Skip to content
Art ConstructionTenders
Practical guide

Overhead, Profit, and Risks: Differentiated Markups on Labour vs Supplies

Calculate your differentiated overhead, profit, and risk markups between labour and supplies in Switzerland in accordance with SIA 118.

Table of contents
The 3 Major Site Risks
  1. Financial / Margin: Applying a uniform markup rate across total direct costs immediately distorts profitability. On a contract dominated by high-end materials or technical equipment, surcharging supplies at the same rate as productive hours leads to an uncompetitive unit price, eliminating the offer during tender evaluation. Conversely, an undifferentiated markup leads to an 8 % to 15 % structural cost shortfall in revenue when dealing with high-labour components without a dedicated margin, conflicting with the calculation of an appropriate price under art. 373 CO and art. 374 CO.
  2. Legal / Parity / SUVA: Artificially cutting overheads allocated to labour to appear competitive risks eroding the mandatory social expenses stipulated by the National Agreement or extended CLAs under the LECCT. During cantonal inspections under the LTN or award criteria audits under art. 12 LMP, failing to substantiate minimum wages and parity contributions within your cost breakdown triggers a clarification procedure under art. 38 LMP for an abnormally low bid, potentially leading to exclusion from public procurement.
  3. Administrative / Acceptance: An inaccurate allocation of overhead, profit, and risk coefficients complicates billing addenda for change orders and claiming daywork compensation governed by standard SIA 118. Failing to state differential rates clearly in the initial bid blocks the approval of monthly statements by site management and delays the final account during final acceptance of the works.

When pricing public procurement and private contracts in French-speaking Switzerland, determining unit prices requires a strict distinction between operating expenses tied to in-house labour and those linked to delivered materials. A general contractor or finishing work trade does not draw on administrative overheads, workshop logistics, and technical supervision in the same proportions for CLA-bound productive hours as it does for supplies delivered directly to the construction site. Undifferentiated cost spreading consistently compromises tender accuracy.

Calibrating markups with precision for overheads, profit, and risks demands separating the rate applied to direct payroll costs from the one burdening raw materials and equipment. This approach ensures your tender withstands plausibility checks under art. 38 LMP from contracting authorities, while protecting your net operating margins on contracts governed by the Code of Obligations (CO) or standard SIA 118. It provides the essential technical foundation needed to sharpen your tender bids without threatening your firm's financial stability.

Mechanism for allocating overheads across direct cost components

Under Swiss cost-estimating practices, markup coefficients cannot be based on a single flat allocation key. Direct costs encompass components with vastly different levels of administrative oversight, cash-flow financing, and risk exposure. Factoring in company overheads (FGE), head-office administration, and profit and risks (B&R) requires an analytical method that separates productive labour from supplied materials.

Direct labour requires substantial management support. It drives human resources management, compliance with collective agreement obligations under the National Agreement for the main construction trade or cantonal collective labour agreements, and strict adherence to occupational health and safety rules set out in the Labour Act and the construction work safety ordinance (OTConst). Under art. 364 CO, the contractor is liable for performing work with due care and diligence. This direct responsibility demands site supervision (site managers, foremen) whose indirect wage costs must be included in the operating overheads allocated to production hours.

Conversely, sourcing raw or processed materials relies on an entirely different workflow: vendor qualification, purchasing negotiations, purchase orders, delivery quantity checks, and supplier credit management. The contractor remains liable for the conformity of materials under art. 365 CO. However, the administrative time required to purchase a lot of rebar or precast concrete elements is negligible compared to supervising a masonry crew over several months. Using an identical coefficient overprices materials and undervalues the actual cost of productive labour.

Analytical allocation structure: Swiss costing model

Calculating a unit price for a position in the standard building catalogue (CAN) relies on two distinct coefficients applied to their respective direct costs:

  • Labour coefficient (k_mo): Covers workshop and yard operating overheads, technical supervision not billed directly in measurements, crew logistics, specific liability insurances, and the largest share of the profit and risk allowance to absorb weather disruptions and productivity variance.
  • Materials and supplies coefficient (k_mat): Encompasses purchasing overheads, temporary staging costs, carrying costs for payment terms granted to the client versus supplier deadlines, on-site handling losses, and a targeted risk margin for unforeseen price spikes or damage prior to installation.

Comparative table of cost items and indicative markup rates

The table below illustrates the typical breakdown of markup rates applied to direct costs for a general contractor or structural work firm operating in the Swiss Plateau. These average yard figures serve as a benchmark for fine-tuning unit prices before bidding.

Cost breakdown item Labour base (MO) Materials base (MAT) Allocation rationale
Central administrative overheads 12,00 % to 18,00 % 4,00 % to 7,00 % Payroll management, CLA wages, social security declarations vs basic supplier invoicing.
Operating and logistics overheads 8,00 % to 14,00 % 2,00 % to 5,00 % Personal equipment maintenance, changing facilities, safety gear vs unloading space.
Financing costs and supplier credit carry 1,50 % to 3,00 % 2,50 % to 4,50 % Cash-flow lag between net payroll cycles and advance payments under standard SIA 118.
Productivity risks and inclement weather 4,00 % to 8,00 % 0,50 % to 2,00 % Variability in human productivity and weather delays vs firm catalogue pricing.
Warranty, defects, and post-completion obligations 3,00 % to 5,00 % 1,50 % to 3,00 % Contractor workmanship liability (art. 368 CO) and site remediation vs supplier recourse (art. 365 CO).
Target net business profit 3,50 % to 6,00 % 2,50 % to 4,50 % Return on invested capital and valuation of technical know-how.

Common methodological errors and financial impacts

The most widespread mistake involves calculating a single global overhead rate at fiscal year-end (e.g. 22,00 % across all items) and applying it indiscriminately across every line of the quote. This shortcut creates severe cost distortions:

  • Overpriced material-heavy items: On packages involving large volumes of structural steel or ready-mix concrete, an across-the-board 22,00 % markup inflates unit prices far beyond the actual administrative procurement work. In an open tender under the Federal Act on Public Procurement (LMP), your offer is immediately undercut by competitors using a 10,00 % to 12,00 % supply markup, losing you the contract over margins sometimes narrower than 40 000,00 CHF.
  • Underpriced labour-intensive tasks: For meticulous demolition, complex formwork, or masonry repairs, applying 22,00 % when actual structural overhead exceeds 32,00 % on productive wages means selling labour hours at a loss. Even if you win the contract, the job yields a negative operating margin.
  • No provision for statutory warranties: Overlooking the specific allowance needed for the 60-day notice of defects period on immovable works under art. 367 CO deprives your firm of the reserves required to handle claims during the five-year liability window under art. 371 CO.

Illustrative practical cases (typical scenarios on Swiss construction sites)

The following figures are illustrative examples designed to show how final margins diverge based on the chosen markup methodology.

Typical scenario: Construction of an office building in the Canton of Vaud

A structural work contractor tenders for a public procurement contract for reinforced concrete works. The planned on-site workforce averages 6 skilled workers covered by the Vaud cantonal collective agreement, overseen by a part-time site manager. Direct cost analysis yields two distinct components:

  • Direct labour costs (productive jobsite hours): 240 000,00 CHF.
  • Direct material costs (concrete, rebar, specialty steel delivered): 360 000,00 CHF.
  • Total direct cost: 600 000,00 CHF excl. VAT.

Option A: Flat approach (single blanket rate)

The estimator applies a single combined overhead + profit & risks markup of 24,00 % to all direct costs, based on the previous year's overall income statement. The calculation runs as follows:

  • Global markup: 600 000,00 CHF x 24,00 % = 144 000,00 CHF.
  • Net tender price: 744 000,00 CHF.
  • Total price incl. 8,1 % Swiss VAT: 804 264,00 CHF.

Under this approach, materials absorb 86 400,00 CHF of the markup, while labour receives only 57 600,00 CHF to cover supervision, productivity risks, and administrative burden.

Option B: Differentiated markup following industry best practice

The firm performs a separate analysis of its actual yard and logistics expenses:

  • Labour markup set at 34,00 % (site supervision, yard logistics, site safety, and performance variance): 240 000,00 CHF x 34,00 % = 81 600,00 CHF.
  • Materials markup set at 11,00 % (procurement admin, delivery checks, and carrying costs): 360 000,00 CHF x 11,00 % = 39 600,00 CHF.
  • Total allocated markups: 121 200,00 CHF.
  • Net tender price: 721 200,00 CHF.
  • Total price incl. 8,1 % Swiss VAT: 779 617,20 CHF.

The tender price differential under the split markup approach reaches 24 646,80 CHF incl. VAT (rounded to the nearest 5 centimes per Swiss commercial practice). This price reduction does not cut net profit: it cleans up material unit prices while boosting the labour risk cushion by 24 000,00 CHF, ensuring robust coverage of jobsite risks and improving the tender's chances of award under federal public procurement evaluation criteria.

Calls for tenders: free tools

Direct public procurement tenders, AIMP thresholds by canton, converting SIA 451 to Excel, quantity takeoff from an IFC model.

View tendering tools

Frequently asked questions

Why apply separate overhead markups to labour and supplies?

Labour entails far higher supervisory, tooling and administrative overheads than raw materials. Differentiating these mark-up rates protects your net margin: a uniform mark-up distorts actual direct costs, undermines award prospects under art. 29 LMP and weakens the performance of a works contract under art. 363 CO when unexpected events arise.

How do you justify these differentiated rates during a price verification under art. 38 LMP?

If questioned regarding an abnormally low price under art. 38 LMP, provide the analytical cost breakdown from your cost accounting. Demonstrate that logistics overheads on supplies are around 8,00 % compared with 25,00 % for labour, thereby justifying an advantageous bid without undercutting wages.

What is the impact of a differentiated mark-up in the event of termination under art. 377 CO?

If the client withdraws from the contract under art. 377 CO, full compensation covers incurred expenses and lost profit. A transparent breakdown of direct costs provides clear evidence of the exact share of profit margin and amortised overheads attributable to delivered supplies and hours worked.

Is the contractor liable for the quality of marked-up supplies under art. 365 CO?

Yes. Under art. 365 CO, the contractor is liable for the sound quality of the materials supplied. The risk mark-up on supplies specifically covers handling contingencies and warranty management costs, supplemented by the duty to notify the client immediately if any supplied material displays a defect.

How should risks and profits be passed on to change orders on a unit price basis?

Addenda must mirror the structure of the initial bill of quantities. Applying the original coefficients avoids disputes when determining the price under art. 374 CO. For additional works, maintaining differentiated rates ensures fair coverage of technical supervision without overcharging for incorporated raw materials.

Can underestimating overheads on wages breach art. 12 LMP?

Yes. Undervaluing labour mark-ups frequently leads to cutting social security contributions or degrading working conditions to maintain financial viability. Art. 12 LMP makes tender awards conditional on strict compliance with worker protection provisions and collective agreements applicable at the place of performance.

Mastering your coefficients to secure contract awards

Surgically calibrating differentiated mark-ups is your ultimate defence against margin erosion in Swiss tendering. To explore direct cost calculation further and make your bids rock-solid, consult our methodological guides:

Art Construction is an independent company: it is not affiliated with the SIA, CRB, SUVA, or KBOB. Referenced norms and standards point to publications from these bodies; only official versions are legally binding.