Table of contents
The 3 Major Site Risks
- Financial / Margin: Cumulative billing error or omission of contractual retention money, leading to unrecoverable overpayments of around 5 % to 10 % of the contract amount in the event of contractor bankruptcy, contrary to the phased payment terms under art. 372 CO and the price terms agreed under art. 373 CO.
- Legal / Joint Body / SUVA: Payment freeze on a subcontractor's progress statement triggering an application for the provisional registration of a statutory mortgage lien of craftsmen and contractors against the property under art. 837 CC and art. 839 CC, paralysing bank construction loans prior to any conciliation.
- Administrative / Handover: Confusion between releasing retention money on monthly progress statements and issuing a joint and several bank guarantee under art. 492 CO, delaying the preparation of the final account and the administrative closure required by standard SIA 118.
Site management, site supervisors, and the client ensure rigorous administrative and financial tracking of interim statements on Swiss construction sites. When processing a monthly progress statement, the structured verification of executed quantity surveys, the deduction of contractual retention money, and the inclusion of index variations under KBOB methods determine the financial stability of the project. Flawed assessment exposes the project to unjustified advance disbursements or deadlocking disputes.
This guide outlines technical cost-allocation protocols for building professionals in French-speaking Switzerland. It details the systematic handling of retention money under standard SIA 118, its replacement by an equivalent guarantee pursuant to the Code of Obligations, and parametric cost increase calculation rules. For initial estimating and tender response preparation, refer to the dedicated Soumissions tools, while unit prices tables fall under the Indice ACIP.
Calculation mechanics for monthly advance payments and order of deductions
Site management follows a strict step-by-step review protocol upon receiving a monthly statement. An advance payment reflects the actual value of work performed on the construction site up to the cut-off date, in accordance with the works contract defined in art. 363 CO and payment terms under art. 372 CO. The valuation is based on jointly agreed quantity surveys of installed quantities or the percentage of completion of bill-of-quantities items. The arithmetical sequence of standard deductions determines the tax and financial validity of the payment certificate issued to the client.
The calculation begins with the gross cumulative amount of work executed in CHF, including main bill items and approved addenda. From this gross subtotal, site management first deducts the contractual rebate agreed at tender award. Contractual retention money under standard SIA 118 is then deducted from this net work amount. Only after these deductions are applied is any prompt payment discount calculated on the net payable share, before adding Swiss VAT at the standard rate of 8,1 %. Inverting the order of rebate, retention, and VAT distorts the taxable base and generates substantial cumulative discrepancies.
Retention money under standard SIA 118: 10% and 5% thresholds and substitution
Standard SIA 118 governs the retention withheld by the client from advance payment statements to guarantee proper execution of the works until joint inspection. By convention, this retention equals 10 % of the verified work value on each interim statement. Once the cumulative retention reaches the contractual cap, typically set at 5 % of the total contract price, no further retention money is deducted from subsequent advance payments unless expressly agreed otherwise.
Contractors may request the release of this retention money by submitting equivalent security. Under the provisions of art. 492 CO governing guarantees, craftsmen and contractors may substitute a joint and several guarantee issued by a Swiss bank or an insurance company established in Switzerland for the interim retention. This guarantee protects the client regarding the rectification of any defects noted during site inspection or governed by art. 367 CO and art. 368 CO. Under art. 371 CO, the limitation period for client defect rights in immovable works is five years against the contractor, architect, or engineer, a period that cannot be shortened to the detriment of the client.
Upon receipt of a compliant deed of guarantee, site management releases the withheld funds or ceases deducting the 10 % retention on subsequent advance payments. In the absence of a guarantee, the retained amount is reconciled in the final account, serving as a performance bond until the contractor has fully discharged all contractual obligations.
Price adjustment under the KBOB methodology
In works contracts governed by unit prices or indexation clauses, cost adjustments reflect movements in official construction indices. The Federal Coordination Commission for Construction and Property Services KBOB publishes specific methodological recommendations to calculate cost increases or decreases. Two primary methods are recognised on the Swiss market: the parametric method (price variation formula weighting material, wage, and energy coefficients) and the documentary evidence method (direct auditing of basic material invoices).
Where works are agreed at a fixed price or lump sum under art. 373 CO, the contractor must complete the work for the agreed sum and cannot claim an increase, barring extraordinary, unforeseeable circumstances warranting judicial review under art. 373 para. 2 CO. Conversely, if the contract specifies KBOB indexing, site management calculates the applicable price variation monthly or quarterly on the value of work executed over the reference period. Validated price variations appear as a distinct line item on the advance payment certificate, subject to Swiss VAT at 8,1 %.
Comparative table of advance payment statement components
| Statement line item | Contractual / standard basis | Basis of calculation | Impact on VAT (8,1 %) | Point of vigilance for site management |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Gross work statement | Standard SIA 118 and art. 363 CO | Cumulative joint quantity surveys | Forms the gross taxable base | Verify strict alignment with quote items and addenda |
| Contractual rebate | Special tender conditions | Percentage applied to the gross statement | Directly reduces the taxable base | Apply before calculating retention or guarantees |
| Retention money (10 % then max 5 %) | Standard SIA 118 | Net amount after rebate | Does not alter tax liability on the service | Check cap of 5 % on the total contract amount |
| KBOB price adjustment | KBOB contractual clauses | Work executed in the period according to indices | Added to the taxable base (8,1 % VAT) | Verify the reference period and official published index |
| Early payment discount | Works contract and art. 1 CO | Net amount payable within the stipulated period | Adjusts the actual consideration received | Contingent on payment strictly within the agreed deadline |
Common financial verification errors and site consequences
A first common pitfall is calculating retention money on the gross amount including VAT. Retention must be deducted from the net amount excluding tax, with VAT applied to total work performed to comply with Swiss tax regulations. This error distorts accounting ledgers and triggers tax adjustments of several thousand CHF on interim structural work statements.
A second mistake is failing to cap the retention. Continuing to withhold 10 % from each advance payment beyond the contractual threshold of 5 % of the total contract price constitutes unlawful withholding of funds. The contractor is then entitled to put the client in default under art. 102 CO, accruing default interest at 5 % per annum under art. 104 CO. Such liquidity freezes disrupt material procurement and workforce scheduling.
A third failure involves applying KBOB indexation without first deducting advance payments already settled in earlier periods. Calculating price adjustments on cumulative totals since site commencement rather than restricting the formula to work performed in the reporting month leads to double indexation. This unjustified surcharge can generate unwarranted excesses of 15 000 CHF to 50 000 CHF on a civil engineering site.
Illustrative practical cases (typical scenarios on Swiss construction sites)
The figures below are illustrative examples constructed for technical analysis and do not reflect any real project.
Typical scenario 1: Administrative structural work in the canton of Vaud
On an administrative building project in the canton of Vaud, the total contractor contract amounts to 4 000 000 CHF excluding VAT, incorporating standard SIA 118 and KBOB recommendations. The general contractor maintains an average site crew of 18 workers. In the fifth month of work, the contractor submits a gross monthly advance payment of 600 000 CHF for concreting operations, bringing the cumulative gross total to 2 200 000 CHF. The contract stipulates a 2 % rebate and 10 % retention money capped at 5 % of the total award, setting the maximum retention ceiling at 200 000 CHF (5 % of 4 000 000 CHF).
Site management applies the 2 % rebate to the gross amount of 600 000 CHF, bringing the net monthly work to 588 000 CHF. The nominal 10 % retention would equal 58 800 CHF. However, cumulative deductions over the first four advance payments already total 160 000 CHF. Applying the full 58 800 CHF would reach 218 800 CHF, exceeding the contractual cap of 200 000 CHF. Site management adjusts the retention deduction to exactly 40 000 CHF, capping deductions at the agreed limit. The net advance payment excluding tax of 548 000 CHF is then adjusted for monthly KBOB indexation (calculated at 4 200 CHF via the parametric method) and increased by Swiss VAT at 8,1 %, safeguarding both parties' statutory rights under art. 372 CO.
Typical scenario 2: Major refurbishment and security substitution in the canton of Geneva
In the canton of Geneva, the conversion of a housing complex involving 8 craftsmen is executed under an external joinery contract for 500 000 CHF excluding VAT, governed by standard SIA 118. The contractor submits its third monthly advance payment for a cumulative total of 300 000 CHF. Site management had withheld a 10 % retention on previous advance payments, accumulating a balance of 20 000 CHF. Alongside its progress statement, the contractor provides a joint and several guarantee certificate issued by a Swiss bank for 25 000 CHF (matching the 5 % cap on the total contract value).
In accordance with art. 492 CO and the substitution provisions of standard SIA 118, site management confirms the validity of the financial instrument. It immediately stops further retention deductions on the current 100 000 CHF advance payment and releases the 20 000 CHF previously withheld back to the contractor. This transfer restores working capital to the craftsman without compromising the financial security of the client, as any remedial works or defects remain fully secured by the deed of guarantee until the expiry of the limitation period under art. 371 CO.
Contracts and SIA 118: free tools
Advance payments and retentions, surety bonds, price escalations, daywork reports, subcontractor monitoring.
Frequently asked questions
What retention money rate applies to monthly statements under standard SIA 118?
Retention money stands at 10% on each monthly advance payment statement until the total retained reaches 5% of the total cost of the works. For a gross statement of 100 000 CHF, the initial deduction is 10 000 CHF. It secures compliant execution and covers any defects found.
How can the 5% retention money be released upon acceptance of the works?
Upon acceptance, the contractor may replace this financial deduction with an equivalent bank or insurance surety bond governed by Swiss law (art. 492 CO). This guarantee covers the client's defect rights during the warranty period, immediately restoring tied-up liquidity to the firm.
When must the Swiss VAT rate of 8,1% be applied to statements?
The statutory VAT rate of 8,1% applies mandatorily to the net payable amount of each statement after deducting the agreed discount, retention money, and any penalties. For a net service of 50 000 CHF, the tax represents an illustrative amount of 4 050 CHF added to the statement.
How are price adjustments calculated on an advance payment under KBOB guidelines?
The KBOB parametric method compares the official construction cost index of the performance month against that of the initial tender offer. The contractual formula weights fixed shares, materials, wages, and energy. On an advance payment invoice of 200 000 CHF, an index increase produces, for instance, a certified illustrative adjustment of 3 200 CHF.
What is the statutory notice of defects period for immovable works under the Code of Obligations (CO)?
Under the current revision, the client strictly has a statutory period of 60 days to give notice of defects following inspection (art. 367 CO). Any shorter contractual period agreed in advance is null and void, protecting the client during the joint inspection of works completed on the construction site.
In the event of culpable delay on the contractual schedule, how are contractual penalties applied?
A contractual penalty agreed in writing becomes due as soon as default is established, even if the client suffers no proven loss (art. 160 CO and art. 161 CO). Capped or reduced in line with art. 163 CO, the amount is deducted directly upon validation of the monthly advance payment certificate.
Strict control of advance payment statements, finalisation of retention money under standard SIA 118, and KBOB adjustments secure the financial stability and contractual compliance of the construction site. To delve deeper into financial management and on-site inspection procedures, explore our specialist guides:
- Financial Site Management: Joint Measurement Surveys, Daywork and Addenda (SIA 118 / ACIP)
- Daywork (SIA 118): Daily Signing of Reports and Unordered Daywork
- Order Amendments and the ± 20% Rule on CAN Quantities (SIA 118): Renegotiating a Unit Price
- Joint On-Site Quantity Surveying vs As-Built Plans (SIA 118): Procedures and Forfeiture
