Skip to content
Art ConstructionTenders
Practical guide

Auditing a Works Contract Form: Derogations Introduced by the Architect

How to audit derogations from the SIA 1023 contract imposed by Swiss architects: penalties, CO notice of defects deadlines, and protecting margins.

Table of contents
The 3 Major Site Risks
  1. Financial / Margin: A contractual derogation imposing a cumulative contractual penalty within the meaning of art. 160 CO, often set unilaterally without a reasonable cap under art. 163 CO, can cut net margins by around 5% to 12% of the total awarded amount if the schedule slips.
  2. Legal / Joint / SUVA: Inserting clauses that transfer overall responsibility for safety coordination or road charges without financial compensation exposes the contractor to penalties and injunctions from the competent authority under the Ordinance on the Safety and Health Protection of Workers in Construction Work (OTConst).
  3. Administrative / Acceptance: Waiving the notice of defects rules set out in standard SIA 118 in favour of the statutory regime of art. 367 CO forces the parties to carry out checks upon handover, risking stripping the contractor of the right to remediation in the event of late or disputed notification.

When a contract is awarded in French-speaking Switzerland, the handover of the works contract form based on the SIA 1023 model is frequently accompanied by special conditions drawn up by site management or the architect. Geared toward site managers, estimators, and business owners, a methodical audit of these derogating clauses is an essential prerequisite before signing. Under the guise of technical adjustments, some forms upset the contractual balance defined by art. 363 CO by shifting coordination contingencies, tightening contractual penalties, or eliminating the standard warranty regime of standard SIA 118 to the sole detriment of the successful tenderer.

This critical analysis requires identifying deviations from the Swiss standards established by the Swiss Society of Engineers and Architects. To preserve job profitability and limit the company's legal exposure, every reservation must be formulated in writing during the finalisation stage of the works contract. Pinpointing unilateral changes relating to defect reporting deadlines under art. 367 CO or to retention money helps restore a strict, balanced operating framework with the client before the construction site opens.

Method for analysing contractual derogations from the SIA 1023 model

The SIA 1023 works contract form serves as a standard template to seal agreements between the client and the contractor. However, design professionals frequently attach special conditions or addenda that alter the scope of mutual rights and obligations. Under art. 1 CO, a contract is concluded as soon as the parties have manifested their mutual assent. Accepting an annotated form without reservation amounts to signing off on major legal waivers. The critical review of a contract submitted for signature should follow three assessment steps: technical, financial, and legal.

Checking the order of precedence of contract documents

The first check focuses on the integration clause and the order of precedence of documents. Under the standard SIA 118 system, written derogations set out in the contract agreement take precedence over the general conditions and the description of works. Some forms invert this order or stipulate that handwritten notes from site management systematically prevail over the contractor's itemised quote. Such a provision exposes the executing party to having to carry out work not initially costed. Contractors must ensure that their technical tender, along with its explicit calculation assumptions, retains priority over general requirements added after tenders are opened.

Reviewing ground risk transfer and quantity take-off clauses

Art. 365 para. 3 CO requires the contractor to inform the client immediately if the designated ground or supplied materials are defective, or else bear the consequences. Many contracts drafted by designers attempt to aggravate this duty to notify by stipulating that the contractor assumes full responsibility for geological surprises or the accuracy of the quantities provided during the call for tenders. A clause requiring the contractor to "validate the nature of the subsoil without reservation" turns a unit price contract into a disproportionate risk. Likewise, under art. 364 CO, the contractor's duty of care mirrors that of an employee; it cannot be treated as a performance guarantee regarding incomplete borehole data provided by third parties appointed by the client.

Reviewing contractual penalties and default regimes

Late penalties are subject to the harshest modifications. Art. 160 CO provides that the creditor may demand both performance and the agreed penalty if the penalty was stipulated for non-performance at the agreed time, unless expressly waived. Under art. 161 CO, the contractual penalty is incurred even if the creditor has suffered no loss. However, heavily annotated forms frequently eliminate the requirement for a prior formal notice governed by art. 102 CO or the granting of a reasonable grace period under art. 107 CO. Moreover, they specify automatic daily penalties with no overall cap, running counter to the spirit of contractual fairness in art. 163 CO, which allows a judge to reduce excessive amounts. The audit must insist on an explicit cap and make any deduction conditional on the delay being exclusively attributable to the contractor.

Audit matrix: standard standard clauses versus abusive derogations

Contract areaBaseline regime (CO / standard SIA 118)Common architect derogationOperational risk for the contractor
Order of precedencePriority of the contract agreement, then the priced tenderAbsolute priority granted to future construction drawingsObligation to execute technical details at no extra cost
Subsoil conditionsImmediate notice under art. 365 para. 3 CO in the event of defectsFull transfer of geological risk to the contractorCovering unforeseen special earthworks and shoring
Delay and penaltiesPrior formal notice under art. 102 CO and a reasonable grace periodAutomatic daily penalty without formal notice or capSubstantial deduction from the final account without proof of damage
Notice of defects deadlineStatutory 60-day deadline for immovable works (art. 367 para. 1bis CO)Attempt to revert to immediate notice under penalty of forfeitureUnlawful forfeiture of rights (clause null and void since 1 January 2026)
Securities and retentionsRetention money releasable by surety bond under art. 492 COCumulation of cash retention and bank guarantee without releaseExtended cash lock-up and squeezed company liquidity

Common audit mistakes and financial consequences

Failing to verify payment and termination terms is a first recurrent error. Under art. 372 CO, the price of the work is payable upon delivery. In Swiss construction practice, monthly advance payments are made based on approved progress payment statements. A derogation specifying a single lump-sum payment upon complete handover blocks cash flow for several months. For a contractor carrying out structural work valued at 450 000,00 CHF, the absence of advance payment statements generates bank pre-financing costs on the order of 12 500,00 CHF to 18 000,00 CHF at current commercial lending rates.

A second mistake involves waiving the rules governing change orders. Without an explicit clause protecting the unit price, the architect may attempt to impose a strict lump-sum framework. Under art. 373 CO, the contractor performs the work for the fixed amount and cannot claim any increase, except in extraordinary, unforeseeable circumstances within the meaning of art. 373 para. 2 CO. Conversely, if the actual quantity take-off deviates from the estimates of a non-lump-sum quote, the price is determined based on the value of the work and the contractor's expenses pursuant to art. 374 CO. Forgoing joint measurements exposes the craftsman to bearing cost overruns of around 35 000,00 CHF on a complex finishing work trade package.

The third frequent abuse involves waiving statutory securities. Under art. 837 para. 1 item 3 CC, craftsmen and contractors may request the registration of a statutory mortgage lien for their labour and materials claims. Art. 837 para. 3 CC lays down the mandatory principle that the beneficiary cannot waive this guarantee in advance. Even though a contractual waiver clause agreed in advance is null and void, its presence in the document delays protective measures. The lien must be registered at the latest within four months of completion of the work pursuant to art. 839 para. 2 CC, meaning any hesitation can prove fatal to recovering disputed balances.

Illustrative practical cases (typical scenarios on Swiss construction sites)

The figures presented in the scenarios below are illustrative examples intended to guide companies in their contractual assessments.

Standard Scenario 1: Heavy renovation in an urban area (Canton of Vaud)

A masonry firm with twelve workers is awarded an alteration package for an initial amount of 320 000,00 CHF, including 8,1% VAT. The works contract proposed by site management contains a derogation stating that the contractor shall bear all public thoroughfare occupancy fees and any repairs to party walls without extra compensation. When opening up the ground floor slab, unexpected deformations require the installation of additional steel shoring not mentioned in the original bill of quantities.

The company immediately issues a notice under art. 365 para. 3 CO to flag the layout of the existing load-bearing structures. When site management refuses to draft an addendum, the firm invokes art. 374 CO to bill the additional hours and expenses. Thanks to a written reservation made before signing the contract excluding liability for structural contingencies in the existing building, the contractor secures payment of an extra 24 500,00 CHF, thereby avoiding a direct loss equal to its entire gross margin on the project.

Standard Scenario 2: Multi-family housing construction (Canton of Valais)

A plastering and painting company employing eight workers signs a contract form for a residential complex with an order value of 185 000,00 CHF. The award form contains a derogating clause imposing a lump-sum penalty of 1 000,00 CHF per calendar day of delay as soon as the overall master schedule is exceeded, regardless of progress in other trades. The plasterers' work is pushed back by four weeks following delays by the window installer, deferring the application of coatings into damp autumn periods.

Site management attempts to apply a 28 000,00 CHF deduction to the closing statement under art. 160 CO. Using site correspondence, the company proves that it notified the client without delay that it could not access the rooms under conditions compliant with technical standards. It establishes that it bears no fault within the meaning of art. 97 CO. The penalty is cancelled in full during the final accounting, confirming that auditing coordination clauses upfront and notifying third-party delays are the only effective protection for operating margins.

Calls for tenders: free tools

Direct public procurement tenders, AIMP thresholds by canton, converting SIA 451 to Excel, quantity takeoff from an IFC model.

View tendering tools

Frequently asked questions

Can a contractual clause waive the contractor's right to remediation?

For a building structure, any agreement concluded in advance that limits or eliminates the right to remedy defects is null and void under art. 368 CO. The architect cannot impose an immediate unilateral waiver. Rectification costs, around 4 864,50 CHF, therefore remain directly executable by the craftsman.

Can the architect shorten the defect notification deadline for buildings to under 60 days?

Under art. 367 CO, for immovable works, the client has a 60-day period to notify defects, and any shorter contractual deadline is formally null and void. The contractor should reject any derogation imposed by site management seeking a 5-day notice for a dispute of 12 972,00 CHF.

How can a disproportionate contractual penalty in the special conditions be neutralised?

The amount of a contractual penalty is freely determined by the parties under art. 163 CO, but the court reduces excessive amounts. If the derogation provides for an abusive flat-rate deduction in the region of 35 673,75 CHF, the contractor must demand a written contractual cap before signing the document.

Can the contractor be prohibited from requesting a statutory mortgage lien of craftsmen and contractors?

The entitled party cannot waive statutory mortgage liens in advance pursuant to art. 837 CC. Any clause inserted into the contract form prohibiting recourse to the land register to secure a claim in the region of 54 050,00 CHF is legally void and in no way binds the craftsman or contractor.

What is the legal validity of a clause waiving the duty of immediate notification to the client?

Art. 365 CO requires the client to be informed immediately if the ground or materials supplied are defective, under penalty of bearing the consequences. A derogating clause purporting to make the successful bidder bear all ground-related risks, representing an exposure in the region of 21 620,00 CHF, must be firmly challenged.

Can the architect sign a financial addendum without explicit power of attorney from the client?

Pursuant to art. 32 CO, the acts of an authorised representative bind the party represented. Without a specific power of attorney, the site management cannot approve a work on daywork rates amount of 8 648,00 CHF. The contractor must demand the written consent of the client, in accordance with the mandate governed by art. 398 CO.

Methodically auditing the derogations inserted into the works contract form safeguards your operating margin against unilateral transfers of liability. Since mutual agreement binds the contracting parties under art. 1 CO, every amendment must be scrupulously settled before the construction site opens.

To secure all your negotiation and contracting processes in Switzerland, consult our specialised guides:

Art Construction is an independent company: it is not affiliated with the SIA, CRB, SUVA, or KBOB. Referenced norms and standards point to publications from these bodies; only official versions are legally binding.