Table of contents
The 3 Major Site Risks
- Financial / Margin: Blocked remuneration on unrecognised joint measurements or contested addenda due to a lack of formalised advance payment rules, representing a direct loss that can exceed 8,5 % of the total awarded sum, under art. 374 CO in the absence of an express clause.
- Legal / Joint Body / SUVA: Absence of a mutual agreement on construction site organisation duties within the meaning of art. 1 CO and art. 364 CO, unduly transferring the financial burden of shared protective measures or disputed facilities onto the successful tenderer.
- Administrative / Handover: Loss of the protective regime of joint inspection upon completion, subjecting the contractor to the strict statutory regime of art. 367 CO and art. 370 CO, with the risk of tacit acceptance or untracked late disputes.
Many managers, cost estimators and bid managers in Switzerland mistakenly assume that standard SIA 118 applies automatically as soon as a private or public tender opens. Under Swiss law, a works contract remains governed by the general provisions of the Code of Obligations (CO), in particular art. 363 CO. The regulations published by the Swiss Society of Engineers and Architects constitute pre-established standard contract terms. They bind the parties only if a mutual, matching expression of intent, explicitly stipulated in accordance with art. 1 CO, incorporates them into the tender documents or the award agreement. Omitting this formal reference deprives the bidder of indispensable technical rules for taking off quantities and managing claims.
When standard SIA 118 is not explicitly integrated into the contractual documents, relations between the client and the contractor fall directly under the statutory regime of art. 367 CO and art. 370 CO for inspection of the work and the notice of defects. From the moment the tender is submitted, the contractor must ensure that the incorporation of standard SIA 118 appears in its cover letter and in the form of tender. This approach prevents disputes regarding the five-year limitation period for building structures set out in art. 371 CO and guarantees the application of a tried-and-tested standard framework for monthly advance payments and the handover of works.
Legal mechanism for the contractual incorporation of standard SIA 118
The statutory regime of the works contract stems from the general definition set out in art. 363 CO. Without specific contractual additions, relations between the client and the contractor are governed exclusively by the provisions of the Code of Obligations (CO). Standard SIA 118 does not hold the status of a federal law or an ordinance; it forms a body of general terms and conditions drawn up by the Swiss Society of Engineers and Architects. To deploy its legal effects during a call for tenders or the final conclusion of the contract, it must be the subject of a formal integration satisfying the requirements of art. 1 CO, through which the parties express their mutual and matching will.
In public procurement governed by the LMP, the contracting authority generally specifies the contractual bases as soon as the tender documents are published under art. 18 LMP or art. 19 LMP. However, in direct award procedures governed by art. 21 LMP, or during private calls for tenders between private clients and general contractors, this reference is frequently missing. If the contractor's offer merely quotes a lump sum without specifying submission to standard SIA 118, and the client's order only confirms the prices without citing this body of rules, the contract remains subject solely to the supplementary statutory regime of the Code of Obligations (CO).
Order of precedence of contract documents at the tender stage
To prevent any ambiguity regarding the application of standard SIA 118 when submitting the itemised quote, the estimator must explicitly state the precedence of contract documents in the tender cover letter. When the contract is concluded within the meaning of art. 1 CO, the express terms prevail over the default statutory rules. Under art. 364 CO, the contractor is liable for the proper execution of the work under rules similar to those governing an employee and must provide appropriate tools. Standard SIA 118, for its part, specifies the procedures for assessing measurements, managing daywork and processing monthly advance payments, thus avoiding the strict application of art. 372 CO, which provides that the price of the work is payable upon delivery.
Comparison table: Statutory regime of the Code of Obligations versus Integration of standard SIA 118
The absence of a formal incorporation of standard SIA 118 substantially alters the contractual balance established at the award. The table below details the major differences between the two legal regimes for a tendering contractor.
| Contractual topic | Default regime of the Code of Obligations (without SIA 118) | Regime with express integration of standard SIA 118 | Operational consequence for the contractor |
|---|---|---|---|
| Terms of payment of the price | Under art. 372 CO, the price of the work becomes due upon delivery of the completed work. | Monthly periodic advance payments based on jointly agreed progress statements and partial measurements. | Essential protection of SME cash flow throughout the entire structural work or finishing work phase. |
| Notification of defects upon delivery | Under art. 367 CO, the client inspects the condition as soon as practicable and has 60 days to report defects in an immovable work (para. 1bis). | Notification period open at any time during the first two years following joint handover. | Uncertainty under the CO regime if a formal joint inspection was not organised on an adversarial basis. |
| Remuneration for order variations | Under art. 374 CO, if the price was not fixed in advance, it is determined according to the value of the work and the contractor's expenses. | Standardised procedure for prior addenda with unit pricing based on the initial itemised quote. | Risk of after-the-fact disputes over hourly rates if no agreement approved the supplementary quote. |
| Exceeding an approximate quote | Art. 375 CO allows the client to withdraw from the contract or demand a price reduction in the event of an excessive overrun. | Contractual framework limiting unilateral reclassification and organising continuous monitoring of actual quantities. | Protection of gross margin against unilateral reductions imposed by site management. |
| Fixed-price or lump-sum regime | Art. 373 CO strictly fixes the agreed sum, except in extraordinary, unforeseeable circumstances within the meaning of paragraph 2. | Precise contractual mechanism for cost adjustments in response to ground hazards or substantial project variations. | Securing financial claims when the plans provided at tender stage exhibit technical deficiencies. |
Common incorporation errors and direct financial consequences
A first recurrent error consists in adding a generic clause at the bottom of the itemised quote, such as "work carried out according to good trade practice". This wording does not constitute a valid incorporation of standard SIA 118. Without a matching agreement within the meaning of art. 1 CO on this specific standard, the court or arbitral tribunal will apply the ordinary rules of the Code of Obligations (CO). On an Interior Joinery contract of 450 000,00 CHF, applying art. 372 CO instead of monthly advance payments can deprive the firm of 180 000,00 CHF in cash flow over several months while waiting for completion.
A second pitfall lies in the contradiction between the client's general conditions of purchase and the contractor's offer. If the client issues a purchase order referencing art. 363 CO and its own directives, tacitly excluding standard SIA 118, the contractor who starts work without a formal objection is exposed to the application of art. 6 CO. The contract is deemed concluded on the client's terms. Regarding warranties, art. 371 CO sets the limitation period at five years for defects in an immovable work (para. 2), but without the contractual management flexibility of standard SIA 118, the contractor is vulnerable to notices of defects issued under pressure from art. 366 CO para. 2, where the client threatens to entrust remedial work to a third party at the contractor's expense.
Finally, failing to make one's offer conditional upon standard SIA 118 when subcontracting creates a dangerous mismatch. Art. 364 CO requires the contractor to perform the work in person or under personal supervision. If the main contractor is bound to the client under standard SIA 118, but enters into a works contract with its subcontractor governed solely by the Code of Obligations (CO) without a mirror clause, it cannot enforce the same expert evaluation deadlines or warranty retentions against that subcontractor.
Illustrative practical cases (typical scenarios on Swiss construction sites)
The amounts and operational figures presented below are illustrative examples designed to analyse contract award mechanisms in French-speaking Switzerland.
Scenario 1: Masonry and reinforced concrete works under open procedure (Canton of Vaud)
A structural work firm with twenty-four employees tenders for the construction of an administrative building in Lausanne, a public contract valued at 1 850 000,00 CHF including all taxes (Swiss VAT of 8,1 % included). During the bid evaluation conducted under art. 38 LMP, site management notes that the contractor amended the itemised quote by stating that its offer is based exclusively on the conditions of standard SIA 118, whereas the municipality's specifications called for a single payment 60 days after full handover without any advance payment.
The municipal awarding authority requests explanations under art. 38 para. 2 LMP. The contractor confirms that its profitability cannot accommodate a departure from art. 372 CO without monthly billing based on progress statements. The municipality formally accepts the incorporation of standard SIA 118 into the award decision under art. 41 LMP, considering that the offer remains the most advantageous. This clarification protects the firm's cash flow to the tune of 150 000,00 CHF in regular monthly advance payments throughout the construction site.
Scenario 2: Roof renovation and sheet-metal work under a private contract (Canton of Geneva)
A roofer and sheet-metal worker employing eight workers submits a quote of 162 050,00 CHF including VAT for the refurbishment of a condominium building under art. 712a CC in Geneva. The quote contains no normative references. During execution, stripping the old roof covering reveals advanced deterioration of the roof structure, requiring the immediate suspension of roofing works and urgent reinforcement.
The craftsman notifies the representative of the community of condominium owners in accordance with art. 365 para. 3 CO, as this circumstance jeopardises the proper execution of the work. However, having failed to incorporate standard SIA 118, which provides for remuneration in the event of site interruptions not attributable to the contractor, the craftsman is forced to negotiate scaffolding immobilisation costs under art. 374 CO. By explicitly integrating standard SIA 118 right from the tender, the craftsman would have immediately secured the billing of standstill costs amounting to 14 250,00 CHF without dispute over the compensation method.
Calls for tenders: free tools
Direct public procurement tenders, AIMP thresholds by canton, converting SIA 451 to Excel, quantity takeoff from an IFC model.
Frequently asked questions
Does standard SIA 118 apply by default without a written mention in the works contract?
No. Under art. 1 CO, a contractual agreement requires matching expressions of intent. Standard SIA 118 constitutes private, proprietary general conditions. Without an express stipulation in the works contract or the accepted offer, only the statutory provisions of the Code of Obligations (CO) apply to govern construction services.
What is the financial risk if standard SIA 118 is not integrated into the contract?
Without standard SIA 118, art. 372 CO makes the price due only upon delivery of the work. The contractor loses the protective framework of regular monthly advance payments, risking a cash flow deficit of around 180 000.00 CHF on a typical contract not financed via interim stages.
Can the client enforce art. 373 CO to exclude unforeseen extra costs?
Yes. Under art. 373 CO, a lump-sum price rules out any increase, unless extraordinary, unforeseeable circumstances arise. Formally incorporating standard SIA 118 clarifies how change orders and as-built quantity measurements are handled, preventing the client from arbitrarily imposing a unilateral financial freeze.
What does the Code of Obligations (CO) provide for notifying defects in immovable works?
Following the statutory revision, art. 367 CO gives the client a 60-day period to notify defects in an immovable work; any shorter contractual notice period is null and void. Standard SIA 118 also establishes a joint inspection and formal acceptance procedures essential to both parties.
Is a mere reference in the descriptive quote enough to bind the contracting authority?
Contractors must pay close attention to the hierarchy of documents. Under art. 1 CO, if the special conditions conflict with the descriptive quote, the express clause takes precedence. You must formalise the incorporation of standard SIA 118 within the tender submission deed itself to safeguard your rights as a bidder.
How can the contractor secure its claims if standard SIA 118 is omitted?
Art. 837 CC and art. 839 CC allow the contractor to apply for the registration of a statutory mortgage lien of craftsmen and contractors no later than four months after the completion of the work. This mandatory statutory entitlement compensates for the absence of contractual provisions governing security or advance payments during execution.
To secure every call for tenders in Switzerland, contractors must systematically review contractual terms and verify that standard SIA 118 is expressly incorporated before signing, thereby avoiding the unamended, rigid rules of the Code of Obligations (CO). Continue optimising your tenders with our expert insights:
- Final Negotiation, SIA 1023 Contract Review, and Handover to Site Operations
- Auditing a Works Contract Form: Derogations Introduced by the Architect
- Unit Price, Lump Sum or Fixed Sum: Choosing the Remuneration Method Under Standard SIA 118
- Negotiating Retainage Caps and Joint and Several Guarantees before Signing
