Table of contents
The 3 Major Site Risks
- Financial / Margin: Cumulative contractual penalties under art. 160 CO and art. 161 CO, reaching an illustrative magnitude of 5 % to 10 % of the contract award amount, coupled with acceleration surcharges of approximately 15 000,00 CHF to 45 000,00 CHF to offset unrealistic production rates.
- Legal / Joint Body / SUVA: Breaching shift work or Saturday work limits to catch up on schedule, leading to joint committee audits and enforcement risks from labour market authorities, without prejudice to art. 366 CO allowing the client to withdraw from the contract in the event of insurmountable delay.
- Administrative / Acceptance: Site management refusing contract extensions at intermediate milestones, forfeiture of compensation rights for site obstructions, and disputed completion dates under standard SIA 118.
When bidding on a call for tenders in Switzerland, a critical review of the master schedule directly determines the final profitability of the contract. For an SME owner or estimator, approving a schedule without verifying that production rates are realistic exposes the company to major financial losses as soon as work begins on the construction site. Contract documents frequently tie strict intermediate milestones to contractual penalties accrued per calendar day or working day. An unrealistic schedule imposed by the client or site management turns a seemingly balanced quote into a continuous dispute during execution.
This preliminary analysis requires cross-referencing the outputs assumed in the specifications against mobilisable resources, while accounting for weather constraints and trade sequencing according to standard SIA 118. Under art. 366 CO, if the contractor fails to commence the work on time, delays its execution, or falls so far behind schedule that timely completion is out of the question, the client may withdraw from the contract without waiting for the agreed deadline. Evaluating production rates, entering the necessary tender reservations, and legally circumscribing penalty clauses under the Swiss Code of Obligations (CO) is therefore essential before making any binding commitment.
Method for critically assessing the master schedule and installation rates
Pre-contractual analysis of the master schedule issued in a call for tenders requires a rigorous breakdown of the mandated rates. Contractors must check total phase durations against actual output ratios observed in French-speaking Switzerland and the capacity of their own site crews. Merely reading key milestone dates is not enough: you must extract the daily and weekly production rates required for each critical item in the bill of quantities, whether for wall formwork, MEP riser installation, or floating screeds.
In public procurement subject to the LMP or private procurement governed by the Code of Obligations (CO) and standard SIA 118, tender documents set out contractual milestones that site management often establishes without fully factoring in essential technological curing times. Scheduling must accommodate concrete curing periods, liquid waterproofing setting times, mortar hardening requirements, and pre-handover testing windows. Underestimating these technical curing windows leads to accepting a theoretical pace that is impossible to maintain using recognised good practice.
Checking output ratios and crew sizing
For each tender chapter, the estimator calculates the total workload in skilled labour hours and divides it by the number of working days allowed in the master schedule. This formula determines the average daily crew size required on the work front. If this theoretical calculation calls for a crew that exceeds the spatial capacity of the work area, the construction site will suffer an immediate drop in productivity due to trade congestion.
This review focuses on three decisive factors:
- Trade coactivity: the number of contractors operating simultaneously within the same building compartment, and congestion across vertical or horizontal access routes.
- Heavy plant rotation cycles: actual availability of the tower crane or builder's hoists, whose lifting cycles frequently become the main site bottleneck.
- Regional climatic conditions: factoring in frost or inclement weather windows, particularly on mountain construction sites or during earthworks and exterior structural work phases.
Legal qualification of delay damages and contractual penalties
Contract clauses regarding delay typically stipulate a financial deduction calculated per calendar day or working day of delay. Under Swiss law, art. 160 CO governs contractual penalties: where a penalty is stipulated for non-performance at the agreed time, the creditor may claim both performance of the obligation and payment of the penalty, unless there is an express waiver or the work is accepted without reservation. Art. 161 CO states that the contractual penalty is due even if the client has suffered no actual loss. If the actual loss exceeds the agreed penalty amount, the client can only claim additional damages by proving fault on the contractor's part.
Contractors responding to a call for tenders must determine whether specified dates represent ordinary target dates or strict deadlines triggering immediate default. Under art. 102 CO, the debtor falls into default upon the mere expiry of the agreed date when such date has been mutually determined. If the schedule designates intermediate milestones as strict deadlines carrying automatic contractual penalties, financial risk becomes a permanent threat from the moment site mobilisation begins. While art. 163 CO states that parties may freely determine the penalty amount and judges must reduce penalties they deem excessive, relying on court reduction after the fact remains unpredictable, slow, and costly. Contractual prevention during the tender stage remains your only effective protection.
Matrix for analysing deadline clauses in tender packages
The following table outlines the key checkpoints that an estimator or bid manager must review before finalising tender pricing:
| Contractual checkpoint | High-risk wording (to adjust or reserve) | Balanced and compliant wording | Financial and operational impact |
|---|---|---|---|
| Nature of time milestones | Contractual penalties applied to every intermediate milestone without a grace period. | Contractual penalties applicable exclusively to the final handover date of the works. | Risk of early margin erosion as early as structural work, with no opportunity to recover during finishing work. |
| Penalty calculation basis | Percentage calculated on the total contract sum for each day of delay. | Percentage applied solely to the value of the specific work phase affected by the partial delay. | Disproportionate accumulation of claimed damages for minor, residual work packages. |
| Overall penalty cap | Complete absence of any limiting clause on the total accumulation of contractual penalties. | Penalty cap expressly set at a fixed percentage of the total contract award amount. | Uncontrolled financial exposure that can exceed the company's entire profit margin. |
| Weather and site hazard management | Deadlines deemed fixed and firm, even in cases of severe frost or exceptional inclement weather. | Automatic extension of completion deadlines according to standard SIA 118 criteria. | Contractual inability to suspend work when weather conditions prevent technically sound execution. |
| Handover by preceding trades | Start date triggered on a fixed calendar date without prior sign-off on structural work readiness. | Lead time starting only once the substrate has been officially inspected and formally released. | Site crews blocked with standing time costs borne by the contractor without compensation. |
Common mistakes when assessing production rates and costing impacts
The most frequent mistake is calculating installation rates by dividing total quantities by the theoretical contract duration without factoring in the site ramp-up curve. During the opening weeks spent setting up the site and coordinating interfaces with site management, crews rarely exceed 50 % of nominal productivity. This unbudgeted initial delay subsequently forces the company to commit massive additional resources to meet the imposed milestone.
A second pitfall is overlooking shared logistical constraints. In tenders for complex urban buildings, crane availability and site laydown areas are severely restricted. If the tender has not priced independent hoisting equipment or dedicated off-hours shifts, reduced installation rates result in acceleration costs of around 18 500,00 CHF to 52 000,00 CHF, including 8,1 % VAT, to offset on-site disorganisation.
Finally, omitting formal written reservations from your tender represents critical negligence. Under art. 365 para. 3 CO, if any circumstance arises that compromises prompt performance, the contractor must inform the client immediately, under penalty of bearing the consequences. Failing to state at the tender stage that the mandated schedule conflicts with technical material requirements leaves the successful bidder liable for all costs arising from missed deadlines.
Illustrative practical cases (typical scenarios on Swiss construction sites)
The figures and scenarios below are illustrative examples designed to assist contractors in making informed technical and contractual decisions during tender preparation.
Scenario 1: Major refurbishment of an office complex in the canton of Vaud
As part of a call for tenders for the refurbishment of an office building in Lausanne, a drywall and painting contractor reviews the master schedule attached to the tender specifications. The project covers 4 200 square metres of partition walls and acoustic suspended ceilings. The master schedule allows a strict duration of 24 working days across all floors, with a contractual penalty clause under art. 160 CO set at a daily rate for every day past an intermediate floor milestone.
The estimator's analysis shows that meeting this schedule requires a permanent crew of 14 workers in spaces simultaneously occupied by electrical and plumbing contractors. The maximum workforce the work areas can accommodate without spatial congestion is estimated at 7 skilled workers. Faced with this physical impossibility, the company submits a technical note alongside its tender demonstrating floor over-occupancy, coupled with a qualification offering an adapted phased handover per half-floor. This measure averts the risk of cumulative penalties of around 35 000,00 CHF, including 8,1 % VAT, while safeguarding the acoustic quality required by standard SIA 181.
Scenario 2: Construction of a school complex in the canton of Geneva
A masonry and reinforced concrete contractor tenders for the structural work of a four-storey school building in Geneva. The master schedule schedules the fair-faced concrete slabs and walls in the middle of winter, with a mandatory 7-working-day cycle per complete floor. The contract specifications mandate fair-faced concrete requiring extended formwork retention times to prevent surface cracking during cold weather.
The technical manager realises that sticking to the 7-day cycle would require premature stripping of formwork, increasing the risk of defects under art. 368 CO and disputes during inspection of the works under art. 367 CO. The firm includes the dedicated costs for thermal enclosures and accelerated curing in its tender, representing an illustrative budget of 28 650,00 CHF, including 8,1 % VAT. By explicitly justifying this cost on the grounds of sound building practice and preventing structural delays, the company protects its operating margin and eliminates the risk of financial holdbacks by local site management.
Calls for tenders: free tools
Direct public procurement tenders, AIMP thresholds by canton, converting SIA 451 to Excel, quantity takeoff from an IFC model.
Frequently asked questions
How can a penalty clause deemed disproportionate in the call for tenders be challenged?
The contractor makes a written reservation before submission. Under art. 163 CO, the judge must reduce excessive penalties. For a public procurement contract, art. 29 LMP and art. 38 LMP require technical plausibility to be reviewed without price negotiations under art. 11 LMP.
Can the client combine specific performance and daily delay penalties?
Yes, under art. 160 CO, if the penalty was agreed for non-performance at the set time, the client may claim both performance and the agreed penalty, unless accepted without reservation. Art. 102 CO and standard SIA 118 govern formal notice when milestones are exceeded.
What does the contractor risk when faced with a clearly unrealistic schedule set out in the tender documents?
Under art. 365 CO, the contractor must promptly notify any circumstance that jeopardises proper execution, failing which they bear the consequences. In case of culpable delay, art. 366 CO allows the client to withdraw from the contract or entrust the works to a third party at the debtor's expense.
Does an extension of time entitle the contractor to additional financial compensation?
If the delay is caused by the client or a third party, standard SIA 118 grants an entitlement to an extension of time. Under art. 373 CO, a lump-sum price does not vary, except in extraordinary, unforeseeable circumstances that allow the court to adjust the contract sum for the works carried out.
How can the impact of excessive production rates on labour costs be established in a tender?
The cost estimator documents additional crew costs and complies with the working conditions required by art. 12 LMP. Under art. 374 CO, work not determined in advance is assessed based on the value of the work and actual expenditure, with an indicative quote in the region of 45 000,00 CHF.
Can night or weekend shifts imposed without compensation be refused?
The contractor may refuse if the tender omits the statutory exemptions. Art. 364 CO binds their duties to the standards of a diligent employee. In public procurement, art. 2 LMP and art. 41 LMP ensure a fair award that respects the protective framework without improperly imposed unilateral changes.
Thoroughly validating production rates and penalty clauses safeguards your company's profitability before contracts are finalised. To strengthen the methodological preparation of your call for tenders files in Switzerland, also explore our specialised analyses:
- Tender Package Analysis, Site Visit and Plan Take-Off
- Order of Priority of Tender Documents: Discrepancies Between Drawings and Quotes Under Standard SIA 118
- Mandatory Site Visit: Complete Checklist and Crane Access
- Quantity Check in a Tender: Discrepancies Between Drawings and Specifications, What Strategy?
