Skip to content
Art ConstructionTenders
Practical guide

Negotiating Retention Caps and Joint-and-Several Guarantees Before Signing

Negotiate retention caps and joint-and-several guarantees before signing under standard SIA 118 and the Swiss Code of Obligations (CO).

Table of contents
The 3 Major Site Risks
  1. Financial / Margin: An excessive deduction of retention money on advance payments without phased release ties up liquidity of around 10% of monthly payment applications, degrading the firm's working capital against the price agreed under art. 363 CO.
  2. Legal / Joint Body / SUVA: Poorly drafted guarantee wording extending commitments beyond the guarantee governed by art. 492 CO creates unforeseen joint liabilities that weaken relations with banking institutions and institutional partners across the construction sector.
  3. Administrative / Acceptance: The lack of a clear agreement on substituting retention money with bank collateral delays the release of the final balance after acceptance of the work, conflicting directly with the five-year limitation period laid down in art. 371 CO for defects in immovable structures.

Negotiating the financial clauses of a works contract before signing is a decisive step to protect the contractor's operating margin in Switzerland. During the tender phase, many clients and site management teams insert retention money requirements on every monthly payment application without setting a reasonable overall cap or planning practical arrangements for its replacement by a joint and several guarantee. Accepting these conditions without prior adjustment exposes the building firm to a prolonged freeze of its cash flow throughout project execution and the subsequent warranty period, even while staff payroll, material purchases, and subcontractors must be paid punctually.

To secure its cash flows, the bidder must master the interaction between the contractual provisions of standard SIA 118, the standard works contract under standard SIA 1023, and the fundamental rules of the Swiss Code of Obligations (CO). Clarifying the retention rate, negotiating a capped maximum amount, and having the principle of a guarantee issued by an approved bank or insurance company confirmed in writing before concluding the agreement avoids administrative standstills upon delivery of the work and ensures sound working-capital management for the SME.

Retention Mechanisms and Substitution Terms Before Signing

During pre-contractual negotiations, calculating the financial security required by the client requires strict structuring. Under art. 363 CO, a works contract obliges the contractor to carry out a work and the client to pay the price. Yet inserting retentions on advance payments without precise limits alters the financial balance of the operation. The contractor preparing a response to a call for tenders must analyse the draft works contract to check whether the schedule of standard SIA 118 applies or whether the site management has introduced restrictive departures.

Within the standard works contract, Swiss practice accepted under standard SIA 118 provides for retention money on monthly payment applications to protect the client against defects or non-performance. When the contract is based purely on the Code of Obligations (CO), art. 372 CO provides that the price of the work is payable upon delivery. Consequently, any retention deducted during the construction site on intermediate advance payments must be subject to an explicit agreement between the parties, formalised in accordance with art. 1 CO on mutual and concordant expressions of intent.

Framing Percentages and Setting an Overall Cap

An unnegotiated clause often allows the client to deduct 10% from each monthly advance payment until full completion, without any stopping point. On a structural work or building services contract running for 18 months, this continuous drain strangles cash flow. Negotiations must establish two cumulative safeguards: reducing the percentage applied as soon as a certain progress milestone is certified by site management, and setting a monetary cap expressed in Swiss francs beyond which no further deduction is permitted.

Introducing a cap at 5% of the total amount safeguards the liquidity needed to pay subcontractors and suppliers. If subcontractors are involved in the construction work or finishing work under art. 5 ODét, the general contractor remains responsible for working conditions and the net minimum wages defined by art. 8a ODét. Excessive withholding of funds by the client directly reduces the operating leeway required to meet these mandatory obligations.

Substitution by a Joint and Several Guarantee

The recognised alternative is to replace cash retention money with a joint and several guarantee issued by a Swiss bank or a top-tier insurance company. Guarantees are governed by art. 492 CO, under which a person undertakes towards the creditor to guarantee payment of the debt contracted by the debtor, an obligation that can only exist for a valid underlying debt. Pre-contractual negotiations must specify that the client releases retentions already deducted upon receipt of a compliant guarantee instrument.

The contractor must pay close attention to how the guarantee instrument is worded. Site management teams sometimes suggest templates resembling on-demand guarantees that are independent of the underlying contract. The guarantee must remain accessory to the primary obligation of performance or warranty for defects. Because the limitation period for client defect rights in an immovable structure is set at five years under art. 371 CO, the validity period of the performance guarantee and subsequently the warranty guarantee must be aligned with the inspection stages set out in standard SIA 118.

Comparison Table of Financial Guarantee Clauses

The table below contrasts the restrictive clauses frequently found in tender documents with balanced wordings to be agreed before entering into the contract.

Negotiation topicCommon unadjusted clause (asymmetrical)Negotiated clause compliant with standard SIA 118Financial impact on the contractor
Retention cap on advance paymentsContinuous 10% deduction on each payment application with no amount limit.Degressive retention capped at 5% of the total agreed remuneration.5% of the contract value preserved in available liquidity.
Time limit for substitution by guaranteeSubstitution prohibited before final acceptance of the work.Substitution permitted at any time upon submission of the bank certificate.Phased release of working capital right from site kick-off.
Nature of the guarantee undertakingOn-demand guarantee payable upon simple request from the client.Accessory joint and several guarantee compliant with art. 492 CO.Protection against wrongful calls where no defect has been established.
Release of retained amountsRetained funds held until the five-year period expires.Balance paid upon acceptance against a defect warranty guarantee.Prevents own equity from being tied up during the art. 371 CO period.
Payment of the contract pricePayments suspended in the event of minor disagreement on a quote line item.Payment for accepted services according to the schedule in art. 372 CO.Steady cash collection without unjustified total freezes.

Frequent Mistakes and Operational Consequences

A first recurring mistake is signing the contract without demanding the removal of open-ended joint liability in guarantee instruments. When the instrument binds the financial institution to pay out funds without possibility of dispute, the client can call the guarantee without having to prove actual damage. On a finishing work contract worth 850 000,00 CHF, an unjustified 10% call results in a cash drain of 85 000,00 CHF, burdening the company's credit line with its bank.

A second mistake lies in omitting a firm expiry date for the performance bond. If the document does not state that the commitment lapses automatically upon acceptance of the work or upon delivery of the defect warranty guarantee, bank fees continue to accrue. These unnecessary financing costs typically amount to between 0,8% and 1,5% per year of the guaranteed sum, representing an avoidable expense of several thousand Swiss francs over the five-year warranty period.

Finally, neglecting alignment between client defect notification deadlines and the release of retention money presents a major legal risk. Since 1 January 2026, art. 367 CO imposes a 60-day period to notify defects in an immovable structure following inspection, with any shorter contractual period being null and void. The contractor must ensure that the joint and several guarantee provided for the warranty period only covers defects notified in due form, without tacit extension linked to late claims.

Illustrative practical cases (typical scenarios on Swiss construction sites)

The figures set out in the scenarios below are illustrative examples intended to guide pre-contractual negotiation methods in the Swiss context.

Scenario 1: Heavy Refurbishment in a Hospital Setting (Canton of Vaud)

A general contractor with 35 employees tenders for the technical conversion of a hospital building in the canton of Vaud. The total tender amount stands at 2 450 000,00 CHF including 8,1% VAT. The initial specifications impose 10% retention money on each monthly progress payment application, with no possibility of release before the end of the five-year warranty period under art. 371 CO.

During the contract finalisation meeting, the contractor rejects this arrangement, which would freeze a total of 245 000,00 CHF in cash. The contractor puts forward a counter-proposal specifying a 10% deduction on progress billings up to a ceiling of 5% of the total price of the work, meaning a cap of 122 500,00 CHF. In addition, the amended clause entitles the firm to replace this retention with a joint and several guarantee issued by a Swiss bank from the very first payment application. This negotiation allows the firm to preserve all its operational liquidity while providing the client with the required legal security.

Scenario 2: Multi-Family Residential Construction (Canton of Fribourg)

An industrial joinery business employing 18 people wins a contract package for interior and exterior joinery on three residential rental buildings in the canton of Fribourg, for a contract value of 680 000,00 CHF including 8,1% VAT. The draft works contract stipulates an 8% advance payment retention and further requires a 10% bank performance bond valid until the end of the works, creating cumulative security reaching 18% of the contract price.

The director reviews the works contract and points out that this accumulation runs counter to the balanced practice recommended by standard SIA 118. The final agreement records the complete removal of retentions on monthly advance payments in exchange for providing a single 5% joint and several guarantee of 34 000,00 CHF covering execution of the works. The contract specifies that this security will be returned upon acceptance without major defect, against delivery of a warranty guarantee of equal value for the subsequent liability period. The firm thus prevents 54 400,00 CHF from being withheld across the works.

Calls for tenders: free tools

Direct public procurement tenders, AIMP thresholds by canton, converting SIA 451 to Excel, quantity takeoff from an IFC model.

View tendering tools

Frequently asked questions

Can payment application retention be replaced by a joint and several guarantee from the first invoice?

Yes, if the works contract or the special conditions allow it. The contractor then submits a certificate issued by a bank or insurance company under art. 492 CO. For an illustrative contract of 500 000,00 CHF, this avoids a progressive deduction of 50 000,00 CHF from operating cash flow.

What maximum retention cap should be negotiated before signing?

Swiss practice under standard SIA 118 commonly applies a degressive rate, such as 10% on advance payments capped at 5% of the total amount. On an 800 000,00 CHF tender, capping the retention by contract preserves a 40 000,00 CHF liquidity buffer for the business.

Is a clause prohibiting the release of the guarantee before five years valid?

The parties may contractually agree on security terms under the principle of freedom of contract set out in art. 1 CO. However, demanding that the full amount remain tied up beyond the initial notice period without proven defects is a heavy derogation that should be firmly refused during preliminary negotiations.

What are the contractor's risks if the client rejects the bank guarantee form?

The client can make a direct retention on the final account in accordance with standard SIA 118. Art. 492 CO governs suretyship, but public clients frequently require the standard KBOB model. A refusal blocks the payout of an illustrative amount of 25 000,00 CHF until formal regularisation.

How do you align the defects guarantee with the new 2026 notice period?

For an immovable work, art. 367 CO gives the client 60 days to give notice of defects. The security ensures coverage of these remedial works without altering the statutory limitation period under art. 371 CO. The deed must stipulate automatic release if no notice has been served.

Does the statutory mortgage lien remain available if a joint and several guarantee is already in place?

Registration of the lien under art. 837 CC secures payment of the contract sum owed to the contractor. It cannot be claimed if the property owner provides sufficient security under art. 839 CC, which is entirely distinct from the guarantee provided by the contractor to cover defects.

Contractual mastery of financial retainages and the joint and several guarantee provides lasting protection for your firm's cash flow against excessive demands from clients. To strengthen the preparation of your tenders and secure your contractual terms before signing, explore our specialist analyses:

Art Construction is an independent company: it is not affiliated with the SIA, CRB, SUVA, or KBOB. Referenced norms and standards point to publications from these bodies; only official versions are legally binding.