before the variant can even be examined.

The evaluation of variants in the public sector follows predefined criteria. Art. 29 LMP provides that the contracting authority evaluates bids according to objective criteria linked to the service, such as technical value, profitability, adherence to deadlines, sustainable development, or pricing plausibility. The contract is then awarded to the most advantageous bid pursuant to art. 41 LMP. If the technical variant fails to demonstrate strict functional equivalence or alters the essential requirements of the specifications, it faces immediate rejection. Furthermore, art. 44 LMP permits the contracting authority to exclude any tenderer whose bid suffers from serious formal defects.

Conversely, in private procurement governed by standard SIA 118, contractual freedom prevails within the limits established by the Code of Obligations (CO). Standard SIA 118 encourages constructive optimization: the contractor is free to propose variants intended to reduce costs, expedite execution, or enhance the structure's durability. However, this freedom comes with a stringent duty to inform. Under art. 365 para. 3 CO, if any circumstance arises that compromises the regular or timely completion of the work, the contractor must inform the client immediately, failing which they bear the consequences. Furthermore, pursuant to art. 364 CO, the contractor's duties and liability are subject to the same rules as those governing an employee, with the work having to be carried out under their personal direction.

Comparison table of variant regimes in Switzerland

Analysis parameter Public procurement (LMP / AIMP) Private procurement (Standard SIA 118)
Prior authorization Mandatory: the variant must be expressly permitted in the tender documentation. Presumed admissible, unless an exclusion clause is stipulated by the client.
Submission of the base tender Almost systematically mandatory, on pain of total bid inadmissibility. Optional if the client agrees to directly evaluate a comprehensive alternative offer.
Technical and financial negotiations Prohibited on price under art. 11 LMP; only formal requests for clarification are permitted. Permitted: open discussions between the contractor, the architect, and site management.
Evaluation criteria Published and weighted criteria under art. 29 LMP, seeking the most advantageous tender. Discretionary choice by the client according to their financial and technical priorities.
Sizing liability The contractor bears full technical liability for their alternative solution. Shared liability under art. 365 CO when formal notice is given to site management.
Consequences of a formal defect Exclusion from the award procedure pursuant to art. 44 LMP with no remedy allowed. Discussions can continue or corrections can be requested with no statutory penalty.

Method for developing a compliant variant and common mistakes

For a contractor variant to be admissible and competitive, the estimator must follow a structured methodology. The first step involves analyzing the mandatory minimum requirements of the specifications: dimensional clearances, thermal or acoustic performance, and prescribed environmental labels. Any variant that degrades baseline performance is deemed a technical downgrade and ruled inadmissible. The second step requires producing a complete technical submittal including structural calculations, material data sheets, and a line-by-line comparison against the base solution.

The third step focuses on pricing. The contractor must present a transparent breakdown detailing additions and deductions relative to the initial bill of quantities. Under a lump-sum price contract governed by art. 373 CO, the contractor performs the work for the agreed sum and cannot claim any increase, even if the work required more labor or expense. If the variant gives rise to unexpected technical execution difficulties, the contractor cannot request an additional fee, except in the presence of extraordinary circumstances that were impossible to foresee or excluded by the parties' assumptions, in accordance with art. 373 para. 2 CO.

Common mistakes identified during the submission of alternative offers frequently lead to disqualification:

  • Failure to submit a compliant base tender: the contracting authority dismisses the bid under art. 44 LMP, leading to a loss of design fees estimated between 9 500,00 CHF and 28 000,00 CHF incl. VAT depending on the project's complexity.
  • Unilateral alteration of quantities without technical justification: altering quantities from the base description without prior approval from site management skews the bid comparison.
  • Failure to prove equivalence: submitting an alternative construction system without providing Swiss conformity certificates exposes the contractor to rejection of the variant for lack of technical plausibility.
  • Inadvertent transfer of engineering liability: by modifying the structural design or waterproofing without written reservations, the contractor assumes sole liability for defects pursuant to art. 365 CO.

Illustrative practical cases (typical scenarios on Swiss construction sites)

The figures and scenarios presented below are illustrative examples intended to guide technical and legal decisions during tendering.

First scenario: in the Canton of Vaud, a Steel Construction general contractor with 35 employees bids for the construction of a pedestrian and cycle footbridge under an open municipal public procurement procedure. The specifications require a powder-coated tubular steel structure estimated at 1 450 000,00 CHF incl. VAT. The tender rules authorize contractor variants subject to the submission of the base tender. The company's engineering office devises a variant featuring welded box girders with variable inertia, saving 12 % in steel mass while ensuring equivalent structural performance. The firm submits its base tender at 1 435 000,00 CHF incl. VAT and its alternative offer at 1 298 000,00 CHF incl. VAT, accompanied by preliminary structural calculations. Upon bid opening and review under art. 38 LMP, the contracting authority confirms formal compliance. The technical variant ranks first on price and technical value pursuant to art. 29 LMP, and the contract is awarded under art. 41 LMP, generating a substantial margin gain for the tenderer.

Second scenario: in the Canton of Neuchâtel, a masonry and reinforced concrete firm of 18 employees responds to a private call for tenders issued by a property management company for the vertical extension of an apartment building, subject to standard SIA 118. The architect specifies a timber-concrete composite slab system costing 420 000,00 CHF incl. VAT. Noting critical procurement lead times that could trigger contractual delays governed by art. 102 CO, the contractor alerts the client pursuant to art. 365 para. 3 CO and proposes a variant using precast hollow-core slabs with lightweight self-leveling screed priced at 395 000,00 CHF incl. VAT, cutting installation time by three weeks. Following consultation with the civil engineer, site management accepts the alternative offer and executes a works contract under art. 363 CO at a lump-sum price under art. 373 CO, thereby preventing contractual delay penalties under art. 160 CO.

Calls for tenders: free tools

Direct public procurement tenders, AIMP thresholds by canton, converting SIA 451 to Excel, quantity takeoff from an IFC model.

View tendering tools

Frequently asked questions

Can you submit a variant without providing the requested base tender?

In public procurement governed by the LMP, submitting a variant alone without a base tender results in disqualification under art. 44 LMP. For a masonry lot estimated at 450 000.00 CHF, the contracting authority requires a compliant tender before evaluating an alternative proposal that reduces costs by 35 000.00 CHF.

How does the contracting authority evaluate the technical equivalence of a material variant?

The contracting authority assesses performance criteria defined under art. 29 LMP without negotiating prices pursuant to art. 11 LMP. For paving worth 120 000.00 CHF, the contractor must prove equivalent strength through certified comparative tests, securing an illustrative saving of 14 500.00 CHF on the project.

Can a private client accept a financial variant without retendering the contract?

Under standard SIA 118 and art. 1 CO, the private client is free to select partners. For a roofing tender submitted at 85 000.00 CHF, they can directly approve a variant at 72 500.00 CHF presented by the contractor, with no obligation to consult competing tenderers.

What risks does a contractor face when submitting an abnormally low price on a variant?

In public procurement awards, art. 38 LMP requires the contracting authority to verify the plausibility of amounts. If a remediation variant is proposed at 190 000.00 CHF instead of 280 000.00 CHF, the authority will demand detailed written justifications on pain of exclusion under art. 44 LMP.

Does a variant entail a modification of the warranty for construction defects?

No. The contractor remains liable for materials supplied under art. 365 CO and warrants the immovable structure for five years under art. 371 CO. For a rear-ventilated facade variant priced at 215 000.00 CHF, this mandatory statutory period protects the client against any construction defects arising after formal acceptance.

Can an alternative offer be submitted by a joint venture of building contractors?

Yes, forming a consortium as a simple partnership under art. 530 CO is permitted under art. 31 LMP. On a structural work contract valued at 1 650 000.00 CHF, jointly and severally liable partners can submit a joint structural variant, for example cutting overall costs by 95 000.00 CHF.

Submitting a contractor variant methodically demands flawless contractual rigor under standard SIA 118 and public procurement rules. By pricing your technical alternatives accurately, your business showcases its expertise while safeguarding its margins.

Explore our dedicated guides to learn more about procurement procedures in Switzerland:

Art Construction is an independent company: it is not affiliated with the SIA, CRB, SUVA, or KBOB. Referenced norms and standards point to publications from these bodies; only official versions are legally binding.