Skip to content
Art ConstructionPortal
Practical guide

Joint Site Measurement vs Measurement on Plans (SIA 118): Procedures and Forfeiture

Procedures for joint site measurement and plans under SIA 118: quantity traceability, CAN rules, and preventing forfeiture on Swiss construction sites.

Table of contents
The 3 Major Site Risks
  1. Financial / Margin: An unrecorded discrepancy between execution plans and excavated or poured volumes can cause a direct loss of around 10% to 25% on the structural work package; the contractor cannot claim an increase for a lump-sum price under art. 373 CO, whereas under art. 374 CO, a price not fixed in advance or fixed approximately is determined based on the value of the work and the contractor's expenses.
  2. Legal / Joint Body / SUVA: Disagreements over trench or earthwork measurements result in the non-validation of the safety measures required by art. 68 OTConst, which mandates that excavations must be arranged so that falling or sliding materials do not endanger any worker.
  3. Administrative / Handover: The forfeiture of joint measurements on works intended to be backfilled compromises the preparation of the final account under standard SIA 118 and halts the joint verification of the work.

On a construction site governed by standard SIA 118, accurately recording executed works is the keystone of contractual balance between the client and the contractor, within the framework set by art. 363 CO for the works contract. Site managers, construction site foremen, and civil engineers face the fundamental choice between theoretical measurement based on plans and joint measurement taken directly on site. The CRB CAN measurement rules impose a strict allocation methodology for each item of the bill of quantities, whether for earthworks, reinforcement, or formwork, preventing any subsequent dispute over actual dimensions.

The practical distinction between these two approaches becomes vital when building elements cease to be measurable during the works, such as bulk earthworks, Special Foundations, riprap, or buried utilities. If measurements are not jointly recorded by the parties before trenches are backfilled, the contractor faces the risk of forfeiture under standard SIA 118, which restricts the admissibility of accounts based on simple post-hoc estimates. Mastering a rigorous joint protocol thus guarantees the smooth issuance of monthly advance payments and the final closing of financial accounts.

Discrepancy between measurement on plans and joint site measurement

Settling a works contract based on unit prices under standard SIA 118 relies on a strict operational distinction between dimensions specified on project plans and the actual geometry of the built work. In Swiss practice, the bill of quantities structured according to the CAN measurement rules sets out theoretical quantities used to compare bids. Once work is carried out, site management and the contractor must determine whether invoicing derives from approved execution plans ("approved for construction") or from joint measurement records taken on site.

Measurement on plans is the default principle for work elements whose final dimensions are strictly defined by engineer or architect plans, such as reinforced concrete walls, slabs, or interior screeds. The CAN measurement rules specify that void deductions (shafts, window openings, blockouts) follow precise geometric thresholds, regardless of actual formwork complexity. Conversely, joint measurement on site becomes mandatory as soon as the boundaries of the work depend on the natural configuration of the ground, geological unforeseen conditions, or on-the-spot decisions by site management.

A joint measurement record is specifically required for earthworks, soft soil cleanouts, riprap, blinding concrete, and all buried connection works. Under art. 365 CO, the contractor has a duty to notify the client immediately whenever the ground presents anomalies that compromise proper execution or alter the scope of work. Without a measurement protocol drawn up before trenches are backfilled, quantities cannot be verified, leaving the contractor exposed to payment refusal when the final account is prepared.

Joint measurement protocol and forfeiture mechanism

Joint measurement requires the simultaneous physical presence of a site management representative and a qualified contractor delegate (site foreman or construction manager). Together, the parties verify elevations, site footprints, cross-sections, and the encountered geological formations. The findings are formalised using a signed measurement sheet or a dated joint inspection record countersigned by both parties, specifically citing the relevant CAN item numbers.

The main risk facing the contractor is the forfeiture of the right to remuneration. If concealed works (Special Foundations, mass concrete infill, under-slab drainage) are backfilled or concreted without requesting a joint inspection record, the contractor runs up against the evidentiary rules of standard SIA 118. Site management is then entitled to reject the claimed quantities and settle the payment statement solely on theoretical dimensions from tender plans, enforcing the contractual rigor highlighted in art. 364 CO regarding the contractor's duty of care.

To prevent this forfeiture, measurement milestones must be integrated into the detailed construction site schedule. Notice of trench opening or reaching the formation level must reach site management with sufficient technical lead time to organise the measuring session. Once the joint inspection record is signed, the figures become binding on both parties, committing site management to the volumes and the contractor to the limit of their claims for that work item.

Comparative analysis of measurement protocols on Swiss construction sites

The choice of measurement method determines the burden of proof and the admissibility of monthly advance payments. The table below summarises the technical and contractual demarcation criteria applied in French-speaking Switzerland.

Type of workPreferred measurement methodReference source documentationMandatory survey timingConsequence in case of dispute
Bulk excavation and earthworksJoint on-site measurementSurveyor profiles and CAN measurement rulesBefore and after bulk excavationBlocking of actual volumes; payment limited to theoretical project profile
Blinding concrete and foundation cleanoutsJoint on-site measurementSigned measurement sheet on trench bottomImmediately before pouring concreteNon-recognition of extra thickness caused by uneven rock profiles
Reinforced concrete walls and slabs (CFC 211)Measurement on execution plansFormwork plans stamped "approved for construction"Prior to pouring (reinforcement inspection)Strict application of deduction thresholds per CAN measurement rules
Trenches and buried utility pipesJoint on-site measurementGeoreferenced measurement sketchBefore backfilling and compactionForfeiture of trench shoring and bedding extras; measurement reduced to design axis
Wall finishes and roof waterproofingMeasurement on plans with site verificationArchitectural plans and final control measurementAfter substrate completionAdjustment of invoiced areas; deduction of openings per CAN thresholds

Frequent quantity management errors and financial impacts

In day-to-day operations, several methodological errors compromise the contractor's standing or put site management in a difficult position:

  • Failure to issue a formal summons: The contractor takes surveyor measurements alone without inviting site management. This unilateral document carries no joint evidentiary value under standard SIA 118, leading to outright rejection of excavation volumes that can represent a loss of 40 000 CHF to 85 000 CHF on a multi-family housing project.
  • Premature backfilling of buried utilities: Covering utility lines or collectors without a joint measurement record or invert level survey deprives the contractor of any way to prove actual depths dictated by slope requirements, forfeiting deep trench surcharges.
  • Confusing unit measurement with daywork: Invoicing excess excavation volumes as daywork instead of taking joint measurements linked to a unit price item. Site management legitimately rejects the daywork sheet because the item falls under unit rates.
  • Misapplying opening deductions: Invoicing masonry without deducting openings as prescribed by the CAN measurement rules, triggering payment adjustments of 10 000 CHF to 30 000 CHF during the final account.

Regarding safety during trench surveys, the employer must comply with art. 68 OTConst, which mandates arranging excavations so that falling or sliding materials do not endanger workers, and art. 71 OTConst for unprotected trench edges. Any measurement at the bottom of an unsecured trench directly engages management liability.

Illustrative practical cases (typical scenarios on Swiss construction sites)

The figures and situations below are illustrative examples constructed for technical analysis and do not represent actual construction sites.

Standard scenario 1: Geological over-depth excavation in the Canton of Vaud

On a three-apartment-building project in Lausanne, the structural work contractor (crew of 12 workers) uncovers an area of loose moraine beneath the spread footings shown on the structural engineer's drawings. The civil engineer orally orders the excavation to be deepened by an additional 1,20 metres over a 250 m² footprint to reach load-bearing ground, followed by pouring lean levelling concrete.

The site foreman carries out the excavation and pours the concrete on the very same day to prevent rain from degrading the trench bottom, without having site management jointly record the levels. On monthly payment application no. 2, the contractor submits an extra invoice for 300 m³ of soft ground excavation and 300 m³ of mass concrete, totalling roughly 48 000 CHF.

Site management refuses to recognize the mass concrete beyond the initial plan dimensions, arguing that backfilling occurred without a prior joint inspection record. The contractual assessment confirms that the lack of a joint protocol before pouring leaves the contractor without physical proof of the applied thickness. After mediation, site management grants only a reduced technical lump sum based on the original topographic profiles, causing a direct loss of 22 000 CHF for the contractor due to procedural non-compliance under standard SIA 118.

Standard scenario 2: Formwork discrepancy on a complex raft foundation in Valais

During the construction of a light-industrial complex in Martigny (workforce of 8 workers), the ribbed raft foundation features drop panels and recesses for service pits. Theoretical measurement in the CAN bill of quantities provides for 420 m² of permanent formwork. During execution, natural ground slopes require the use of propped steel formwork panels over an actual measured surface of 560 m² on the ground.

The construction manager sends written notice to local site management 48 hours prior to reinforcement placement, requesting a joint measurement meeting. The joint inspection record is recorded on a tablet, complete with dimensioned sketches and digital signatures from the site management technician and the site foreman. The discrepancy amounts to an additional 140 m² at 95 CHF per square metre, or 13 300 CHF. Thanks to this prompt record, the addendum is approved without reservations in that month's payment statement, in full compliance with works contract rules.

Contracts and SIA 118: free tools

Advance payments and retentions, surety bonds, price escalations, daywork reports, subcontractor monitoring.

View the contracts and SIA 118 tools

Frequently asked questions

Who must call for the joint measurement of concealed works under standard SIA 118?

The contractor reports the completion of excavations or reinforcement prior to covering up. Site management arranges the joint inspection record on site. If the client fails to act, a formal written notice is served. Pursuant to art. 365 CO, the contractor immediately flags any circumstance jeopardising the work, avoiding a financial dispute of around 15 000 CHF.

How do you settle discrepancies between theoretical plan take-offs and on-site geometric surveys?

Standard SIA 118 and the CAN measurement rules prescribe direct joint surveys for earthworks and actual volumes. In the event of a geological discrepancy not attributable to the contractor, the recorded cubatures prevail over the design plan, avoiding an uncovered gross earthworks loss in the region of 28 000 CHF.

What is the legal risk of a missing signature on a measurement report?

Without a signed record, forfeiture threatens remuneration for the works carried out. Under art. 363 CO, the contractor must prove the work performed. Lacking joint approval, the client can reject disputed advance payment statements, blocking an illustrative amount of around 45 000 CHF at the time of the final account for the works.

How do you account for additional excavation work not visible during the initial tender?

The contractor immediately records extra depths by means of joint measurements established jointly with site management. The items from the CAN bill of quantities apply to the measured quantities. Immediate notification as required by art. 365 CO protects the contractor against the refusal of an earthworks addendum of around 18 500 CHF.

Can the client impose theoretical plan measurements for blinding concrete?

No, not if the excavation base profile requires a validated technical extra thickness. The CAN measurement rules require joint measurement of the actual poured surfaces. An unjustified refusal breaches the principle of the contract for work and services (art. 363 CO), exposing the construction site to a hold-up of around 12 000 CHF.

What should you do if site management refuses to sign joint measurement sheets?

The contractor promptly sends an expert survey or a documented record by registered post. Pursuant to art. 102 CO, site management is formally placed in default by reminder notice. This rigorous approach safeguards the contractor's claim, securing full settlement of a claim in the order of 34 000 CHF.

Strict command of on-site joint measurement protects the project's financial balance against discrepancies in execution drawings. To secure overall contract management and administrative traceability across your construction sites, consult our specialist guides:

Art Construction is an independent company: it is not affiliated with the SIA, CRB, SUVA, or KBOB. Referenced norms and standards point to publications from these bodies; only official versions are legally binding.