Skip to content
Art ConstructionTenders
Reference guide

Final Negotiation, SIA 1023 Contract Audit, and Handover to Execution

Practical guide to auditing the SIA 1023 contract in Switzerland: negotiating guarantees, advance payments, critical clauses, and transfer to site works.

Table of contents
The 3 Major Site Risks
  1. Financial / Margin: Direct erosion of operating margins through the combined impact of excessive retention money, unilateral deductions for the site account (compte prorata), and an uncapped penalty clause. The financial impact can reach an illustrative magnitude of 8,00 % to 15,00 % of the total award sum in the event of contractual drift, jeopardising the successful bidder's positive cash flow when paying advance payments to its own subcontractors. Under art. 160 CO, a contractual penalty stipulated for non-performance at the agreed time entitles the creditor to claim both performance and the penalty incurred, unless expressly waived. Without prior negotiation of a strict monetary cap and a release mechanism via a bank guarantee under standard SIA 118, the contractor alone bears the pre-financing of its procurement cycle.
  2. Legal / Joint Body / SUVA: Imposition of joint and several liability and administrative shutdowns resulting from unlawful transfer clauses or a lack of due diligence across the subcontracting chain. In accordance with the Posted Workers Act and the Federal Act on Combating Undeclared Work, the procurement authority and the general contractor may be held liable if minimum net wage conditions or joint monitoring obligations are not scrupulously observed on the construction site. At the same time, the inclusion by the agent of clauses waiving art. 837 CC in advance directly violates paragraph 3 of that provision, which expressly prohibits beneficiaries from waiving their contractor's statutory mortgage lien in advance, making such stipulations completely void while generating disruptive disputes.
  3. Administrative / Acceptance: Blocking of securities release and operational misalignment during the handover from tender to the field in the absence of a formal transfer protocol. Omitting an express reference subjecting the agreement to standard SIA 118 deprives the contractor of a protective special regime against the strict provisions of the Swiss Code of Obligations, which lays down in art. 367 CO a mandatory 60-day deadline to give notice of defects in an immovable work. This contractual void leads to major delays in drawing up joint inspection minutes, unduly prolonging exposure to daily penalties under the works contract and delaying the final account.

In the construction sector in French-speaking Switzerland, the formal conclusion of the works contract is the strategic turning point where the actual profitability of an awarded tender crystallises. Whether dealing with public procurement governed by the Public Procurement Act or a private project subject to the ordinary rules of the Swiss Code of Obligations (CO), receiving the contract form issued by project management must never be treated as a mere administrative formality. Estimators, technical directors, and tender managers routinely face forms based on the SIA 1023 contract template that have been heavily altered by the client's agents. These modifications frequently introduce insidious deviations from the recognised rules of the trade established by standard SIA 118, shifting geological risks, site organisation overheads, or restrictive financial terms onto the contractor that were not identifiable in the original call for tenders documents. A critical review of every clause in the commitment document before signing is vital to protect the calculated gross margin and ensure long-term business viability.

This comprehensive guide details the methodical protocol for auditing, negotiating contracts, and conducting internal handovers before starting any work across the French-speaking cantons. The first section examines the formal incorporation of standard SIA 118 under art. 363 CO and neutralises unilateral deviations made to the standard SIA 1023 contract, particularly document hierarchy and abusive charges for the site account (compte prorata). The second section addresses the financial trade-off between unit price, lump-sum price, and global price in light of the fixed-price rules of art. 373 CO, while setting up the essential mechanisms needed to preserve positive net operating cash flow through the negotiation of order advance payments and joint and several guarantees. Finally, the last section outlines legal safeguards against unlawful waivers of real estate liens, along with a rigorous handover protocol between estimator and site manager to ensure seamless control over technical requirements on site.

Regulatory framework and structure of Swiss contract standards

The framework governing construction contracts in Switzerland is built on a methodical alignment between the non-mandatory provisions of the Code of Obligations, formal public procurement rules, and technical standards issued by the Swiss Society of Engineers and Architects. Contrary to a widespread misconception among tenderers, standard SIA 118 never applies automatically to a works contract. For this body of rules to govern contractual relationships, the parties must formally agree on its incorporation in the instrument of commitment or the particular conditions. Art. 364 CO requires the contractor to perform with due care and loyalty, subject to the same liability standards that apply to an employee, with the contractor providing its own means of production unless agreed otherwise. When the SIA 1023 contract form is submitted for signature, it synthesises the agreement of minds, but it is routinely subject to unilateral additions imposed by the site management or the client's representative.

In the public sector, awarding orders is governed by the Federal Act on Public Procurement or the Intercantonal Agreement on Public Procurement (AIMP) across French-speaking cantons. This legislation strictly prohibits price negotiations after tenders are opened, requiring absolute transparency in selecting the most economically advantageous tender. Consequently, the contract finalisation phase cannot be used to modify unit rates or the awarded lump sum. In private procurement, however, freedom of contract prevails, opening the door to structural adjustments regarding financial terms. Art. 6 CO provides that silence constitutes acceptance only if the offeror could not expect an express statement under the circumstances. A contractor who receives an altered contract form and begins work without issuing written reservations risks having those unfavourable terms confirmed by conclusive conduct.

The hierarchical ranking of contract documents is the cornerstone of legal analysis. Under the order of precedence set by standard SIA 118, the text of the works contract expressly overrides the particular conditions, which in turn prevail over the bill of quantities and the original tender. If a planner insidiously alters the standard clauses of standard SIA 1023—for instance, by reversing the order of precedence to give priority to derogating clauses slipped into the standard building specification preliminaries—the contractor is stripped of customary protections. This inverted contractual hierarchy disables early-warning mechanisms, changes payment deadlines, and undermines payment terms for unexpected additional work.

The regime governing defects and liability demands heightened vigilance when reviewing pre-drafted terms. The law of the works contract in the Code of Obligations strictly regulates remediation and the notification of defects. Standard SIA 118 sets out a balanced framework that begins with a joint inspection upon completion, followed by a two-year warranty period during which the contractor has the primary right to remedy the defect, while the client may issue a notice of defects at any time without immediate forfeiture of rights. When the architect contractually eliminates the provisions of standard SIA 118 to return to the statutory regime of the Code of Obligations without adjustments, the duty of immediate inspection and formal notification is reinstated. Furthermore, art. 366 CO grants the client the right to terminate the contract before the agreed completion date if the contractor is in default, or to assign completion to a third party at the defaulting tenderer's expense if defective execution is certain to occur.

Performance bonds and financial retentions form the third regulatory pillar. Swiss practice, backed by standard SIA 118, provides for a deduction from monthly valuations that is released upon acceptance of the work in exchange for a joint and several guarantee issued by a bank or insurance provider. Some contracts simultaneously impose ongoing cash retentions and a bank guarantee covering the entire five-year warranty period. This double burden suffocates an SME's operational cash flow. A meticulous review of draft guarantee instruments is essential to eliminate wording resembling on-demand guarantees, which deprive the contractor of the right to raise defences inherent to the main contract.

Methodical 7-step contract audit and commitment protocol

A critical assessment of contract documents before entering into a legal commitment leaves no room for improvisation. The management team, bringing together the tender estimator and the future site manager, must carry out a rigorous, step-by-step audit procedure to clean up the contractual framework before executing any binding agreement.

Step 1: Complete reconciliation between the awarded tender and draft contract

The estimator must conduct a line-by-line comparison between the final technical and financial tender submitted on simap.ch or sent to the private client, and the contract document drafted by site management. Focus areas include the accuracy of figures in Swiss francs exclusive of tax and with VAT at 8,1 %, the full inclusion of expressly agreed rebates or cash discounts, and the reference date for wages and raw materials selected to calculate price adjustments under index-based or actual cost methods.

Step 2: Establishing the contractual hierarchy of documents

The technical management must ensure that clause 1 of the contract explicitly specifies the order of precedence of documents according to standard industry practice. Any draft contract stating that the client's particular conditions or the preliminary notes of the descriptive specifications take precedence over the provisions of standard SIA 118 must be met with an immediate, reasoned refusal. The absolute priority of the instrument of commitment and standard dispute settlement rules over project-specific specifications must be restored.

Step 3: Tracking down and eliminating derogating clauses

The in-house legal counsel or company manager systematically flags unilateral changes inserted into the text of the SIA 1023 contract. The most frequent and harmful derogations involve unilaterally extending verification periods for monthly payment applications, imposing daily penalties without an overall cap, eliminating the contractor's right to demand payment security from the client, or arbitrarily shifting liabilities for delays caused by other trades.

Step 4: Defining Remuneration Terms and Managing Ground Risks

The contract must unambiguously define the agreed form of remuneration: unit price based on actual measurement, lump-sum price, or strict fixed price. Where a lump-sum price is used, the contractor verifies that the call for tenders file included full soil investigations and definitive execution drawings. If geotechnical investigations prove incomplete, an express reservation must state that unforeseen ground conditions, groundwater, or the discovery of pollutants will be handled by addenda billed on a daywork basis or at unit prices agreed between the parties.

Step 5: Negotiating the Payment Schedule and Limiting Deductions

The financial officer adjusts the schedule of advance payments to ensure positive operating cash flow throughout the construction cycle. This negotiation involves securing an advance payment upon order to finance workshop drawings and the procurement of specific manufactured materials, requiring a payment term of no more than 30 days for monthly advance payments, and formally capping general construction site overhead or shared-site account (compte prorata) deductions at a predefined percentage of the net invoiced amount.

Step 6: Locking Down Securities and Protecting In Rem Rights

The contractor insists that guarantee requirements align with the rules of the SIA 118 standard. Performance retention money must be strictly capped and its release conditioned upon handing over the works free of major defects preventing operational use, backed by a guarantee certificate issued by a Swiss bank or an insurance company authorised by FINMA. Any wording waiving access to statutory real estate security instruments in the event of non-payment must be firmly rejected.

Step 7: Auditing Technical Capacity and Fulfilling Warning Duties

Before signing, the successful tenderer ensures it has the skilled labour and equipment needed to meet the works schedule. Under art. 369 CO, the client's rights regarding defects in the works are barred where defective performance is personally attributable to the client, notably following instructions issued contrary to the contractor's formal warnings. The contractor must therefore put in writing, as early as the pre-contractual phase, any technical discrepancy identified in the tender drawings provided by the mandated engineers.

Comparative table of contract clauses: common pitfalls and counter-proposals

The table below details the most critical friction points observed when negotiating construction contracts in Switzerland, contrasting unreasonable demands made by certain clients with balanced solutions aligned with Swiss professional standards.

Element or situationObserved demand or statutory provisionPractical impact on the projectCounter-proposal and key check
Precedence of contract documentsPriority granted to the architect's particular conditions over the SIA 118 standard.Fair dispute-resolution mechanisms and standard procedural safeguards are overridden.Reinstate the strict priority of the SIA 1023 contract form and the SIA 118 standard over particular conditions.
Remuneration methodFull lump-sum conversion imposed without final execution drawings.The successful tenderer bears measurement variances and design errors made by designers.Require remuneration at unit prices based on the bill of quantities until drawings are signed off "approved for construction".
Retention money and guaranteeA 10 % cash retention combined with an on-demand bank guarantee for 5 years.Prolonged lock-up of cash and deterioration of the firm's bank credit line.Replace retention money with a joint and several guarantee from acceptance, capped at the standard rate under the SIA 118 standard.
Shared-site account (compte prorata) and site overheadFlat-rate deduction of 3 % to 5 % without receipts or detailed accounting.Arbitrary reduction of the firm's net margin with no link to actual expenditure.Cap shared expenditure at 1 % maximum, with an obligation to provide quarterly statements of paid invoices.
Contractual delay penaltyDaily amount with no overall cap and automatic application without prior formal notice.Disproportionate financial risk that can consume the entire gross margin of the project.Contractually cap the cumulative total amount and exclude delays caused by third parties or recognised adverse weather.
Contractor's payment securityContract clause stipulating a final waiver of the right to register a statutory mortgage lien.Loss of the primary legal leverage against the risk of client insolvency.Reject the clause, noting that civil law voids any advance waiver by the entitled party.

Decision criteria for approving or withholding contract signing

The final decision to legally commit the firm rests on a thorough multi-criteria review. When faced with a rigid or one-sided construction contract, the executive management must rely on clear benchmarks to decide whether to execute, issue a prior corrective addendum, or withdraw the tender.

1. Forecast Financial Balance and Net Cash Flow

The projected gross margin must not be eroded by indirect deductions. If the combined impact of discounts conceded during negotiations, non-bondable cash retentions, and shared-site account costs exceeds one quarter of the projected operating profit, signature must be paused. The firm should never finance the construction site out of its own working capital without a secured schedule of advance payments backed by a solvent client.

2. Control of Liabilities and Penalties

Accepting a contractual penalty is only viable if the cumulative total amount remains capped at a reasonable proportion of the works and the programme formally incorporates the time allowances required for weather constraints and interactions with other trades. Any contract that refuses to automatically postpone completion milestones when variation orders are issued must be stopped prior to commitment.

3. Technical Clarity of the Tender Package and Scope Definition

The agreed scope must match the priced bills of quantities exactly. Where major discrepancies exist between the architect's drawings and the bill descriptions, the contractor must draft a clarification memorandum included as a priority annex to the contract agreement. This step eliminates the risk of having to carry out complex work free of charge under the pretext of an ill-defined lump-sum price.

4. Statutory Compliance and Safeguarding Emergency Relief

No concessions can be granted on the core statutory protections shielding the firm against payment default or arbitrary decisions by designers. Clauses limiting the freedom to seek conciliation or imposing private arbitral tribunals with cost structures prohibitive for an SME must be struck out in favour of ordinary Swiss courts at the location of the property. Protecting these fundamental rights secures the firm's financial viability throughout the upcoming execution phase.

Operational implementation of contract trade-offs by site situation

Finalising contract documents before breaking ground on the construction site requires careful tailoring to the type of project, the client profile, and the setup chosen for site management. Standard clauses from the SIA 1023 standard form cannot be applied indiscriminately without adjusting remuneration mechanisms, execution interface management, and the schedule of financial disbursements. The table below outlines the concrete measures to adopt across three representative scenarios in the Swiss construction sector.

Typical site scenario Frequent contractual friction points Recommended technical and legal trade-off Direct impact on execution
Municipal or cantonal civil engineering public procurement Imposition of a fixed lump-sum price on variable soils, rigid daily penalties, and working hours restricted by road traffic requirements. Strictly preserve actual measurement based on standard unit prices from the Catalogue of Standardised Articles (CAN); expressly limit liability to the geotechnical data disclosed during the tender stage. Payment reflects actual excavated volumes without bearing the financial fallout of unforeseen ground conditions; revenue remains aligned with actual expenditure.
Major urban refurbishment while premises remain in use High shared-site account deductions, strict delay penalties with no allowance for municipal noise restrictions, increased risk of damage to existing structures. Cap site management expenses at a moderate percentage audited against invoices; require site management to set a phased programme agreed jointly. Elimination of unjustified interim retentions and automatic suspension of penalties for delays caused by municipal working-hour restrictions.
Private new build under a general architect mandate Contractual removal of the initial advance payment, requirement of a joint and several bank guarantee from day one, waiver of the right to suspend works upon late payment. Establish a payment schedule linked to measurable physical milestones; set up retention money via progressive deductions on advance payments rather than an upfront bank guarantee. Positive operating cash flow is maintained throughout structural work, keeping the trade contractor's bank credit lines intact.

Illustrative practical cases (typical scenarios on Swiss construction sites)

The following financial and operational figures are illustrative examples designed to analyse decision-making mechanisms prior to contract signature.

Scenario 1: Residential Building Conversion in the Canton of Vaud

A general contractor specialising in masonry and reinforced concrete with 18 employees is awarded a project for an additional storey and energy retrofit on an apartment building in Lausanne. The initial contract award sum stands at 1 245 800,00 CHF including taxes (Swiss VAT of 8,1 % included, i.e. 93 300,00 CHF in tax). When issuing the draft construction contract on the SIA 1023 standard form, the architectural practice representing the owner amends the general terms by converting the unit-price itemised quote into an overall lump-sum price remuneration.

The preliminary review performed by the quantity surveyor reveals several major technical discrepancies: destructive trial pits on the existing load-bearing structure were only partially carried out, and final formwork drawings have not been supplied. If the firm accepts the classification of a lump-sum price under the provisions of the Code of Obligations (CO) governing works carried out for a fixed price, it absorbs the full cost of any extra volume of concrete needed to underpin the foundations, with no claim to additional remuneration.

To counter this imbalance, the firm's management decides to formally reject the overall lump-sum price. It submits a written counter-proposal requiring unit prices to be kept for demolition, underpinning, and structural consolidation sections, while agreeing to a lump-sum price only for new, fully quantified roof works. It also introduces a dimensional tolerance clause aligned with the SIA 118 standard, ruling out any delay penalties until other trades grant full, clear access to floor slabs.

On the financial side, the architect demanded an automatic lump-sum deduction of 2,5 % of the total amount for the pro-rata account (a cut of 31 145,00 CHF including VAT) without any duty to provide a detailed statement. The contractor negotiated reducing this rate to 0,8 % covering solely construction site electricity and water expenses, provided that power supplier invoices are submitted at the time of the final account. This step avoided a net margin loss of more than 21 000,00 CHF.

Scenario 2: Construction of a commercial and administrative hall in the Canton of Fribourg

A steel construction firm with 32 employees won the tender for the structural frame, cladding, and metalwork of a commercial facility in Bulle, for a contractual amount fixed at 885 450,20 CHF including Swiss VAT at 8,1 % (of which 66 312,20 CHF is VAT). The contract drafted by the client's representative included a contractual penalty for delays set at 1 500,00 CHF per calendar day past the overall schedule, without any aggregate cap, as well as a clause strictly prohibiting the use of real estate collateral.

The contractor's obligation to deliver a defect-free work and bear liability for it requires extreme care before signing. The firm noted that the absence of a cap on penalties posed an existential threat to its balance sheet in the event of administrative hold-ups or harsh Fribourg winter weather. In accordance with contractual freedom governed by federal law, it demanded a maximum cap on contractual penalties set at 5 % of the order value, representing a maximum of 44 272,50 CHF including VAT, along with the explicit exclusion of weather-related downtime recorded in the construction site minutes.

In addition, the firm firmly rejected the clause waiving statutory lien rights. Since the Swiss Civil Code guarantees protective mechanisms for the claims of building craftsmen and contractors, an advance waiver inserted in general conditions poses an unacceptable legal risk if the client becomes insolvent before the work is finished. The firm preserved its statutory rights while offering the client, in return, a performance bank guarantee issued by a Swiss banking institution as a guarantee bond, releasable upon acceptance of the work for the steel frame without reservations.

The final agreement signed included a schedule providing for a 15 % advance payment upon ordering (132 817,55 CHF including VAT) to cover shop procurement of structural steel, followed by monthly progress billings based on joint quantity surveys. The firm's net cash flow thus remained positive throughout the entire fabrication of the structures.

Operational checklist before signing and commitment

The internal review process for a works contract based on the SIA 1023 standard requires the estimator and the site manager to systematically check the following points:

  • Verification of the formal designation of the contracting parties, including the exact company name entered in the commercial register and the signing powers of the representatives under the Code of Obligations.
  • Formal inclusion of the SIA 118 standard in the body of the contract as an integral part, verifying its rank in the order of precedence relative to the special conditions drafted by the architect.
  • Review of the pricing structure: a clear distinction between unit prices based on actual quantity take-offs for specification items and fixed, non-adjustable prices for subsoil contingencies.
  • Explicit contractual capping of contractual penalties, setting a limit as a percentage of the contract value and clearly defining valid reasons for time extensions.
  • Establishment of the payment schedule for advance payments: deletion of clauses conditioning payments to the contractor on prior bank disbursements to the client.
  • Regulation of deductions for the pro-rata account, general site clean-up, construction site insurance, and shared skips: requirement of financial caps expressed in francs or billing at verified actual cost.
  • Validation of terms for the release of retention money, with the option to substitute a joint and several guarantee governed by Swiss law right upon acceptance of the work.
  • Confirmation that there are no exclusionary clauses restricting the right to request a provisional entry of a statutory mortgage lien in the event of proven non-payment.

Common contracting mistakes and financial consequences

Overlooking certain technical and legal checks during contract conclusion causes direct financial losses that can no longer be rectified once site work begins.

1. Confusing lump-sum pricing and unit pricing in a bill of quantities by chapters

When a works contract sets a fixed sum for an entire chapter without specifying that the quantities in the bill of quantities are estimates, the contractor risks having to perform unexpected work without extra pay. Under statutory rules governing the works contract, if the price was agreed as a fixed lump sum, the contractor must carry out the work for the agreed amount even if the actual volume of work or the costs exceed expectations. Failing to explicitly state that unit prices remain applicable to actual quantity surveys deprives the craftsman of the right to adjust billing when site management orders larger quantities.

2. Accepting clauses waiving notices of inclement weather or force majeure

Certain contracts prepared by planning consultants impose unreasonably short notification deadlines, under pain of immediately forfeiting the right to request an extension of the contract schedule. If the contractor accepts such a clause without reservation, any minor delay caused by extreme weather is treated as contractor default. The client can then demand the contractual penalty agreed upon without having to prove actual damage. Adjusting these notification windows upon signing ensures fair consideration of work stoppages ordered for technical or meteorological reasons.

3. Neglecting the duty to notify and immediately report design defects

A contractor who spots a flaw in the architect's plans, inadequate ground conditions, or contradictory specifications in the call for tenders file must notify the client without delay. Art. 365 para. 3 CO explicitly states that if the material supplied by the client or the building ground designated by him is found to be defective, or if any other circumstance jeopardises the proper or punctual completion of the work, the contractor must inform the client immediately, under pain of assuming liability. Failing to record these reservations in writing upon signing the contract or upon receiving execution drawings shifts full liability for subsequent defects onto the contractor, extinguishing claims for payment of remedial work.

Long-term monitoring, document management, and archiving of agreements

Traceability of contractual commitments provides the indispensable foundation to secure site performance and prevent disputes during the final account.

Setting up the initial contract file

As soon as the works contract has been signed, a master file must be locked away in the firm's technical archives. This file must contain:

  • The original executed copy of the works contract signed by authorised representatives of both the client and the contractor.
  • The complete initial tender offer with its detailed bill of quantities, updated with any adjustments negotiated during clarification meetings.
  • The minutes of pre-contractual negotiations, explicitly recording items that were deleted or amended from the initial draft.
  • The set of drawings used as the basis for the contract take-off, signed and dated by both contracting parties.

Managing and tracking change orders during construction

Any instruction modifying the scope of work described in the contract must be covered by a prior written addendum or a change order formally approved by the site management. Oral agreements made on the construction site create severe legal exposure when closing the accounts. When the client or its representative orders a design variant or additional work, the contractor must promptly submit a supplementary quote detailing the financial impact and the effect on the completion schedule. Daywork sheets must be signed off jointly on a strict weekly basis, in accordance with trade practices and the rules of the SIA 118 standard.

Document retention and statutory limitation periods

Filing contract documents, monthly progress billings, written warnings, and final accounts must comply with strict retention schedules dictated by Swiss federal law. For claims arising from a works contract and actions regarding builder liability, the complete execution file must be retained in secure paper and digital formats for at least ten years following the date of acceptance of the work. This duration covers the full five-year statutory limitation period applicable to construction defects on real estate, while ensuring documentary evidence remains available in the event of financial litigation or subsequent claims by successive buyers.

Calls for tenders: free tools

Direct public procurement tenders, AIMP thresholds by canton, converting SIA 451 to Excel, quantity takeoff from an IFC model.

View tendering tools

Frequently asked questions

What should you do when a works contract tacitly excludes the SIA 118 standard in favour of statutory law alone?

Without express inclusion in the contract, the SIA 118 standard does not apply to the contractual relationship. The project falls exclusively under the Swiss Code of Obligations. Pursuant to art. 367 CO, the client has a 60-day notice of defects period for real estate works. However, the absence of the standard deprives the contractor of clear rules for joint quantity surveys, joint verification deadlines, and a structured framework for contingency claims. For an illustrative project worth 450 000,00 CHF, you should demand that the standard be formally added to the works contract before signing to safeguard site execution.

Can the appointed architect validly sign financial change orders without written power of attorney?

The client's representation by the site management is governed by agency rules and art. 32 CO. Under this provision, actions carried out on behalf of the client bind the client only if the representative holds appropriate authority. The architect oversees technical supervision, but does not ipso facto have the power to commit to unforeseen expenses exceeding the budget envelope. On an illustrative package worth 280 000,00 CHF, a change addendum of 18 500,00 CHF signed solely by the local project manager remains legally precarious. The contractor must require the client's formal countersignature or a specific written power of attorney before starting any work.

What recourse is available when contract retention money exceeds normal industry practice?

The SIA 1023 contract template provides a benchmark, but the parties remain free to negotiate financial guarantees. If the client demands 10 % retention on each progress payment instead of the standard 5 %, the contractor's working capital is severely strained. On a monthly claim of 95 000,00 CHF, such a deduction freezes 9 500,00 CHF in immediate cash. The contractor can negotiate replacing this retention outright with a joint and several bank or insurance guarantee, governed by art. 492 CO. This mechanism fully protects the creditor while releasing regular cash flows due to the craftsmen.

Is a clause prohibiting the registration of a statutory mortgage lien of craftsmen and contractors valid?

The Swiss Civil Code strictly protects builders' lien rights through mandatory law. Under this legislation, any contract clause providing for an advance waiver by the contractor of the right to apply for registration is null and void. On an unpaid claim of 62 400,00 CHF, the firm retains all of its real security rights. Under art. 839 CC, provisional registration in the land register must take place no later than four months after the completion of the work. This statutory right remains enforceable despite any contrary wording in the special conditions drafted unilaterally by the client.

How do you mitigate the impact of a contractual delay penalty calculated per working day?

Set freely according to the contractual provisions, the penalty applies regardless of proof of any direct damage. Under art. 163 CO, the judge retains only the authority to reduce the amounts if he deems them excessive during a dispute. To avert any risk on an illustrative construction site of 520 000,00 CHF, the contractor must negotiate upstream a strict cap, typically 5% of the total amount, i.e. 26 000,00 CHF. It is essential to include automatic suspension clauses in the event of bad weather, delays attributable to interfaces with other trades, or pending technical instructions from the site management.

Is it permitted to demand substantial initial advance payments for the procurement of custom elements?

The principle of party autonomy governs the payment schedule in the contract for work. While the text of art. 372 CO provides for payment of the price upon delivery of the work, the parties can validly agree on derogatory terms. For the workshop manufacturing of joinery elements representing 140 000,00 CHF, demanding an advance payment upon order of 20%, i.e. 28 000,00 CHF, allows raw materials to be funded. This advance offsets the absence of a direct lien as long as the goods are not incorporated into the real property, safeguarding the SME's financial stability.

Can the shared-expense account and deductions for collective cleaning be challenged prior to signing?

Lump-sum shared-expense account deductions, sometimes reaching 2% to 3% of the final amount, constitute undue transfers of general construction site overheads. If the descriptive quote does not explicitly mention these organisational costs, the contractor is entitled to refuse them during contract adjustments. On an award invoice of 310 000,00 CHF, a deduction of 2.5% represents 7 750,00 CHF in net margin erosion. You should require an actual statement based on verified supporting documents or purely and simply exclude any contribution to non-individualised general administrative expenses.

What steps should be taken in the event of systematic payment delays on monthly advance payment statements?

The timeliness of remittances determines the normal continuation of the work. If the agreed deadline is not met, the contractor must issue a formal notice. In accordance with art. 104 CO, default interest of 5% per annum is due as a matter of right once the default is constituted for any outstanding monetary claim. For an unpaid certified advance payment of 80 000,00 CHF, the formal notice triggers the running of statutory interest. If the default persists following a formal warning, the contractor may suspend the works in accordance with the general rules applicable to the non-performance of bilateral contracts.

Contractual security and transition to the operational phase

Finalising a SIA 1023 contract for work allows no drafting approximations or administrative haste. Every derogation inserted by the professional agent, every daily penalty clause and every financial guarantee mechanism directly affects the economic outcome of the order and the solvency of the Swiss firm. Estimators and executives must lock down payment clauses, cap retentions and remove unlawful waivers before appending any signature. Once the agreement is fully secured, methodically handing over the file to internal site management ensures that negotiated commitments will be strictly enforced on the ground. Subsequent technical execution, tracking of quantity surveys and handling of work acceptances are then supported by the dedicated construction site operations tools on our portal.

To explore each facet of the negotiation further and structure your contract review before the construction site opens, consult our specialised publications:

Art Construction is an independent company: it is not affiliated with the SIA, CRB, SUVA, or KBOB. Referenced norms and standards point to publications from these bodies; only official versions are legally binding.