Table of contents
The 3 Major Site Risks
- Financial / Margin: Incorrectly deducting openings below CAN normative thresholds directly underestimates measured quantities. The contractor then absorbs material wastage and trimming labour without compensation, leading to gross margin erosion of roughly 4% to 8% on building envelope or masonry items under art. 373 CO governing lump-sum pricing.
- Legal / Joint Committees / SUVA: Incorrect quantity takeoff distorts the allocation of productive hours required by collective labour agreements extended via the LECCT. During audits by joint committees on declared working hours or reviews of abnormally low bids in public procurement under art. 38 LMP, mismatched production rates expose the tenderer to formal requests for justification.
- Administrative / Acceptance: Applying divergent measurement rules between the tender and the final payment statement leads to billing standoffs with the site management. Without prior agreement on deduction methods at the signing of the works contract under art. 363 CO, intermediate payment validation and settlement of the balance will stall.
Preparing a compliant tender for Swiss calls for tenders requires thorough command of the quantity surveying rules issued by CRB through the Catalogue of Standardised Articles (CAN). All too often, estimators and firm owners intuitively apply superficial gross-for-net methods without verifying the sector-specific rules for each trade. Yet, every CAN chapter defines strict thresholds below which openings, penetrations, floor openings or bays are not deducted from the measured area or volume, so as to compensate for cutting, edge stops, and finishing constraints.
In a public procurement or private contract governed by Swiss rules, improper deduction of an opening distorts the unit price and undermines overall project profitability. This guide details standard deduction thresholds by trade, from masonry to interior finishes, helping you lock down your tender quantification and guarantee dispute-free accounts with the site management.
Methodological fundamentals of quantity surveying according to CRB CAN chapters
Calculating quantities in Swiss tenders is grounded in a fundamental principle: distinguishing raw geometric dimensions from billable work quantities actually measured for payment. The Swiss Research Centre for Building Rationalisation (CRB) structures the Catalogue of Standardised Articles (CAN) by including deduction rules tailored to site installation complexity. The gross-for-net rule is not an arithmetical shortcut, but an integrated lump-sum allowance for waste, layout cuts, joint details, and plaster stops.
When drafting or pricing a bill of quantities, the general principle is that openings, recesses, and interruptions in an area or volume are not deducted as long as they stay below the normative threshold stated in the preliminary notes of each chapter. Once an opening exceeds that threshold, it is deducted entirely from the main item, and specific peripheral work, such as reveals, corner bead installations, or edge formwork, is billed as separate items paid by the linear metre or per piece.
Under a works contract governed by the rules of standard SIA 118 and the Code of Obligations (CO), any departure from these rules without express agreement upsets the contractual balance. A contractor failing to apply the deduction rules of the relevant CAN chapter faces two major pitfalls: a severe underestimation of costs by pricing net geometry with uncompensated edge work, or outright disqualification during bid evaluations under the LMP for failing to meet the bill of quantities' technical specifications.
Rules for deducting voids and openings by trade
Structural work, concreting, and masonry
In masonry and reinforced concrete work, walls are generally measured by theoretical surface area or volume. Openings for building service ducts, piping, or small sleeves are not deducted if their individual cross-section is below the threshold. This non-deduction compensates the builder for positioning formers, cutting supplementary rebar, and thoroughly compacting concrete around embedded items.
As soon as a door or window opening exceeds the chapter limit, the entire opening area is deducted. However, lintel formwork, headers, and reveals are then measured as specific bill items. If a tenderer deducts a small opening without pricing these peripheral details, they incur an unrecoverable loss of labour under art. 373 CO whenever the project is let at a lump-sum price.
Plastering, painting, and interior linings
For interior finishes, areas are measured between unfinished or finished wall surfaces. Standard interior door openings are generally not deducted from total drywall or plaster areas, because cutting metal studs, taping joints, and skimming corners require far more installer hours than running a continuous plain wall.
Painting and renders follow a similar logic: small glazed openings are not deducted from wall measurements, which compensates for unavoidable masking, taping, and frame-protection tasks. Systematically deducting every square metre of openings cuts billable quantities by 10% to 15% across a typical storey, severely eroding construction site productivity.
Facades, external renders, and external thermal insulation systems
External thermal insulation composite systems (ETICS) demand rigorous execution. Lintels, plinth returns, and window sills are the most critical thermal bridging points. CAN facade insulation rules maintain gross measurements over small and medium openings to offset edge reinforcement beads, embedded mesh returns, and precise cuts of insulation boards.
When an opening exceeds the limit, the void is deducted, but the perimeter is quantified as a separate item per linear metre for edge profiles and flashings. In public procurement governed by the economic viability and plausibility checks of art. 29 LMP, the contracting authority will verify the exact alignment between facade surfaces and the linear edge trims scheduled in the tender.
Comparative table of CAN measurement logic and deductions
| Trade / Work category | CAN measurement basis | Void non-deduction principle | Additional items when deducted | Financial impact of errors |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Brick / block masonry | Area (m²) or Volume (m³) | Small openings and niches not deducted | Lintel formwork, bed joint reinforcement | Underestimating cutting labour (3% to 5%) |
| In-situ cast concrete | Volume (m³) or Formwork area (m²) | Small penetrations and voids retained | Edge stop formwork, rebar trimming around corners | Losses on complex formwork hours (5% to 8%) |
| Plasterwork and lightweight partitions | Developed net area (m²) | Standard door openings not deducted | Subframe reinforcements, reinforced corner tape | Underestimating jointing hours (4% to 6%) |
| Painting and wall finishes | Developed area (m²) | Isolated windows and doors measured solid | Supply and placement of fine-line masking tape | Unpaid absorption of protection hours (6% to 10%) |
| Facade insulation systems | Outside visible area (m²) | Voids below trade thresholds not deducted | Reveal transition profiles, corner mesh (m) | Heavy margin erosion on scaffolding and installation |
Recurring pricing errors and contractual repercussions
The most common mistake made by estimators is relying blindly on BIM models or digital takeoff software that extracts net geometric surfaces without applying CAN rules. A bill of quantities based purely on raw geometry deducts every opening down to the millimetre, eliminating pay for edge details. Upon submitting the quote, the contractor ends up with an artificially deflated total price.
Conversely, measuring large glazed facades solid when they clearly exceed trade limits inflates the quote. During arithmetic checks by the site management under art. 38 LMP, this practice triggers an official correction or disqualification of the bid for non-compliance with the tender documents. Moreover, if the contract is awarded based on unit prices, the final account based on joint measurement will slash billed amounts, sparking an immediate cash-flow deficit.
Contractually, under art. 364 CO, the contractor is liable for the proper performance of their professional duties. Submitting an offer based on flawed quantity takeoffs prevents the firm from claiming variations for essential edge or frame trim works that were implicitly covered under a rigorous application of Swiss catalogue deduction rules.
Illustrative practical cases (typical scenarios on Swiss construction sites)
The figures and scenarios below are illustrative examples designed to demonstrate the impact of quantity survey deductions and do not depict specific construction sites.
Scenario 1: Masonry and reinforced concrete in the Canton of Fribourg
On an industrial and logistics hall project in Bulle, a local general contractor deploys a crew of 8 bricklayers. The bill of quantities based on the CAN catalogue schedules 1 450 m² of exposed clay block masonry walls. The building includes 18 penetrations for ventilation ducts and service runs, each with a small frontal area, as well as 6 industrial doorway openings.
The estimator inadvertently calculated pure net surfaces by deducting all 18 service penetrations along with the doorways. This incorrect deduction stripped 65 m² of masonry from the quote, creating an initial revenue shortfall of about 11 500,00 CHF. Worse still, the firm failed to price the precast lintels and edge formwork required around these openings. When awarding at unit prices, the site management refused to compensate the installation of penetration sleeves on the grounds that these tasks had to be factored into the standard item measurement rules. The total financial hit on the package margin reached 16 850,00 CHF, absorbed entirely by the masonry contractor.
Scenario 2: Facade render renovation in the Canton of Vaud
In Lausanne, a plastering and painting contractor employing 6 workers enters an invited call for tenders for the thermal renovation and facade restoration of an apartment building containing 24 residential units. The total facade area measures 2 200 m², punctuated by 96 standard-sized windows.
The estimator applies the standard methodology of the corresponding CAN chapter: individual openings below the normative thresholds are not deducted from the plaster and paint area, which finances the estimated 480 hours required for sanding reveals, protecting external joinery with taped sheeting, and installing corner beads. The total bid price comes out to 214 000,00 CHF, incorporating a planned net margin of 7,5%. A direct competitor who deducted every window to present an artificially low price won a similar package the previous year, only to face a flat rejection of extras at the acceptance of the work, ending the project with a gross loss of 24 500,00 CHF on finishing labour.
Calls for tenders: free tools
Direct public procurement tenders, AIMP thresholds by canton, converting SIA 451 to Excel, quantity takeoff from an IFC model.
Frequently asked questions
How do you deduct a window opening in masonry according to the CAN?
The estimator applies the deduction rule set by CRB for the chapter in question. If the opening remains below the standard threshold, the quantity is calculated solid for void. Above it, the total area of the opening is deducted in full from the billed volume of masonry.
Does a slab penetration change a fixed lump-sum price?
No. Under art. 373 CO, the contractor executes the works for the agreed price without claiming any increase. A penetration not deducted during the initial tender allows no subsequent extra cost, except in the event of a formal change order issued by site management.
How should door reveals be priced in interior plasterwork?
Openings below the contractual threshold are not deducted from partition wall areas. This tolerance compensates for the extra labour involved in corner beads and reinforced taping. Frame supply is listed as a separate closed item in the tender under standard SIA 118.
Can an incorrect quantity take-off justify exclusion from a public procurement procedure?
Yes. In an open procedure governed by LMP, art. 44 LMP allows the contracting authority to exclude an offer containing significant formal defects. Moreover, a systematic omission of void deductions distorts the bill of quantities and exposes the bidder to rejection for an abnormally low tender.
What impact do technical blockouts have on unit prices?
Ventilation shafts and pipe penetrations through slabs remain measured solid when they do not exceed the threshold limit. The contractor incorporates the fitting of lost formwork into their unit price calculation, with no right to claim additional compensation at the final account stage.
Can site management impose net void measurement?
Site management must comply with the measurement rules set out in the contract for works (art. 363 CO). If the specifications rely on the Standardised Item Catalogue and standard SIA 118, the stated deduction rules strictly apply to both contracting parties.
Mastering deductions for voids and openings according to CRB rules protects your profit margins and prevents disputes during contractual quantity verification. To learn more about structuring tender documents in Switzerland, see our dedicated guides:
