Table of contents
The 3 Major Site Risks
- Financial / Margin: Committing to a closed lump sum based on incomplete specifications exposes the contractor to a gross margin loss of 15 % to 30 % of the award amount (for instance, an unforeseen overrun of 45 000,00 CHF on an earthworks lot of 180 000,00 CHF), as art. 373 CO prohibits any price increase for predictable hazards or bidder quantity takeoff errors.
- Legal / Joint Body / SUVA: Underestimating a unit price or global price under competitive pressure leads to undersized collective safety equipment items, exposing site management and the successful bidder to inspections by workplace safety enforcement bodies under the Construction Workers' Ordinance (OTConst) as well as audits by joint industry committees.
- Administrative / Acceptance: Mischaracterising the remuneration structure right from the quote causes unilateral rejection of monthly accounts and holds up the joint verification minutes under standard SIA 118, deferring the release of contractual advance payments and delaying hand-over of the as-built documentation.
When responding to a call for tenders in Switzerland, the choice of remuneration method governs the entire allocation of financial and technical risks between the client and the contractor. Whether handling a public procurement contract under the LMP or a private project governed by standard SIA 118 and the Code of Obligations (CO), the estimator must accurately identify the pricing structure required by the tender dossier. A technical confusion between a unit price based on a bill of quantities drawn from the Standard Building Description (CAN) and a fixed global or lump-sum price shifts the volume risk entirely onto the contractor, leaving no room for subsequent adjustments to invoiced amounts.
This operational guide examines the compensation mechanisms set out in the works contract and standard SIA 118 to help directors and quantity surveyors protect their tenders. By contrasting the rules applicable to unit prices, global prices with indexation clauses, and strict lump-sum prices as defined by art. 373 CO, you will gain a systematic decision framework to audit procurement documents, formulate standard reservations upon bid submission, and safeguard your company's final profitability against discrepancies in architectural drawings.
Typology of Remuneration Methods under Standard SIA 118 and the Code of Obligations
Before submitting an offer, reviewing the tender package requires properly classifying the applicable pricing regime from both a legal and technical perspective. Swiss law distinguishes three primary methods for remunerating construction work, each entailing fundamentally different consequences regarding quantity risks and cost variations.
Unit Price: Billing Based on Quantities Actually Executed
Under a unit price system, the total tender amount is purely indicative and based on a provisional bill of quantities prepared by the designer. Each item from the Standard Building Description receives a fixed unit price for a specific unit of measurement (cubic metre, square metre, kilogram, or unit piece). The final remuneration payable to the contractor is calculated using actual quantity measurements jointly recorded on the construction site.
This compensation method protects the firm against dimensional uncertainties and volume calculation errors within the call for tenders documents. If actual earthworks or reinforced concrete volumes exceed initial projections without altering the nature of the work, the contractor receives payment for the actual quantities multiplied by the tendered unit prices. Under default statutory law, this mechanism mirrors the principles of art. 374 CO when quantities are only approximate.
Global Price: Fixed Total Amount Without Quantity Risks but with Indexation
A global price is a pre-agreed total sum for executing a clearly defined building structure or part of a structure. Unlike unit pricing, the client transfers the risk of quantity discrepancies relative to the tender execution drawings to the contractor. The contractor commits to delivering the specified work for the agreed sum, regardless of the actual quantities surveyed on site.
However, under standard SIA 118, qualifying an arrangement as a global price does not automatically forfeit the contractor's right to price adjustments should raw material costs or collective bargaining agreement wages rise, unless the contract explicitly stipulates fixed, non-adjustable prices through project completion.
Lump-Sum Price: Strict Invariability under Art. 373 CO
A lump-sum price represents the most binding commitment for the contractor. Governed statutorily by art. 373 CO, this arrangement stipulates that the contractor undertakes to execute the entire described structure for a definitively settled sum. Art. 373 CO establishes the mandatory principle that the contractor cannot claim any price increase, even if the work required more labour or expenditure than anticipated.
The sole legal exception under art. 373 para. 2 CO applies when extraordinary circumstances arise that were impossible to foresee or excluded from the parties' initial expectations, allowing a court to grant a price increase or order contract termination. In Swiss commercial practice, a lump-sum price absorbs both quantity execution risks and labour and materials cost fluctuations across the agreed delivery schedule.
Comparative Matrix of Risks and Invoicing Methods
The table below summarises the operational and contractual implications of each pricing regime for a tendering contractor:
| Analysis Criteria | Unit Price | Global Price | Lump-Sum Price (Art. 373 CO) |
|---|---|---|---|
| Remuneration basis | Actual survey of quantities multiplied by the agreed unit price | Total sum agreed for a defined scope of work | Fixed total sum for the full completion of the agreed work |
| Handling of quantity risk | Borne entirely by the client | Borne by the contractor on the basis of contract drawings provided | Borne entirely and without reservation by the contractor |
| Cost indexation adjustments | Adjustable according to parametric methods or agreed index tables | Adjustable by agreement, unless contractually stated as fixed prices | Generally locked in as fixed, non-adjustable prices |
| Required detail level in tender | Cost breakdown analysis per item of the standardised description | Full quantity recalculation and identification of plan omissions | Exhaustive audit of site constraints, trade interfaces, and technical risks |
| Change management | Addenda priced using existing or derived unit prices | Must demonstrate a formal change to the initial design brief | Requires a written order from the client substantially modifying the works |
Common Arbitration Mistakes and Financial Consequences
The most damaging mistake when preparing a quote is accepting a lump sum based only on preliminary draft documents or an outline description of works. When tender drawings do not match the level of detail of actual working drawings, the contractor agreeing to a global or lump-sum price inadvertently absorbs omissions and ambiguities left behind by the architect or civil engineer.
From a contractual perspective, if the contractor fails to report incomplete specifications in writing before signing the agreement, they risk having to pay for all works required to bring the construction into technical compliance out of pocket, pursuant to art. 364 CO regarding contractor liability. For instance, on a plumbing & sanitary installations lot tendered as a lump sum for 220 000,00 CHF, missing connecting pipework omitted from the tender text but required by trade rules can trigger a direct additional cost of 28 500,00 CHF, fully payable by the contractor.
A second common pitfall is overlooking derogation clauses tucked away in the special conditions of the tender dossier. Some clients include terms combining multiple disadvantages: unit prices that apply only if quantities decrease, paired with an unalterable global ceiling if quantities rise. Such contractual imbalances must be flagged during your compliance review so you can state the necessary reservations before the tender submission deadline.
Illustrative practical cases (typical scenarios on Swiss construction sites)
The figures and scenarios outlined below are illustrative examples designed to examine financial and contractual decision-making processes in French-speaking Switzerland.
Scenario 1: Speciality Works and Earthworks in the Canton of Vaud
A structural work and civil engineering firm with 45 employees responds to a private call for tenders to build a multi-family residential complex in the Nyon district. The tender documents specify an all-inclusive global price of 480 000,00 CHF for all excavation and trench shoring work, with no final geotechnical survey attached to the file.
Following a risk review by its technical department, the firm declines to commit to a fixed global or lump-sum price. Relying on the contractor's duty to inform under art. 365 para. 3 CO regarding ground-related defects, the bidder submits its offer using strict unit prices per cubic metre of excavated spoil, with separate items based on the encountered soil classification. When ground conditions on site revealed an unexpected rock lens requiring hydraulic rock-breaker equipment costing an additional 65 400,00 CHF, applying the unit price schedule ensured the client covered these cost overruns in full, avoiding protracted litigation under art. 373 para. 2 CO.
Scenario 2: Major Renovation in Public Procurement in the Canton of Neuchâtel
A finishing work general contractor with 18 employees submits a tender to a public authority for the refurbishment of interior joinery and suspended ceilings across a school complex. The initial contract award sum stands at 315 000,00 CHF. The specifications demand a fixed lump-sum price based on approximate measurements recorded during early design stages.
When verifying site measurements prior to signing the final contract, the estimator identifies a 12 % discrepancy in the actual surface area of the acoustic ceilings, amounting to an uncovered financial shortfall of 37 800,00 CHF. Citing the bid assessment provisions under art. 38 LMP, the firm formally requests clarification from the contracting authority to rectify this obvious quantity error. This proactive approach led to the lot being reclassified as a fixed unit price schedule, ensuring payment for actual installed surface areas without eroding the site's operating margin.
Calls for tenders: free tools
Direct public procurement tenders, AIMP thresholds by canton, converting SIA 451 to Excel, quantity takeoff from an IFC model.
Frequently asked questions
What is the main legal difference between a unit price and a lump-sum price under the Code of Obligations?
A unit price pays for the quantities actually executed as verified by site measurements. In contrast, art. 373 CO provides that a lump-sum price binds the contractor to complete the work for the agreed sum without any increase, barring extraordinary, unforeseeable circumstances granted by a court or approved change orders.
How does a global price handle quantity variations compared to a unit price?
A unit price automatically aligns final compensation with measured actual quantities. A global price binds the contractor to a fixed total sum for precisely described services without joint remeasurement of actual quantities, shifting the risk of quantity discrepancies onto the contractor provided the initial works description was complete.
Does exceeding an approximate estimate allow the client to terminate the works contract?
Yes. In the event of an excessive overrun of the approximate quote through no fault of the client, art. 375 CO grants the client the right to withdraw from the contract. For construction on their own land, they may demand an equitable price reduction or stop the works against compensation.
What conditions govern material cost increases in a lump-sum contract?
Under standard SIA 118 and art. 373 CO, the lump sum generally absorbs ordinary wage or material increases. Price adjustments are only possible if an escalation clause is expressly stipulated in the contract or in the event of extraordinary, unforeseeable circumstances recognised under the rules of good faith.
Can the type of remuneration be modified unilaterally during negotiations for an SIA 1023 contract?
No. Under art. 1 CO, entering into a contract requires mutual, concurrent consent. Converting a tender based on unit prices into a lump-sum amount requires formal bilateral agreement, often contingent on a complete recalculation of contingency risks and a clearer project description.
How do you claim variation orders under a lump-sum contract?
Any modified service or work ordered beyond the contractual scope must be covered by a prior written addendum. As art. 373 CO only protects the agreed scope of work, additional work ordered by the client or site management entitles you to supplementary remuneration calculated on the initial basis.
Strategic Choice of Contractual Remuneration
Choosing between unit price, lump sum, or fixed price directly affects your firm's profitability and risk allocation in both public procurement and private projects. Before signing any contract, safeguard your legal commitments and guarantees by consulting our specialised guides:
- Final Negotiation, SIA 1023 Contract Review, and Handover to Site Operations
- Explicitly Incorporating Standard SIA 118 into the Works Contract: It Is Not Automatic
- Auditing a Works Contract Form: Derogations Introduced by the Architect
- Negotiating Retainage Caps and Joint and Several Guarantees before Signing
