Table of contents
The 3 Major Site Risks
- Financial / Margin: Taking on complex logistical constraints or penalty clauses unnoticed during pricing. The accumulation of a contractual penalty under art. 160 CO and unexpected access costs leads to gross margin erosion of around 4 % to 12 % of the bid amount if the contract for work (art. 363 CO) is signed at a lump-sum price (art. 373 CO).
- Legal / Joint Body / SUVA: Improper contractual transfer of hygiene, waste disposal, or safety coordination obligations onto the tenderer without bill-of-quantities remuneration, triggering joint-body sanctions or SUVA interventions if first-aid facilities are lacking on the site.
- Administrative / Acceptance: Tacit acceptance of derogatory clauses altering the order of precedence of contract documents set by standard SIA 118, restricting the contractor's claim rights during joint quantity surveys or improperly shifting dimensional tolerance thresholds during the inspection of the works.
In Swiss tendering practice, CAN chapter 102 covering the special conditions of the works is the most decisive contract document for a firm's future profitability. This document sets the project-specific ground rules: available site boundaries, authorised working hours, logistical organization, earthworks disposal, and billing procedures. Estimators and SME executives frequently make the mistake of focusing their analysis solely on production-related technical chapters, treating CAN 102 as a routine administrative formality. Yet it is precisely within these preliminary articles that clients insert substantial derogations from standard SIA 118 or coordination requirements not quantified in the paid line items.
A methodical review of these special conditions before submitting your tender helps uncover disproportionate risk transfers. Once a bid is handed in without formal written reservations, the provisions of CAN 102 bind the successful bidder and void any subsequent financial claims arising from access difficulties or schedule interferences. To protect their operating margins, tenderers must systematically identify common pitfalls surrounding contractual penalties, strict deadlines, and shared installation costs.
Methodical analysis of CAN 102 and contractual hierarchy
During the award phase in public or private procurement, catalogue CAN 102 gathers all special conditions specific to the works. This document supplements, refines, or amends standard SIA 118 as well as the general rules of the Swiss Building Documentation Centre (CRB). Within the framework of a contract for work governed by art. 363 CO, the derogations stipulated in CAN 102 generally take precedence over general normative provisions. A superficial reading exposes the contractor to accepting unpriced risk transfers when lodging the bid.
The contracting authority assesses submissions against the award criteria defined under art. 29 LMP, which include price, schedule, and the plausibility of the tender. When the tender dossier stipulates remuneration on a lump-sum price basis within the meaning of art. 373 CO, the total amount covers all constraints described in CAN 102. The contractor cannot claim any supplementary compensation for organizational hurdles explicitly noted in this document, even if they entail altered work tempos or dedicated lifting equipment.
Reviewing derogatory clauses and managing construction site risks
Scrutinizing CAN chapter 102 requires a line-by-line check across six strategic areas that directly alter cost-price calculations:
- Construction site boundaries and access: Clearance limitations on road routes, load limits on access bridges, or requirements to deliver using low-tonnage vehicles must be factored into the transport unit price. The contractor procures the necessary tools and equipment at its own expense under art. 364 CO, unless agreed otherwise.
- Working hours and nuisances: Working windows restricted by the municipality often require backup crews. If the tender specification demands night or Saturday operations, wage supplements mandated by the declared generally binding collective labour agreement pursuant to art. 1 LECCT must be built into the rate breakdowns.
- Waste disposal and excavation materials: Managing contaminated soil or unsorted demolition rubble can sharply inflate disposal facility invoices. Under art. 365 CO, if the land designated by the client is defective or presents unforeseen obstacles, the contractor must inform the client immediately to safeguard its rights.
- Coordination and shared installations: Having to share a crane or a temporary electrical network creates waiting times that undermine labour productivity.
- Protective measures and safety: Supplying and maintaining fences, walkways, or safety nets often falls to the first trade on site without separate compensation if CAN 102 stipulates so.
- Quantity surveying methods and advance payments: Billing clauses that depart from standard SIA 118 sometimes restrict payments for site-delivered materials, altering the company's cash flow management.
Comparison table: standard clauses vs high-risk derogations
The table below sets out the clauses most frequently encountered in CAN 102, the variances compared to the statutory framework of the Code of Obligations (CO) and standard SIA 118, as well as essential corrective actions prior to submitting the tender.
| CAN 102 domain | Standard framework (standard SIA 118 / CO) | Frequent CAN 102 derogation | Financial and legal impact | Corrective pricing action |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Late penalties | Compensation upon proof of actual damage suffered by the client. | Fixed contractual penalty per calendar day without prior formal notice. | Art. 160 CO permits agreed penalties; the amount can be reduced by a judge under art. 163 CO in cases of clear excess. | Build safety margins into the critical path of the provisional schedule. |
| Soil conditions and excavation | Immediate notification of defective ground (art. 365 CO) and price adjustment. | Geotechnical risk fully shifted to the contractor without site investigation logs provided. | Excavation stoppage and disposal cost overruns non-recoverable on a lump-sum price basis (art. 373 CO). | State an explicit reservation or submit a formal query via simap.ch. |
| Site power and water | Utility consumption costs shared across trades or borne by the client. | Site connections and overall consumption charged exclusively to the structural work contractor. | Unforeseen electricity and technical connection expenses reaching several thousand francs. | Include a dedicated contingency item in the site setup cost calculations. |
| Waste management | Each contractor manages and empties its own skips and installation residues. | Provision and emptying of collective skips placed under the responsibility of the main contractor. | Uncontrolled costs resulting from fly-tipping by other trades on the site. | Budget a site security guard or restrict skip access using padlocks. |
| Acceptance of the works | Joint inspection with a 60-day notification period for immovable structures (art. 367 CO). | Final acceptance deferred until the complete conclusion of all construction trades. | Undue extension of liability and delayed release of retention guarantees. | Demand phased acceptance for completed and usable portions of the works. |
Common interpretation mistakes and financial impacts
The first mistake lies in overlooking local traffic access constraints imposed by the local authority. For example, a vehicle ban on trucks exceeding 18 tonnes requires split deliveries of concrete or precast elements. For a volume of 600 cubic metres, this division requires extra round trips representing an additional haulage and pumping cost of around 8 500,00 CHF to 14 000,00 CHF.
A second error involves the unilateral shift of road maintenance costs, such as daily public roadway cleaning or setting up a truck wheel-washing facility. When this obligation is featured in CAN 102 as an unitemised lump-sum item, the contractor shoulders the complete equipment and labour cost. Failing to price this obligation can represent an unbudgeted charge of roughly 12 000,00 CHF to 25 000,00 CHF on a medium-sized earthworks site.
Lastly, neglecting contractual penalty clauses directly undermines overall profitability. Pursuant to art. 161 CO, the contractual penalty is due even if the client cannot prove direct economic harm. If CAN 102 sets a delay penalty of 1 000,00 CHF per working day, a two-week schedule slippage instantly absorbs 15 000,00 CHF of operating profit.
Illustrative practical cases (typical scenarios on Swiss construction sites)
The following figures are illustrative examples designed to guide tenderers through their review.
Scenario 1: Earthworks and remediation in the Canton of Vaud
A firm tenders for the construction of a school complex involving an excavation volume of 4 500 cubic metres. The operations team consists of eight production workers. CAN chapter 102 specifies that spoil must be hauled to a designated certified facility located 28 kilometres away, with no intermediate storage permitted on the plot.
The estimator had initially budgeted for a local disposal facility 6 kilometres away. The logistical restriction requires an extra 45 minutes of driving time per trip. Factoring in the CAN 102 requirements, the haulage surcharges and weighbridge fees were revised upwards to 34 250,50 CHF all taxes included (including 8,1 % Swiss VAT). Adjusting the unit price before tender submission preserved the project's financial balance without triggering later disputes.
Scenario 2: Dense urban refurbishment in the Canton of Geneva
An open-procedure call for tenders under art. 18 LMP involves the thermal retrofit of an administrative building while retaining continuous tenant occupancy. The deployed workforce includes six finishing work operatives. CAN 102 prohibits any noise emissions exceeding standard thresholds between 11:30 and 14:00 and restricts rubble removal via external hoists exclusively to 06:30 to 08:00.
The contractor evaluated the productivity loss caused by these fragmented work windows, estimated at an 18 % reduction in output for partition wall and ceiling installations. The tender total was adjusted by including extra labour costs of 19 800,00 CHF (8,1 % VAT included) and extended hoist rental for 4 350,00 CHF. The bid was deemed the most advantageous under art. 41 LMP thanks to a technical proposal proving full command of the site's constraints.
Calls for tenders: free tools
Direct public procurement tenders, AIMP thresholds by canton, converting SIA 451 to Excel, quantity takeoff from an IFC model.
Frequently asked questions
How do you challenge an unfair clause inserted into CAN 102 during a call for tenders?
The tenderer formulates written reservations during the official question period or requests a formal clarification. In public procurement governed by the LMP, any evident contradiction or disproportionate demand must be flagged before the tender is submitted, otherwise the right to appeal at a later stage is forfeited.
Can a daily delay penalty be reduced if it appears excessive?
Yes. The amount of a contractual penalty is freely agreed under art. 163 CO, but a civil court judge must reduce excessive penalties. A contractor facing an unreasonable deduction, such as 1 080,00 CHF per working day for a minor delay causing no actual harm, can legally challenge its amount in court.
Which document takes precedence if CAN 102 and standard SIA 118 contradict each other?
The agreed contractual hierarchy prevails. As a general rule, the project-specific special conditions take precedence over the general conditions. The vigilant contractor checks the order of priority set out in the contract for work and services, as the client frequently departs from it to transfer coordination constraints not provided for by standard SIA 118.
Can the client impose lump-sum spoil removal without a soil survey?
Under art. 365 CO, the contractor must immediately notify any ground defects that jeopardise punctual performance. A blind lump sum covering unforeseeable contaminated soil justifies a contractual adjustment pursuant to art. 373 CO, allowing the court to grant a price increase or termination if extraordinary circumstances arise.
What occupational safety obligations fall upon the tenderer under special conditions?
The contractor incorporates all protective measures required by the OTConst and the Labour Act. If the project-specific special conditions impose specific collective protective equipment not paid under separate items, the firm must break down these costs—running into thousands of francs—or bear these expenses on its own.
Can a five-year warranty period be shortened in the contract for work and services?
No. Under art. 371 CO, the five-year limitation period for defects in an immovable work cannot be amended to the detriment of the client. Any attempt at a contractual derogation reducing this statutory term to the disadvantage of the purchaser or client remains strictly invalid.
A thorough mastery of the project-specific special conditions and CAN 102 chapters constitutes the contractor's primary financial bulwark against the unfair transfer of administrative risks. Before making any commitment on a public or private tender in Switzerland, methodically reviewing the contractual clauses and recording formal reservations prevents disputes during execution. To secure your pricing and strengthen your call for tenders submissions, delve deeper into Swiss technical and contractual standards:
