Skip to content
Art ConstructionTenders
Practical guide

Linking Workforce, Quantities, and Critical Path: The Tender Gantt Chart

Link bills of quantities, team outputs and critical path on your Swiss tender Gantt. Analysis of deadlines, margins and SIA 118 and LMP compliance.

Table of contents
The 3 Major Site Risks
  1. Financial / Margin: A critical path misaligned with actual output rates leads to unplanned acceleration costs or delay damages that can erode gross margins by around 8% to 15% of the award amount (art. 364 CO).
  2. Legal / Joint Body / SUVA: Underestimating the workforce needed to meet milestones forces unauthorised overtime or undeclared labour, risking exclusion from the procedure (art. 44 LMP) or administrative penalties (art. 9 LDét).
  3. Administrative / Acceptance: A glaring mismatch between volumes and installation rates leads to the tender being rejected for lack of plausibility during tender evaluation (art. 38 LMP) or to the early enforcement of measures for delay in performance under art. 366 CO.

When responding to public and private calls for tenders in Switzerland, the provisional construction schedule is far more than a simple sequence of Gantt bars. For company executives, estimators, and tender managers, the rigorous integration of the Gantt chart within the technical submission provides mathematical proof of the tender's feasibility. The contracting authority evaluates the technical merit and plausibility of the schedule in accordance with art. 29 LMP. Systematically linking bill of quantities figures, hourly team outputs, and the critical path ensures realistic scheduling, protecting both your financial margin and your credibility as a bidder.

Matching human resources with installation rates determines the success of the preparation phase. Submitting a critical path backed by production ratios consistent with trade practice and SIA 118 requirements proves that contractual milestones will be met without compromising safety. Compliance with the criteria laid down in art. 12 LMP regarding working conditions and the transparency provided during tender evaluation under art. 38 LMP are decisive assets for winning contracts before increasingly demanding award committees.

Method for aligning CAN bill of quantities, installation rates, and critical path

Developing a robust provisional schedule for a tender relies on an unbroken logical chain between the bill of quantities, the operating capacity of the teams, and time-sequencing constraints. Tender evaluation carried out under art. 38 LMP enables the contracting authority to verify the consistency of the figures and question the bidder when the planned resources appear disproportionate to the stated deadlines. To satisfy the award criteria of art. 29 LMP, notably tender plausibility and technical merit, the work breakdown must follow a transparent arithmetic formula.

The gross operational duration of each activity is calculated by dividing the total work quantities by the average unit production time, then dividing this figure by the size of the deployed team and the number of daily working hours. The standard formula is as follows: Duration (working days) = [Work quantity (CAN units) × Hours ratio per unit] / [Assigned workforce (workers) × Actual hours per day]. This approach ensures compliance with the contractor's obligations to supply the resources necessary for timely execution, pursuant to art. 364 CO.

Once the durations of each line item are established, the critical path is identified by analysing strict technical dependencies, drying times prescribed by good building practice, and physical interface points between trades. On a contractual level, mutually agreed dates govern debtor default in accordance with art. 102 CO, justifying meticulous attention to links with zero float.

Comparative table of scheduling methods in the tendering phase

The choice of scheduling method directly influences the score awarded by the evaluation committee when assessing the technical submission. Methods used in the Swiss market present varying degrees of rigor:

Scheduling methodDirect link between quantities and ratesVisibility of the critical pathPlausibility under art. 29 LMPRobustness against art. 366 CORecommended use in tenders
Simplified visual Gantt (static bars)None (arbitrary durations)Zero (no dynamic logical links)Low (deemed inconclusive)Vulnerable in the event of disputeTo be avoided in public procurement
Gantt linked to CAN bill of quantitiesDirect (hours-to-units ratio)Explicit (finish-to-start links identified)High (arithmetic demonstration)Secures initial commitmentsRecommended standard (finishing work/structural work)
Time-Chainage diagram (Time-Location)Direct per physical sectionStrong on linear bottlenecksVery high for infrastructure construction sitesHigh protection against default risksInfrastructure, tunnels, pipe networks
Scheduling by average ratiosPartial (aggregated by chapter)Medium (overall float estimated)Medium (depends on level of detail)Moderate protection against initial delaysFeasibility studies and preliminary drafts
Levelled multi-team schedulingDirect with peak smoothingComplete (clear free and total float)Optimal (full workforce justification)Maximum (robust defense of deadlines)Complex structures, tight deadlines

Frequent scheduling mistakes and their financial consequences

A common mistake involves concealing concrete curing or screed drying times to force the overall schedule to fit the contracting authority's desired completion date. Such technical negligence exposes the contractor to the remedies of art. 366 CO: the client may set a reasonable deadline to rectify the situation when it becomes clear that the work will be defective or delayed through the contractor's fault.

A second recurring error lies in overestimating the number of workers deployed simultaneously within a confined workspace. Overcrowding leads to productivity drops of up to 20% to 35% compared to theoretical output. This phenomenon results in unforeseen additional labour costs that can range from around 45 000,00 CHF to 90 000,00 CHF on a standard structural work package.

Finally, breaches of equal treatment and a lack of technical transparency leave bidders open to sanctions under public procurement law. Pursuant to art. 44 LMP, the contracting authority may exclude a tenderer from the procedure, notably if they submit an offer with major formal defects or provide false information regarding their workforce or production rates.

Illustrative practical cases (typical scenarios on Swiss construction sites)

The figures presented in the following scenarios are illustrative examples intended to model the calculation framework of a compliant tender.

Typical Scenario 1: Structural work for a school complex in the canton of Vaud

Within an open public call for tenders for the construction of a school facility (tender amount of around 4 200 000,00 CHF, including 8,1% VAT), the bidding firm must schedule the execution of 1 850 m³ of in-situ reinforced concrete and 4 200 m² of floor slabs. The overall deadline set for the building shell is 24 working weeks.

The estimator sets an average execution ratio of 1,10 hours per square metre of slab formwork and pouring, and 3,20 hours per cubic metre of structural walls. The total productive labour required amounts to 10 540 productive hours. Based on a 40-hour working week of actual site time per operative, steady progress requires a core team of 11 operatives to maintain the pace. The calculations show that the critical path runs exclusively through the central vertical core and the installation of the upper-floor slabs.

The justification provided in the technical submission details the cycle times for one tower crane and two complete sets of steel wall shutters. By factoring in a standard curing period of 21 days before the final strike of props on main spans, the tender demonstrates that the schedule preserves a total float of 8 working days prior to handover, eliminating the risk of early termination or damages under art. 366 CO.

Typical Scenario 2: Major commercial refurbishment in the canton of Geneva

A contractor tenders for a building services and finishing work package including the refurbishment of modular partitions (3 600 m²) and raised access flooring (2 400 m²), for an estimated sum of around 1 650 000,00 CHF, including 8,1% VAT. The contractual phasing imposes 4 successive phases of 18 working days each, with daily delay damages governed by art. 160 CO.

The initial mistake avoided by the tender manager was planning for a mobile crew of 4 installers working linearly. The bill of quantities calculation indicated a requirement of 2 160 hours for partitions (ratio of 0,60 h/m²) and 960 hours for flooring (ratio of 0,40 h/m²), amounting to 780 hours per phase. A 4-person crew could only deliver 576 hours over 18 days, creating a structural shortfall of 204 hours per phase.

The bidder adjusts the schedule by mobilising 6 full-time installers supported by a dedicated logistics storeman for night-time material deliveries. Critical path analysis highlights the strict dependency between installing plenum services and locking down the raised floor panels. The Gantt chart appended to the tender clearly illustrates this intermediate milestone on day 11 of each phase, providing the proof of tender plausibility required by art. 29 LMP and preventing disputes during tender evaluation by site management.

Calls for tenders: free tools

Direct public procurement tenders, AIMP thresholds by canton, converting SIA 451 to Excel, quantity takeoff from an IFC model.

View tendering tools

Frequently asked questions

How do you prove the feasibility of a tight critical path in a public tender?

To convince the contracting authority under art. 29 LMP, submit a Gantt chart tied to the CAN bill of quantities. Include a calculation sheet proving that daily outputs are backed by realistic labour ratios, with identifiable free float for weather delays.

Can the contracting authority reject a tender with an unrealistic schedule?

Yes. Under art. 38 LMP, the contracting authority assesses the technical plausibility of the tender. If it notes an obvious underestimation of the workforce required to meet contractual deadlines, it may request justifications and disqualify the bidder under art. 44 LMP.

What are the contractual implications of agreed milestones in a tender?

When completion dates are agreed upon, art. 102 CO provides that the debtor is in default upon the simple expiration of the set date. The client can then enforce the contractual penalty clauses stipulated in the contract.

How should subcontractors be integrated into the schedule's critical path?

Art. 31 LMP permits the use of subcontractors. Their operational capacity must align with the timing of critical activities. The main contractor remains responsible for deadlines and must ensure compliance with local working conditions under art. 12 LMP.

What contingency should be budgeted for accelerated work rates in a tender?

On a structural work package valued at around 1 200 000,00 CHF including 8,1% VAT, allocate a contingency margin for shift work. Art. 373 CO requires anticipating these logistical surcharges; otherwise, you will have to bear all unexpected additional costs yourself.

How does the awarded tender schedule bind the contractor after contract signing?

Pursuant to art. 364 CO, the contractor is liable for the proper execution of the works. Once the works contract is signed (art. 363 CO), the approved schedule becomes contractually binding, and SIA 118 regulates any time extension claims.

The rigorous correlation between quantities, labour resources and the critical path forms the foundation of a credible and competitive bid. By securing your daily output rates right from the tender phase, you demonstrate complete operational control while protecting your firm's margin against delay penalties. To delve deeper into each technical and methodological component of your call for tenders submission in Switzerland, explore the following specialised resources:

Art Construction is an independent company: it is not affiliated with the SIA, CRB, SUVA, or KBOB. Referenced norms and standards point to publications from these bodies; only official versions are legally binding.