Skip to content
Art ConstructionPortal
Practical guide

Change Orders & ± 20% Rule on CAN Quantities (SIA 118): Renegotiating a Unit Price

Master the SIA 118 ± 20% rule: renegotiate CAN CRB unit prices, handle addenda, and safeguard construction site margins.

Table of contents
The 3 Major Site Risks
  1. Financial / Margin: An undetected deviation in actual quantities exceeding the 20 % threshold compared to the CAN bill of quantities exposes the contractor to a gross margin squeeze of 15 % to 25 % on the item concerned, or the client to an unexpected late claim of several tens of thousands of CHF. Without a prior addendum formalized under standard SIA 118 and the principles of art. 374 CO, the final account becomes contentious.
  2. Legal / Joint / SUVA: Carrying out a massive increase in work without adjusting the contractual schedule or allocated resources raises the risk of accidents under time pressure, engaging general duty of care as defined in art. 82 LAA and art. 3 OPA. Furthermore, a substantial change in volumes alters the preventive planning required under art. 3 OTConst, exposing site supervisors to art. 229 CP in the event of breaches of recognised trade practices.
  3. Administrative / Acceptance: Blocking the joint verification of measurement records during the final account prevents final settlement. In the absence of an agreement on the new unit price before the physical execution of the modified work, the client may refuse disputed advance payment requests, delaying acceptance under SIA 118 and the due date of payments under art. 372 CO.

On Swiss construction sites governed by standard SIA 118, the initial determination of remuneration often relies on actual measurements applied to fixed unit prices, based on CRB standardised building components descriptions. When actual quantities performed vary by more than 20 % upwards or downwards from the estimates in the works contract, the economic balance of the order is fundamentally altered. This standard threshold does not act as a mere mathematical adjustment clause: it grants each party a formal right to demand that a new unit price be set to match actual production conditions, whether to amortise fixed costs over a reduced volume or to pass on economies of scale from significantly larger volumes to the client.

This technical and contractual guideline is intended specifically for site managers, civil engineers, project managers, and site supervisors running construction operations in French-speaking Switzerland. Anticipating the crossing of the 20 % tolerance threshold requires rigorous traceability right from initial field observations, before any change orders are carried out. Linking the requirements of standard SIA 118 to the default rules of works contracts in the Code of Obligations (CO), this operational guide details the prior notification procedure, the rules for analytically breaking down the new unit price, and the sign-off procedures needed to avoid financial deadlocks at the final account stage.

Trigger mechanism of the 20 % threshold under SIA 118

In a construction contract governed by standard SIA 118 and backed by the CAN standard catalogue of building elements published by CRB, works are initially valued by applying agreed unit prices to estimated quantities. Exceeding the variation margin of plus or minus 20 % on a quantity takeoff item does not automatically alter the unit price: it creates a unilateral right, available to both the client represented by the site management and the contractor, to demand that a new unit price be established for the surplus portion or for the entire remaining volume. In the absence of an express derogation in the special conditions of contract, the rule applies item by item in the CAN bill of quantities, rather than to the overall tender amount or the Building Cost Code chapter.

Site management observing a foreseeable drift in executed quantities must verify whether this variation stems from a unilateral change order from the client, a technical unforeseen event relating to ground conditions or materials under art. 365 CO, or a mere inaccuracy in the call for tenders description. As soon as the cumulative joint measurement exceeds 120 % of the initial quote quantity, the contractor has grounds to claim that production conditions have changed. Conversely, if the final measured volume fails to reach 80 % of the initial quantity, the contractor suffers an under-recovery of site setup costs and site overheads, which justifies an upward reassessment of the unit price applied to the reduced quantities actually installed.

Analytical breakdown and calculation of the new unit price

Setting the new unit price is neither arbitrary nor based on a lump sum. It follows the principles governing price determination according to the value of work and the contractor's expenses, in line with art. 374 CO when no price was set in advance for altered circumstances. The analysis requires breaking down the initial unit price into four fundamental components: productive wages and associated social security contributions, consumed materials and supplies, depreciation and wear on tools or plant, and the proportional share of general overheads plus profit and risk.

When the quantity increases beyond the 20 % threshold, site management is entitled to demand a lower unit price on the surplus volume. Since the fixed costs for plant delivery, demobilisation, and general site setup were already covered by the first 100 % of the scope, the contractor benefits from economies of scale and more favourable installation rates. The new unit price applicable to quantities exceeding the 120 % threshold is then recalculated by retaining only actual direct costs plus proportional operating overheads. Conversely, in the event of a reduction exceeding 20 %, the contractor demonstrates the under-recovery of fixed charges by isolating unrecoverable fixed costs to establish a revised amount that ensures full recovery of actual expenditure.

CAN takeoff configuration Economic impact on the construction site Calculation basis for the new price Mandatory notification timing Direct contractual consequence
Quantity overrun exceeding + 20 % Dilution of fixed setup costs and equipment productivity gains Deduction of fixed charges already amortised on the portion exceeding 120 % As soon as the projected overrun is established by joint measurement Reduction of the unit price applicable only to surplus quantities
Quantity shortfall exceeding - 20 % Under-recovery of overheads and losses on bulk purchasing Inclusion of the unamortised share of overheads over the actual volume Before completion of the reduced work item Increase in the unit price applied to all executed quantities
Ordered geometric change without change of material Disruption to production rates and tooling modifications Replacement of the unit rate by a price analysis derived from the initial breakdown Prior to implementation on the workface or structure Drafting a formalized addendum with a new specific CAN description
Quantity variance resulting from contractor error Material overconsumption due to remedial work or defective execution Strict adherence to the initial price or refusal to pay for surplus volumes During the joint on-site measurement Application of art. 368 CO to rule out any payment for the surplus
Forced transfer of an item to daywork Loss of the unit price contractual framework in favour of time-and-materials payment Official trade association hourly rates and supporting vouchers for expenses Prior written order from site management before any work starts Requirement for daily or weekly sign-off on daywork reports

Common management errors and financial consequences on site

The first critical error consists in postponing the unit price renegotiation until submitting the final account. If the contractor continues to execute massive volumes exceeding the 20 % threshold without prior notice to the site management, the client can plead budget surprise and refuse payment for extras based on art. 373 CO applied by analogy to unagreed overruns. For example, on an earthworks package where an initial volume of 2 000 m³ rises to 3 500 m³ due to unforeseen geotechnical conditions, continuing excavations without an addendum exposes the firm to a frozen claim of around 60 000 CHF to 90 000 CHF at the final account stage, blocking interim advance payment applications.

The second common error lies in confusing increased quantities with extra work stemming from a qualitative change in the programme. A change order introducing a technically different material does not fall under the quantity tolerance rule, but requires the issue of a non-catalogue item complete with a full price breakdown. Treating new work as a simple volume overrun of an existing item frequently leads to underestimating actual handling costs or scaffolding requirements mandated by art. 26 OTConst, eroding gross margins by 10 % to 15 % on the structural work package.

The third failure lies in neglecting to record joint measurements on weekly measurement sheets. By allowing verbal site requests to pile up without written sign-off from site management, the contractor risks forfeiting claims. Once work has been backfilled or concealed, proving the surplus physically becomes impossible without expensive destructive testing, the costs of which remain with the defaulting party.

Illustrative practical cases (typical scenarios on Swiss construction sites)

The figures and operational data presented below are illustrative examples designed to model the contractual management of quantity variances on Swiss construction sites.

Standard scenario 1: Bulk excavation and muck-away in an urban setting (Canton of Vaud)

On a collective residential construction site in the canton of Vaud, the CAN specification provided for the mass excavation of 4 000 m³ of soft ground at a firm contractual unit price of 38 CHF per m³. When the excavation was opened, the presence of erratic boulders and the requirement to create stepped benching under art. 68 OTConst and art. 75 OTConst led to an actual excavated volume of 5 400 m³, an increase of 35 % over initial estimates. The workforce deployed on this phase comprised a site foreman, three machine operators, and a rotation of five haulage trucks.

Faced with this variance well beyond the 20 % limit, the site management and contractor drew up a joint inspection record as soon as 4 800 m³ was reached. The volume between 4 000 m³ and 4 800 m³ was paid at the initial contract price of 38 CHF per m³. For the surplus portion of 600 m³, however, a price breakdown was prepared: because fixed mobilisation costs for the heavy excavator and water supply setup costs were amortised, the parties agreed on a negotiated new unit price of 32 CHF per m³. Furthermore, the fraction of materials requiring on-site sorting under art. 17 OLED and art. 19 OLED for off-site recovery was handled under a separate transport item, averting a financial dispute estimated at over 25 000 CHF when closing out the monthly account.

Standard scenario 2: Drastic reduction in a modular partition package (Canton of Geneva)

During the refurbishment of an administrative complex in the canton of Geneva, the initial tender awarded to a general contractor included 2 500 m² of double-skin lightweight partition walls, distributed over four levels, at a unit price of 85 CHF per m². Following a decision by the client altering the interior layout to favour open-plan spaces, the final volume actually ordered and installed was reduced to 1 200 m², representing a 52 % decrease compared to the initial bill of quantities. The planned site team comprised eight qualified plasterer-painters.

The contractor immediately noted the collapse of the depreciation base for its technical management overheads and the cancellation of volume discounts granted by its plasterboard supplier. Formally notifying the deviation to the site management before completing the first level, the contractor submitted a substantiated recalculation sheet: the share of overheads and external hoist delivery constraints, initially allocated over 2 500 m², was reallocated to the 1 200 m² volume. The unit price applicable to the surfaces actually executed was legitimately adjusted to 102 CHF per m². The site management approved this adjustment through a written variation order, thereby preventing a claim for disruption of the contractual balance under art. 375 CO and securing the completion of the finishing work within the construction schedule.

00:00 - 00:15 | AI Avatar: Has an earthworks item from the CAN CRB surged by 35 % on your construction site in French-speaking Switzerland? Do not approve the former unit price blindly. Standard SIA 118 strictly governs renegotiation as soon as the 20 % threshold is crossed.

00:15 - 01:10 | Screen and Diagrams: View of a CAN descriptive quote with an earthworks line item initially estimated at 500 cubic metres at a unit price of 48 CHF. The graphic animation highlights the contractual zone up to 600 cubic metres, then colours the surplus zone beyond the 20 % threshold in orange. On-screen demonstration calculating the degressive impact on fixed costs and equipment depreciation. Display of a standard addendum template incorporating the change order before any on-site execution.

01:10 - 01:30 | AI Avatar: Master the financial management of your projects with our calculation tools and secure your contractual relationships. Browse our portal resources now to make your quantity surveying and addenda fully reliable.

Contracts and SIA 118: free tools

Advance payments and retentions, surety bonds, price escalations, daywork reports, subcontractor monitoring.

View the contracts and SIA 118 tools

Frequently asked questions

When does unit price renegotiation apply during a quantity variation?

Under standard SIA 118, setting a new unit price occurs when the final quantity executed deviates by more than 20 % upwards or downwards from the quantity scheduled in the CAN CRB description. The adjustment applies solely to the volume exceeding this threshold, or compensates for the loss of overheads if the quantity decreases.

Who is responsible for notifying that the 20 % threshold has been exceeded on the construction site?

The party that notices the deviation must notify the other party in writing before executing the surplus volumes. If circumstances compromise proper or timely execution, art. 365 CO requires that the client be notified, under penalty of bearing the consequences. For standard earthworks quoted at 40 000 CHF, this alert prevents any dispute over quantities.

How is the new unit price calculated for surplus quantities?

The new unit price is based on the statement of actual costs revised using the original calculation bases of the submitted tender. Because fixed costs and construction site installation are already amortised over the contractual quantities, the unit rate applicable to the volume beyond 20 % is generally revised downwards, unlike in cases involving a sharp decrease in total volume.

Does the 20 % threshold rule apply to lump-sum contracts?

No, this clause is strictly reserved for contracts entered into on the basis of unit prices and estimated quantities under the CAN CRB catalogue. In accordance with art. 373 CO, the contractor performs the works for the agreed sum and cannot claim any increase, unless extraordinary circumstances, impossible to foresee or excluded from projections, justify an adjustment of the price.

What should be done if no agreement is reached on the revised unit price?

If the site management and the contractor fail to agree on a written addendum, works carried out without an agreement can be assessed under art. 374 CO, whereby the price is determined according to the value of the work and the contractor's expenses. The parties can also rely on standard SIA 118 or the Indice ACIP.

Is a written addendum mandatory before starting works beyond the threshold?

Drawing up a contractual addendum beforehand is essential to secure account statements and comply with art. 1 CO regarding the mutual expression of intent. Without a formal agreement, the site management may contest the valuation of quantities during the audit of advance payments, risking financial blockages on the monthly payment applications of the construction site.

Managing quantity overruns in accordance with standard SIA 118 safeguards the financial balance of the works contract and prevents deadlocks during final settlement. To explore administrative and financial management best practices on site in greater depth, browse our dedicated guides:

Art Construction is an independent company: it is not affiliated with the SIA, CRB, SUVA, or KBOB. Referenced norms and standards point to publications from these bodies; only official versions are legally binding.