Skip to content
Art ConstructionTenders
Practical guide

Geotechnical Report: Groundwater, Rock and Excavation Costing

Analyze soil reports, hard rock and the water table to price excavations accurately under SIA 118 and art. 365 CO.

Table of contents
The 3 Major Site Risks
  1. Financial / Margin: An unforeseen extra cost of earthworks in hard rock or an underestimation of groundwater lowering can lead to direct losses ranging from 40 000,00 CHF to over 180 000,00 CHF. If the contract is concluded at a lump-sum price pursuant to art. 373 CO without explicit geological reservations in the tender, the contractor risks having to bear these additional expenses at its own expense.
  2. Legal / Joint Body / SUVA: Non-compliance with the battering or shoring rules prescribed by the Construction Work Ordinance exposes crews to a fatal risk of burial. A serious failing in safety measures triggers an immediate construction site shutdown ordered by the labour inspectorate or SUVA.
  3. Administrative / Acceptance: The appearance of uncontrolled water or settlement of neighbouring structures due to a lack of shoring stalls stage approvals by site management. Failing to report unfavourable ground without delay under art. 365 CO jeopardises the future acceptance of the works under standard SIA 118 and engages the contractor's liability for cumulative delays.

During the tender phase of an earthworks or structural work contract, a thorough examination of geotechnical boreholes directly determines the financial viability of the tendering firm. In French-speaking Switzerland, the diversity of sedimentary ground, the presence of compact moraines, sandstone molasse or pressurised water pockets demands rigorous technical analysis well before submitting the schedule of rates. The cost estimator must identify discrepancies between geological sections, measured piezometric levels and the bill of quantities in the call for tenders in order to anticipate heavy hydraulic rock breaker plant, continuous pumping or watertight excavation enclosures.

This professional guide is aimed at site managers, estimators and business owners faced with the pricing of complex earth movements. It details the method for interpreting soil reports, rock classification rules, as well as the immediate notice requirements under art. 365 para. 3 CO when the ground designated by the client reveals hydrogeological constraints not mentioned in standardised item series. Mastering these contractual and operational parameters under standard SIA 118 helps protect margins and state formal reservations as soon as the tender is submitted.

Geotechnical report analysis method when costing excavations

A rigorous assessment of the subsoil during the tendering phase requires systematic cross-checking between raw geological data and the scope of work. The quantity surveyor or cost estimator cannot settle for a quick read of the geotechnical engineer's general conclusions. Every borehole log, penetrometer test and piezometer reading must be scrutinised to determine the technical feasibility of the excavation as well as the actual output of the mechanical plant on the construction site.

Contractually, designating the ground is the responsibility of the client. However, pursuant to art. 365 para. 3 CO, if the ground designated by the client is recognised as defective or if any circumstance compromises the proper execution of the works, the contractor must immediately notify the client, under penalty of bearing the consequences. In tendering, this obligation requires reporting in writing any geotechnical anomaly detected before submitting the tender, via tender queries or precise accompanying reservations, especially when a lump-sum price is required within the meaning of art. 373 CO.

Analysis of geological horizons and rock identification

Distinguishing between loose ground, compact ground and solid rock directly dictates earthwork production rates. Analysing geotechnical soundings entails breaking down the layers encountered according to precise mechanical criteria:

  • Lithological nature of the layers: identifying modern alluvium, compressible lacustrine silts, heavily consolidated ground moraines and rock strata (sandstone molasse, limestone, marls).
  • Compaction and strength indices: examining dynamic penetrometer refusal, core drilling values (core recovery percentage and RQD index) as well as seismic wave propagation velocities if a geophysical survey is provided.
  • Quarrying and excavation method requirements: determining whether direct excavation with a backhoe bucket is adequate compared to requiring a heavy hydraulic rock breaker, a ripper tooth or rock cutting.
  • Bulking factor and disposal destination of spoil: calculating volumetric expansion (around 10 % to 20 % for silts versus 40 % to 60 % for crushed massive rock) affecting transport and type A or B landfill disposal.

Hydrogeological interpretation: water table and water inflows

Water in excavations is the primary factor that disrupts earthworks. The review of hydrogeological data must verify whether piezometric readings correspond to low-water or high-water periods:

  • Maximum foreseeable piezometric elevation: identifying seasonal water table fluctuations and correlating them with the theoretical excavation bottom to assess the residual head of water.
  • Soil permeability (K factor): assessing groundwater flow velocity through sandy or gravelly lenses, which determines the expected dewatering flow rate.
  • Shoring and sealing mechanisms: selecting suitable excavation retention systems (permeable soldier pile walls requiring dewatering, watertight sheet piling or diaphragm walls keyed into an impermeable horizon).
  • Construction site water discharge constraints: planning for settlement, filtration or pH neutralisation systems prior to discharge into the cantonal network or natural watercourses in compliance with water protection regulations.

Technical assessment matrix: geotechnical impacts on the tender

The following table summarises the estimating trade-offs the tenderer must make based on the ground characteristics identified in the boreholes:

Identified geotechnical contextGround technical indexRequired excavation methodRetention or dewatering systemDirect impact on pricing
Saturated surface silty alluviumLow strength, soft consistencyExcavation with backhoe on bog mats or wide tracksSafe battering or light trench box shoringSurcharges on haulage cycles and stabilised site haul roads
Compact moraine with large erratic bouldersVery high penetrometer resistanceHeavy excavator (> 30 t), reinforced bucket and occasional rock breakerStandard shoring or drilled ground anchorsIncreased bucket wear, pricing a dedicated line item for boulder breaking
Sound sandstone molasse in massive bedsHigh RQD, resistant continuous core recoveryContinuous mechanical breaking with heavy rock breaker or pre-splittingSoil nailed wall, passive anchors or steep self-supporting batterDrastic drop in daily outputs, lump-sum rock volume to be ring-fenced
Unconfined water table above excavation formation levelPermeable alluvial gravel soilsExcavation underwater or after prior drawdownVacuum wellpoints, deep well dewatering and watertight shoringFixed setup costs for continuous 24h/24 pumping and permanent power supply
Confined aquifer under artesian pressureImpermeable layer capping a pressurised aquiferExcavation under strict piezometric monitoringPreventive aquifer pressure relief through relief wellsRisk of base heave, major extra cost for specialist engineering

Frequent estimating errors and budget drift

Omitting clear reservations in the tender when faced with an imprecise geotechnical report exposes the firm to severe disputes during execution:

  • Treating fractured rock as loose ground: assuming that weathered molasse can be excavated without dedicated machinery leads to collapsed margins. The unit cost difference between loose excavation and hydraulic hammer work can range from around 18,00 CHF to over 75,00 CHF per excavated cubic metre. On a 2 500 m³ excavation, this unforeseen gross variance represents an illustrative direct loss exceeding 140 000,00 CHF.
  • Undersizing dewatering facilities: restricting pumping to a simple surface sump pump when the subsoil exhibits an aquifer with constant recharge causes recurring breakdowns, flooding of the excavation bottom and delays. Unbudgeted costs for a water treatment plant and dewatering monitoring can reach approximately 35 000,00 CHF to 90 000,00 CHF.
  • Absence of contingency clauses in the lump-sum tender: accepting a firm lump-sum price without specifying that rock quantities or water discharge rates are limited to the volumes stated in the call for tenders tender documents binds the contractor under art. 373 para. 1 CO. Geological risk can then only be invoked under art. 373 para. 2 CO for completely extraordinary and unforeseeable circumstances, which Swiss case law interprets very strictly if a soil report was appended to the procurement procedure.

Illustrative practical cases (typical scenarios on Swiss construction sites)

The figures and scenarios presented below are illustrative examples designed to guide operational analysis during the tendering phase.

Scenario 1: Discovery of a rockhead higher than call for tenders forecasts (Canton of Vaud)

As part of a call for tenders for an office complex in the Lausanne area, the tender specifications mention 6 000 m³ of bulk earthworks, including a provisional line of 300 m³ of soft molasse rock to be extracted with a toothed bucket. The pricing team examines the attached geotechnical report thoroughly. Two core samples taken at the parcel boundary show sound molasse at an elevation 1,80 metres higher than the theoretical earthworks profile shown on the excavation drawings.

The cost estimator models the actual volumes: the effective volume of hard rock requiring systematic hydraulic breaker use amounts to 1 850 m³, a differential of 1 550 m³ compared to the bill of quantities. The company decides not to incorporate this extra cost into its standard unit price to avoid undermining its competitiveness during tender evaluation. Applying the principles of standard SIA 118, it submits a compliant tender based on the provided quantities, while recording a technical reservation regarding the borehole interpretation in writing. As an alternative, it quotes a dedicated unit price of 65,00 CHF per cubic metre for rock breaking beyond the provisional volume of 300 m³. This precaution avoids a foreseeable shortfall of around 100 000,00 CHF once excavation works commence.

Scenario 2: Presence of a perched water table during excavations in a dense urban environment (Canton of Geneva)

A general contractor submits a tender for the construction of a two-storey underground car park in Carouge. The call for tenders dossier specifies a soil nailed wall enclosure with a temporary sump pump priced at a lump sum of 12 000,00 CHF for the entire earthworks package. A detailed review of the attached piezometers reveals the presence of a perched water table within sandy lenses, recharged directly by upstream surface runoff and showing piezometric levels halfway up the excavation slopes.

The tender manager notes that the permeable nailed retaining wall planned will cause sand washouts under water pressure and that disposal without settling will breach cantonal water protection regulations. In its response, the tenderer submits its base bid in line with the tender documents, but attaches a technical variant replacing the nailed wall with watertight sheet piles and preliminary wellpoints, combined with a settling tank featuring automatic pH regulation. The cost of the environmental installation is priced at 54 000,00 CHF. Recognizing the thoroughness of the analysis and the prevention of work stoppage risks, the contracting authority approves the technical variant during the assessment of the award criteria pursuant to art. 29 LMP, ensuring full financial coverage of construction site constraints for the contractor.

Calls for tenders: free tools

Direct public procurement tenders, AIMP thresholds by canton, converting SIA 451 to Excel, quantity takeoff from an IFC model.

View tendering tools

Frequently asked questions

How should you react during tendering if the geotechnical report did not measure the water table during high-water periods?

Submit a formal inquiry via the procurement platform or state an explicit reservation in your bid. Under art. 365 para. 3 CO, the contractor must promptly report defective ground conditions that jeopardize timely performance. Allow for dewatering priced illustratively at around 45 000,00 CHF.

Who bears the extra cost associated with discovering hard rock not mentioned in the bill of quantities?

SIA 118 standard and art. 365 para. 3 CO require notifying the site management. For a lump-sum contract under art. 373 para. 2 CO, extraordinary and unforeseeable circumstances allow for a price adjustment. A hydraulic rock breaker generates an indicative extra cost of around 160,00 CHF per cubic metre.

Can a contracting authority reject a bid whose price for rock excavation is abnormally low?

Yes. In public procurement, art. 38 para. 3 LMP requires requesting explanations if the total price appears abnormally low. Without a credible technical justification regarding the extraction rate, the authority may order exclusion from the procedure pursuant to art. 44 para. 2 LMP to safeguard the project.

What approach should be taken if excavation quantities below the water table differ substantially between drawings and specifications?

Request written clarification prior to submission. Under standard SIA 118, contradictions between project documents must be resolved by the contracting authority. If a discrepancy of 1 200 cubic metres persists, with an indicative figure of around 85 000,00 CHF, report the anomaly to prevent rework or a subsequent dispute.

Can the contractor claim an addendum for the disposal of contaminated soil discovered during excavation?

Absolutely. The discovery of undisclosed ground contamination falls under art. 365 para. 3 CO. The duty of prompt notice protects the contractor. Sorting, transport and licensed landfill disposal generate additional expenses that must be covered by a supplementary work order approved by the site management.

In the event of a dewatering delay attributable to the municipality, how does the firm protect its rights?

Notify the hindrance to the site management without delay. Under art. 366 para. 1 CO, the contractor must document the reasons for an extension of time to avert any default. Quantify the financial impact of excavator downtime, estimated for illustrative purposes at around 2 850,00 CHF per day.

Securing the geotechnical estimate before submitting the tender

Thorough review of soil borehole logs, piezometric levels and rock density serves as your primary defense against financial losses on the construction site. To reinforce your tender preparations and safeguard the accuracy of your quantity takeoffs, refer to the following professional guides:

Art Construction is an independent company: it is not affiliated with the SIA, CRB, SUVA, or KBOB. Referenced norms and standards point to publications from these bodies; only official versions are legally binding.