Table of contents
The 3 Major Site Risks
- Financial / Margin: Downgrading of the technical score leading to the direct loss of tendering costs, often in the range of 15 000,00 CHF to 50 000,00 CHF per file, and risk of hasty justifications requiring explanations under art. 38 LMP without any possibility of modifying the price in accordance with art. 11 LMP.
- Legal / Joint Body / SUVA: Rejection of the tender due to lack of plausibility regarding compliance with working conditions under art. 12 LMP, or disqualification under art. 44 LMP in the event of a major discrepancy between oral commitments and joint body declarations or occupational safety rules.
- Administrative / Acceptance: Permanent loss of the award in favour of a competitor scoring higher on the qualitative criteria of art. 29 LMP and art. 41 LMP, blocking all subsequent access to the works contract governed by art. 363 CO and standard SIA 118.
The oral hearing before the contracting authority represents the decisive step in Swiss public procurement subject to the LMP or the AIMP, under open or selective procedures. This stage is directly intended for site managers, SME leaders and French-speaking Swiss estimators tasked with defending the technical value of their tender before the client's experts. Far from being a mere commercial repetition of the technical proposal, the oral pitch serves to test the credibility of key personnel, the robustness of the operational organisation and the exact alignment of the methodology with local scheduling constraints.
Before an awarding commission bound by the strict principle of transparency and the prohibition on negotiating prices laid down in art. 11 LMP, speaking turns must adhere to a rigorous legal framework. Evaluators seek to verify whether the contractor has mastered its duties of diligence arising from art. 364 CO and can explain its technical choices in accordance with the evaluation criteria defined in art. 29 LMP. A methodical preparation of the presentation, aligned with the CAN descriptive quote and the actual phasing of the construction site, constitutes the only lever to secure the maximum mark and turn a written tender into a successful award decision.
Regulatory Framework and Precise Role of the Awarding Commission
The oral hearing before the awarding commission takes place within the strict framework established by the LMP and the AIMP to decide between tenderers pursuant to art. 29 LMP and art. 41 LMP. In accordance with the principles of art. 11 LMP, the contracting authority is required to act with transparency, objectivity and impartiality, while ensuring strict equal treatment among competitors. This imperative precludes any negotiation regarding price or basic services. Consequently, the oral pitch in no way constitutes a commercial bargaining session, but rather an adversarial evaluation meeting aimed at verifying the plausibility of the methods described in the technical proposal and the management of project risks.
When an awarding commission summons a company, it relies on the possibility of obtaining formal explanations pursuant to art. 38 LMP. The panel members, consisting of civil engineers, architects, client representatives and financial experts, seek to ensure that planned deadlines, construction site logistics and the organisation of human resources rest on realistic foundations. Any obvious discrepancy between written commitments and oral responses may lead to an unacceptable drop in the technical score, or even exclusion from the procedure under art. 44 LMP if participation conditions are not met or if the tenderer submits an offer tainted by major formal defects.
Verification of Qualification Criteria and Compliance with Labour Standards
During the hearing, the commission scrupulously examines the legal and social compliance of the proposed organisation. Pursuant to art. 12 LMP, a public contract may only be awarded to firms that comply with worker protection provisions, working conditions in force at the place of performance, equal pay, and the notification and authorisation duties prescribed by the LTN. The commission directly questions tenderers regarding the management of their workforces and any potential reliance on external partners.
Under art. 31 LMP, the involvement of subcontractors is permitted, but the characteristic performance must, in principle, be provided by the tenderer itself. The experts assess whether the general contractor or total contractor fully controls the chain of delegation. If subcontractors are involved in building, civil engineering or finishing work within the meaning of art. 5 ODét, the contracting firm must justify the exercise of its duty of diligence in accordance with art. 5 LDét and art. 8c ODét. During the hearing, the panel may demand proof of the organizational measures taken to collect joint-body certificates and verify compliance with net minimum wages as defined in art. 8a ODét, thereby ruling out any risk of unlawful wage undercutting.
Preparation Protocol and Conduct of the Hearing Interview
A successful hearing relies on a strictly operational team composition. Public clients in French-speaking Switzerland refuse to interview sales representatives who will not participate in the execution phase. The team presented must match the contractual organigram exactly: the project manager in charge of the mandate, the prospective site manager, and the construction methods or scheduling specialist. These key persons must embody technical competence and respond autonomously to the panel's questions without seeking approval from a superior.
The allotted time is systematically locked by the commission chair: typically 20 minutes of presentation followed by 20 to 30 minutes of technical questions. The pitch structure must get straight to the point, avoiding any corporate overview of the company:
- Critical understanding of the project's challenges and analysis of the municipal site's environmental constraints.
- Detailed construction methodology, accurate phasing and trade interface management in accordance with recognized trade standards.
- Site installation plan, traffic flows, neighbourhood nuisance management and materials removal.
- Organisation of internal quality control, adherence to contractual schedules and management of technical contingencies.
- Concrete measures for worker safety and health protection on the construction site.
Comparative Matrix of Oral Pitch Practices
The table below highlights the fundamental differences between a presentation penalised by the panel and one achieving the maximum mark during the technical evaluation:
| Criterion Evaluated by the Panel | Inappropriate Practice (Risk of Rejection) | Best Practice of Successful Awardee | Scored Impact on Evaluation Grid |
|---|---|---|---|
| Delegation composition | Exclusive presence of sales directors or estimators without field managers. | Active participation of the project manager and site foreman designated for the mandate. | Direct validation of managerial credibility and the competency criterion under art. 29 LMP. |
| Site constraints management | Theoretical presentation without mentioning actual access routes, slope or party walls. | Precise demonstration of turning radiuses, HGV access and footprint phasing. | Award of maximum score for technical value and construction site logistics. |
| Subcontracting oversight | Lack of clarity regarding subcontracted volume and unfamiliarity with applicable collective agreements. | Clear presentation of agreements, due diligence checks under art. 5 LDét and art. 8c ODét. | Full safeguard of social compliance and elimination of risks of joint-body disputes. |
| Responsiveness to contingencies | Unrealistic promises of catching up delays without substantiating installation rates. | Quantified fallback scenarios, crew adjustments and rigorous critical path analysis. | Positive assessment of tender plausibility and commitment reliability. |
| Cost and addenda management | Informal mention of subsequent financial adjustments to offset technical uncertainties. | Strict commitment to submitted unit prices, reminding the prohibition on negotiations under art. 11 LMP. | Scrupulous compliance with the legal framework, avoiding any disqualification for procedural violation. |
Frequent Mistakes Before the Commission and Financial Consequences
The gravest error observed during oral pitches lies in the direct contradiction between statements made orally and the content submitted in the written tender. When a company representative verbally alters a sequence or suggests an unrequested variant, the commission is obliged to record the irregularity. Pursuant to art. 11 LMP, no alteration to tender conditions is admissible after opening. This misstep invalidates the argument and instantly degrades the qualitative criterion score.
A second major mistake consists in underestimating the precision of questions regarding work rates. If a panel requests clarifications within the meaning of art. 38 LMP on an overall price that appears abnormally low for structural work or earthworks, the tenderer must prove on the spot that its labour ratios comply with the declared universally binding collective labour agreements under the LECCT. An inability to justify output rates leads the contracting authority to identify a lack of plausibility in the tender and may justify exclusion under art. 44 LMP.
The financial consequences of a failed oral hearing are substantial. The engineering and estimating costs incurred to respond to a complex public procurement call frequently range from 15 000,00 CHF to 45 000,00 CHF, including 8,1 % VAT. This dead loss is compounded by direct lost earnings on the financial year's projected turnover. Added to this are strategic repercussions: a poor impression left with professional consultants and municipal officials permanently harms the firm's reputation in its regional market.
Illustrative practical cases (typical scenarios on Swiss construction sites)
The figures and contexts described below are illustrative examples designed to guide tender teams in preparing their oral pitch.
Typical Scenario 1: Oral Pitch for the Construction of a Municipal School (Canton of Vaud)
As part of an open call for tenders for the structural work of a school complex valued at 4 850 000,00 CHF inclusive of all taxes, a Vaud general contractor is summoned by the municipal technical committee. The panel wishes to examine protection measures for neighbouring schoolchildren and the management of noise nuisances during concreting phases.
The team sent comprises the branch manager and the prospective site manager. Answering the experts' questions, the site manager details the logistics plan: installation of a two-metre-high opaque hoarding, an absolute ban on lorry movements during school arrival and dismissal times, and the use of a damped concrete skip. By demonstrating perfect coordination with the building control authority and guaranteeing strict compliance with standard SIA 118 requirements, the firm earns a score of 4,8 out of 5 for the technical value criterion, allowing it to win the award against competitors whose financial offer was nevertheless 35 000,00 CHF lower.
Typical Scenario 2: Methodological Justification for Underground Utilities (Canton of Valais)
In a selective procedure concerning the replacement of main pipelines in a dense urban environment quoted at 1 620 000,00 CHF including VAT, the public client summons the three finalist firms for a 45-minute hearing. The main challenge lies in continuously maintaining road traffic and guaranteeing access to neighbouring businesses.
One bidder makes the mistake of sending their sales manager, who is unable to detail the thickness of the trench shoring or the backfilling rates. In contrast, the successful firm brings in its methods engineer alongside the roadworks foreman. Together, they present a phasing plan based on 25-metre sections, incorporating temporary steel bridging designed to support emergency vehicles. By answering safety questions precisely and proving their personnel comply fully with art. 12 LMP, they completely reassure the evaluation panel and secure the contract without a single technical objection.
Calls for tenders: free tools
Direct public procurement tenders, AIMP thresholds by canton, converting SIA 451 to Excel, quantity takeoff from an IFC model.
Frequently asked questions
Can unit prices be renegotiated during the oral interview?
No, art. 11 LMP strictly prohibits entering into price negotiations in public procurement. The interview serves solely to clarify the technical merit or methodology. Any revised price proposal, even an illustrative discount of 15 000,00 CHF, leads to the bid being rejected for procedural irregularity.
Is the presence of the managing director mandatory before the panel?
The contracting authority calls primarily upon the key individuals identified in the contractual organisational chart. Under art. 364 CO, the contractor is liable for the personal management of the works. Having the site manager and the foreman speak directly, rather than a commercial executive, reassures the panel regarding genuine operational control.
How should you respond to a question regarding an abnormally low bid?
Pursuant to art. 38 LMP, the contracting authority must request relevant information to verify whether the figures are plausible. The firm must detail its production rates, plant yields, or specific, quantified optimisation processes, demonstrating that it fully complies with the specifications without compromising safety.
Can a member of a consortium be absent from the presentation?
An absence weakens the technical credibility of the consortium. Under art. 31 LMP, joint bidding is permitted, but responsibility for the core work must be clearly accounted for. Each key partner, particularly the civil engineering or finishing work specialist, must present their own organisation and coordination measures in person.
What supplementary documents can be submitted to the contracting authority during the meeting?
No document modifying the initial bid is admissible, as this would breach the principle of equal treatment. Art. 11 LMP requires a transparent and objective procedure. Only projected explanatory visual aids or summary handouts that faithfully reproduce elements of the submitted technical memo are accepted by the evaluation panel.
Can the panel penalise a lack of CLA compliance during the oral hearing?
Absolutely. Under art. 12 LMP, a public contract is awarded only to bidders who comply with applicable working conditions. If the interview exposes undeclared subcontracting or wages that do not meet collective labour agreements declared generally binding under the LECCT, the contracting authority immediately excludes the firm from the award procedure.
Mastering the oral interview before the evaluation panel demands rigorous preparation, strictly aligned with the assessment criteria of the written submission and Swiss public procurement regulations. To strengthen your technical and documentary groundwork ahead of the presentation, explore our specialised resources:
- Winning Technical Proposal, Human Resources, Safety, and KBOB Life-Cycle Assessment
- Structuring a Method Statement to Score Top Marks: What the Panel Evaluates First
- Site Organisational Chart, Key Personnel CVs and Apprentice Bonus (SEFRI)
- Justifying Phasing in Occupied Buildings: Supporting Sketches and 2D/3D Plans
